Paul Pope - Is D1X better than 1D ??

  • Thread starter Thread starter jim kelly
  • Start date Start date
J

jim kelly

Guest
Although your recent 1D beach pics are - well - appreciated : ) to say the least. But couldn't you have taken these pics with equal image quality using the D1X ?? How much better is Canon's IS versus Nikon's VR and how much better is Canon's USM versus Nikon's AFS ??
 
I am not Paul, but I have owned and shot with both, the af of the Nikon lenses even the afs are just not as fast, getting close though so I am not saying that Nikons are bad. The canon IS technology has been around for a long time vs nikons more recent use.
Although your recent 1D beach pics are - well - appreciated : ) to
say the least. But couldn't you have taken these pics with equal
image quality using the D1X ?? How much better is Canon's IS versus
Nikon's VR and how much better is Canon's USM versus Nikon's AFS ??
 
Errrr.... The EOS 1D is SO MUCH better then the D1x that 8it isn't funny.
Nikons AFS and VR simply are not in the same class as Canon's USM and IS lenses.
Although your recent 1D beach pics are - well - appreciated : ) to
say the least. But couldn't you have taken these pics with equal
image quality using the D1X ?? How much better is Canon's IS versus
Nikon's VR and how much better is Canon's USM versus Nikon's AFS ??
 
Paul, he's asking specifically about image quality, not how the cameras work.
Although your recent 1D beach pics are - well - appreciated : ) to
say the least. But couldn't you have taken these pics with equal
image quality using the D1X ?? How much better is Canon's IS versus
Nikon's VR and how much better is Canon's USM versus Nikon's AFS ??
 
Al,

Reread the second question:

"How much better is Canon's IS versus Nikon's VR and how much better is Canon's USM versus Nikon's AFS ?? "

Jim
Although your recent 1D beach pics are - well - appreciated : ) to
say the least. But couldn't you have taken these pics with equal
image quality using the D1X ?? How much better is Canon's IS versus
Nikon's VR and how much better is Canon's USM versus Nikon's AFS ??
 
Hi, I have in front of me three 30x40" blow ups from the D30, I have printed dozens this large and have been impressed with everyone so far. I have created my own actions in PS6.0 to upsample that i find better then Bicubic and maybe better then GF as well. I usually print off of 311 MB files, so my one question to you is can the 1D deliver the same quality file and smooth blow up potential as the D30 has, I know the value of the 1V body I still have two 1VHS's that are sitting unused for over a year, but what about the final image quality? I keep hearing about banding, I sometimes see a sharp (grainlike) quality that may begin to pixelate at large blow ups like the D1 and even some D1x files I have played with. At the moment I am only shooting D30 and hassy slides, 35mm is a dead format for me, but should I be buying the 1D or waiting for the next alternative? have you any examples shot of the same subject under the same conditions from both?

Stephen
http://www.nyphotographics.com

Just one of the blow ups


Although your recent 1D beach pics are - well - appreciated : ) to
say the least. But couldn't you have taken these pics with equal
image quality using the D1X ?? How much better is Canon's IS versus
Nikon's VR and how much better is Canon's USM versus Nikon's AFS ??
 
Stephen:

Couple of questons.

1. Where do you get your prints made? What printer is used and what do they charge for the prints.

2. Any chance you'd share your action, or at least talk about how you accomplish it? I have GF, but one problem is many of the commercial labs don't support stn file types...

Thanks
Stephen
http://www.nyphotographics.com

Just one of the blow ups


Although your recent 1D beach pics are - well - appreciated : ) to
say the least. But couldn't you have taken these pics with equal
image quality using the D1X ?? How much better is Canon's IS versus
Nikon's VR and how much better is Canon's USM versus Nikon's AFS ??
 
Luminous Landscape wrote a terrific review of the 1D, and included several comparison photos from the D30. It's here:
http://www.luminous-landscape.com/1d-review.htm

His findings were, in a nutshell: If you can afford it, shoot sports, need the better AF, write speed and buffer, the 1D is a slam-dunk. Get it. Also, at high ISO's the 1D has far less pixelation.

The image quality is better on the 1D, but on the order of 20%, not incredible improvement. The upgrade probably wouldn't be worth it on image quality alone.

Also, the 1D has a lot more trouble with getting the sensor dirty, and battery consumption is an issue. As we all know, the D30 battery consumption rate is by far the best of any camera made at any price.
Hi, I have in front of me three 30x40" blow ups from the D30, I
have printed dozens this large and have been impressed with
everyone so far. I have created my own actions in PS6.0 to
upsample that i find better then Bicubic and maybe better then GF
as well. I usually print off of 311 MB files, so my one question
to you is can the 1D deliver the same quality file and smooth blow
up potential as the D30 has, I know the value of the 1V body I
still have two 1VHS's that are sitting unused for over a year, but
what about the final image quality? I keep hearing about banding,
I sometimes see a sharp (grainlike) quality that may begin to
pixelate at large blow ups like the D1 and even some D1x files I
have played with. At the moment I am only shooting D30 and hassy
slides, 35mm is a dead format for me, but should I be buying the
1D or waiting for the next alternative? have you any examples shot
of the same subject under the same conditions from both?
 
Hello, first I will say that i use an Epson 10000 and another Epson archival printer (not sure what number) I usually use http://www.epixel.com they are local and always do a great job, there print prices are the sum of the sides of your prints in dollars so the 30x40" is $70.00 if you want it on canvas or linen I think it is the sum of the sides times 1.5 in dollars.

I have uploaded the actions (avtually one is to 100 megs one is to 311 megs and one is for exxcellent 9x12'S which is the standard format I use for model portfolios) The link below will let you download the action usually to adobe> photoshop6.0> presets> photoshopactions its called myinterpolation2a.atn you can change the name, the indeivdual actions say to 100megs, to 300megs and to 9x12 all are at 300dpi and all are based on an original d30 file either full frame or cropped to 9x12 proportionally. I would warn that these actions take a while depending on the speed of your system, also they are purging the history a few times throughout to save space and time, and i would reccommend that you do this as the almost last step after merging to only one layer (mulitiple layers at 311 megs is a very large file to deal with) you should do everything ecept sharpen before running these actions, the 9x12 actually does oversize then blur the pixels then sharpen and reduce size but the others do no sharpening at all so as to leave the final amount of sharpening up to the individual picture. Hope they work well for you all.

If you have any questions feel free to email me through the site or this forum.

http://www.nyphotographics.com/dpreview/myinterpolation2a.atn

Stephen
http://www.nyphotographics.com
Just another one of the blow ups

Couple of questons.

1. Where do you get your prints made? What printer is used and
what do they charge for the prints.

2. Any chance you'd share your action, or at least talk about how
you accomplish it? I have GF, but one problem is many of the
commercial labs don't support stn file types...

Thanks
Hi, I have in front of me three 30x40" blow ups from the D30, I
have printed dozens this large and have been impressed with
everyone so far. I have created my own actions in PS6.0 to
upsample that i find better then Bicubic and maybe better then GF
as well. I usually print off of 311 MB files, so my one question
to you is can the 1D deliver the same quality file and smooth blow
up potential as the D30 has, I know the value of the 1V body I
still have two 1VHS's that are sitting unused for over a year, but
what about the final image quality? I keep hearing about banding,
I sometimes see a sharp (grainlike) quality that may begin to
pixelate at large blow ups like the D1 and even some D1x files I
have played with. At the moment I am only shooting D30 and hassy
slides, 35mm is a dead format for me, but should I be buying the
1D or waiting for the next alternative? have you any examples shot
of the same subject under the same conditions from both?

Stephen
http://www.nyphotographics.com

Just one of the blow ups

Although your recent 1D beach pics are - well - appreciated : ) to
say the least. But couldn't you have taken these pics with equal
image quality using the D1X ?? How much better is Canon's IS versus
Nikon's VR and how much better is Canon's USM versus Nikon's AFS ??
 
I appreciate your help. By the way, this photo is stunning, to say nothing of the model...
I have uploaded the actions (avtually one is to 100 megs one is to
311 megs and one is for exxcellent 9x12'S which is the standard
format I use for model portfolios) The link below will let you
download the action usually to
adobe> photoshop6.0> presets> photoshopactions its called
myinterpolation2a.atn you can change the name, the indeivdual
actions say to 100megs, to 300megs and to 9x12 all are at 300dpi
and all are based on an original d30 file either full frame or
cropped to 9x12 proportionally. I would warn that these actions
take a while depending on the speed of your system, also they are
purging the history a few times throughout to save space and time,
and i would reccommend that you do this as the almost last step
after merging to only one layer (mulitiple layers at 311 megs is a
very large file to deal with) you should do everything ecept
sharpen before running these actions, the 9x12 actually does
oversize then blur the pixels then sharpen and reduce size but the
others do no sharpening at all so as to leave the final amount of
sharpening up to the individual picture. Hope they work well for
you all.

If you have any questions feel free to email me through the site or
this forum.

http://www.nyphotographics.com/dpreview/myinterpolation2a.atn

Stephen
http://www.nyphotographics.com
Couple of questons.

1. Where do you get your prints made? What printer is used and
what do they charge for the prints.

2. Any chance you'd share your action, or at least talk about how
you accomplish it? I have GF, but one problem is many of the
commercial labs don't support stn file types...

Thanks
Hi, I have in front of me three 30x40" blow ups from the D30, I
have printed dozens this large and have been impressed with
everyone so far. I have created my own actions in PS6.0 to
upsample that i find better then Bicubic and maybe better then GF
as well. I usually print off of 311 MB files, so my one question
to you is can the 1D deliver the same quality file and smooth blow
up potential as the D30 has, I know the value of the 1V body I
still have two 1VHS's that are sitting unused for over a year, but
what about the final image quality? I keep hearing about banding,
I sometimes see a sharp (grainlike) quality that may begin to
pixelate at large blow ups like the D1 and even some D1x files I
have played with. At the moment I am only shooting D30 and hassy
slides, 35mm is a dead format for me, but should I be buying the
1D or waiting for the next alternative? have you any examples shot
of the same subject under the same conditions from both?

Stephen
http://www.nyphotographics.com

Just one of the blow ups

Although your recent 1D beach pics are - well - appreciated : ) to
say the least. But couldn't you have taken these pics with equal
image quality using the D1X ?? How much better is Canon's IS versus
Nikon's VR and how much better is Canon's USM versus Nikon's AFS ??
 
Although your recent 1D beach pics are - well - appreciated : ) to
say the least. But couldn't you have taken these pics with equal
image quality using the D1X ?? How much better is Canon's IS versus
Nikon's VR and how much better is Canon's USM versus Nikon's AFS ??
The more I use my EOS 1D the more amazed I am, there truly is no equal!
 
The 1D KILLS ...I REPEAT KILLS the D1x for image quality especialy if RAW files are converted in Linear mode.
The 1D using Genuine Fractels has no problems prinitng a 24x36 poster the
D1x color,saturation and pure raw information per pixel is not up to the 1D.
Although your recent 1D beach pics are - well - appreciated : ) to
say the least. But couldn't you have taken these pics with equal
image quality using the D1X ?? How much better is Canon's IS versus
Nikon's VR and how much better is Canon's USM versus Nikon's AFS ??
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top