Sick of Manufacturer's Ink Scam....

seanmcr6

Senior Member
Messages
1,614
Reaction score
0
Location
Quinte West, CA
ok, I know that the manufacturer's make their money off the ink, not the printers...at least not at the low end. I can understand that, but their practice of making things overly expensive for consumers is driving me nuts.

I don't think separate ink cartridges saves us any money at all...as all the users I've spoken to, from multiple manufacturers, use ink at the saem rate. Of course they can engineer this into the print driver anyway....so unless you are printing images that are overtly cool or warm, you will suck up all your ink in the same time frame anyway.

Case in point...my R200. I use this printer for 4x6 proofing and CD/DVD printing right now.

I used up my black cartridge first, but the others were not far behind. The Cyan's seemed to have more left, as I print mostly portraits and they tend to be on the warm side.

When balck fell below 5%, I replaced it. The others were all above the last tick mark in the Ink Level display. I know this display is an estimate but here is where my frustration really began.

I continued to print as normal, as yellow tipped of 10% warning....then when it hit 5% warning, my magenta and light magenta hit 10%. I printed a few pages of B&W text and then my light cyan hit 10% warning.

I stopped printing in color all together and only printed about 10 pages of text using balck ink only (and man, did it suck up a lot of black ink for just text!)

So now I had:

Black - 85%
Cyan - Above 10%, no low ink warnings yet
Light Cyan - 10% warning
Magenta - 10% warning
Light magenta - 10% warning
Yellow - 5% warning.

So today I bought Yellow, L Mag, Mag, L Cyan. I figured I'd get Cyan next week as I don't intend to print much this weekend.

I get home....open the printer, change the yellow and then press the Ink button.

yellow now full....and MG, LMG, LCY all read 5% warning now..and Cyan says 10% warning for the first time? What the hell? Ok, no point trying to use up the little bit, so I change the MG, LMG and LCY and then press the button. All show full...no wait, now it says Cyan is completely out...cannot print. WTH? I'm quite upset now, I went from above 10% to completely out, without printing anything, not even a test page.

I pull out the Cyan cartridge and I can hear ink in it...far more ink that in the yellow (bone dry) and the other 3 (which all sound like they have a little left, but not as much as the Cyan.)

Bloody hell! I know there is ink in it...and the damn printer will not work at all until I replace the cartridge. I'm fairly certain it's simply a software issue with relation to the ink cartridge chip. But to lose that 10% is not right!

The damn thing costs more to refill with ink than to buy a new printer! Now to lose even more usable ink due to their chip system has me right bent! It just increased my cost for ink by just little more than 5%...doesn't wound like much, but I just lost a possible 10 4x6 proofs out of a set of inks.

Maybe I should expect it...maybe I should just get of the fence and buy the 4000 or i9900....

Sorry to vent, but I'm sick of throwing money down a toilet.....

where's that link to a good CIS system again? :-)

sean
 
Right...i just came back from Staples with a new Cyan cartridge and installed it...now the ink level shows the Yellow, Magenta and Light Magenta at about 80%....and I haven't printed anything on the printer since installing those cartridges...an hour ago!

What the hell....

anyone else have these issues?

sean
ok, I know that the manufacturer's make their money off the ink,
not the printers...at least not at the low end. I can understand
that, but their practice of making things overly expensive for
consumers is driving me nuts.

I don't think separate ink cartridges saves us any money at
all...as all the users I've spoken to, from multiple manufacturers,
use ink at the saem rate. Of course they can engineer this into the
print driver anyway....so unless you are printing images that are
overtly cool or warm, you will suck up all your ink in the same
time frame anyway.

Case in point...my R200. I use this printer for 4x6 proofing and
CD/DVD printing right now.

I used up my black cartridge first, but the others were not far
behind. The Cyan's seemed to have more left, as I print mostly
portraits and they tend to be on the warm side.

When balck fell below 5%, I replaced it. The others were all above
the last tick mark in the Ink Level display. I know this display is
an estimate but here is where my frustration really began.

I continued to print as normal, as yellow tipped of 10%
warning....then when it hit 5% warning, my magenta and light
magenta hit 10%. I printed a few pages of B&W text and then my
light cyan hit 10% warning.

I stopped printing in color all together and only printed about 10
pages of text using balck ink only (and man, did it suck up a lot
of black ink for just text!)

So now I had:

Black - 85%
Cyan - Above 10%, no low ink warnings yet
Light Cyan - 10% warning
Magenta - 10% warning
Light magenta - 10% warning
Yellow - 5% warning.

So today I bought Yellow, L Mag, Mag, L Cyan. I figured I'd get
Cyan next week as I don't intend to print much this weekend.

I get home....open the printer, change the yellow and then press
the Ink button.

yellow now full....and MG, LMG, LCY all read 5% warning now..and
Cyan says 10% warning for the first time? What the hell? Ok, no
point trying to use up the little bit, so I change the MG, LMG and
LCY and then press the button. All show full...no wait, now it says
Cyan is completely out...cannot print. WTH? I'm quite upset now, I
went from above 10% to completely out, without printing anything,
not even a test page.

I pull out the Cyan cartridge and I can hear ink in it...far more
ink that in the yellow (bone dry) and the other 3 (which all sound
like they have a little left, but not as much as the Cyan.)

Bloody hell! I know there is ink in it...and the damn printer will
not work at all until I replace the cartridge. I'm fairly certain
it's simply a software issue with relation to the ink cartridge
chip. But to lose that 10% is not right!

The damn thing costs more to refill with ink than to buy a new
printer! Now to lose even more usable ink due to their chip system
has me right bent! It just increased my cost for ink by just little
more than 5%...doesn't wound like much, but I just lost a possible
10 4x6 proofs out of a set of inks.

Maybe I should expect it...maybe I should just get of the fence and
buy the 4000 or i9900....

Sorry to vent, but I'm sick of throwing money down a toilet.....

where's that link to a good CIS system again? :-)

sean
 
I had that on my Epson printer many times, so I got a refill kit and chip reset kit. Just clogged up the printer, got so annoyed bought a Canon i960 and haven't regretted it once.
What the hell....

anyone else have these issues?

sean
ok, I know that the manufacturer's make their money off the ink,
not the printers...at least not at the low end. I can understand
that, but their practice of making things overly expensive for
consumers is driving me nuts.

I don't think separate ink cartridges saves us any money at
all...as all the users I've spoken to, from multiple manufacturers,
use ink at the saem rate. Of course they can engineer this into the
print driver anyway....so unless you are printing images that are
overtly cool or warm, you will suck up all your ink in the same
time frame anyway.

Case in point...my R200. I use this printer for 4x6 proofing and
CD/DVD printing right now.

I used up my black cartridge first, but the others were not far
behind. The Cyan's seemed to have more left, as I print mostly
portraits and they tend to be on the warm side.

When balck fell below 5%, I replaced it. The others were all above
the last tick mark in the Ink Level display. I know this display is
an estimate but here is where my frustration really began.

I continued to print as normal, as yellow tipped of 10%
warning....then when it hit 5% warning, my magenta and light
magenta hit 10%. I printed a few pages of B&W text and then my
light cyan hit 10% warning.

I stopped printing in color all together and only printed about 10
pages of text using balck ink only (and man, did it suck up a lot
of black ink for just text!)

So now I had:

Black - 85%
Cyan - Above 10%, no low ink warnings yet
Light Cyan - 10% warning
Magenta - 10% warning
Light magenta - 10% warning
Yellow - 5% warning.

So today I bought Yellow, L Mag, Mag, L Cyan. I figured I'd get
Cyan next week as I don't intend to print much this weekend.

I get home....open the printer, change the yellow and then press
the Ink button.

yellow now full....and MG, LMG, LCY all read 5% warning now..and
Cyan says 10% warning for the first time? What the hell? Ok, no
point trying to use up the little bit, so I change the MG, LMG and
LCY and then press the button. All show full...no wait, now it says
Cyan is completely out...cannot print. WTH? I'm quite upset now, I
went from above 10% to completely out, without printing anything,
not even a test page.

I pull out the Cyan cartridge and I can hear ink in it...far more
ink that in the yellow (bone dry) and the other 3 (which all sound
like they have a little left, but not as much as the Cyan.)

Bloody hell! I know there is ink in it...and the damn printer will
not work at all until I replace the cartridge. I'm fairly certain
it's simply a software issue with relation to the ink cartridge
chip. But to lose that 10% is not right!

The damn thing costs more to refill with ink than to buy a new
printer! Now to lose even more usable ink due to their chip system
has me right bent! It just increased my cost for ink by just little
more than 5%...doesn't wound like much, but I just lost a possible
10 4x6 proofs out of a set of inks.

Maybe I should expect it...maybe I should just get of the fence and
buy the 4000 or i9900....

Sorry to vent, but I'm sick of throwing money down a toilet.....

where's that link to a good CIS system again? :-)

sean
--
Fuji 5100
Olympus Z700
 
ok, I know that the manufacturer's make their money off the ink,
not the printers...at least not at the low end. I can understand
that, but their practice of making things overly expensive for
consumers is driving me nuts.
I have refilled cartridges before and when choosing just recently between an Epson and a Canon ...I refuse to screw with Epson's chip resetting BS and went with the iP4000 ...love it ...ordered 3rd party ink from Abacus for $1.50 instead of $12 per cart ...search these threads for abacus and note the following article:
http://www.neilslade.com/Papers/inktest.html

Stew corman from sunny Endicott
 
ok, I know that the manufacturer's make their money off the ink,
not the printers...at least not at the low end. I can understand
that, but their practice of making things overly expensive for
consumers is driving me nuts.

I don't think separate ink cartridges saves us any money at
all...as all the users I've spoken to, from multiple manufacturers,
use ink at the saem rate. Of course they can engineer this into the
print driver anyway....so unless you are printing images that are
overtly cool or warm, you will suck up all your ink in the same
time frame anyway.

Case in point...my R200. I use this printer for 4x6 proofing and
CD/DVD printing right now.

I used up my black cartridge first, but the others were not far
behind. The Cyan's seemed to have more left, as I print mostly
portraits and they tend to be on the warm side.

When balck fell below 5%, I replaced it. The others were all above
the last tick mark in the Ink Level display. I know this display is
an estimate but here is where my frustration really began.

I continued to print as normal, as yellow tipped of 10%
warning....then when it hit 5% warning, my magenta and light
magenta hit 10%. I printed a few pages of B&W text and then my
light cyan hit 10% warning.

I stopped printing in color all together and only printed about 10
pages of text using balck ink only (and man, did it suck up a lot
of black ink for just text!)

So now I had:

Black - 85%
Cyan - Above 10%, no low ink warnings yet
Light Cyan - 10% warning
Magenta - 10% warning
Light magenta - 10% warning
Yellow - 5% warning.
I don't have experience with Epson, so can't speak to that. But something seems badly wrong if you used up 15% of the black ink in only ten pages of text. That would empty the cartridge after about 70 pages. A few months ago, curiosity led me to test ink consumption on a Canon 860, which had a separate black cartridge. I started with a typical page of single-spaced text and printed it at standard quality, not draft, in batches of a hundred copies until the ink ran out. I still have the figures. The cartridge emptied partway through page 1,058. That was a 27 ml cartridge, same capacity as the current black cartridge.

Norman
 
simply pay the $10 for a software chip reset program and keep using the printer. $10 will save you a lot of money on carts with ink in them. If you go to off brands you run the risk of clogging the heads and color problems with the papers. $10 is cheap peace of mind.

Barry
Frederick,Md.
ok, I know that the manufacturer's make their money off the ink,
not the printers...at least not at the low end. I can understand
that, but their practice of making things overly expensive for
consumers is driving me nuts.

I don't think separate ink cartridges saves us any money at
all...as all the users I've spoken to, from multiple manufacturers,
use ink at the saem rate. Of course they can engineer this into the
print driver anyway....so unless you are printing images that are
overtly cool or warm, you will suck up all your ink in the same
time frame anyway.

Case in point...my R200. I use this printer for 4x6 proofing and
CD/DVD printing right now.

I used up my black cartridge first, but the others were not far
behind. The Cyan's seemed to have more left, as I print mostly
portraits and they tend to be on the warm side.

When balck fell below 5%, I replaced it. The others were all above
the last tick mark in the Ink Level display. I know this display is
an estimate but here is where my frustration really began.

I continued to print as normal, as yellow tipped of 10%
warning....then when it hit 5% warning, my magenta and light
magenta hit 10%. I printed a few pages of B&W text and then my
light cyan hit 10% warning.

I stopped printing in color all together and only printed about 10
pages of text using balck ink only (and man, did it suck up a lot
of black ink for just text!)

So now I had:

Black - 85%
Cyan - Above 10%, no low ink warnings yet
Light Cyan - 10% warning
Magenta - 10% warning
Light magenta - 10% warning
Yellow - 5% warning.

So today I bought Yellow, L Mag, Mag, L Cyan. I figured I'd get
Cyan next week as I don't intend to print much this weekend.

I get home....open the printer, change the yellow and then press
the Ink button.

yellow now full....and MG, LMG, LCY all read 5% warning now..and
Cyan says 10% warning for the first time? What the hell? Ok, no
point trying to use up the little bit, so I change the MG, LMG and
LCY and then press the button. All show full...no wait, now it says
Cyan is completely out...cannot print. WTH? I'm quite upset now, I
went from above 10% to completely out, without printing anything,
not even a test page.

I pull out the Cyan cartridge and I can hear ink in it...far more
ink that in the yellow (bone dry) and the other 3 (which all sound
like they have a little left, but not as much as the Cyan.)

Bloody hell! I know there is ink in it...and the damn printer will
not work at all until I replace the cartridge. I'm fairly certain
it's simply a software issue with relation to the ink cartridge
chip. But to lose that 10% is not right!

The damn thing costs more to refill with ink than to buy a new
printer! Now to lose even more usable ink due to their chip system
has me right bent! It just increased my cost for ink by just little
more than 5%...doesn't wound like much, but I just lost a possible
10 4x6 proofs out of a set of inks.

Maybe I should expect it...maybe I should just get of the fence and
buy the 4000 or i9900....

Sorry to vent, but I'm sick of throwing money down a toilet.....

where's that link to a good CIS system again? :-)

sean
--
Barry in Frederick, Md.
 
One thing that I think is deliberate is that if I run seperate print jobs on my Canon s9000, the printer runs through a pre-head clean for each print wasting a ton of ink. The only way Ive found around this is to Que up several at a time and run them as one job. I figure this helps Canon to produce a low per print cost via a print test comparison, but the real cost for most users is higher due to the extra head cleans. Id like the printer to clean itself when I tell it to. I have the same futile goal with my kids, so I can live with it.....

Take Care
Trebor
ok, I know that the manufacturer's make their money off the ink,
not the printers...at least not at the low end. I can understand
that, but their practice of making things overly expensive for
consumers is driving me nuts.

I don't think separate ink cartridges saves us any money at
all...as all the users I've spoken to, from multiple manufacturers,
use ink at the saem rate. Of course they can engineer this into the
print driver anyway....so unless you are printing images that are
overtly cool or warm, you will suck up all your ink in the same
time frame anyway.

Case in point...my R200. I use this printer for 4x6 proofing and
CD/DVD printing right now.

I used up my black cartridge first, but the others were not far
behind. The Cyan's seemed to have more left, as I print mostly
portraits and they tend to be on the warm side.

When balck fell below 5%, I replaced it. The others were all above
the last tick mark in the Ink Level display. I know this display is
an estimate but here is where my frustration really began.

I continued to print as normal, as yellow tipped of 10%
warning....then when it hit 5% warning, my magenta and light
magenta hit 10%. I printed a few pages of B&W text and then my
light cyan hit 10% warning.

I stopped printing in color all together and only printed about 10
pages of text using balck ink only (and man, did it suck up a lot
of black ink for just text!)

So now I had:

Black - 85%
Cyan - Above 10%, no low ink warnings yet
Light Cyan - 10% warning
Magenta - 10% warning
Light magenta - 10% warning
Yellow - 5% warning.

So today I bought Yellow, L Mag, Mag, L Cyan. I figured I'd get
Cyan next week as I don't intend to print much this weekend.

I get home....open the printer, change the yellow and then press
the Ink button.

yellow now full....and MG, LMG, LCY all read 5% warning now..and
Cyan says 10% warning for the first time? What the hell? Ok, no
point trying to use up the little bit, so I change the MG, LMG and
LCY and then press the button. All show full...no wait, now it says
Cyan is completely out...cannot print. WTH? I'm quite upset now, I
went from above 10% to completely out, without printing anything,
not even a test page.

I pull out the Cyan cartridge and I can hear ink in it...far more
ink that in the yellow (bone dry) and the other 3 (which all sound
like they have a little left, but not as much as the Cyan.)

Bloody hell! I know there is ink in it...and the damn printer will
not work at all until I replace the cartridge. I'm fairly certain
it's simply a software issue with relation to the ink cartridge
chip. But to lose that 10% is not right!

The damn thing costs more to refill with ink than to buy a new
printer! Now to lose even more usable ink due to their chip system
has me right bent! It just increased my cost for ink by just little
more than 5%...doesn't wound like much, but I just lost a possible
10 4x6 proofs out of a set of inks.

Maybe I should expect it...maybe I should just get of the fence and
buy the 4000 or i9900....

Sorry to vent, but I'm sick of throwing money down a toilet.....

where's that link to a good CIS system again? :-)

sean
 
Sean,

Come on now, it's not that bad, at least for me. I have an Epson R800. My costs for an 8"x10" print are $1.01 (paper and ink). It has worked flawlessly from day one for me. My customers go, "Oooh!" and "Aaah!" when they see their color portraits. I've never had it so good.

My ink use experience is quite a bit different from yours. I use 2 cyan and magenta cartridges for every one of the other inks. As for the "monitoring" device - I just keep on printing. I've gotten about 9-8x10's more before I've chickened out and changed the "empty" cartridge. I too wish that it were more accurate, but it's not that difficult to learn to live with. The end results are better printed images than I've seen elsewhere done by other printers.

Not every printer is perfect. Yes, most ink monitoring systems aren't perfect. I prefer to use them as a "guideline", not an absolute. Lastly, if you had an opportunity to talk with someone in the ink business as I've had about a year ago, you'd develop a whole new respect for the problems and associated costs in developing paper/ink combinations to suit the wants and needs of the consuming public. It's not that easy. I won't get into any of the details, but there are considerations such as drying time, how one pigment/dye interacts with another, paper saturation/finish and on and on and on. It's enough to give anyone a headache. There are an almost overwhelming number of considerations. So, do I complain about paying $1.01/8"x10" print? Not on your life. I can remember the "good old days" - they were the "dark ages" by comparison - been there, done that and don't want to go back.

Color me happy :-)

CJ
ok, I know that the manufacturer's make their money off the ink,
not the printers...at least not at the low end. I can understand
that, but their practice of making things overly expensive for
consumers is driving me nuts.

I don't think separate ink cartridges saves us any money at
all...as all the users I've spoken to, from multiple manufacturers,
use ink at the saem rate. Of course they can engineer this into the
print driver anyway....so unless you are printing images that are
overtly cool or warm, you will suck up all your ink in the same
time frame anyway.

Case in point...my R200. I use this printer for 4x6 proofing and
CD/DVD printing right now.

I used up my black cartridge first, but the others were not far
behind. The Cyan's seemed to have more left, as I print mostly
portraits and they tend to be on the warm side.

When balck fell below 5%, I replaced it. The others were all above
the last tick mark in the Ink Level display. I know this display is
an estimate but here is where my frustration really began.

I continued to print as normal, as yellow tipped of 10%
warning....then when it hit 5% warning, my magenta and light
magenta hit 10%. I printed a few pages of B&W text and then my
light cyan hit 10% warning.

I stopped printing in color all together and only printed about 10
pages of text using balck ink only (and man, did it suck up a lot
of black ink for just text!)

So now I had:

Black - 85%
Cyan - Above 10%, no low ink warnings yet
Light Cyan - 10% warning
Magenta - 10% warning
Light magenta - 10% warning
Yellow - 5% warning.

So today I bought Yellow, L Mag, Mag, L Cyan. I figured I'd get
Cyan next week as I don't intend to print much this weekend.

I get home....open the printer, change the yellow and then press
the Ink button.

yellow now full....and MG, LMG, LCY all read 5% warning now..and
Cyan says 10% warning for the first time? What the hell? Ok, no
point trying to use up the little bit, so I change the MG, LMG and
LCY and then press the button. All show full...no wait, now it says
Cyan is completely out...cannot print. WTH? I'm quite upset now, I
went from above 10% to completely out, without printing anything,
not even a test page.

I pull out the Cyan cartridge and I can hear ink in it...far more
ink that in the yellow (bone dry) and the other 3 (which all sound
like they have a little left, but not as much as the Cyan.)

Bloody hell! I know there is ink in it...and the damn printer will
not work at all until I replace the cartridge. I'm fairly certain
it's simply a software issue with relation to the ink cartridge
chip. But to lose that 10% is not right!

The damn thing costs more to refill with ink than to buy a new
printer! Now to lose even more usable ink due to their chip system
has me right bent! It just increased my cost for ink by just little
more than 5%...doesn't wound like much, but I just lost a possible
10 4x6 proofs out of a set of inks.

Maybe I should expect it...maybe I should just get of the fence and
buy the 4000 or i9900....

Sorry to vent, but I'm sick of throwing money down a toilet.....

where's that link to a good CIS system again? :-)

sean
--
http://www.pbase.com/cjmax/galleries

'May the best you've ever seen
Be the worst you'll ever see...'
from A Scots Toast by Robert Burns
 
You just learned that when you change one cartridge some ink gets sucked out of every cartridge and it is best to change all low cartridges at the same time as that wastes less ink than changing each individually. What yiou should have done is changed all (except for black) at the same time.

I do agree that the system is ackward and there should be some calculator that would tell which cartridges should be changed (based on the previous use).

a
 
It is interesting that your ink usage is the same for every colour. Mine on the R210 is radically different. So far I have used:
Light Magenta 9x
Light Cyan 8x
Yellow 8x
Magenta 6x
Cyan 5x
Black 5x

By adjusting the figure for the ink still left in the current cartridges, I estimated to have used a total of 45 cartridges to do around 460 A4 (210x297mm or 8.25x11.75") sizeprints. That works out around 60+ prints per set of cartridges! In addition since the original Epson ones I have only used third party Calidad cartridges and never had a single problem.

I have since done some further investigation and discovered that not only does the printer 'waste' ink to clean the heads on changing each cartridge or after a specified number of prints, on average it leaves about 3ml of ink in the cartridge when it shows empty. Obviously it is not possible for Epson to calculate the exact remainder, and I would suggest that it is left behind so that halfway through a print it doesn't run out of ink. For instance if the print is 90% black, it has to allow for that eventuality.
What the hell....

anyone else have these issues?

sean
ok, I know that the manufacturer's make their money off the ink,
not the printers...at least not at the low end. I can understand
that, but their practice of making things overly expensive for
consumers is driving me nuts.

I don't think separate ink cartridges saves us any money at
all...as all the users I've spoken to, from multiple manufacturers,
use ink at the saem rate. Of course they can engineer this into the
print driver anyway....so unless you are printing images that are
overtly cool or warm, you will suck up all your ink in the same
time frame anyway.

Case in point...my R200. I use this printer for 4x6 proofing and
CD/DVD printing right now.

I used up my black cartridge first, but the others were not far
behind. The Cyan's seemed to have more left, as I print mostly
portraits and they tend to be on the warm side.

When balck fell below 5%, I replaced it. The others were all above
the last tick mark in the Ink Level display. I know this display is
an estimate but here is where my frustration really began.

I continued to print as normal, as yellow tipped of 10%
warning....then when it hit 5% warning, my magenta and light
magenta hit 10%. I printed a few pages of B&W text and then my
light cyan hit 10% warning.

I stopped printing in color all together and only printed about 10
pages of text using balck ink only (and man, did it suck up a lot
of black ink for just text!)

So now I had:

Black - 85%
Cyan - Above 10%, no low ink warnings yet
Light Cyan - 10% warning
Magenta - 10% warning
Light magenta - 10% warning
Yellow - 5% warning.

So today I bought Yellow, L Mag, Mag, L Cyan. I figured I'd get
Cyan next week as I don't intend to print much this weekend.

I get home....open the printer, change the yellow and then press
the Ink button.

yellow now full....and MG, LMG, LCY all read 5% warning now..and
Cyan says 10% warning for the first time? What the hell? Ok, no
point trying to use up the little bit, so I change the MG, LMG and
LCY and then press the button. All show full...no wait, now it says
Cyan is completely out...cannot print. WTH? I'm quite upset now, I
went from above 10% to completely out, without printing anything,
not even a test page.

I pull out the Cyan cartridge and I can hear ink in it...far more
ink that in the yellow (bone dry) and the other 3 (which all sound
like they have a little left, but not as much as the Cyan.)

Bloody hell! I know there is ink in it...and the damn printer will
not work at all until I replace the cartridge. I'm fairly certain
it's simply a software issue with relation to the ink cartridge
chip. But to lose that 10% is not right!

The damn thing costs more to refill with ink than to buy a new
printer! Now to lose even more usable ink due to their chip system
has me right bent! It just increased my cost for ink by just little
more than 5%...doesn't wound like much, but I just lost a possible
10 4x6 proofs out of a set of inks.

Maybe I should expect it...maybe I should just get of the fence and
buy the 4000 or i9900....

Sorry to vent, but I'm sick of throwing money down a toilet.....

where's that link to a good CIS system again? :-)

sean
 
On my i960 I have noticed that my Photo Magenta, Photo Cyan, Yellow and Black are used the most. And when my Photo Magenta was low and I changed it I did not notice any other cartridge getting lower after changing it.
Come on now, it's not that bad, at least for me. I have an Epson
R800. My costs for an 8"x10" print are $1.01 (paper and ink). It
has worked flawlessly from day one for me. My customers go,
"Oooh!" and "Aaah!" when they see their color portraits. I've
never had it so good.

My ink use experience is quite a bit different from yours. I use 2
cyan and magenta cartridges for every one of the other inks. As
for the "monitoring" device - I just keep on printing. I've gotten
about 9-8x10's more before I've chickened out and changed the
"empty" cartridge. I too wish that it were more accurate, but it's
not that difficult to learn to live with. The end results are
better printed images than I've seen elsewhere done by other
printers.

Not every printer is perfect. Yes, most ink monitoring systems
aren't perfect. I prefer to use them as a "guideline", not an
absolute. Lastly, if you had an opportunity to talk with someone
in the ink business as I've had about a year ago, you'd develop a
whole new respect for the problems and associated costs in
developing paper/ink combinations to suit the wants and needs of
the consuming public. It's not that easy. I won't get into any of
the details, but there are considerations such as drying time, how
one pigment/dye interacts with another, paper saturation/finish and
on and on and on. It's enough to give anyone a headache. There
are an almost overwhelming number of considerations. So, do I
complain about paying $1.01/8"x10" print? Not on your life. I can
remember the "good old days" - they were the "dark ages" by
comparison - been there, done that and don't want to go back.

Color me happy :-)

CJ
ok, I know that the manufacturer's make their money off the ink,
not the printers...at least not at the low end. I can understand
that, but their practice of making things overly expensive for
consumers is driving me nuts.

I don't think separate ink cartridges saves us any money at
all...as all the users I've spoken to, from multiple manufacturers,
use ink at the saem rate. Of course they can engineer this into the
print driver anyway....so unless you are printing images that are
overtly cool or warm, you will suck up all your ink in the same
time frame anyway.

Case in point...my R200. I use this printer for 4x6 proofing and
CD/DVD printing right now.

I used up my black cartridge first, but the others were not far
behind. The Cyan's seemed to have more left, as I print mostly
portraits and they tend to be on the warm side.

When balck fell below 5%, I replaced it. The others were all above
the last tick mark in the Ink Level display. I know this display is
an estimate but here is where my frustration really began.

I continued to print as normal, as yellow tipped of 10%
warning....then when it hit 5% warning, my magenta and light
magenta hit 10%. I printed a few pages of B&W text and then my
light cyan hit 10% warning.

I stopped printing in color all together and only printed about 10
pages of text using balck ink only (and man, did it suck up a lot
of black ink for just text!)

So now I had:

Black - 85%
Cyan - Above 10%, no low ink warnings yet
Light Cyan - 10% warning
Magenta - 10% warning
Light magenta - 10% warning
Yellow - 5% warning.

So today I bought Yellow, L Mag, Mag, L Cyan. I figured I'd get
Cyan next week as I don't intend to print much this weekend.

I get home....open the printer, change the yellow and then press
the Ink button.

yellow now full....and MG, LMG, LCY all read 5% warning now..and
Cyan says 10% warning for the first time? What the hell? Ok, no
point trying to use up the little bit, so I change the MG, LMG and
LCY and then press the button. All show full...no wait, now it says
Cyan is completely out...cannot print. WTH? I'm quite upset now, I
went from above 10% to completely out, without printing anything,
not even a test page.

I pull out the Cyan cartridge and I can hear ink in it...far more
ink that in the yellow (bone dry) and the other 3 (which all sound
like they have a little left, but not as much as the Cyan.)

Bloody hell! I know there is ink in it...and the damn printer will
not work at all until I replace the cartridge. I'm fairly certain
it's simply a software issue with relation to the ink cartridge
chip. But to lose that 10% is not right!

The damn thing costs more to refill with ink than to buy a new
printer! Now to lose even more usable ink due to their chip system
has me right bent! It just increased my cost for ink by just little
more than 5%...doesn't wound like much, but I just lost a possible
10 4x6 proofs out of a set of inks.

Maybe I should expect it...maybe I should just get of the fence and
buy the 4000 or i9900....

Sorry to vent, but I'm sick of throwing money down a toilet.....

where's that link to a good CIS system again? :-)

sean
--
http://www.pbase.com/cjmax/galleries

'May the best you've ever seen
Be the worst you'll ever see...'
from A Scots Toast by Robert Burns
--
Fuji 5100
Olympus Z700
 
Just a tip, it sounds like you guys are wasting ink by replacing the ink before the printer tells you it is empty. With the Epson R800 you don't have to worry about situation where you
"chickened out and changed the "empty" cartridge."
I just keep on printing until the printer says "Empty . . . replace xxx cartridge". The Epson tells you it is low, but you can ignore that, the printer knows when it is empty and will not print anymore till you replace the cartrige. Then if I have other cartridges that show no color in the status monitor I will replace them at the same time.

Good Luck
Rick
Come on now, it's not that bad, at least for me. I have an Epson
R800. My costs for an 8"x10" print are $1.01 (paper and ink). It
has worked flawlessly from day one for me. My customers go,
"Oooh!" and "Aaah!" when they see their color portraits. I've
never had it so good.

My ink use experience is quite a bit different from yours. I use 2
cyan and magenta cartridges for every one of the other inks. As
for the "monitoring" device - I just keep on printing. I've gotten
about 9-8x10's more before I've chickened out and changed the
"empty" cartridge. I too wish that it were more accurate, but it's
not that difficult to learn to live with. The end results are
better printed images than I've seen elsewhere done by other
printers.

Not every printer is perfect. Yes, most ink monitoring systems
aren't perfect. I prefer to use them as a "guideline", not an
absolute. Lastly, if you had an opportunity to talk with someone
in the ink business as I've had about a year ago, you'd develop a
whole new respect for the problems and associated costs in
developing paper/ink combinations to suit the wants and needs of
the consuming public. It's not that easy. I won't get into any of
the details, but there are considerations such as drying time, how
one pigment/dye interacts with another, paper saturation/finish and
on and on and on. It's enough to give anyone a headache. There
are an almost overwhelming number of considerations. So, do I
complain about paying $1.01/8"x10" print? Not on your life. I can
remember the "good old days" - they were the "dark ages" by
comparison - been there, done that and don't want to go back.

Color me happy :-)

CJ
ok, I know that the manufacturer's make their money off the ink,
not the printers...at least not at the low end. I can understand
that, but their practice of making things overly expensive for
consumers is driving me nuts.

I don't think separate ink cartridges saves us any money at
all...as all the users I've spoken to, from multiple manufacturers,
use ink at the saem rate. Of course they can engineer this into the
print driver anyway....so unless you are printing images that are
overtly cool or warm, you will suck up all your ink in the same
time frame anyway.

Case in point...my R200. I use this printer for 4x6 proofing and
CD/DVD printing right now.

I used up my black cartridge first, but the others were not far
behind. The Cyan's seemed to have more left, as I print mostly
portraits and they tend to be on the warm side.

When balck fell below 5%, I replaced it. The others were all above
the last tick mark in the Ink Level display. I know this display is
an estimate but here is where my frustration really began.

I continued to print as normal, as yellow tipped of 10%
warning....then when it hit 5% warning, my magenta and light
magenta hit 10%. I printed a few pages of B&W text and then my
light cyan hit 10% warning.

I stopped printing in color all together and only printed about 10
pages of text using balck ink only (and man, did it suck up a lot
of black ink for just text!)

So now I had:

Black - 85%
Cyan - Above 10%, no low ink warnings yet
Light Cyan - 10% warning
Magenta - 10% warning
Light magenta - 10% warning
Yellow - 5% warning.

So today I bought Yellow, L Mag, Mag, L Cyan. I figured I'd get
Cyan next week as I don't intend to print much this weekend.

I get home....open the printer, change the yellow and then press
the Ink button.

yellow now full....and MG, LMG, LCY all read 5% warning now..and
Cyan says 10% warning for the first time? What the hell? Ok, no
point trying to use up the little bit, so I change the MG, LMG and
LCY and then press the button. All show full...no wait, now it says
Cyan is completely out...cannot print. WTH? I'm quite upset now, I
went from above 10% to completely out, without printing anything,
not even a test page.

I pull out the Cyan cartridge and I can hear ink in it...far more
ink that in the yellow (bone dry) and the other 3 (which all sound
like they have a little left, but not as much as the Cyan.)

Bloody hell! I know there is ink in it...and the damn printer will
not work at all until I replace the cartridge. I'm fairly certain
it's simply a software issue with relation to the ink cartridge
chip. But to lose that 10% is not right!

The damn thing costs more to refill with ink than to buy a new
printer! Now to lose even more usable ink due to their chip system
has me right bent! It just increased my cost for ink by just little
more than 5%...doesn't wound like much, but I just lost a possible
10 4x6 proofs out of a set of inks.

Maybe I should expect it...maybe I should just get of the fence and
buy the 4000 or i9900....

Sorry to vent, but I'm sick of throwing money down a toilet.....

where's that link to a good CIS system again? :-)

sean
--
http://www.pbase.com/cjmax/galleries

'May the best you've ever seen
Be the worst you'll ever see...'
from A Scots Toast by Robert Burns
 
Sean,

Come on now, it's not that bad, at least for me. I have an Epson
R800. My costs for an 8"x10" print are $1.01 (paper and ink).
My experience with the R800 is very close to yours, in terms of ink use. Though, I would add the GlOp to the 2X Magenta, Cyan ink vs. the remaining 1X Y, MBlk, PhBlk, R and B. My cost, here in Canada was estimated at 2.50. but now I readjusted that figure with EpPSGloss to be above 3.50.

Also, the actual cost of printer maintenance could be as high as, 35% of ink cost, but under normal conditions balanced out about up to $17 per ink cart change. That is about %10 ink waste on removing any of the inkcarts for whatever reasons.

For sometime now I considered to post my Un-Official review of this printer, since I bought it to experiment with this technology advancing into the ?2200 or the 13x19 format.

Judging the technical specs, the ?2200 will prove to be one of the most expencive (per print) printer to sit on our desktop.

My "only" negative comments about this printer(R800) are the missing 5760dpi optimised Epson paper profiles. Somebody at Epson missed the boat!!! They, so far, have NEGLECTED to creat a Photo RPM mode 5760dpi profiles for the printer that is SOLD as a 5670dpi OPTIMISED printer.

The other is the PRIMITIVE Epson printer driver. The steps one need to go through to get the printer processing the image just leaves too many opportunity for the user to make a bad print. Why even include all those FALSE controls in? They provide a demostretably inferior print vs. the one is achived leaving the driver out of the color management loop!

Tony K
 
ok, I know that the manufacturer's make their money off the ink,
not the printers...at least not at the low end. I can understand
that, but their practice of making things overly expensive for
consumers is driving me nuts.

I don't think separate ink cartridges saves us any money at
all...as all the users I've spoken to, from multiple manufacturers,
use ink at the saem rate. Of course they can engineer this into the
print driver anyway....so unless you are printing images that are
overtly cool or warm, you will suck up all your ink in the same
time frame anyway.
Sorry to comment like this, however; You either have very little experience or you just sinply do NOT know what you are talking about in the last 3 lines above.

Vernon....
Case in point...my R200. I use this printer for 4x6 proofing and
CD/DVD printing right now.

I used up my black cartridge first, but the others were not far
behind. The Cyan's seemed to have more left, as I print mostly
portraits and they tend to be on the warm side.

When balck fell below 5%, I replaced it. The others were all above
the last tick mark in the Ink Level display. I know this display is
an estimate but here is where my frustration really began.

I continued to print as normal, as yellow tipped of 10%
warning....then when it hit 5% warning, my magenta and light
magenta hit 10%. I printed a few pages of B&W text and then my
light cyan hit 10% warning.

I stopped printing in color all together and only printed about 10
pages of text using balck ink only (and man, did it suck up a lot
of black ink for just text!)

So now I had:

Black - 85%
Cyan - Above 10%, no low ink warnings yet
Light Cyan - 10% warning
Magenta - 10% warning
Light magenta - 10% warning
Yellow - 5% warning.

So today I bought Yellow, L Mag, Mag, L Cyan. I figured I'd get
Cyan next week as I don't intend to print much this weekend.

I get home....open the printer, change the yellow and then press
the Ink button.

yellow now full....and MG, LMG, LCY all read 5% warning now..and
Cyan says 10% warning for the first time? What the hell? Ok, no
point trying to use up the little bit, so I change the MG, LMG and
LCY and then press the button. All show full...no wait, now it says
Cyan is completely out...cannot print. WTH? I'm quite upset now, I
went from above 10% to completely out, without printing anything,
not even a test page.

I pull out the Cyan cartridge and I can hear ink in it...far more
ink that in the yellow (bone dry) and the other 3 (which all sound
like they have a little left, but not as much as the Cyan.)

Bloody hell! I know there is ink in it...and the damn printer will
not work at all until I replace the cartridge. I'm fairly certain
it's simply a software issue with relation to the ink cartridge
chip. But to lose that 10% is not right!
If you are willing to take the risk -- then -- have you considered using a Resetter for your Cartridges in order to use the last drop of ink -- as well as some air which would NOT be good....
The damn thing costs more to refill with ink than to buy a new
printer! Now to lose even more usable ink due to their chip system
has me right bent! It just increased my cost for ink by just little
more than 5%...doesn't wound like much, but I just lost a possible
10 4x6 proofs out of a set of inks.

Maybe I should expect it...maybe I should just get of the fence and
buy the 4000 or i9900....

Sorry to vent, but I'm sick of throwing money down a toilet.....

where's that link to a good CIS system again? :-)

sean
--
Vernon...
http://www.pbase.com/vrain
 
Tony,

I dunno. No complaints here on the driver and profiles. It does everything that I need, and it has done so from print #1.

Interestingly, 2 of the larger calibration companies told me flat out not to bother getting custom ICC profiles made for my R800 because they can't really improve on what Epson has done - now that was a bit of a shock to hear from them. That can mean one or two things - or both: 1. the profiles are of a high enough quality that recalibration pros really can't improve on it (I like that. Why should we have to throw more money out the window for more printer profiles?), and 2) the quality control is exceptionally good compared to other printer manufacturers. It's poor quality control that is the cause of much of the aftermarket profile business. Acutually, the custom profile makers key in on both these points, so it's not just one. Personally, I like that, and I like my R800.

CJ
Sean,

Come on now, it's not that bad, at least for me. I have an Epson
R800. My costs for an 8"x10" print are $1.01 (paper and ink).
My experience with the R800 is very close to yours, in terms of ink
use. Though, I would add the GlOp to the 2X Magenta, Cyan ink vs.
the remaining 1X Y, MBlk, PhBlk, R and B. My cost, here in Canada
was estimated at 2.50. but now I readjusted that figure with
EpPSGloss to be above 3.50.
Also, the actual cost of printer maintenance could be as high as,
35% of ink cost, but under normal conditions balanced out about up
to $17 per ink cart change. That is about %10 ink waste on removing
any of the inkcarts for whatever reasons.
For sometime now I considered to post my Un-Official review of this
printer, since I bought it to experiment with this technology
advancing into the ?2200 or the 13x19 format.
Judging the technical specs, the ?2200 will prove to be one of the
most expencive (per print) printer to sit on our desktop.
My "only" negative comments about this printer(R800) are the
missing 5760dpi optimised Epson paper profiles. Somebody at Epson
missed the boat!!! They, so far, have NEGLECTED to creat a Photo
RPM mode 5760dpi profiles for the printer that is SOLD as a 5670dpi
OPTIMISED printer.
The other is the PRIMITIVE Epson printer driver. The steps one need
to go through to get the printer processing the image just leaves
too many opportunity for the user to make a bad print. Why even
include all those FALSE controls in? They provide a demostretably
inferior print vs. the one is achived leaving the driver out of the
color management loop!

Tony K
--
http://www.pbase.com/cjmax/galleries

'May the best you've ever seen
Be the worst you'll ever see...'
from A Scots Toast by Robert Burns
 
seeing as how I used to work with graphic software engineers that wrote printer drivers, and my job was to provide them with feature specifications...yes, I do know what I am talking about and they can optimize their drivers to use up as much or as little ink as they want given a certain set of conditions.

CJ, I have the R200, not the 800....and I'm in Canada, land of the expensive consumables ;-) It cost me $150 for a set of 6 ink cartridges...that's the best price I can find for Epson inks. Best guess so far is that I'm going to get 45-50 8x10s before I need to replace at least 2-3 cartridges. So it's costing me pretty close to $3 for each print. Really good photo paper is almost $1 a sheet (although I just found a really good source at .60 sheet)

This printer costs me close to $4 per print.

The prints are stunning! Even without the gloss optimizer option I'm fairly impressed with the output from this $150 (cdn) printer! The cost per print is too high though.

The ink cartridges is 16-18 ml...and a bad chip costing me 2 ml equates to losing 12% of my printing capacity.

Yeah, I guess I'll have to get a chip resetter or something. I just hate the fact that I need to do such a thing. It should work right...right out of the box. I shouldn't need all this stuff.

sean
 
Sean,

Guess who was born in Toronto, got tired of everything costing 20+% more than in the States while wages were lower, and bailed out eventually landing in sunny Texas? Save your energy. C'est moi.

I know where you are coming from with the higher prices. Much of that I found out is due to the insertion of an extra layer of "distributors" in many product lines - like it or not. It's an expensive burden on the working man up there. I had a grower/friend in Mexico who wanted to know if he/we could tap into the Canadian market. I did some legwork and was astounded at the archaic and costly distribution methods. We ended up throwing our hands up in the air and backing off.

CJ
seeing as how I used to work with graphic software engineers that
wrote printer drivers, and my job was to provide them with
feature specifications...yes, I do know what I am talking about and
they can optimize their drivers to use up as much or as little ink
as they want given a certain set of conditions.

CJ, I have the R200, not the 800....and I'm in Canada, land of the
expensive consumables ;-) It cost me $150 for a set of 6 ink
cartridges...that's the best price I can find for Epson inks. Best
guess so far is that I'm going to get 45-50 8x10s before I need to
replace at least 2-3 cartridges. So it's costing me pretty close to
$3 for each print. Really good photo paper is almost $1 a sheet
(although I just found a really good source at .60 sheet)

This printer costs me close to $4 per print.

The prints are stunning! Even without the gloss optimizer option
I'm fairly impressed with the output from this $150 (cdn) printer!
The cost per print is too high though.

The ink cartridges is 16-18 ml...and a bad chip costing me 2 ml
equates to losing 12% of my printing capacity.

Yeah, I guess I'll have to get a chip resetter or something. I just
hate the fact that I need to do such a thing. It should work
right...right out of the box. I shouldn't need all this stuff.

sean
--
http://www.pbase.com/cjmax/galleries

'May the best you've ever seen
Be the worst you'll ever see...'
from A Scots Toast by Robert Burns
 
With all that I've read and witnessed (peers at work) regarding the Epson R series (except the 800), I'm glad I held out for the Canon i960. I paid $150 and got a $50 mail in rebate on top of that, so basically $100. This is my 5th printer, so I'm very concious about ink costs. I'm one of those fuddy duddies that sticks to OEM inks.

I"ve seen some good deals on ink via eBay for Canon OEM, perhaps you could try there for your R200?
--
Zalllon
Olympus C-8080WZ
Canon i960
http://gallery125884.fotopic.net/
 
have you ever had any issues with ink you've bought on ebay? I'd still rather buy my ink from a store that has an address and a reputation, you know?

It is worth looking into, thanks.

sean
With all that I've read and witnessed (peers at work) regarding the
Epson R series (except the 800), I'm glad I held out for the Canon
i960. I paid $150 and got a $50 mail in rebate on top of that, so
basically $100. This is my 5th printer, so I'm very concious about
ink costs. I'm one of those fuddy duddies that sticks to OEM inks.

I"ve seen some good deals on ink via eBay for Canon OEM, perhaps
you could try there for your R200?
--
Zalllon
Olympus C-8080WZ
Canon i960
http://gallery125884.fotopic.net/
 
I understand the concern of buying ink from someone reputable. I haven't bought ink off the net as of yet, but I will the next time around for my S750 (used strictly for my daughter's homework, and mine too). The price is too cheap to ignore, so if I have to throw it out it's not a huge issue.

--
Zalllon
Olympus C-8080WZ
Canon i960
http://gallery125884.fotopic.net/
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top