Compared to...
Like the Panasonic DMC G1 the GH1 is technically not an SLR. However, in both design and specification the Panasonic Micro Four Thirds cameras are in many aspects not too dissimilar from an 'upper entry level' DSLR such as the Canon EOS 500D or Nikon D5000. However, the GH1's versatile video mode (something that the G1 does not offer) and the fact that it is, at least for the moment, only available as a kit with the new Lumix G Vario HD 14-140mm lens lift it above the price levels of these mirrored competitors. Having said that, the GH1 kit price is quite difficult to compare. If you look at the price figures in the table below you should keep two things in mind:
1. At the time of writing of this review at most major retailers the GH1 is only available for pre-order - at the recommended retail price. As soon as larger quantities of GH1s will be in stock prices will almost certainly start dropping but at this point we can only speculate about a realistic street price.
2. The GH1 is only available as a kit with the new and optimized-for-video Lumix G Vario HD 14-140mm F4-5.8 lens that offers a much more variable zoom range and would no doubt, if it was available on its own, be significantly more expensive than the standard zoom kit lenses the DSLRs in this comparison come with. The Canon and Nikon with lenses equivalent to the 14-140mm (Nikon 18-200 AF-S VR f/3.5-5.6 and Canon EF-S 18-200mm F3.5-5.6 IS) would currently cost you around $1400 and $1360 respectively, which brings the overall price much closer to GH1 territory. The Panasonic GH1 can therefore, depending on your photographic (and videographic) needs, be a more than viable alternative to its peers in the DSLR world.
Therefore we have chosen three of those peers to compare it to, each of which competes with the GH1 in one way or another. The E-620 is one of the smallest image stabilized DSLR available. It offers a high degree of external control and customizability, and, like the GH1, a swivel-screen. It has no video recording feature though. The new Nikon D5000 comes with 720p video recording, a swivel-screen and arguably one of the most refined user interfaces in its class. Finally, we've included the Canon EOS 500D, which with 1080p video (20fps) and a 15.1 megapixel sensor is perhaps the strongest all-round DSLR in its price range. Let's start with a quick look at how the competitors line up:
| Camera | Kit price |
LCD | Anti Shake |
Sensor (effective pixels) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Panasonic GH1 | $1499 | 3.0" / 460k pixels | Lens option | 12.1 LiveMOS (2.0x crop), Multi aspect ratio |
| Canon EOS 500D | $895 | 3.0" / 920k pixels | Lens option | 15.1 MP CMOS (1.6x crop) |
| Nikon D5000 | $800 | 2.7" / 230k pixels | Lens option | 12.3 MP CMOS (1.5x crop) |
| Olympus E-620 | $700 | 2.7" / 230k pixels | In-body | 12.3 MP LiveMOS (2.0x crop) |
Panasonic GH1 advantages
- Smaller and lighter than the competition
- 1080P AVCHD video at 30fps
- Full manual control in video mode
- Auto Focus tracking
- Kit lens specifically designed for video recording with silent continuous AF and seamless aperture adjustment
Panasonic GH1 disadvantages
- Price
- 3 fps continuous shooting
 Panasonic GH1 |
 Canon 500D |
 Nikon D5000 |
 Olympus E-620 |
|
| Price (single lens kit) |
US: $1499 [check price] including 14-140mm kit lens |
US: $895 [check price] | US: $800 [check price] | US: $700 [check price] |
| Sensor | • 4/3 type MOS ('Live MOS sensor') • 14.0 million total pixels • 12.1 million effective pixels • RGB (Primary) color filter array |
• 22.3 x 14.9 mm CMOS • 15.1 million effective pixels • 15.5 million effective pixels |
• 23.6 x 15.8 mm CMOS • 12.3 million effective pixels • 12.9 million effective pixels |
• 17.3 x 13.0 mm LiveMOS • 12.3 million effective pixels • 13.1 million effective pixels |
| Dust reduction | • Supersonic Wave Filter | • Anti-dust materials • Low pass filter vibration • Dust reference image |
• Low pass filter vibration • Airflow Control System • Dust reference image |
• Supersonic Wave Filter |
| Native image size | 4000 x 3000 (4:3)
4128 x 2752 (3:2) 4352 x 2448 (16:9) 2992 x 2992 (1:1) (multi aspect ratio sensor) |
4752 x 3168 (3:2 ratio) |
4288 x 2848 (3:2 ratio) |
4032 x 3024 (4:3 ratio) |
| Video | 1080p AVCHD @ 30fps 720p Motion JPEG @ 30fps Dolby stereo sound |
1080p @ 20fps |
720p @ 24 fps |
no video capability |
| Lens support | • Micro Four Thirds mount lenses • Four Thirds mount lenses via adapter DMW-MA1PP (AF not available with all lenses) |
• Canon EF mount • Including EF-S lenses |
• Nikon F-mount • Includes DX lenses • AF only available with AF-S or AF-I lenses |
• 4/3 standard lens mount • Olympus and third party 4/3 |
| FOV crop | 2.0x | 1.6x | 1.5x | 2.0x |
| Body shake reduction | No | No | No | Yes |
| Live view | The GH1 has a mirrorless design and therefore always operates in live view | Yes, Contrast detect (inc Face detection) or Phase detect AF | Yes, Contrast detect (inc Face priority) or Phase detect AF | Yes, Contrast detect (inc Face detection) or Phase detect AF |
| File formats | • RAW
• JPEG (2 levels) |
• RAW (comp.
lossless 14-bit) • JPEG (2 levels) |
• RAW (compressed) • JPEG (3 levels) |
• RAW (comp. lossless) • JPEG (4 levels) |
| RAW+JPEG | RAW + JPEG (Any quality) | RAW + JPEG (Fine) | RAW + JPEG (Any quality) | RAW + JPEG (any quality) |
| Auto focus | • Contrast detect AF • 23-Area-Focusing/1 Area Focusing • Manual focus • Face Detection • AF Tracking |
• 9 area TTL • Cross-type F2.8 at center • Range: -0.5 to +18 EV • Contrast detect AF in live view |
• 11 area TTL • Cross-type at center • Range: -1 to +19 EV • Contrast detect AF in live view |
• 7 area TTL • Range: -1 to +19 EV • Contrast detect AF in live view |
| AF illuminator | Built-in lamp | Flash strobe, must be raised | Built-in lamp | Flash strobe, must be raised |
| Color space | • sRGB • Adobe RGB |
• sRGB • Adobe RGB |
• sRGB • Adobe RGB |
• sRGB • Adobe RGB |
| Metering | • Intelligent Multiple • Center-Weighted • Spot |
• Evaluative • Partial • Center-weighted average • 4% spot |
• 3D Color Matrix Metering II |
• Digital ESP • Center-weighted average • Spot • Highlight based spot • Shadow based spot |
| Exp. comp. | +/- 3.0 EV |
+/- 2.0 EV | +/- 5.0 EV | +/- 5.0 EV |
| Sensitivity | • ISO 100 - 3200 | • ISO 100 - 3200 (with 6400 and 12800 equiv) |
• ISO 200 - 3200 |
• ISO 100 - 3200 |
| Auto ISO | Auto (100-1600) Intelligent ISO |
Auto (100-1600) | User definable maximum ISO and minimum shutter speed | Auto (100 - 1600) |
| High- ISO NR | Yes (5 levels) | Yes (4 levels) | Yes (4 levels) | Yes (4 levels) |
| Shutter speed | • 60 -1/4000 sec / Bulb
• Flash X-sync 1/160 sec |
• 30 - 1/4000 sec / Bulb • 1/200 sec Flash sync |
• 30 - 1/4000 sec / Bulb • 1/200 sec Flash sync |
• 60 - 1/4000 sec / Bulb • 1/180 sec Flash sync |
| Continuous shooting |
• 3 fps • Unlimited JPEG/HQ frames • 7 RAW frames |
• 3.4 fps • 170 JPEG/Fine frames • 9 RAW frames |
• 4 fps |
• 4 fps • Unlimited JPEG/HQ frames • 5 RAW frames |
| White balance | • Auto • Five presets • Two custom presets • Kelvin temperature • Fine tunable |
• Auto • Eight presets • Manual preset • Kelvin temperature • Fine tunable |
• Auto • Twelve presets • Manual preset • Fine tunable |
• Auto • Eight presets • Manual preset • Kelvin temperature • Fine tunable |
| Flash | Electronic release pop-up | Electronic release pop-up | Electronic release pop-up | Electronic release pop-up |
| Viewfinder | • Electronic Viewfinder • Color LCD Viewfinder • Field of view 100% • Eye point 14 mm at -1 dioptre • Magnification 1.4x (equivalent to 0.7x on a 35mm camera / 50mm lens) • Dioptre adjustment -4 to +4 dioptre • 1,440,000 dots • Field Sequential (RGB) |
• Pentamirror • Eyepoint 18 mm • Frame coverage 95% • Magnification approx 0.87x • Precision matte screen |
• Pentamirror • Eyepoint 18 mm • Frame coverage 95% • Magnification approx 0.78x • B-type Bright View Clear Matte Mark V |
• Pentamirror • Eyepoint 16 mm • Frame coverage 95% • Magnification approx 0.96x • Lumi-Micron Matte screen |
| LCD monitor | • 3.0 " TFT LCD • 460,000 dots • Hinged/swivel |
• 3.0 " TFT LCD • 920,000 dots |
• 2.7 " TFT LCD |
• 2.7 " TFT LCD • 230,000 dots • Hinged/swivel |
| Storage | SD/SDHC card | SD/SDHC card | SD/SDHC card | • Compact Flash card • xD Picture card |
| Battery | DMW-BLB13PP (1250 mAh 7.2v) | LP-E5 (7.4 V, 1050 mAh) | EN-EL9a (7.2 V, 1080 mAh) | PS-BLS1 (7.2 V, 1150 mAh) |
| Vertical grip | No | BG-E5 (option) | No | HLD-5 (option) |
| Software | • Photofun Studio • Silkypix |
• Canon DPP • Canon PhotoStitch • Canon ZoomBrowser EX • EOS Utility (Remote Capt.) |
• Nikon Transfer • ViewNX • Nikon Capture NX (trial) |
• Olympus Master 2.0 • Olympus Studio 2.0 (trial) |
| Dimensions | 124 x 90 x 45 mm (5.7 x 3.5 x 1.8 in) |
129 x 98 x 62 mm (5.1 x 3.9 x 2.4 in) |
127 x 104 x 80 mm (5.0 x 4.1 x 3.1 in) |
130 x 94 x 60 mm (5.1 x 3.7 x 2.4 in) |
| Weight (no batt) | 385g (0.8 lb) | 480 g (1.1 lb) | 560 g (1.2 lb) | 475 g (1.0 lb) |
Comments