Do any 5D owners here use the Direct Print button?

Its RKM

Veteran Member
Messages
3,136
Solutions
1
Reaction score
305
Location
UK
The 5D has been around for 2 years now and is clearly scheduled for a facelift soon - there are more than a few wishlists on this forum as to what that facelift will bring.

However, in the 20 months that I have owned my 5D I have NEVER deliberately pressed the Direct Print button and it seems absurd that Canon dedicated such prime real-estate to what IMHO is an essentially useless function. It is especially galling when other useful functions are buried in custom menus.

I understand that Canon would like their camera owners to buy into their inkjet printers too, and the DP button is tailored for that, but that concept really belongs to movie spin-offs and toy stores. I would prefer a properly designed photographic tool rather than direct access function controls dedicated to mere marketing gimmickry.

Am I unusual in never using this prime level feature of the 5D?

If you own a 5D, do you use the Direct Print button on the 5D
a) all the time,
b) often,
c) occasionally,
d) tried it a couple of times for experimentation but never again, or
e) (like me) never at all except by accident.

I don't expect any of this to influence Canon one iota, however they must be doing their own market research and I doubt that the percentage breakdown will differ much from this forum in terms of this button's use. It will be interesting to compare the percentages in favour or against this 'feature' and compare that to whether Canon keep it on the 5DII.
 
--
Bryan

Canon five dee - twenty four to one oh five L IS and other bits left over from 20D
 
I have NEVER
deliberately pressed the Direct Print button and it seems absurd that
Canon dedicated such prime real-estate to what IMHO is an essentially
useless function.
The Direct Print button gives Canon a lockup on the circus/theme park/get-your picture-now business. As other segments slip through their fingers, that's the last button they will remove . . . .

joking aside, I am a 5d owner, I strangely enough I did think of the DP button as I was unpacking my new ipf5000 . . . and might give it a try for fun. Awesome printer.

Maybe all the smart designers were moved out of the dslr department to the printer division - hopefully they will come back for the 5d mkII and demand it includes a pro a/f system without any glitches . . .
 
--
Joe Sesto
 
Someone once posted here that PCs are not nearly as ubiquitous in Japan as they are here in the US. Therefore, most Japanese connect their cameras directly to a printer to print their pictures.

Dont know if that's true but it explains why Canon would dedicate valuable button space to it.

-dickm
 
The 5D has been around for 2 years now and is clearly scheduled for a
facelift soon - there are more than a few wishlists on this forum as
to what that facelift will bring.

However, in the 20 months that I have owned my 5D I have NEVER
deliberately pressed the Direct Print button and it seems absurd that
Canon dedicated such prime real-estate to what IMHO is an essentially
useless function. It is especially galling when other useful
functions are buried in custom menus.

I understand that Canon would like their camera owners to buy into
their inkjet printers too, and the DP button is tailored for that,
but that concept really belongs to movie spin-offs and toy stores. I
would prefer a properly designed photographic tool rather than direct
access function controls dedicated to mere marketing gimmickry.

Am I unusual in never using this prime level feature of the 5D?

If you own a 5D, do you use the Direct Print button on the 5D
a) all the time,
b) often,
c) occasionally,
d) tried it a couple of times for experimentation but never again, or
e) (like me) never at all except by accident.

I don't expect any of this to influence Canon one iota, however they
must be doing their own market research and I doubt that the
percentage breakdown will differ much from this forum in terms of
this button's use. It will be interesting to compare the percentages
in favour or against this 'feature' and compare that to whether Canon
keep it on the 5DII.
I have focusing set to the asterisk (star) button (C. Fn 4). This introduced a problem though: whenever I'm reviewing pictures and try to focus I just end up zooming out the preview image. This is fixed by setting C. Fn 18 to 1 so that pressing the asterisk button returns to shooting. So now to zoom out while previewing I have to hold down the print button while pressing the asterisk button.

So yes, i use it all the time. ;)

--
Whoever said 'a picture is worth a thousand words' was a cheapskate.

http://www.pbase.com/dot_borg
 
I'd like instant sensor maping on image review.
  • you could map dust or dead pix.
-add layers, or select and boost over/under exposed areas on following shot.
-push it again to reset.
great on 5d.
 
almost forgot it was there.. but then this post reminded me it is there.. being completely useless lol.
 
Was going to use it with a little Canon printer on holidays to save going to the local shop, but you have to have shot jpg or RAW+jpg to get anything out (took a while to find that out ...)

I only use RAW, so that idea bit the dust!

Keep the button, but make it user mappable to whatever they like.
 
Philip
 
Someone once posted here that PCs are not nearly as ubiquitous in
Japan as they are here in the US. Therefore, most Japanese connect
their cameras directly to a printer to print their pictures.

Dont know if that's true but it explains why Canon would dedicate
valuable button space to it.

-dickm
Believe it or not - Canon and all Japanese companies think very carefully about its home market :-) After all, it is only after being successful here in Japan, the world's second largest economy, they have the muscles to move to other markets. Yes, they've been at it for a long time and other markets are already there, but failure at home is to be avoided at all costs, and here we actually tap into the Japanese mentality and cultural thingy - something too long to go into here.

Anyway, in Japan, where I live, the largest agegroup of amateur photographers are retired SalariMan - who have the cash - the passion - but not nessecerily the PC skills for processing (although they will know how to handle Excel Spread sheets ;-). In fact, they were literally the target group in Japan for the 5D, and they sure responded well to its release.

Go anywhere and you will see them move in groups, photo west, a tripod, 5D and 24-105IS !!! Now, why they want to take the tripod with them with all the fine IS technology I have no idea, but we're touching again on cultural thingy here...

So, to get an end to this long story, this target group is in fact the one that Canon is building the button into the body for. Plugin, push the button and print.

Personally I see nothing wrong with the button being there - but then again - I don't ever use it :-)

cheers
gislisnaer
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top