Why we haven't taken a stance on in-body stabilization vs OIS - and why that has changed
DPReview has never taken sides in the row over whether image stabilization should be provided in-body or in the lens. But we'll now list the absence of in-body stabilization as a Con in our camera reviews. We'll explain what's happened to change our stance.
For at least the last decade, our internal policy has been to have no preference between in-body and in-lens stabilization. It's an approach that was sometimes seen as fence-sitting but was driven by two logical precepts:
Our primary reasoning was based on our guiding principle that it makes more sense to concentrate on the photographic impact, rather than which technology was used. For many years, a majority of users bought DSLRs that came with a stabilized lens and had essentially the same experience as those users who bought a camera body with stabilization. The in-body advocates talked a good game about 'every lens being stabilized' but we didn't hear reports from thousands of distraught DSLR buyers wondering why their shots were blurry.
There are genuine advantages and disadvantages to both approaches
Secondly, there are genuine advantages and disadvantages to both approaches. As a broad generalization, in-body stabilization does a better job of correcting the translational movements that affect close-up and wide-angle photography, while in-lens designs cope better with the large pitch and yaw corrections needed with long focal lengths. So why would we give credit for one and ignore the benefits of the other?
The result was close enough to a wash that we felt it was inappropriate to have a preference.
So what's changed?
That's now changed, again for two main reasons. The first is prevalence: for our review Pros and Cons, we tend to recognize a new feature as a Pro if it's rare or exceptional but then acknowledge its absence as a shortcoming, once it's become a common (and hence expected) feature. So, for example, we started off seeing USB charging as a 'Pro' (with an associated 'Con' if it was used as an excuse to leave an external charger out of the box), when it first appeared. But, now that it's become commonplace, it's the absence of USB charging that would be seen as a negative.
Now that Ricoh, Olympus, Panasonic, Sony, Fujifilm and Nikon all offer in-body IS on at least some of their interchangeable lens cameras, its omission starts to look like a factor we should highlight to would-be buyers.
The second factor is the growth in importance of video. There may have been little difference in performance between in-lens and in-body stabilization when it came to stills, but the same can't be said for video. Watch TV or movies and you'll see all sorts of camera movements, but what you won't tend to see is roll: left-and-right rotations that cause the horizon to tilt. In-lens stabilization can correct for pitch and yaw but it can't correct for roll: which gives in-body stabilization an immediate advantage.
There may have been little difference in performance between in-lens and in-body stabilization when it came to stills, but the same can't be said for video
We'll still test each camera to see how well its IS works: our approach of assessing effect, rather than technology means we'll check whether digital stabilization in concert with in-lens stabilization provides a good degree of correction. But don't be surprised if you see Cons highlighting the lack of in-body stabilization in our future reviews.
|Cheetah in the wild by cmgpereira|
|Kilchurn Castle, Scotland by johanmieke|
from Ancient Castles, Forts, and Defensive Structures - EXTERIOR
|Incoming by Scott Vail|
from Your Duck shot
Back in the film days Canon had 'eye-controlled' focus that let you set an AF point just by looking at it, and a recent patent suggests Canon is still interested in this technology. Chris and Jordan consider what a modern eye-controlled AF system might mean to photographers.
CyberLink has revealed the latest updates to its suite of creative production apps, including PhotoDirector 11, PowerDirector 18 and more.
Aputure's impending LED light has 600W raw output in a size not much larger than your standard cinema light.
Apple's iPhone 11 camera updates will inevitably be seen as attempts to catch up to Android. But, taken together, we think they stack up to meaningful upgrades that might make an already very capable camera one of the most compelling options on the market.
Monogram, a company formerly known as Palette Gear, has a new crowdfunded campaign up for its next-generation modular control panel, the Creative Console.
Rumors have been heating up regarding Canon's potential IBIS system and this new patent application gives us the best look yet at what Canon is up to.
The new filters use artificial intelligence to automatize and simplify a range of portrait retouching tasks.
The Laowa 100mm F2.8 2X Ultra Macro APO is unusual among macro optics for offering a maximum reproduction ratio of 2:1. Check out our gallery to see how it performs.
A group of friends traversed around California in an attempt to recreate the stock wallpapers Apple has included with macOS.
With iOS 13 the iPhones XS and XR as well as the latest iPad Pro models will be capable of simultaneously recording video streams from multiple cameras.
The paid firmware update doubles the range for remote cameras/flash units and brings a number of additional features.
The two ‘MicroPrime’ lenses add additional options to SLR Magic's current MFT cine lens lineup, which includes the 12mm T2.8 and 18mm T2.8.
It's not every day that we get to shoot with a system like the medium-format IQ4. We took it into the studio for some portraiture as well as a more casual spin around the block because, well, why not?
Our friends over at Cinema5D have gone hands-on with Sony's new full-frame cinema camera, the FX9, and shared their thoughts on what the camera has to offer.
The Google Pixel 4 will likely launch with an astrophotography feature, HDR in the preview image and a range of other new imaging functions.
In the first part of his series, landscape photographer Erez Marom starts with the very basics of drone photography – namely, what a drone is and how it works.
Blackmagic has announced an update to Blackmagic RAW that adds support, via plugins, to Adobe Premiere Pro and Avid Media Composer. Blackmagic also announced a pair of Video Assist 12G monitor-recorders with brighter HDR displays, USB-C recording and more.
This week Chris and Jordan review the new Canon EOS M6 II mirrorless camera. Even if you're not interested in the camera, you should probably watch just to see Jordan sing a Dire Straits cover.
A new gallery from the Canon EOS M6 II, shot by Chris and Jordan while filming this week's episode of DPReview TV. As usual, it comes complete with reflected images in puddles.
STC Optics announced new filters for Panasonic Lumix M43 camera systems, Z Cam E2 4K Cinema Cameras and Blackmagic Pocket Cinema Camera 4K units.
Atomos continues its partnership with camera manufacturers to get the best image possible from the sensors inside the latest camera systems.
Sony has announced the impending arrival of its next-generation video camera system, the FX9. The full-frame E-mount system is set to be released later this year with a 16-35mm E-mount lens to follow in spring 2020.
Slow-mo videos are awesome on their own, but have you ever wondered what 72 slow-mo cameras are capable of producing? Well, wonder no more.
Google uses machine learning to pick your best photos from previous years and pins them to the top of your gallery.
The new tool uses AI and machine learning to automatically reframe video sequences to fit different aspects ratios so a single video can easily be edited for publishing on multiple platforms.
The Canon RF 85mm F1.2L USM is one of the most impressive lenses released for the nascent RF system, and we've just updated our gallery of sample images.
The new calibration systems are designed to work with bright HDR monitors and OLED screens of every shape and size.
The XEEN CF lenses will be offered in 16mm, 24mm, 35mm, 50mm, and 85mm options for Canon EF, Sony E and PL mounts.
It's an extremely minor firmware update, but it's better to be safe than sorry. The last thing you want is to have to stop mid-shot in the field to address a little software glitch.