G2 CF or microdrive

andrew baker

New member
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
Location
US
I m a new and unsophisticated owner of the G2. I know I will need more memory.

Should I buy a type I or II CF - or a microdrive. [Was leaning to a 256 CF] If CF (as opposed to microdrive), does it matter which of the many manufacturers?

Thanks!
 
I have a 340 IBM microdrive for my S30 and it works alright.

For some reason I've gotten CF Card errors 3 times over past 2 weeks.

I like the idea of having 340 megs instead of 256.

I got my for $130 with a mpsuperstore scam.

I wonder if G2 owners would get the same odd error.

When I get the error, if I remove the microdrive and reinsert it, it goes away.

I haven't gotten the error in 3 days.--.: Rick James
 
I m a new and unsophisticated owner of the G2. I know I will need
more memory.

Should I buy a type I or II CF - or a microdrive. [Was leaning to
a 256 CF] If CF (as opposed to microdrive), does it matter which
of the many manufacturers?
I went with a 256MB CF over the microdrives for the following reasons:

1) first digital camera, didn't know how much space I actually needed.
2) 256MB CF was cheaper
3) microdrives have moving parts
4) microdrives are slower

I have found that for my needs at the moment the 256 is enough, though I am getting close to the limit (haven taken at most 100 pictures mixed JPEG/some RAW). If I find that I need to go up I'll either get another 256 or go to 512 and use current 256 as a backup.
 
First, DO NOT GET a 170MB or 340MB Microdrive. These are IBM's first version, and you will get a lot of CF errors. They are annoying and you can loose pictures.

The 512MB and 1GB versions are newer and don't seem to have this problem. My friend uses a 1GB drive in his D30 and he has never seen a CF error.

I was fed up with my 340MB microdrive, but I couldn't afford the 1GB one, so I went with a 256MB CF from http://www.newegg.com for $90. Works great.

--Bill
I m a new and unsophisticated owner of the G2. I know I will need
more memory.

Should I buy a type I or II CF - or a microdrive. [Was leaning to
a 256 CF] If CF (as opposed to microdrive), does it matter which
of the many manufacturers?

Thanks!
 
Rick,

I had the same problem with the 340Mb and ended up returning it. It scared me when sometimes not even pulling it out and reinserting would solve. I got the "No images" in the display and after powering the camera on and off a couple of times it would work again. I don't think this is normal, you should try to talk to the IBM tech support.
Herbet.
I have a 340 IBM microdrive for my S30 and it works alright.

For some reason I've gotten CF Card errors 3 times over past 2 weeks.

I like the idea of having 340 megs instead of 256.

I got my for $130 with a mpsuperstore scam.

I wonder if G2 owners would get the same odd error.

When I get the error, if I remove the microdrive and reinsert it,
it goes away.

I haven't gotten the error in 3 days.
--

.: Rick James
 
The only strong reason I have heard NOT to buy a microdrive is that they can't be used over 10,000 ft- so you won't be able to take it on your fourteener climbs. But if you plan on staying closer to sea level, go for it.
I m a new and unsophisticated owner of the G2. I know I will need
more memory.

Should I buy a type I or II CF - or a microdrive. [Was leaning to
a 256 CF] If CF (as opposed to microdrive), does it matter which
of the many manufacturers?

Thanks!
 
I haven't yet bought a digital camera, but here's a slightly different perspective: Since I think one of the big advantages to digital is the flexibility of storage, I'm planning on probably using 2 or 3 128 or 256 MB CF's - with different sorts of shooting, and specific projects on each one. Just like we used to use floppies in our computers!

OTOH, are 1GB microdrives partitionable? Or can you at least store in folders?

--Ken Durling
 
Hi,

I have been using a 340Mb microdrive in an S10 for about 18months. I recently got a G2. The microdrive has worked fine upto now, about 1000 pictures in 6 weeks. No errors. I will soon get a 1Gb microdrive specifically for the G2.

Mike
The 512MB and 1GB versions are newer and don't seem to have this
problem. My friend uses a 1GB drive in his D30 and he has never
seen a CF error.

I was fed up with my 340MB microdrive, but I couldn't afford the
1GB one, so I went with a 256MB CF from http://www.newegg.com for $90.
Works great.

--Bill
I m a new and unsophisticated owner of the G2. I know I will need
more memory.

Should I buy a type I or II CF - or a microdrive. [Was leaning to
a 256 CF] If CF (as opposed to microdrive), does it matter which
of the many manufacturers?

Thanks!
 
Hey Bill,

How fast (write speed) is your 256 card from newegg? I checked out the website, could not find this info. I believe the brand name is Mr. Flash. If you don't know the write speed, can you tell me if it seems reasonably fast or slow for both writing and playback. The $90 price is very good, what is the shipping cost or tax if any? Thanks!

Casey
The 512MB and 1GB versions are newer and don't seem to have this
problem. My friend uses a 1GB drive in his D30 and he has never
seen a CF error.

I was fed up with my 340MB microdrive, but I couldn't afford the
1GB one, so I went with a 256MB CF from http://www.newegg.com for $90.
Works great.

--Bill
I m a new and unsophisticated owner of the G2. I know I will need
more memory.

Should I buy a type I or II CF - or a microdrive. [Was leaning to
a 256 CF] If CF (as opposed to microdrive), does it matter which
of the many manufacturers?

Thanks!
--Casey
 
I m a new and unsophisticated owner of the G2. I know I will need
more memory.

Should I buy a type I or II CF - or a microdrive. [Was leaning to
a 256 CF] If CF (as opposed to microdrive), does it matter which
of the many manufacturers?
I went with a 256MB CF over the microdrives for the following reasons:

1) first digital camera, didn't know how much space I actually needed.
2) 256MB CF was cheaper
3) microdrives have moving parts
4) microdrives are slower

I have found that for my needs at the moment the 256 is enough,
though I am getting close to the limit (haven taken at most 100
pictures mixed JPEG/some RAW). If I find that I need to go up I'll
either get another 256 or go to 512 and use current 256 as a backup.
How much faster is the 256mb cf than for example the 1gig ibm microdrive?
Randy
 
I actually don't have the times myself, but I had done some slight research and the upshot was that the MD was slower (in some cases not so much, in others more; depending on camera). The big item for me was price and the fact that its a moving part. I think the newer versions are getting faster and the price has come down quite a bit.
How much faster is the 256mb cf than for example the 1gig ibm
microdrive?
 
That's interesting. If pressue is the issue,then I guess I couldn't use a MICRODIVE in the underwater camera I'm getting - either G2 or CP5000.

Have you heard of any issues underwater?

Thanks
Joe
I m a new and unsophisticated owner of the G2. I know I will need
more memory.

Should I buy a type I or II CF - or a microdrive. [Was leaning to
a 256 CF] If CF (as opposed to microdrive), does it matter which
of the many manufacturers?

Thanks!
 
I'd be interested as well - this is an incredible deal.

BTW - the home page for Mr. Flash is:

http://www.mrflashusa.com/product_cf.html

Unfortunately, not much more data available there.

Tom
How fast (write speed) is your 256 card from newegg? I checked out
the website, could not find this info. I believe the brand name is
Mr. Flash. If you don't know the write speed, can you tell me if
it seems reasonably fast or slow for both writing and playback.
The $90 price is very good, what is the shipping cost or tax if
any? Thanks!

Casey
The 512MB and 1GB versions are newer and don't seem to have this
problem. My friend uses a 1GB drive in his D30 and he has never
seen a CF error.

I was fed up with my 340MB microdrive, but I couldn't afford the
1GB one, so I went with a 256MB CF from http://www.newegg.com for $90.
Works great.

--Bill
I m a new and unsophisticated owner of the G2. I know I will need
more memory.

Should I buy a type I or II CF - or a microdrive. [Was leaning to
a 256 CF] If CF (as opposed to microdrive), does it matter which
of the many manufacturers?

Thanks!
--
Casey
 
I bought a 256MB CF Mr Flash from newegg.com for my Nikon 775. Inexpensive and it worked well. A twist of fate bestowed the G2--with 1 gig microdrive--and the S40 on me. Again, no problems with the G2/microdrive. I put the 256 mr flash into the S40. All works well—so far. I'm a casual shooter—with some experience—and I notice nothing concerning speed of the CF or microdrive.
 
Take a look at Phill's review

http://www.dpreview.com/articles/mediacompare/
I have been using a 340Mb microdrive in an S10 for about 18months.
I recently got a G2. The microdrive has worked fine upto now,
about 1000 pictures in 6 weeks. No errors. I will soon get a 1Gb
microdrive specifically for the G2.

Mike
The 512MB and 1GB versions are newer and don't seem to have this
problem. My friend uses a 1GB drive in his D30 and he has never
seen a CF error.

I was fed up with my 340MB microdrive, but I couldn't afford the
1GB one, so I went with a 256MB CF from http://www.newegg.com for $90.
Works great.

--Bill
I m a new and unsophisticated owner of the G2. I know I will need
more memory.

Should I buy a type I or II CF - or a microdrive. [Was leaning to
a 256 CF] If CF (as opposed to microdrive), does it matter which
of the many manufacturers?

Thanks!
 
I went for the 256 CF Kingston from Buy.com.

It is fast, and has a $20 rebate through the end of the month.

It will take plenty of pictures in capacity, I usually download to computer fairly often.
 
Thanks, for this link. I had never read this. The Kingston 256mb looks good and fast and someone posted a link a few days ago, thru Dell, where you could get this for around $90.00. For moving parts and for still good speed with 1 gig space, the ibm looks nice also. Thanks again for posting Phil's article on this.
Randy
I have been using a 340Mb microdrive in an S10 for about 18months.
I recently got a G2. The microdrive has worked fine upto now,
about 1000 pictures in 6 weeks. No errors. I will soon get a 1Gb
microdrive specifically for the G2.

Mike
The 512MB and 1GB versions are newer and don't seem to have this
problem. My friend uses a 1GB drive in his D30 and he has never
seen a CF error.

I was fed up with my 340MB microdrive, but I couldn't afford the
1GB one, so I went with a 256MB CF from http://www.newegg.com for $90.
Works great.

--Bill
I m a new and unsophisticated owner of the G2. I know I will need
more memory.

Should I buy a type I or II CF - or a microdrive. [Was leaning to
a 256 CF] If CF (as opposed to microdrive), does it matter which
of the many manufacturers?

Thanks!
 
Both the D-Store and Googlegear.com have the IBM 1 GB drive for about $271. Not a bad price
Thanks, for this link. I had never read this. The Kingston 256mb
looks good and fast and someone posted a link a few days ago, thru
Dell, where you could get this for around $90.00. For moving parts
and for still good speed with 1 gig space, the ibm looks nice also.
Thanks again for posting Phil's article on this.
Randy
I have been using a 340Mb microdrive in an S10 for about 18months.
I recently got a G2. The microdrive has worked fine upto now,
about 1000 pictures in 6 weeks. No errors. I will soon get a 1Gb
microdrive specifically for the G2.

Mike
The 512MB and 1GB versions are newer and don't seem to have this
problem. My friend uses a 1GB drive in his D30 and he has never
seen a CF error.

I was fed up with my 340MB microdrive, but I couldn't afford the
1GB one, so I went with a 256MB CF from http://www.newegg.com for $90.
Works great.

--Bill
I m a new and unsophisticated owner of the G2. I know I will need
more memory.

Should I buy a type I or II CF - or a microdrive. [Was leaning to
a 256 CF] If CF (as opposed to microdrive), does it matter which
of the many manufacturers?

Thanks!
 
Re your storage needs, you would need to establish how often
you normally download into a digital wallet or computer, if price
or storage space present questions for you.

If you can download frequently, you might want to go with CF
cards.

If you expect to make trips afar, vacations, etc with no
downloading capabilities, I would go with the incredible storage
on microdrives, where you can store 500+images on the G2 and
m/d combination.

I have used 340Mb and 1Gb m/d's for a while with absolutely NO
problems. Their capacity makes you absolutely fearless in your
image-capturing, nothing escapes !! I love 'em !!

Re the altitude comment, I was in Switzerland during the summer
and used both m/d's up to 13,000 ft in the Alps, with nothing
amiss. The m/d relies on air within the moving parts, hence the
warnings not to use it above 10,000 ft. There is a cumulative
effect on the moving parts when constantly used at altitude. The
occasional trip to the roof of the world is probably OK :-)

Disadvantages to the m/d are :

slightly longer write-time (almost unnoticeable in normal life).

slightly greater power drain on batteries.

The invisible risk of having 500+ images on a m/d and dropping
it into a river forever :-(

So, if you are now completely confused, join the club :-)

I use both m/d's and CF cards happily. The m/d's are good for
photographic time away from home without downloading
opportunities. The CF cards are fine for day-to-day stuff when
you can download every night ...

What should you do ?
Get a small capacity CF card, say 64 Mb, good for perhaps
30 images. Also, get a 1Gb type II m/d for your heavy duty
shoots/trips, etc.

Good Luck,
Keith
 
The problem is that the microdrive, like all hard drives, has a head that floats on a thin cushion of air (just a few molecules). So at high altitudes, less air, not enough to float the head, head crashes. I don't think it would be a problem using it underwater--assuming you are planning on putting the camera in an underwater housing ;0
Have you heard of any issues underwater?

Thanks
Joe
The only strong reason I have heard NOT to buy a microdrive is that
they can't be used over 10,000 ft- so you won't be able to take it
on your fourteener climbs. But if you plan on staying closer to sea
level, go for it.
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top