Kate

Andreas P. · Dec 14, 2001

Hi,

(I posted the same in the S&G forum but it might be interesting here too, because one was taken with the F707)

Which one do you like more? (Personally i prefer number one).

BTW: Taken with 2 different cameras

Regards,

Andreas

Homer40784 · Dec 14, 2001

Well I prefer #2.
Reason- Skin tone appears more realistic. Lighting seems more natural.

Homer

Andreas P. said:
Hi,

(I posted the same in the S&G forum but it might be interesting
here too, because one was taken with the F707)

Which one do you like more? (Personally i prefer number one).

BTW: Taken with 2 different cameras

Regards,

Andreas

Willyee · Dec 14, 2001

I prefer the colors on pic #2. But I don't like the softness in either picture.

Picture #1 looks just a wee tad sharper than #2. Overall the colors in #2 draw me more to it. I realize that for portraits some folks like it slightly blurry to not show skin defects... but I am a perfectionist and want it sharp and clear. :-}

Willyee.

Andreas P. said:
Hi,

(I posted the same in the S&G forum but it might be interesting
here too, because one was taken with the F707)

Which one do you like more? (Personally i prefer number one).

BTW: Taken with 2 different cameras

Regards,

Andreas

Dominic L · Dec 14, 2001

I like both photos. Great Job Andreas! I think # 2 was taken with the 707.
Dom Liberoni

Willyee said:
Willyee.

Andreas P. said:

Hi,

(I posted the same in the S&G forum but it might be interesting
here too, because one was taken with the F707)

Which one do you like more? (Personally i prefer number one).

BTW: Taken with 2 different cameras

Regards,

Andreas

Click to expand...

Ulysses · Dec 14, 2001

Andreas P. said:
Hi,

(I posted the same in the S&G forum but it might be interesting
here too, because one was taken with the F707)

Which one do you like more? (Personally i prefer number one).

Heheheheh.... this is pretty funny.

I think you're going to have a lot of surprised people guessing on this one. Nice work.

And my complements to your lovely model. She is still very patient with you.

-- Ulysses

Homer40784 · Dec 14, 2001

Surprised?
I pick the one I like.

If it was taken with a pinhole camera. so what? ........shrugs shoulders and ambles away......

Homer

Ulysses said:
Andreas P. said:

Hi,

(I posted the same in the S&G forum but it might be interesting
here too, because one was taken with the F707)

Which one do you like more? (Personally i prefer number one).

Click to expand...

Heheheheh.... this is pretty funny.

I think you're going to have a lot of surprised people guessing on
this one. Nice work.

And my complements to your lovely model. She is still very patient
with you.
--

Ulysses

Ulysses · Dec 14, 2001

Homer said:
Surprised?
I pick the one I like.

Talking about those that are guessing which cameras were used.

You and me can stick with our pinhole cameras and be quite happy.

)-- Ulysses

You Wish · Dec 14, 2001

There's hardly any guessing to be done, The first one was shot with a D30 and the second is the DA.

Ulysses said:
Andreas P. said:

Hi,

(I posted the same in the S&G forum but it might be interesting
here too, because one was taken with the F707)

Which one do you like more? (Personally i prefer number one).

Click to expand...

Heheheheh.... this is pretty funny.

I think you're going to have a lot of surprised people guessing on
this one. Nice work.

And my complements to your lovely model. She is still very patient
with you.
--

Ulysses

Andreas P. · Dec 15, 2001

Hi Homer!

Homer40784 said:
Well I prefer #2.
Reason- Skin tone appears more realistic. Lighting seems more natural.

I guess the differences here were caused by WB and/or used lens.

Regards,

Andreas

Andreas P. · Dec 15, 2001

Willyee,

Willyee said:
I prefer the colors on pic #2. But I don't like the softness in
either picture.
Picture #1 looks just a wee tad sharper than #2. Overall the colors
in #2 draw me more to it. I realize that for portraits some folks
like it slightly blurry to not show skin defects... but I am a
perfectionist and want it sharp and clear. :-}

Of course tastes are differents, generally i prefer sharp pictures too. Here

i think (for my taste) soft is better. Both picture are not retouched, except cropping and resizing. The F707 version were taken with internal camera sharpening set to -2.

Regards,

Andreas

Andreas P. · Dec 15, 2001

Dominic,

Thanks for your input. And you are correct, the second is the DA shot (EXIF header intact).

Regards,

Andreas

Andreas P. · Dec 15, 2001

Ulysses,

Generally i am the impatient one

The EXIF headers are intact so it should not be difficult.

Regards,

Andreas

Andreas P. · Dec 15, 2001

You Wish said:
There's hardly any guessing to be done, The first one was shot with
a D30 and the second is the DA.

Yes, this is correct!

Regards,

Andreas

Ulysses · Dec 15, 2001

Andreas P. said:
Ulysses,

Generally i am the impatient one
The EXIF headers are intact so it should not be difficult.

It's still surprising how many did not check.

... or double-check your post in the S&G forum. -- Ulysses

Search

Kate

Andreas P.

Veteran Member

Homer40784

Senior Member

Willyee

Leading Member

Dominic L

Member

Ulysses

Guest

Homer40784

Senior Member

Ulysses

Guest

You Wish

Senior Member

Andreas P.

Veteran Member

Andreas P.

Veteran Member

Andreas P.

Veteran Member

Andreas P.

Veteran Member

Andreas P.

Veteran Member

Ulysses

Guest

Keyboard shortcuts