Why we haven't taken a stance on in-body stabilization vs OIS - and why that has changed
DPReview has never taken sides in the row over whether image stabilization should be provided in-body or in the lens. But we'll now list the absence of in-body stabilization as a Con in our camera reviews. We'll explain what's happened to change our stance.
For at least the last decade, our internal policy has been to have no preference between in-body and in-lens stabilization. It's an approach that was sometimes seen as fence-sitting but was driven by two logical precepts:
Our primary reasoning was based on our guiding principle that it makes more sense to concentrate on the photographic impact, rather than which technology was used. For many years, a majority of users bought DSLRs that came with a stabilized lens and had essentially the same experience as those users who bought a camera body with stabilization. The in-body advocates talked a good game about 'every lens being stabilized' but we didn't hear reports from thousands of distraught DSLR buyers wondering why their shots were blurry.
There are genuine advantages and disadvantages to both approaches
Secondly, there are genuine advantages and disadvantages to both approaches. As a broad generalization, in-body stabilization does a better job of correcting the translational movements that affect close-up and wide-angle photography, while in-lens designs cope better with the large pitch and yaw corrections needed with long focal lengths. So why would we give credit for one and ignore the benefits of the other?
The result was close enough to a wash that we felt it was inappropriate to have a preference.
So what's changed?
That's now changed, again for two main reasons. The first is prevalence: for our review Pros and Cons, we tend to recognize a new feature as a Pro if it's rare or exceptional but then acknowledge its absence as a shortcoming, once it's become a common (and hence expected) feature. So, for example, we started off seeing USB charging as a 'Pro' (with an associated 'Con' if it was used as an excuse to leave an external charger out of the box), when it first appeared. But, now that it's become commonplace, it's the absence of USB charging that would be seen as a negative.
Now that Ricoh, Olympus, Panasonic, Sony, Fujifilm and Nikon all offer in-body IS on at least some of their interchangeable lens cameras, its omission starts to look like a factor we should highlight to would-be buyers.
The second factor is the growth in importance of video. There may have been little difference in performance between in-lens and in-body stabilization when it came to stills, but the same can't be said for video. Watch TV or movies and you'll see all sorts of camera movements, but what you won't tend to see is roll: left-and-right rotations that cause the horizon to tilt. In-lens stabilization can correct for pitch and yaw but it can't correct for roll: which gives in-body stabilization an immediate advantage.
There may have been little difference in performance between in-lens and in-body stabilization when it came to stills, but the same can't be said for video
We'll still test each camera to see how well its IS works: our approach of assessing effect, rather than technology means we'll check whether digital stabilization in concert with in-lens stabilization provides a good degree of correction. But don't be surprised if you see Cons highlighting the lack of in-body stabilization in our future reviews.
|Red-eyed Tree Frog by Kukla|
from Best Photo of the Week...
|D80_DSC_7607 - Hard Working Life by nemark|
|Sun Lamp by Barry Twycross|
from Found letters "r" in LOWER CASE ONLY
B&H Photo spokesperson Jeff Gerstel has shared a detailed statement in response the New York Attorney General's accusations that it 'defrauded' over $7M in sales tax.
Have you ever looked at your smartphone or GoPro and said, "I wish my camera could stabilize an image like that?!" Chris explains the limits of electronic image stabilization.
The Canon RF 70-200mm F2.8 IS is a true feat of engineering. When fully retracted, the lens measures just 146mm / 5.8in. We've been eager to try it out ever since its announcement – and it's finally here.
Firstlight is a new premium camera app capable of Raw capture, HDR, fine-tuned exposure control and more.
The report claims Sigma is 'actively working on an RF-mount lens roadmap' that is set to be announced in 'early 2020.'
The vulnerability is extensive, potentially allowing unauthorized users to gain access to photos, videos, audio, location and more through a little trickery in Google and Samsung's camera apps.
This marks the first time a dedicated camera battery has ever been included in a first-party case from Apple and shows the importance of the new triple-camera array on the latest iPhone 11 models.
The VideoMic NTG takes Rode's technology from its 'broadcast-quality' line of NTG microphones and condenses it down into a hotshoe-mountable VideoMic.
The new system is compatible with the latest iPhone and Samsung Galaxy devices. It includes the Olloclip StartPack, MacroProPack and ElitePack, a trio of kits offering various lens bundles.
The firmware updates address bug fixes for essentially all models and add new functionality to other models. The Panasonic G9 in particular has received a notable update with 4K 30p/25p 4:2:2 10-bit video recoding.
Apple's support document for its new 16-inch MacBook Pro reveals the computer is capable of powering two 6K displays or four 4K displays.
Terry O'Neill, who captured The Beatles, Rolling Stones, and James Bond actors in their formative years, passed away at 81.
The SC2 retains a similar form factor as its SC predecessor, but adds a number of incremental updates, including a small OLED display and new shooting modes.
The team at XDA Developers has found several references at new camera features in the Samsung Camera app apk.
The four lenses are fully-manual cinema lenses designed to offer multiple focal lengths in nearly identical form factors for easy swapping out.
After several teasers of its new AI-powered tools Skylum's Luminar 4 is now finally available to purchase.
A lawsuit filed by the State of New York accuses electronics retailer B&H Foto & Electronics Corp of alleged tax fraud to the tune of more than $7M.
As if you needed another reason to fear for what your gear goes through when being transported from the retailer to your house.
Sony Japan has issued a service advisory noting that select units are causing full-frame Sony cameras to stop working when the lens is attached to them.
We follow photographer Micael Bonocore as he tells the story of Igram Askar, a young eagle huntress in Mongolia. Filmed and photographed using the Sony a7R IV.
A University of Georgia student photographer was knocked unconscious on the sideline after a wide receiver collided with her after going out of bounds.
It offers a few benefits for photographers, but ultimately LG's Dual Screen accessory is a multi-tasker's dream come true. It just remains to be seen whether or not it will catch on.
We've updated our guide to the best cameras for landscape photographers with a new overall winner: the Sony a7R IV. Take a look at the full shortlist for all of our picks.
The a6100 is Sony's newest entry-level APS-C mirrorless camera. As Chris and Jordan highlight in their review, it features some useful upgrades over to the [apparently immortal] a6000.
Check out our gallery of Sony a6100 sample photos captured during this week’s production of DPReview TV.
Sigma says the lens will ship 'early December' for $1,099, just in time for a late holiday stocking stuffer.
As diplomat William Taylor and State Department official George Kent took their seats in day 1 of the house impeachment hearings this week, our eye was caught by David Burnett, and his custom-made 4 x 5 film camera.
Olympus has issued a statement to Chinese financial publication Sina Finance News claiming it will continue 'to work on the improvement of profitability and efficiency in these two business areas,' a direct response to a rumor that stated its imaging division would be shut down within a year.
Instagram has been hiding like counts for some users across several regions since earlier this year. Now the trial is expanded to a global scale.