Special K? Pentax K-1 Review
By Chris Williams
The Gorge located along the Columbia River just outside of Portland Oregon was my first stop. The main goal for this trip was to test out the different Pixel Shift shooting modes, but I also wanted to get an idea of just how hard I could push this camera in real life circumstances. The weather wasn't optimal in terms of hiking but it definitely gave me a leg up in terms of shooting waterfalls and really testing the dynamic range due to the cloudy and rainy weather.
My fiance and I started the 3 hour drive down to the gorge at around 8am on a wet and gloomy Saturday morning and thankfully traffic wasn't too terrible so we made fairly good time. We arrived at Eagle Creek trail in the early afternoon and proceeded to make our way down to Metlako and Punch Bowl Falls located about 2 miles along the Eagle Creek trail head just outside of Portland, OR.
Most of the Eagle Creek trail is carved into some fairly steep cliffs and snakes its way back along the deep river valley that lies several hundred feet below the trail.
Pentax K-1, HD PENTAX-D FA 28-105mm F3.5-5.6 ED DC WR, 28mm, F6.3, 1/50, ISO 100
There are a number of beautiful spots to take in the views and two waterfalls (Punch Bowl and Metlako falls) to make the trip more than worthwhile. The weather conditions were, well, pretty miserable. My fiancé and I experienced moderate rain throughout most of the day which definitely put a damper (literally) on the trip.
An Introduction to Pixel Shift
It's clear that the Pixel Shift Resolution shooting modes make a huge difference to image quality from our studio tests, but how does that translate to real world shooting situations?
In previous iterations of this feature (in the K3 II) we found that movement within a scene could cause major issues during Pixel Shift Capture. So if leaves rustled in the wind or your subject moved in any way the camera compensated poorly for the movement, which then resulted in pixel blur and artifacts in the regions where the movement occurred.
Like the K-3 II, Pixel Shift on the K-1 takes four separate exposures at single pixel increments; however, the K-1 now offers a 'Motion Correction' option. If movement is detected in subsequent images, the camera is supposedly able to differentiate pixels that have changed from the first frame and clone in pixels to cover that area from the first frame of the 4-shot capture. In theory, this should produce a much better final product then was possible in the Pentax K3 II.
To determine just how much the technology has improved in the K-1 over the previous iteration, I took the camera out into the field to really push the limits of the Pixel Shift Resolution shooting modes. I converted the resulting files in both Adobe Lightroom (my Raw converter of choice) (using ACR 9.5.1, which Adobe has confirmed represents final support for Pixel Shift) and also SilkyPix, which is bundled with the K-1 (although not the latest version SilkyPix 7.0).
Pushing the Limits of Pixel Shift Resolution
Our first stop was Metlako Falls located about a mile from the trail head. The access trail to Metlako is poorly marked, so it's definitely easy to miss if you aren't careful. I chose this waterfall because it offers an excellent opportunity to examine not only how the Pixel Shift deals with movement but also detail resolution, since the waterfall is surrounded by dense and lush foliage. The following widget contains files that were shot at 70mm and an aperture of F/10 to limit the effects of diffraction and to really give you a sense of the detail resolution that is possible with the Pixel Shift mode turned on.
Using the widget below you can examine files converted using Adobe Lightroom, Silkypix, and out of camera JPEGs. We're showing files taken with Pixel Shift turned off, and with Pixel Shift turned on with Motion Correction enabled.
While files from our movement-free studio scene look great when run through ACR, our waterfall images (converted in the same way, using the same software) show very . SilkyPix does a much better job, and there's no sign of any false colors in the same areas in files converted through the K-1's bundled software.
However, while there's no crazy false color, even in the out of camera JPEGs and Raw images processed using SilkyPix you can still see some issues withwhere movement took place (mostly in the foliage surrounding the waterfall) as the four frames were captured. This can lead to some strange . And when it comes to landscapes, finding truly static shooting environments can be difficult, if not impossible.
With that said, if you process your Pixel Shift files through SilkyPix, the end result might be good enough (depending on the amount of movement you're dealing with) that cloning or masking in rough-looking areas via your favorite post processing software becomes an option. Interestingly, sometimes SilkyPix does an eventhan the camera JPEG engine itself. In fact, much of the image is quite usable in the SilkyPix conversion, but if you're the kind of person that desires the detail Pixel Shift brings, you'll still find yourself cloning out in many regions for a scene like this one.
Out of Camera JPEG Options
If you don't mind JPEG output, you can also retroactively add motion correction in-camera to an image shot with Pixel Shift.
After applying the Pixel Shift to the file, you can export it as an out of camera JPEG. With that said, I don't know too many landscape photographers that shoot in JPEG or want to produce out of camera JPEGs, since they're mostly un-editable from a post processing standpoint. You're probably better off using SilkyPix, with all the caveats that brings (more on that later).
Dynamic Range Benefits
There's another benefit to Pixel Shift we briefly alluded to: since information from four Raw files are essentially combined, noise is decreased. It's not that frames are averaged, but that 4x as much total light is collected and used in generating the final image, which decreases relative shot noise. This suggests a nearly 2 EV theoretical increase in dynamic range (ignoring read noise), and indeed a significant improvement is evident in the +4 EV pushed shots below. The non-pixel shift file still shows respectable noise performance in the shadows thanks to the very high dynamic range sensor, and the Pixel Shift file is even cleaner. While it's not quite a 2EV advantage, the Pixel Shift files in our studio dynamic range tests look better than the standard shots despite a 1EV relative underexposure. Hence, we'd estimate a benefit of somewhere between 1 and 2 EV.
So what does this mean?
When it comes to Pixel Shift Raws, ACR is unable to cope with any sort of movement that may have occurred in the short time that the K-1 takes to capture the four separate files. Color artifacts and cross-hatching result in areas of motion, although the rest of the image experiences a significant detail increase. ACR doesn’t support Motion Correction at all. So (for now, at least) Pixel Shift and ACR simply don't mix.
SilkyPix, on the other hand, handles Pixel Shift Raws in a different manner from ACR, which alleviates the color artifacts that we see in the files processed through ACR. It can also interpret the Raws shot with Motion Correction activated and produce a final image with far fewer motion artifacts - sometimes doing an even better job than the K-1's in-camera JPEG engine.
Digging a little deeper, we've found that only the first of the four exposures taken during the Pixel Shift process is used to mask in problem areas when the Motion Correction setting has been enabled (in in-camera JPEGs or SilkyPix conversions). This makes sense - comparing the four files to find the sharpest one would be too computationally intensive to be practical - but it does mean that if the first exposure should happen to contain the most blur, results might not be optimal.
Punchbowl Falls, Columbia River Gorge, OR. No Pixel Shift modes enabled.
Pentax K-1, HD Pentax D FA 24-70mm F2.8 ED SDM WR 70mm, F16, 1/4 sec, ISO 100
The amount of detail in the Pixel Shift files is markedly better than those taken with the mode turned off, but for landscape work (assuming anything short of totally still conditions) artifacts caused by movement in the scene can still cause issues. I'm glad that things aren't quite as bad as we feared from looking solely at the output from Adobe Lightroom, but even the SilkyPix version 7.0 software shows some movement artifacts in Pixel Shift files. And, at least for Mac users, SilkyPix is not the most stable or easy to use software out there. 9 out of 10 times we tried to use it, we got an unusable image preview even at 100% - making editing cumbersome, if not impossible. Capture One and DxO Optics Pro don't currently support the K-1 or Pixel Shift (e.g. on the older K-3 II) at all.
The reality, then, is that Raw shooters wanting to take advantage of Pixel Shift for scenes with motion will have to resort to (the buggy and cumbersome) SilkyPix. That's a real limitation, but not an insurmountable one - you can perform rudimentary processing in SilkyPix and then output a 16-bit TIFF to continue processing in Lightroom or Photoshop.
In absolutely perfect shooting conditions though (macro, portrait, and some telephoto work), the K-1's Pixel Shift shooting modes can offer outstanding results. The OOC JPEG and SilkyPix Raw images below depict a (mostly) static cityscape, and the real-world detail resolution is very impressive when movement isn't a factor.
It is worth noting, however, that if there is a chance of any movement occurring in the frame I would definitely recommend backing your files up with non-Pixel Shift exposures so you can choose to mask areas in using post processing tools or choose to use the non Pixel Shift files.
May 12, 2016
Nov 17, 2015
Feb 24, 2017
Oct 3, 2016
|Smile by Olymguy|
from Ultra Asian Indian Female Faces
|Space Shuttle Cockpit- by vbuhay|
from Aircraft Control Stick
Just a guy wearing a VR headset, smashing invisible Goombas in Central Park.
NASA's Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter captured this gorgeous aerial photo of the Martian landscape. And if you look really close, you can actually see the Mars Curiosity rover in the very middle.
The city of Laguna Beach, California has provided some clarification around the kinds of photography permits it offers.
Later this year, a VR180 camera will be Joining Yi's Halo and 360 VR cameras, which will offer stereo 3D capture, yet be as easy to use and compact as a 2D camera.
Caltech researchers have developed an 'optical phased array' chip that uses time delays instead of a lens to focus the incoming light.
Pricing and shipping have finally been revealed for two highly anticipated lenses from Sigma, announced in February.
These macro photos of clouds of paint billowing through clear water might look like high-quality CGI, but they're real photographs. And photographer Alberto Seveso told us how they were made.
Facebook is testing a feature that prevents people from saving, sharing, or even taking a screenshot of your profile picture.
We've reshot the Sony a9 in our studio. The short story: it's sharper! The long story... well you can read it all here.
The collection will be officially launched during the Europeana Transcribathon Campus Berlin 2017 crowdsourcing event which will be held on 22 and 23 June at the Berlin State Library.
Light gives us some insight into the preparations for the launch of the pre-order shipments of its much anticipated L16 multi-lens camera.
OnePlus co-founder Carl Pei has confirmed in a tweet that the second lens on the back of the OnePlus 5 uses a 1.6x optical zoom and that digital zoom is used to reach the claimed 2x zoom factor.
Fujifilm recently unveiled the second in its series of affordable cine lenses, the MK50-135mm T2.9. We got our hands on it for a couple days and took it for a spin.
Leica's first attempt at an M-series digital rangefinder was rough around the edges, but set a pattern for all of the cameras that came after it. In this week's Throwback Thursday article, Barney remembers the M8.
No stranger to extreme situations, legendary climber and filmmaker Jimmy Chin talks to Outside Magazine about his career, and the challenge of filming Alex Honnold's rope-free solo climb of El Capitain.
A company backed by Android co-founder Andy Rubin is attempting to make video conferencing less terrible.
Rangefinder magazine asked five professional portrait and wedding photographers about posting on Instagram; no surprise, they got five different answers.
This captivating stop motion film was created by stripping away one layer of wood at a time. It's hard to look away.
It will enable users to simulate the presence of the sun, moon and Milky Way and see how they interact with an area's topography.
Since its introduction in November last year Instagram's live streaming feature has been used by millions, but videos could not be archived for watching at a later stage. A new update has now added the capability.
CopyTrack's study also found that the second most-stolen image is a woman wearing painted jeans. That's apparently a thing.
Forget expensive lenses with fancy coatings and special lens elements – photographer Robin de Puy took these portraits using just a water drop for a lens.
Adobe reports a record quarterly revenue of $1.77 billion for the second quarter fiscal year 2017 ended June 2, 2017.
Zeiss says its new lens is particularly suited for portrait photography but also a good all-rounder and can be used in video applications.
We present to you the top photos from the Kennel Club's 2017 Dog Photographer of the Year photo contest – take a look at 10 of the award-winning puppers.
In case you were looking for any more inspiration to go fly one.
Following a couple of successful Kickstarter campaigns, Videre 35mm's creator has re-tooled the camera with sturdier components and a simpler user assembly process.
The two hour long video covers everything an aspiring drone pilot needs to know.
This is what happens when a Canon 17-85mm F4-5.6 lens meets 60,000 PSI of water pressure. Spoiler Alert: the water jet always wins.
Andrew Harnik discusses the challenges – and rewarding moments – of a career making images for the Associated Press in his native DC.