Canon 35-135mm f/3.5-4.5 - better than 28-135mm?

ohcello

Senior Member
Messages
1,787
Reaction score
185
Location
NY, US
I'm looking for a cheap walkaround for the 5d, and the 24-105mm is a little too much right now... so I trying to find faster/better alternatives to the 28-135 and ran this lens and the 35-105mm..

Any information on either of these compared to the 28-135mm.

I know the old ARC AF is slow a noisy compared to USM ring type, but I would gain 2/3 of a stop throughout most of the tele portion of the zoom.

Thanks for any input.
 
if you want a cheaper zoom than the 28-135 that has half-decent IQ then get the 28-105 mk2. It's usually easy to find a used one on ebay, etc.

The 24-85mm is also a good cheap zoom for FF.

:)
I'm looking for a cheap walkaround for the 5d, and the 24-105mm is a
little too much right now... so I trying to find faster/better
alternatives to the 28-135 and ran this lens and the 35-105mm..

Any information on either of these compared to the 28-135mm.

I know the old ARC AF is slow a noisy compared to USM ring type, but
I would gain 2/3 of a stop throughout most of the tele portion of the
zoom.

Thanks for any input.
 
Do you have direct experience with the 35-135mm? If so, what did you notice about the lens?
 
I did not do this review:

"Canon EF 35-135 4.0-5.6 USM

In 1990, Canon introduced three consumer-level zooms with ring-type USM: EF 35-135 4.0-5.6 USM, EF 70-210 3.5-4.5 USM and EF 100-300 4.5-5.6 USM. The EF 35-135 4.0-5.6 USM debuted as the kit lens for the EOS 10S. I gave my wife an EF 35-135 4.0-5.6 USM and EOS Elan as a gift in 1994. The small size and moderate wide angle to medium telephoto range made an it ideal as part of her travel kit. Polycarbonate construction, but with a metal lens mount, keep it to a featherweight 425 g. The twist action zoom is smooth and does not creep. Zooming is accomplished by expanding and contracting the nested barrels. Like most AF lenses, the manual focus ring is small and not as silky or fine turning as the manual lenses of yesteryear.

The EF 35-135 4.0-5.6 USM is the first Canon zoom lens to use a rear element focusing group. The ring-type USM dives the small rear elements easily, resulting in extremely fast AF. The ring-type USM also allows full-time manual focusing. A molded glass (GMo) aspherical lens element (12th) is used to correct astigmatism, achieve sharp definition and to make the lens compact. Canon manages to pack 14 elements into a 72 x 86.4 mm barrel!

The front element does not rotate and the barrel does not expand or contract during focusing. If you prefocus manually, the distance window in meters and feet is very useful. The closest focusing distance is .75 m and is available at all focal lengths. A modest 58 mm filter thread makes filters affordable and easy to share with common Canon lenses.

For a consumer zoom, the EF 35-135 4.0-5.6 USM is sharp and contrasty, on a par with the EF 28-105 3.5-4.5 USM. At normal distances there is little distortion. Like most zooms, the short end has noticeable barrel distortion at macro distances. Flare and ghosting will occur if you shoot bright sunsets or other strong light sources. However, this lens is reasonably flare resistant under most conditions. Of course, you should use the lens shade (EW-62) to help keep flare in check. The hood is a standard wide angle design and is too shallow for use at 135mm. A petal design would have insured maximum coverage at the long end of the range.

This lens is out of production (replaced by the EF 28-135 3.5-5.6 IS USM in 1997) but used stock appear on EBay and KEH.com often. One in excellent condition goes for $125-150."
--
Happy New Year.
Rationally I have no hope, irrationally I believe in miracles.
Joni Mitchell
 
http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/read.asp?forum=1029&message=6007926
I did not do this review:

"Canon EF 35-135 4.0-5.6 USM

In 1990, Canon introduced three consumer-level zooms with ring-type
USM: EF 35-135 4.0-5.6 USM, EF 70-210 3.5-4.5 USM and EF 100-300
4.5-5.6 USM. The EF 35-135 4.0-5.6 USM debuted as the kit lens for
the EOS 10S. I gave my wife an EF 35-135 4.0-5.6 USM and EOS Elan as
a gift in 1994. The small size and moderate wide angle to medium
telephoto range made an it ideal as part of her travel kit.
Polycarbonate construction, but with a metal lens mount, keep it to a
featherweight 425 g. The twist action zoom is smooth and does not
creep. Zooming is accomplished by expanding and contracting the
nested barrels. Like most AF lenses, the manual focus ring is small
and not as silky or fine turning as the manual lenses of yesteryear.

The EF 35-135 4.0-5.6 USM is the first Canon zoom lens to use a rear
element focusing group. The ring-type USM dives the small rear
elements easily, resulting in extremely fast AF. The ring-type USM
also allows full-time manual focusing. A molded glass (GMo)
aspherical lens element (12th) is used to correct astigmatism,
achieve sharp definition and to make the lens compact. Canon manages
to pack 14 elements into a 72 x 86.4 mm barrel!

The front element does not rotate and the barrel does not expand or
contract during focusing. If you prefocus manually, the distance
window in meters and feet is very useful. The closest focusing
distance is .75 m and is available at all focal lengths. A modest 58
mm filter thread makes filters affordable and easy to share with
common Canon lenses.

For a consumer zoom, the EF 35-135 4.0-5.6 USM is sharp and
contrasty, on a par with the EF 28-105 3.5-4.5 USM. At normal
distances there is little distortion. Like most zooms, the short end
has noticeable barrel distortion at macro distances. Flare and
ghosting will occur if you shoot bright sunsets or other strong light
sources. However, this lens is reasonably flare resistant under most
conditions. Of course, you should use the lens shade (EW-62) to help
keep flare in check. The hood is a standard wide angle design and is
too shallow for use at 135mm. A petal design would have insured
maximum coverage at the long end of the range.

This lens is out of production (replaced by the EF 28-135 3.5-5.6 IS
USM in 1997) but used stock appear on EBay and KEH.com often. One in
excellent condition goes for $125-150."
--
Happy New Year.
Rationally I have no hope, irrationally I believe in miracles.
Joni Mitchell
 
I'm referring to the 35-135mm f/3.5-4.5 with ARC drive, not the 35-135mm f/4-f/5.6 USM...
 
I'm referring to the 35-135mm f/3.5-4.5 with ARC drive, not the 35-135mm f/4-f/5.6 USM...
 
I saw this lens on the local market for 20 euro. Searching the internet, I came along this thread and was intruiged by your comment that it had to had some quality because it was a first replacement for the FD lenses, so I picked it up.



On one side it had a marumi uv filter, at the other end there was an EOS 500 attached. Got rid of the EOS 500, kept the handy pocket-bag it was nestled in with the 500 for the future.

All-in-all you can't go wrong for 20 euro.. Then again, I go to flea-markets and pick up m42 Zeiss Glass for 4 or 5 euro a piece. The risk of broken zoom-rings, apertures and fungus are always there.

Just played with it for an hour while my youngest daughter had training. I like the zoom-range on an APS-H sensor, colors come out handy. Wasn't overly impressed with the sharpness, but can't really judge on it within an hour of panning and pin-pointing running rascals.



For now, I think I'll keep it as walk around lens.

Worth 20? yes! Worth 100? in mint condition, fungus free and all: yes. But you have to be a sucker for old lenses - like I am.



 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top