Super Shootout: Samsung Galaxy S4 vs HTC One vs Apple iPhone 5 vs Nokia Lumia 920
1 Landscape & Outdoor Portraits
2013 is still young but has been an interesting year so far in terms of mobile image capture. At the Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas and at the Mobile World Congress in Barcelona a number of devices, all of them running the Android operating system and boasting 13MP camera modules, were announced. This includes the Sony Xperia Z, the ZTE Grand S, Huawei Ascend D2 and Lenovo K900. In March Samsung followed with their new flagship device, the Galaxy S4.
While Samsung is betting on a 13MP horse, HTC, the second largest manufacturer of Android devices, is going the opposite way, equipping its HTC One top-end phone with an unusually low resolution 4MP sensor with large photosites (which HTC calls "ultrapixels") and optical image stabilization (OIS) which, in theory, should result in improved low light capabilities.
However, Google's Android OS is of course not your only option if you are currently in the market for a smartphone with good imaging capabilities. Apple's iPhone 5 and the Nokia Lumia 920 have been on the market for a while and successors are no doubt in the pipeline, but for now these devices are more than valid options for iOS and Windows Phone users, respectively.
Arguably the most interesting new Android devices, the Samsung Galaxy S4 and HTC One are finally available for purchase - and crucially at last in our office - so we put them head-to-head with the established competition from Apple and Nokia. Here is an overview of our competitors in this shootout and their key photographic specifications:
|Phone||Sensor||Aperture||Optical IS||Focal length*||Aspect ratio|
|Samsung Galaxy S4||13MP CMOS||F2.2||no||31mm||4:3|
|HTC One||4MP CMOS||F2.0||yes||28mm||16:9|
|Apple iPhone 5||8MP CMOS||F2.4||no||33mm||4:3|
|Nokia Lumia 920||8MP CMOS||F2.0||yes||26mm||16:9|
For the purpose of this shootout we have taken sample images in a variety of "real-life" situations and in our controlled studio environment. This article comprises of four pages with the following content:
- Page 1: Landscape image and portrait in good light
- Page 2: Low light portrait, flash shot and night scene
- Page 3: Studio scene in bright light
- Page 4: Studio scene in low light and conclusion
This shot was taken in bright sunlight with all cameras in Auto ISO and White Balance modes. The phones were mounted on a tripod using an iStabilizer smartphone holder and all images where shot from the same position.
Looking at the four samples above there are some obvious differences in terms of contrast and saturation. The Samsung, HTC and Nokia all produce very saturated and contrasty images, with the Nokia almost going slightly over the top. The iPhone captures a more natural image, with less saturated colors and visibly lower contrast.
Looking at the 100% crops, the difference in pixel count between the cameras becomes very obvious. The HTC One looks the sharpest at a pixel-level but this is due to a combination of the low pixel count and pretty strong sharpening. However, with its 13MP sensor the Samsung, at least in good light, simply captures more detail.
All the cameras here struggle with low-contrast detail, even at low ISOs and in good light. This is very visible on all the trees and foliage in the scene. However, the Nokia's mix of heavy noise reduction and sharpening looks worse than the rest up close. The Apple and Samsung arguably offer the best balance between noise reduction and sharpening here. The S4's sharpening is still quite strong but in good light its 13MP CMOS captures the most detail in this comparison (by a whisker).
This outdoor portrait was shot hand-held in the shade, with consistent camera-subject distance. Again, all cameras were set to Auto ISO and White Balance and as you can below, the light was bright enough for all devices to select base ISO (or close to it in the case of the HTC One).
In these portraits we can see the same differences in saturation and contrast as in the landscape shot above, but there is also some exposure variance. The HTC has produced a darker image than the rest while the iPhone's image is the brightest. In this light situation Auto White Balance has produced a slightly blue cast on all images.
Despite all devices keeping the sensitivity low in this low contrast situation, all images suffer from a loss of fine detail through noise reduction. The sharpening on both the Nokia and HTC is very strong, resulting in a punchy but slightly unnatural look. Again, the iPhone and Samsung show a better balance of noise reduction and sharpening, but ultimately the Samsung captures slightly more image information than the Apple device.
This is another portrait shot, taken hand-held in bright sunlight, to see how the cameras deal with skin tones in contrasty lighting conditions. Again, all cameras were set to Auto modes.
Again, the HTC captures a slightly darker image than the iPhone with the Samsung and Nokia falling in between, but overall exposure is within acceptable limits on all devices.
All cameras struggle with the bright highlights caused by the reflection of the sun on the subject's skin. On the Samsung, Apple and Nokia the red channel is clipping, resulting in blown out areas on the skin. The Apple iPhone is the worst offender here. The HTC One, on the other hand, is the only camera here to capture most of the highlight detail which indicates that its large photosites can capture an additional amount of highlight range over the higher resolution competition.
YouTube channel Filmmaker IQ has put together a very interesting, technically detailed, and scientifically accurate description of exactly how various image sensors (and photographic film) work. One of the best overview videos we've seen.
In Part 1 of his series on photographing Greenland in winter, landscape photographer Erez Marom shares the freezing details of his arrival on the town of Uummannaq where the temperature was -25°C. Still, he went out shooting.
SmugMug has acquired struggling photography site Flickr for an undisclosed sum, with CEO Don MacAskill promising to give the neglected photo sharing service 'the resources that it deserves'.
The APO-Makro-Plasmat 105mm F2.7 is Meyer Optik's latest Kickstarter lens revival, and it promises "natural sharpness, unbelievable color reproduction, and a glowing bokeh united at every step of the aperture" ... whatever that means.
The update also comes with "post-scan cloud processing," which allows you to render 3D models with 4K resolution textures for better detail and realism.
Chinese accessories brand Meike has announced it will introduce an 85mm F1.8 lens for Canon and Nikon full frame DSLRs that will feature autofocus. This will be the company’s first AF lens.
The World Photo Organization has finally revealed the overall winners for the 2018 Sony World Photography Awards, including the coveted Photographer of the Year, Open Photographer of the Year, Youth Photographer of the Year, and Student Photographer of the Year winners.
Venus Optics has unveiled four new lenses that will ship later this year: a wide-angle zoom for Sony FE, a circular fisheye for Micro Four Thirds, a wide-angle lens for the medium format Fujifilm GFX, and a 2x Ultra Macro for multiple full-frame mounts.
The One Backpack is a 5-in-1 modular backpack that can be used as a camera bag, work & gym pack, suit carry backpack, travel pack or tech-backpack.
This highly-specialized lens is perfect for sports, action and wildlife photography. Check out these first sample images for a taste of what it's capable of.
For KFC Hong Kong’s latest ad campaign, New York City-based advertising agency Ogilvy and Mather used Photoshop to magically morph pieces of flaky fried chicken into fire and smoke in various scenes.
The Android and iOS app from Surpuba AR lets you place animated 3D models in real-world environment using augmented reality technology. You can alter poses and location, insert lighting equipment, and more... right from your phone or tablet.
Under the agreement, the two companies will work together to develop Oppo's smartphone camera roadmap, covering optical zoom, depth mapping and other innovative imaging features that dual cameras allow.
Canon is jumping into the portable printing game with the new IVY Mini Photo Printer: a rechargeable battery-powered printer for creating 2x3 prints and stickers of your smartphone snaps on-the-go.
The program first launched last year, but only as a temporary promotion limited to previous-generation GoPro cameras exchanged for discounts on current-generation models. This time around, GoPro is accepting nearly any digital camera in any condition.
One of the most usable 360° cameras on the market is getting even better. With its latest update, Rylo adds a 180° mode, bluetooth remote capture, and a cinematic motion blur effect for your timelapse shots.
Phase One has released the first major update to its Capture One Pro 11 photo editing program. The update adds support for 8 new cameras and 16 new lenses, and includes several new features and functional improvements that speed up workflow.
We recently got our hands on Samsung's latest and greatest smartphone, the dual camera, variable aperture Galaxy S9+, and took it to mostly sunny Southern California for a long weekend.
It's spring, and that means wedding season is upon us! If you're one of the many photographers planning wedding shoots this year, this is a great time to think about including aerial photography in your plans.
The first firmware update for the Sony a7 III addresses an issue in video mode wherein "blinking pixels" would show up along the base of footage recorded with certain settings.
Researchers with Switzerland's EPFL have developed a soft exoskeleton that enables its wearer to control a drone using their upper body. The human-robot interface is said to offer "natural and intuitive control of drones."
Photokina has released an official list of confirmed exhibitors for the 2018 expo, quieting rumors that major brands like Canon and Profoto might follow in Elinchrom's lead and skip this year's show.
For owners of Sony's a7R III, a9 and the new a7 III, there's now an easy fix for the rare but dreaded 'striping' in backlit shots with lots of flare. Click through to learn more.
The team behind the ubiquitous JPEG format has unveiled an all new image format designed to quickly and efficiently stream content across wired and wireless networks alike. Surprisingly, it actually uses less compression than traditional JPEG.
Canon USA has released a promotional video showcasing its latest CMOS sensor technology. Albeit over daraticized, it’s an interesting overlook at the work it’s continually putting into its camera systems.
The large-format digital LargeSense LS911 is the "world's first 8x10 digital single shot camera for sale." The camera features a 12-megapixel 9x11-inch monochrome CMOS sensor, which translates into massive 75 micron pixels.
Pricing and availability have been announced for Tokina's high-end Fírin 20mm F2 FE AF autofocus lens for Sony E-Mount. If you're curious about this lens, you'll be able to pick up your own starting in June for $950 USD.
It's the copyright lawsuit that refuses to die. In September 2017, PETA finally settled its monkey selfie lawsuit with photographer David Slater, but the request to dismiss the case has since been rejected by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.
As part of his ongoing ‘Good Light’ YouTube series, London-based photographer Sean Tucker has created a simple tutorial on how to find good natural light for portraits.
The 2018 Pulitzer Prizes were announced yesterday, with the photography awards going to photojournalist Ryan Kelly for image of a car plowing into protesters in Virginia, and the entire Reuters photo staff for a series on Rohinga refugees fleeing persecution.