Sony NEX-3 / NEX-5 Review
Studio Tests - E 16mm F2.8 Pancake lens
The NEX system's second kit lens is the fixed-focal length 16mm F2.8 'pancake'. This is a tiny lens that matches the cameras' miniaturized body size very well, but as 24mm-equivalent wideangle, we think it's far from ideal as a general-purpose kit lens for Sony's stated target market (the compact camera upgrader).
The 16mm pancake underwent something of a painful gestation, with some early sample shots that appeared on the internet looking far from satisfactory due to being shot using pre-production lenses. Sony tells us it has made changes to the manufacturing process which result in improved quality and consistency, and the results seem to bear this out. The lens is decently sharp across most of the frame even at F2.8 (although the extreme corners are distinctly blurred), and improves on stopping to give perfectly respectable results at smaller apertures.
Sharpness is very high in the center of the frame even at F2.8. It falls gradually towards the corners, and while most of the frame is perfectly acceptable, the corners are soft (particularly at the extremes, represented by the corner checkerboards but beyond our outermost measurement targets). Things improve on stopping down, with the corners picking up noticeably. The very best results are obtained around F5.6 - F8; apertures smaller than F16 are best avoided due to diffraction blurring.
Chromatic aberration is reasonably well controlled, and certainly no worse than the average kit lens or wideangle zoom. Red/cyan ringing is clearly visible towards the corner of the frame, but readily correctable in post-processing if required.
We consider falloff to become perceptible when the corner illumination falls to more than 1 stop less than the center. It's not at all bad here - about 1.3 stops wide open, which falls to about 1 stop at smaller apertures (but never quite goes away entirely).
Geometric distortion is, typically for Sony's recent kit lenses, quite high. Unusually for a wideangle it's of the pincushion type, and quite complex in character, with the center of the frame well-corrected but extreme stretching towards the corners.
Specific image quality issues
Corner softness and chromatic aberration
Early pre-production samples of the 16mm F2.8 which were made available to journalists at the NEX system's launch clearly showed real problems, most notably poor corner sharpness and relatively high chromatic aberration. Now we have a production-quality sample, we can give potential buyers some idea of the image quality they should be able to expect from a lens they might buy in a shop. Roll your mouse over the labels below to see how the lens's sharpness changes with aperture in the marked areas of the frame (center, edge and extreme corner).
What we can see here is that the center of the frame is sharp at F2.8, but with a slight 'glow' or halo effect that disappears at F4. The edge of the frame is quite soft wide open, but sharpens up nicely by F5.6, while the extreme corner is distinctly soft at F2.8 and hasn't fully sharpened up even at F8 (of course this tiny section of the frame is unlikely ever to be important in real pictures). Red/cyan fringing from lateral chromatic aberration is also visible, most clearly in the edge crop.
This isn't the kind of output that will satisfy pixel-peeping purists, and clearly there's a price to pay for such a small, inexpensive wideangle. But it's also worth remembering that this is the type of lens you're likely to shoot at stopped down most of the time anyway, and the performance at the most commonly-used apertures (F5.6-11) should satisfy all but the most demanding of users. As usual there are plenty of examples to look at in our samples gallery.
It's also worth bearing in mind that the NEX-3 + 16mm lens combination is cheaper and more portable than most wide zooms for APS-C SLRs - let alone the cameras to put them on. Only Pentax offers a comparable prime, the 15mm F4 Limited, but it costs almost as much as the NEX-3 16mm kit and is a stop slower.
What's wrong with 16mm?
No doubt some of our readers will be wondering why we don't think the 16mm is the best choice for the NEX system at launch. Let's make it clear that we don't object to the lens at all per se; indeed we actually like the idea of having a compact wideangle prime to complement the kit zoom (arguably every system should have one). And, as wide primes go, the 16mm is really rather good in normal, everyday shooting. What concerns us more us is that it's being bundled with the bodies as the cheapest available kit, which is likely to tempt beginners to buy it in the promise of getting a portable, high image quality package for everyday shooting.
The problem here is that a wideangle prime like the 16mm isn't really a general purpose lens, but instead better suited to specific subjects - typically landscapes, architecture, interiors and the like. It's certainly not a great choice for photographing friends or family on a day out; because of its short focal length, that F2.8 aperture isn't going to give you significantly blurred backgrounds, and the inevitable wideangle distortion means anyone towards the edge of the frame will look unflatteringly fat. Overall it's certainly less capable an all-rounder than the fast normal primes available for competing systems, such as the Samsung NX 30mm F2, or the Panasonic 20mm F1.7 for Micro Four Thirds.
Because of this, we wouldn't recommend anyone buys the 16mm F2.8 as their only lens for a NEX unless they are absolutely sure they know what they are doing. Yes we know it's going to give the most compact, portable combination, but we'd advise against sacrificing function for form so dramatically. It would be great as the second or third prime for the system, it's just not an ideal kit lens.
Jun 7, 2010
Feb 28, 2011
Jun 14, 2010
Jun 4, 2013
|Christine by JP Zanotti|
from Car wreck
|Fangorn Forest by cand1d|
|Yosemite Falls with Moonbow by Jonathan Shapiro|
from Best Landscape of the Week 4
Tamara Lackey, a Nikon ambassador USA and pro shooter, discusses embracing self-consciousness as a means of connecting with subjects.
There's a new Spiderman movie coming out (no, really - another one) and the most recent poster been generating a lot of online chatter. Mostly about how it looks like the creation of a fevered teenager that just discovered Photoshop. Read more
An honest defense of the system's merits, with photos as proof.
Copyright disputes are no fun at all. 'Binded' is a new startup that aims to simplify the process of registering - and enforcing - copyright for photographers. Read more
Not everyone wants to pay a premium for a long zoom camera. Thankfully, there are many reasonably priced cameras available, though they won't offer the same image quality as enthusiast models. In this updated roundup we look at big zoom cameras with more consumer-friendly price tags. Read more
Think Tank Photo has updated two of its popular bag lines with improvements to functionality. Read more
We’ve all seen Bob Jackson’s Pulitzer Prize winning photo, but there's another.
The sample footage looks good.
It will automatically pick the best camera settings depending on shooting conditions. It even promises enhanced functionality for your camera, like exposure and focus stacking. It already supports many cameras from Canon, Fuji, Nikon and Sony. Read more
As if $13,950 wasn’t enough to pay for a special edition lens, the Leica Store in San Francisco is offering a prototype of said lens for $24,995. Read more
Make those old photos disappear without deleting them forever.
Firmware updates enable 10 fps shooting with adapted A-mount lenses, and faster startup times and better compatibility for 20 fps shooting when using native lenses on the a9.
Fujifilm has released firmware updates for its camera models X-T2, X-Pro2, GFX 50s, X-T20, X100F and X-T1 and updates to three of its software products.
A 22 year-old Romanian photographer uses his DJI Phantom 4 drone to capture unique perspectives of the city where he now lives.
What's it like to ride the waves with champion surfer Kelly Slater? This VR video from Teton Gravity Research gives you a taste.
When Nikon released the full-frame D3 in 2007, it changed the professional photography industry. In this week's Throwback Thursday, Barney remembers a legend. Read more
The new stuff should have better red hues, improved sensitivity and finer grain - but don't worry - will still shift blues to green, greens to purple and yellows to pink.
Ricoh has introduced a new rugged compact camera with a 16MP CMOS sensor, 28-140mm lens, 2.7" LCD and built-in LED macro lights. Read more
This compact drone can shoot HD video using a 2-axis stabilized 12MP camera. Read more
The new Prynt Pocket can print a photo directly from their iPhone simply by inserting the phone into the printer, then snapping a photo. Each print will cost about 50 cents. Read more
Updates for Adobe Camera Raw and Lightroom CC bring support for the Sony A9 and Panasonic ZS70/TZ90, along with bug fixes.
The Triggertrap remote camera control system is no longer sold due to the company folding, but now users will be able to build their own. Read more
The Magic Format Converter comes with internal optics that expand the image circle of full-frame DSLR lenses for use on the Fuji medium format camera. Read more
The usually Apple-exclusive MacPhun software developer has announced that it will introduce PC versions of two of its most popular applications. Both Aurora HDR and Luminar should be available for the Windows operating system by the autumn of this year. Read more
Sony's newest G Master telephoto zoom, announced alongside the a9, is the first of the company's FE lenses to reach 400mm natively. We had one in California and photographed horses, portraits, and landscapes - check out how it did. Read more
Garmin has entered the 360-camera market with the VIRB, which captures 5.7K video at 30p as well as 15MP stills. Read more
German media reports that the founders of the company behind the Panono 360-degree ball camera have filed for bankruptcy at a court in Berlin. Read more
With a claimed 800 new custom parts, Microsoft's updated Surface Pro comes with the latest Kaby Lake processors, better battery life, a new hinge, plus the Surface Pen is updated as well. Read more
DW Photo is attempting to resurrect the Hy6 medium format camera, though the legal tangles of its development may stop it being branded Rolleiflex.
The Kodak EKTRA, the company's 'camera first' smartphone, is now available to purchase in the United States. Read more