Best portable hard drive for photos on trip?

opusone

Forum Enthusiast
Messages
463
Reaction score
31
I love my Nexto Extreme. I used to use a Wolverine that I thought was as good as I could afford (or rationalize spending on), but for not really more money the Nexto is just worlds beyond it. In speed, functions and support. The Wolverine was so slow that if I didn't have to back up I wouldn't. The Nexto just hammers the card in. And it has been rock solid.
 
Western Digital Passport drives. I have three of them and you can now get them for $120 for 320gb's and they do NOT need an ac adapter and are super small.
--
George with the (big) rack
 
I didn't realize you wanted something that you can copy from directly. Sorry, the WD's are drives only
--
George with the (big) rack
 
I had a very positive experience with the Hyperdrive Space on a recent trip to Namibia. Over 4,000 RAW files transferred from Sandisk Extreme IV CF cards with full verification and not one file lost.

Cheers!
--
Hans H. Siegrist
http://www.pbase.com/hhsiegrist
 
+1 on the Nexto Extreme.

I just put together my OTG file backup solution with the Nexto Extreme at the core.

Nexto Extreme ND-2700 $130
Samsung M6 Series 2.5" SATA 320GB $85
Fujitsu 2.5"Ext USB 300GB $65

With the external power supply included with the nexto, the USB OTG port will power and host the Fujisu USB drive with no problem. This capability allows me to back up my SD cards to the Nexto and then using the OTG port I can sync all the data on the Nexto to the Fujitsu as a mirrored backup. I had the whole setup running and tested within 10 minutes of the unceremonious unboxing. And that included installing the 320GB SATA drive into the NEXTO case.

This isn't the cheapest solution but it seems to work very well and is MUCH faster and more confidence inspiring than the Vosonic VP8360 I used previously and reasonably compact considering it offers full redundancy without needing a PC. I've suffered the heartache of a harddrive failure in the past that wiped out a portion of my collection so redundant image storage is important to me.
 
Thanks for posting that - useful to know that it can also power an external drive. I've just got a Nexto 160gb on order - they're a bit more pricey over here - but am considering extra options. It may be I get a netbook once there's more choice as I'd like something to view photos as well and am put off by the astronomical price of the Epson P7000.
--
Lizzie
----------------------------------
http://www.lizzieshepherd.com
 
There seem to be more and more options, yet they're never easy to find in stores. Nevermind that; the online places and some larger brick and mortars do have a small selection.

I used a Wolverine FlashPac 7100 (100GB) for about a year. It is as simple as can be; put the card in it, turn it on, press copy, come back later. It's not very fast; about 5mb/sec, in my experience. But it works reliably, runs on batteries as well as AC, and is pretty compact.

Looking at the Wolverine Data website, I see that they have a slew of newer models available; some with a picture viewer, some without, all faster than my old FlashPac.

Now I have a Sanho Hyperdrive Colorspace O (SATA version). It has a 500GB drive in it, and a color screen for viewing photos. It's much, much faster than the Wolverine, though a little larger. Battery life seems better too.

My father has an Epson P-2000. The Epson P-n000 series (2000, 3000, 4000, 5000, etc) spans several model years, and a variety of capacities. These units rank among the most expensive in price per gigabyte of storage, but do offer playback of audio and video in addition to photos. They seem to have one of the better user interfaces.

At any rate, I'm very happy with my Hyperdrive Colorspace. With a fast memory card, it can download about 1GB per minute. It works as a normal USB hard drive when plugged into the computer. It also allows files to be read AND written to the memory cards, though it does not function as a card reader while plugged into the computer (apparently that would hamper the read/write speeds too much. If I could choose any drive, it would be either the Colorspace O, or the highest capacity Epson model, at about twice the price for half the capacity (an exaggeration, but not by much).
 
I have had an Epson P-2000 for 4 years and it was rock solid but slow, very slow and the battery died after transferring 12-16'ish GB of data. I could throw the card in and walk around while downloading without issue.

A month ago I picked up a Hyperdrive Colorspace and it was blazing fast and worked fine the first day but then on the 2nd day had some problems and by day 3 apparently the drive became corrupted. Luckily the internal OS worked and I was able to get my data off of it. I returned it.

Then a coupe of weeks ago I picked up a Nexto eXtreme and it is even faster downloading, no picture verfication like the Hyperdrive, which was pretty nice, but it does have a metal case. I did notice though that when I was transferring cards while on the go the copy would fail, some kind of OTG disconnect error. I had firmware v.1.03 and apperantly there is a firmware upgrade to 1.04 that is supposed to address that issue with certain hard drives. I performed the upgrade today, I should be able to test it tomorrow. If I still have the same problems I would say the Epson is worth every penny, as overpriced as it may seem.

Now if you're transfers will occur in a static environment then the Hyperdrive and Nexto are great. Hopefully this firmware upgrade will allow me to safely transfer with minor movement as the Sales person at mydigitaldiscount said.

--
Arnold
http://kensingt0n.smugmug.com
http://lindedin/in/arnoldsese
http://twitter.com/kensingt0n
http://spaces.msn.com/members/kensingt0n/
2002 WRB WRX Wagon :)
http://www.newschoolofphotography.com/forum/showpost.php?p=10468&postcount=22
 
I have gone through about a half a dozen portables over the past twelve years and while they have improved as have the cameras, I finally started carrying my laptop. The problem with the lap top is it is big and heavy, but I just found a solution. The Acer Aspire One. Weighs two pounds, has a 120 Gig HD one Gb of memory two card slots and a 8 1/2" screen. I can now download, view and edit images while on a trip. The computer is no biger than a hard cover book and cost less that some portable HD that allow viewing of RAW images.
http://www.alldigital.fotopic.net
--
Art
 
I agree - these mini laptops seem far better value than the likes of the Epsons but I've not actually tried looking at the screen on one - how good is the picture quality? There's a couple of new ones coming out soon from Lenovo and Fujitsu Siemens which sound interest. I would think using one of these in tandem with a portable hard drive and a non viewing storage device such as the Nexto (for extra/duplicate storage) would be a good bet.
--
Lizzie
----------------------------------
http://www.lizzieshepherd.com
 
one thing you might like to try, (slightly off in relevance) is, in addition to whatever hard drive you choose, try the following:

Burn DVDs of your shots as a backup, and mail the DVDs home to yourself. use hi capacity cards, thereby negating the need to erase/format cards until you and your images are safely backed up.

This of course, depends on you having facility/opportunity to burn DVDs- but in many areas now (at least in Oz- even in our booyong outback towns) one can find a computer available for public use.

I carry pre addressed, pre tabbed express mailers and packaging, and burn DVDs, send them home, don't erase ANYthing off ANY card, and back up a set to laptop and portable USB drive. Where possible, all sets of media are separated in different bags.

A bit pedantic yes I know, but we work too hard to get these images... so we do our darnedest to reduce the risk of loss, from every angle.

Cheers

Proshooter
--

LIFE is a 'long exposure'... and full of 'noise'. Wouldn't want it any other way!
 
Burn DVDs of your shots as a backup, and mail the DVDs home to
yourself. use hi capacity cards, thereby negating the need to
erase/format cards until you and your images are safely backed up.

This of course, depends on you having facility/opportunity to burn DVDs- but in > many areas now (at least in Oz- even in our booyong outback towns) one can > find a computer available for public use.
I am trepidatious about this avenue for one reason: I did this on a long trip through Spain, France, and Italy a few years ago, and I found the quality of internet cafes in all three countries to be abysmal. In most of them the staff wouldn't let you manage your own copying, they have to do it for you, and the workers rarely seem to know the first thing about their equipment. I got whole discs full of photos renamed and dumped into a single folder, workers who gave me three discs only a quarter full instead of one full disc (and charging me for all three) and -- the worst thing of all -- in almost every case they copied the pictures to the host computer before burning, where there were folders full of other people's photos. I got a couple stray pictures from previous patron's camera on mine, and I DEFINITELY don't want my pictures stored for infinity on some random computer elsewhere in the world. That experience was, in fact, my primary impetus for buying a portable drive solution (I got the Nexto, works well).

I'm not picking on Spain, France, and Italy here (I love all three countries!) -- I've been to cafes in the US where I saw the workers displaying the exact same incompetence towards tourists. With netbooks and portable drives so readily available now, the risk of my photos being mangled or stolen just isn't worth it.

David
 
David, I was amazed to read of your experiences with internet cafes!

I have never encountered the conditions you wrote about- and I too would hesitate using them in such a case.

Before I carried my laptop- before I owned one- I would plug my card reader in to someone's computer, burn the CD direct from the card, without storing the files in their computer- and that was "it".

I kept used cards in their plastic cases, safely packaged in seperate bags, and for really crucial photographic situations, I would shoot the same scene on two seperate cards, and store them seperately on the trip. (different bags)

I have read elsewhere, about tiny laptops- dunno whether or not they have a disc burning capacity- but either way, perhaps they provide another "pillar" in the support mechanism for your "backup beam".

I suppose it is a mobile version of an effective "base" backup system you are seeking here- 3 copies, 2 seperate "types" of storage (different media), and one copy offsite. We invest a lot in travel- and it's not just the money- though changes to technology in recent times make the prospect of safeguarding images MUCH easier than it was when I first started.

There is no more humidity/temp issues with film storage, x ray, risk of the rollfilm "un" rolling due to retaining band failure, it really IS much easier now.

Good Luck with your trip- safe travels to you AND your files!

Cheers

Proshooter
--

LIFE is a 'long exposure'... and full of 'noise'. Wouldn't want it any other way!
 
Hi

In analogue days, we used to carry many rolls of films...
In the digital world, I carry a handhul of CF cards...

I shoot raw+smallest jpeg and get 200+ pictures with my EOS 5D per 4GB CF Card.

At the end of the day, I review the pictures and delete the bad ones (whatever I consider a bad shot: blurred, unsharp or meaningless).

I recently spent 2 weeks in Japan and filled 3 cards (740 raw + 740 jpeg files)

This works well for me...

Greetings
Christian
 
I have three of them and they are super cheap and work great and are very fast. Up to 500 gigs today and many colors to choose from and even with firewire and usb if you need it (some models only)
--
George with the (big) rack
 
There is a difference in price. $350 and up for a netbook and around 100 bucks for a WD passport drive..
--
George with the (big) rack
 
Take a look at the New MemroyKick MediaCenter just made available from B&H Photo and Adorama. This is a ground breaking portable storage device that has more features than any other portable storage device on the market and will most likely replace Ipods, Epsons and other portable photo storage devices.

I have a 120GB model and I just gave my son a 30GB model for his 12th birthday and everyone that sees it wants one. It stores and plays photos, videos and music.

The built-in usb ports and card reader lets you share files without a computer with bi-directional file transport.

Isaac
 
Take a look at the New MemroyKick MediaCenter just made available
from B&H Photo and Adorama. This is a ground breaking portable
storage device that has more features than any other portable storage
device on the market and will most likely replace Ipods, Epsons and
other portable photo storage devices.
I have a 120GB model and I just gave my son a 30GB model for his 12th
birthday and everyone that sees it wants one. It stores and plays
photos, videos and music.
The built-in usb ports and card reader lets you share files without a
computer with bi-directional file transport.
Though its rated speed of 7MB/s for uploading images is on the slow side compared to the Nexto/Sanho (quoted at 25MB/s). I'm also not sure I would want to watch videos on a 2.2" screen.
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top