SD card recommendations for LX3

NicoT

Forum Enthusiast
Messages
376
Reaction score
207
Location
Boulder, CO, US
I'm up on the CF world (have a Canon 5D) but I just bought a LX3 and I have no idea what to be looking for in an SD card for this camera. Does write speed make much difference with a little point and shoot jewel like this? Or is the camera slow enough that write speeds don't really matter.

I'm looking for something in the 4GB range, but I'd consider a 2 or 8GB if the price/performance are compelling.

What SD card would you recommend?

Thanks.
 
Apparently pretty much any HDSC card will do. I bought three 16 GB Class 6 HDHC cards for mine. My sister just ordered an LX3 from amazon ($400) and ordered a Transcend 16 GB class 6 card from Amazon for $37.00 delivered. Class 6 is the fastest SD card made so to play it safe I got that. Costco is selling two 4GB cards (but not Class 6) for $40.00 or one 4Gb card for $25.00 (I was just in the store yesterday). I believe you get about 5 minutes of video per GB.
--
Bill
 
I've got a 16Gb (C4) but could be tempted with more. If you ever have to go a few days without downloading the extra space is worth it. Yes you can get extra cards, but why bother? If they offered high-capacity batteries I'd get them too.

I wouldn't bother with 2Gb unless you tend to shoot conservatively, jpeg only, use no video, download frequently and/or delete in-camera.

I tend to shoot like John Wayne then sort it all out later, deleting the rubbish in the comfort of home. I don't use video much but when I have been inspired to use it, I haven't wanted it to max out my card either.

Running out of memory sucks.
 
Welcome to the Land of the LX3
--Most any 2 gig or smaller card will work fine if you are not shooting video.

The faster the better ... there are a number of 133X and 166X 2 gig cards out there as well. Both SD (2gig and under) and SDHC (4 gig and higher) will work.

4 gigs and above ... I would suggest at least class 4 SDHC . That should be fast enough just in case you shoot a few video clips ... also remember that the camera limits any single continuous video clip to 2 gigs in length. It is explained rather crypticly in the manual.

Currently I am using:
4 gig SDHC Lexar class 4
6 gig SDHC Panasonic class 4
8 gig SDHC Patriot class 6
plus 2 spare 2 gig SD Patriot 133X
Use what you can afford ... prices continue to fall.

pK
 
I recommend at least 16GB if you plan to shoot much video. LX3 records video at about 24Mb/s (or 3MB/s) so it appears any Class 4 or Class 6 card is adequate. Still photo bursting is buffered and continuous mode runs at about 1fps for 5MB jpegs so again any class 6 card should be adequate.

The class rating means it meets a minimum set of speed requirements. Some Class 6 cards are faster than others, but it really shouldn't matter when using the LX3. There are always exceptions of course. For example, mislabeled Chinese knockoff cards.

I use the most inexpensive Class 6 card I could find, Patriot 16GB, and it works fine.

-------------
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secure_Digital_card#SD_Speed_Class_Ratings

SD Speed Class Ratings

SDHC cards have SD Speed Class Ratings defined by the SD Association. The SD Speed Class Ratings specify the following minimum write speeds based on "the best fragmented state where no memory unit is occupied":[19]
Class 2: 2 MB/s
Class 4: 4 MB/s
Class 6: 6 MB/s

SDHC cards will often also advertise a maximum speed (such as 133x or 150x) in addition to this minimum Speed Class Rating. See section Speeds above for a further explanation. One critical difference between the Speed Class and the maximum speed ratings is the ability of the host device to query the SD card for the speed class and determine the best location to store data that meets the performance required. "Maximum speed" ratings are quoted by the manufacturers but unverified by any independent evaluation process.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secure_Digital_card#Speeds

There are different speed grades available which are measured with the same system as CD-ROMs, in multiples of 150 kB/s (1x = 150 kB/s). Basic cards transfer data up to six times (6x) the data rate of the standard CD-ROM speed (900 kB/s vs. 150 kB/s). High-speed cards are made with higher data transfer rates like 66x (10 MB/s), and high-end cards have speeds of 200x or higher. Note that maximum read speed and maximum write speed may be different, with maximum write speed typically lower than maximum read speed. Some digital cameras require high-speed cards (write speed) to record video smoothly or capture multiple still photographs in rapid succession. The SD card specification 1.01 allows for a maximum speed of 66x. Higher speeds of up to 200x are defined by specification 2.0.

The following table lists some common ratings and their respective maximum transfer rates.

Rating Speed (MB/s)
6x 0.9
32x 4.8
40x 6.0
66x 10.0
100x 15.0
133x 20.0
150x 22.5
200x 30.0

--
Phanfare supporter-
 
Rating Speed (MB/s)
6x 0.9
32x 4.8
40x 6.0
66x 10.0
100x 15.0
133x 20.0
150x 22.5
200x 30.0

--
So are you saying a Class 6 (6MB/s) card has a rating of x40?

Mike
 
Rating Speed (MB/s)
6x 0.9
32x 4.8
40x 6.0
66x 10.0
100x 15.0
133x 20.0
150x 22.5
200x 30.0

--
So are you saying a Class 6 (6MB/s) card has a rating of x40?
It does look a bit odd to me as well.

It's worth pointing out that Panasonic specify 10MB/s as the speed requirement to record smooth video, and since many people have reported using class 4 cards without issues the class speeds quoted earlier would appear to have a meaning that is not as clear-cut as it seems at face value.

--
John Bean [GMT]

 
Rating Speed (MB/s)
6x 0.9
32x 4.8
40x 6.0
66x 10.0
100x 15.0
133x 20.0
150x 22.5
200x 30.0

--
So are you saying a Class 6 (6MB/s) card has a rating of x40?
It does look a bit odd to me as well.

It's worth pointing out that Panasonic specify 10MB/s as the speed
requirement to record smooth video, and since many people have
reported using class 4 cards without issues the class speeds quoted
earlier would appear to have a meaning that is not as clear-cut as it
seems at face value.

--
John Bean [GMT]

--
My sentiments entirely John.

Mike
 
hi,
i'm about to buy a LX3 and my question, concerning speed, is:
will a SanDisk Ultra II SDHC (4 or 8 GB) do the job?
thanks
 
Rating Speed (MB/s)
6x 0.9
32x 4.8
40x 6.0
66x 10.0
100x 15.0
133x 20.0
150x 22.5
200x 30.0

--
So are you saying a Class 6 (6MB/s) card has a rating of x40?

Mike
Sorry for the delay in responding, lost track of this thread.

Yes, my point is that a Class 6 rating shows it has met a minimum criteria, but doesn't tell you a lot, other than to avoid Class 2/4 cards. MB/s speed rating is more indicative.

Brian

--
Phanfare supporter-
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top