How weather sealed is the 1DmkII?

...has sat in the pouring rain for 5 hours during O-ring testing.
Let me see if I understand the train of thought here...you spend thousands of your hard earned dollars on equipment designed to take photographs and then you sit out in the rain for 5 hours just to see if it lets water in?

Don't you have better things to do with your time? ;^)

If it had leaked then what?

Sent it back to Canon and spend yet more money to replace/repair it because it wouldn't be covered under warranty?

Have I missed the point here?

Even if I bought a cheap umbrella I wouldn't dream of sitting out in the rain for 5 hours just to see if it let water in... ;^)

Kind regards,
-=Glyn=-
 
I've had my 20D in spitting rain and also in the heavy mist of Niagara Falls with no issues. I haven't had my 1DIIN out in any inclement weather yet, but not out of fear just lack of shooting time.
 
So, which rain covers do people like/dislike?

Rick
I have a couple of the generic Hong Kong made rain covers that I got from ebay ... they are a padded nylon form fitted case which basically covers the whole DSLR body and lens and secures onto it with Velcro ... there is elastic where the lens goes through, and usually an elastic "sleeve" that you can insert your arm into on the right side of the case so you can operate the camera controls ... the ones I have also have a clear window on the back and top where the camera displays are

these generic ones aren't bad for the money, and they DO work to keep your gear dry ... they are also useful for shooting in an area where you don't want the camera to make any noise because they absorb all of the camera sounds ... kind of like a blimp – to be honest, I don’t have anything bad to say about the generic ones, but you get what you pay for

Here are the 2 non-Kata covers that I got ( http://cgi.ebay.com/Camera-Rain-Protector-cover-for-Sony-Canon-Nikon-KM-C5C_W0QQitemZ200134229544QQcmdZViewItem?hash=item200134229544 )

One thing about the generic ones, I haven't found any of them that have a provision for a flash

However, I also have a Kata 702 ( http://www.amazon.com/Kata-E-702-Digital-Camera-Raincover/dp/B0001VB1QU )

With the Kata 704 lens cover ( http://www.amazon.com/Kata-E-704-Lens-Sleeve-Kit/dp/B0001VB1X8/ref=pd_bxgy_p_text_b/103-7618497-6185456 )

and the Kata covers are just the nicest ones that are made that I know of ... but you will pay a little more for them

I don't think that the Kata system actually keeps out the water any better than the cheap HK covers, but they are a lot nicer to use and it gives you a much better view of the camera displays and controls … the quality and fit differences are obvious though, and you can tell that these are a higher quality item

If I had it to do all over again, I would have just bought 3 of the Kata 702/704 systems instead of what I have now just because they are so much nicer to use (and you CAN use a flash with the Kata cover) ... the Kata covers are easier to install/uninstall, and just seem like they are built to a higher standard, which I'm sure they are

----> One thing I will say in favor of the Hong Kong no-name brand covers … they are REALLY nice to have in the winter – they provide a lot of thermal insulation where the Kata doesn’t … so, when shooting in the nasty Minnesota winters, I’m happy to have the HK covers when it gets insanely cold – it really helps out with battery life and condensation

Kata makes all of the covers for the video gear for the Discovery channel, History channel and other documentary shooting in harsh environments, they are pretty much the 'standard' in weather covers for professional photographic and video equipment

Watch what you’re buying though, there are quite a few ebay auctions listing rain covers called ‘702’ and 704’ that are NOT Kata … it’s a rip-off brand that looks like a Kata, but isn’t made by them … I've never seen one, or used one of these, and to be fair, they might be just as good as the genuine Kata, but I wouldn’t take that chance

Kata is right up there in line with Lowepro and Tamrac – it’s a huge company that you will be able to count on if any problems arise – it’s not some no-name HK company that will go out of business next week and then pop up again under a different name the week after that … as usual with Hong Kong stuff, Caveat Emptor
 
1D newb question here, assuming there is a weather sealed lens on a 1
series body, how wet can the combo get?

I am coming from a 20D and 5D and would NEVER dare get a drop of rain
on them. So what is reasonable for a 1 series camera?

--
http://www.pbase.com/anerino
Its pretty weather sealed BUT regardless you are always taking a chance when you get a camera wet. Its a gamble no matter how you look at it...so tqhe question is, do you feel lucky??
 
So, which rain covers do people like/dislike?

Rick
Safeway plastic bag with hole cut in the bottom for the lens. Cheap
(free) and easy to carry.

--
jerryk.smugmug.com
I'll second that one as well ... That's excellent advice that everyone can, and should, easily follow

I carry a couple of garbage bags and a handful of rubber bands in each of my camera cases as well ... Rip a small hole in it for the lens, and start wrapping rubber bands around it to secure the bag to the camera - Iit works great and keeps your camera dry

Sometimes a little protection can mean the difference between saving and drowning your camera ... The garbage bag thing might not be as nice to use or pretty as a dedicated cover, but it will work in a pinch, and takes up almost no room in your bag
 
I think you are babying your cameras. I have gotten rain on my EOS
650, 20D, and 5D numerous times with no ill effects. I was just
shooting in the rain for about 20 minutes with my 5D the a few weeks
ago. These cameras will last longer in the rain than I do. I hate
getting wet and constantly wiping off the lens is a pain.

--
jerryk.smugmug.com
--My 5D lasted less than a minute in a hard downpour. I was protecting it, but when I tried take a shot, it was TKOed.
Didn't even get the image.

Saw the LCD go funny, immediately powered it off, pulled the battery, and toweled it down.
Took it to a nice warm, dry place...
An hour or two later it was fine.

-nothing beats a fast lense, except a fast girl-
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top