D700 with 18-200 VR lens ...

Did they mention the Nikon USA warranty may not apply to people who aren't the original purchaser? Doesn't look like it.

(Nikon USA may honor it... or they may not... best not to raise potentially false hopes on part of the potential purchaser, eh?)
 
The 18-200 vignettes even on DX bodies, so it would be a disaster on a D700. Don't get me wrong, it's a nice lens for walkabouts, but really only on DX bodies.

--
I Reject Your Reality And Substitute My Own

Web Site - http://www.hgiersberg.com/
 
Perhaps the seller knows that some rich people buy high end cameras and lenses only to impress others in gatherings and parties with no clue how to use them. I have seen the lot. So some people must be buying those FX cameras with DX lenses.
 
even though D700 can do DX but it's not the optimum function of D700

and it is only 5MP in Dx
 
Some DX lenses will work OK on FX bodies when used in FX mode, but not over the full focal range. For example, I've heard the 12 to 24 DX lens is perfectly OK on FX bodies as long as you don't go below 18 mm focal length. With the 18-200, however, given how it vignettes even on DX bodies, I think you'd be limited to using in on the D700 in DX mode, which of course means you're throwing away a lot of pixels, and using the D700 as a 5 MP camera. For some applications that may be fine, just as long as you know the limitations before hand.

--
I Reject Your Reality And Substitute My Own

Web Site - http://www.hgiersberg.com/
 
What do you mean by this, EricStephan? "and it is only 5MP in Dx"

I guess everyone else has heard this, but I haven't. Wondering about
using my old lenses (see profile) on my new D3.
A DX lens will mostly benefit from the FX capabilities (especially high ISO), but will be an approximately 5.1 MP [at best] photo when in DX mode with a DX lens.

See page 69 of the English D3 manual (or PDF file). In DX mode, it says, the largest format possible in DX mode is 2784x1848, or 5,144,832 pixels. Hence, about 5 or 5.1 MP.

In essence, when you use a DX lens in DX mode, you are projecting the smaller DX image circle onto the larger FX sensor... so the FX sensor (in auto-DX mode) will just simply ignore everything outside of the DX image area. The camera is capable of determining if a lens is DX or not.

In essence, it is trimming roughly 7 MP of FX-specific area outside of the DX area and retaining what's left as a DX image. The final image will still look the same way it did on a DX camera, but will have only about 5.1 MP to work with.

If you don't need to do significant uprez'ing (e.g. for printing at large sizes) or image editing work, then 5.1 MP may not be a big deal. But if you do, sometimes it does matter.

P.S. Congratulations on your D3! Darned fine machine (and camera), and ditto for your previous cameras.
 
What's the big deal - it will operate in DX mode. For vacation snaps and the like, which is what the 18-200VR is designed for, the reduced resolution doesn't matter much. I don't think Nikon makes a more versatile travel lens than the 18-200VR, so why give it up on FX.
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top