Sigma 17-70mm f/2.8-4 DC Macro OS HSM | C review
5 Conclusion & samples
Conclusion - Pros
- Useful combination of zoom range and relatively fast aperture
- Very good image quality across most of the range
- Compact size
- Reasonably fast and near-silent autofocus
- Effective image stabilisation
Conclusion - Cons
- Somewhat weak image quality at wideangle (soft corners and chromatic aberration)
- Macro shooting a little impractical (very short working distance)
The Sigma 17-70mm F2.8-4 DC Macro OS HSM is designed as an upgrade to the 18-55mm kit lenses supplied with most SLRs, and offers an interesting middle ground between fast zooms of the 17-50mm F2.8 type, and extended-range zooms in the 16-85mm class. In effect you get a bit of both - a usefully-extended range compared to those typical kit zooms, and a faster maximum aperture for better low light capability and a bit more creative control over depth of field.
In practice, the 17-70mm turns out to be an excellent choice if you've grown out of a kit zoom and want something a bit better. It offers generally better optics, a broader zoom range, and of course that faster aperture. But this all comes in a package that's surprisingly compact, and doesn't take up too much extra space in your camera bag. It's not as light as a kit zoom, but not excessively heavy either.
The lens's focusing and image stabilisation systems work well too. Autofocus is pretty fast, and near-silent when shooting stills; we've seen no obvious problems with accuracy either. Likewise the OS system is silent in operation, and works generally very well; we generally got about three stops worth of stabilisation out of it (although as usual, it's best to take a few replicate shots when relying on OS for sharpness).
The 17-70mm's main weakness is its image quality at wideangle; here it suffers from somewhat soft edges which don't sharpen up on stopping down, coupled with quite strong chromatic aberration. The latter can easily be fixed in post-processing if you shoot RAW, but note that only Nikon SLRs will correct it in their JPEG output. Softer edges are more difficult to deal with, so if you spend a lot of time shooting detailed landscapes at wideangle, this may not be the best choice of lens.
The 'Macro' in the lens name points to its impressive-on-paper close focusing, but we found this to be a bit less useful than you might hope. The numbers certainly look good - 22cm minimum focus, 0.37x magnification - but in practice this equates to a very short working distance between the lens and the subject. This means you'll often find yourself blocking out your own light, or casting a visible shadow on your subject. As it happens, those lowly 18-55mm kit zooms offer similar magnification with more practical working distances. So despite the 'Macro' label, we wouldn't necessarily recommend this lens if close-ups are a specific priority.
The Final Word
Sigma's faster-than-average 17-70mm lenses have long had a pretty good reputation as kit zoom upgrades, and the latest iteration continues in this tradition. Its combination of extended focal length range and faster aperture offers useful extra compositional flexibility compared to an 18-55mm F3.5-5.6, and the optics are overall better too. It's not perfect, and in particular may not be the best option if you shoot a lot at wideangle or close-up. But it's very good indeed, and a great choice for SLR owners looking to expand their horizons beyond the kit zoom.
Sigma 17-70mm F2.8-4 DC Macro OS HSM | C
Category: Normal Lens
Ergonomics and Handling
Sigma's latest 'C' badged 17-70mm F2.8-4 is an excellent upgrade option for SLR shooters who've outgrown their kit zooms, and are looking for better image quality and more creative flexibility. It offers a fine balance of zoom range and maximum aperture, while still being highly portable. Autofocus and image stabilisation both work well, but image quality at wideangle isn't the best.
There are 36 images in the samples gallery. Please do not reproduce any of these images on a website or any newsletter / magazine without prior permission (see our copyright page). We make the originals available for private users to download to their own machines for personal examination or printing (in conjunction with this review), we do so in good faith, please don't abuse it.
Unless otherwise noted images taken with no particular settings at full resolution. Because our review images are now hosted on the 'galleries' section of dpreview.com, you can enjoy all of the new galleries functionality when browsing these samples.
Sigma 17-70mm f/2.8-4 DC Macro OS HSM C review samples
The Chinese manufacturer has published a list of improvements it wants to make after a videography-focused feedback session with its users.
Autel has confirmed to DPReview that its EVO II series drones won't hit shelves until March 2020 after discovering a bug that ‘could limit flight performance under normal operation.’
Chinese company Xiaomi has so far (as far as we know) worked without the help of a big name in the camera business, but it appears this could be about to change.
DNP Photo is back with another dye sublimation photo printer. The QW410 is relatively compact and includes wireless support for mobile users.
Photographer Pye Jirsa is teaching photographers how to pose couples as part of a new educational video series from Adorama.
Award-winning French photographer Florian Ledoux has captured photos of the arctic from both a drone's perspective and the ground.
Photographer and filmmaker Mark Holtze shares his top five reasons why vintage lenses are still relevant in 2020.
What if astrophotography was as simple as using an app? The Stellina smart telescope promises to make this a reality, allowing anyone to channel their own inner Galileo while capturing images of the night sky.
The Fujifilm XC 35mm F2 prime lens has the same optical formula as the company's XF 35mm F2 WR prime but costs half as much. How can this be? Chris and Jordan explain the differences.
In the latest episode of DPReview TV, Chris and Jordan compared the new, inexpensive Fujifilm XC 35mm F2 with the more durable XF version that's twice the price. See some of the photos they took side-by-side in this sample gallery.
The 2019 winners and finalists of the Travel Photographer of the Year Awards have been revealed.
PBS recently gave viewers a look at MIT Museum's new The Polaroid Project instant photography exhibition.
Researchers with IBM and MIT have published a new demonstration tool that allows anyone to 'paint' new elements into existing digital images.
Venus Optics says the lens is the first Laowa macro lens specifically designed for APS-C mirrorless camera systems.
The updates mostly address only a single issue for each lens, but it continues to show Sigma's continued dedication to addressing various issues, even small ones, across its lens lineup.
Spider Holster has launched four new products, including two updated versions of existing gear, that make life easier for photographers.
While nearly all of Tokina's F-mount lenses will work without issue on Nikon Z-series mirrorless cameras, there are a select few that can't use autofocus.
The X-T200 is arguably the company's most compelling entry-level option yet. Take a closer look in our detailed hands-on article.
Last year, DJI announced they will be adding ADS-B sensors to their commercial-grade drones weighing over 250 grams. Now, it is rumored that 3 new drone models will be released this year.
The Fujifilm X-T200 is what we wish the X-T100 had been, offering a solid AF system, proper 4K video and a more responsive interface. Click through to see what else is new and improved.
Fujifilm just announced its newest camera, the X-T200. In this hands-on preview, Chris and Jordan explain how it fits into Fujifilm's lineup and why they like it.
Fujifilm will add the weather-sealed GF 45-100mm F4 to its medium format lens lineup in February. The approximately 35-80mm equivalent zoom will cost around $2300.
Two new primes are hitting the roadmap for Fujifilm's GF system: the 24mm equiv. 30mm F3.5 R WR and an ultra-fast 80mm F1.7.
The 'XC' variant uses the same optical design as the existing XF 35mm F2, but has no aperture ring and a plastic mount to lower the cost.
Fujifilm has refreshed its entry-level series with the X-T200, adding a giant touchscreen, proper 4K/30p video recording and shaving off 80g of weight compared to its X-T100 predecessor.
The telephoto zoom features a constant F4 aperture across its 70-210mm focal length range, uses Pentax's supersonic direct-drive motor (SDM), and weighs 859g (1.89lbs).
DynaLite, the photographic lighting company founded in the 1970s, has been forced to file for bankruptcy and permanently shutter its service.
Flickr increased its Pro plan subscription price this week, but existing customers are given the option of staying at their current lower rate.
Advertising photographer Blair Bunting recounts one of his most memorable shoots—the time he photographed late New England Patriots football star Aaron Hernandez, no more than 24 hours after committing murder.
Lace up your dancing shoes for a trip to Seattle's Emerald City Soul Club, where we put the Panasonic S1H's impressive video capabilities to the test.