Panasonic Lumix DC-GH5S Review
Dynamic Range in video
Like the GH5 and 4, the GH5S can shoot using Panasonic's V-Log L gamma curve, to increase the dynamic range you capture and to make it more usable. This is how it works:
Since you can't shoot Raw video on these cameras, the next best thing is to ensure you make the best use of the limited bit depth of the 8 or 10-bit footage the camera can capture. To achieve this, a Log curve crams lots of highlights into the top ~20% of the file's values, then devotes around ~60% of the remaining file to capturing as much of the tonal information about the midtones as possible, then leaves the remainder for the shadows.
The idea is to devote as much of the file's capacity for tonal information to the most important tones in the image. The result is footage that initially looks grey and low-contrast because so much of the middle of the tonal range has been stretched out across the file, but in a way that should allow you to give a gentle roll-off to the highlights and allow significant manipulation of the midtones without the risk of posterization.
All of this makes it crucial to expose Log footage accurately, so that the tonal information you're trying to capture isn't crushed into the highlight or shadow portion, where only limited information is retained. It also means it's important for the gamma curve to be a good match for the sensor's characteristics.
An 'L' of a price to pay?
Where it gets interesting is that the GH5S doesn't use the same V-Log curve as the company's Varicam line of professional camcorders. Instead it uses a truncated version called V-Log L, designed to offer compatibility with fully fledged V-Log. This use of a less ambitious curve makes sense: the Varicam cameras tend to be capable of capturing greater dynamic range than the GH5S, so it would be detrimental to use the same gamma curve on the Lumix (it would encourage the use of lower exposure to capture more highlights, leading to increased shot noise in all the most valuable tones).
Instead, V-LogL clips the top of the VLog curve: encouraging you to apply more exposure, to get cleaner mid-tones at the cost of losing some very bright highlights. It's a perfectly sensible approach. However, it's the next decision that is likely to divide GH shooters: rather than mapping the camera's brightest captured tone to the brightest value in the file, Panasonic has mapped it to 80% brightness. This doesn't throw away any captured data but means that some of the capacity for tone retention (the entire point of shooting Log) is left unused. The footage also never reaches black, so there are wasted values at the bottom of the files, too.
|The V-Log L curve (blue) is essentially the lower section of the full V-Log curve, which includes the red section to capture additional highlights. The GH5S's clipping point is mapped to an output level of 768, to provide cross-compatibility.|
The result is a file that can be easily integrated into a mixed V-Log/V-Log L workflow but one where there are fewer values available to record midtones and shadows than there could/should be, risking posterization and noise. The problem is most likely to be visible in 8-bit mode, where leaving around 64 values blank mean there are fewer than 192 left for capturing everything else. The drawback is less detrimental in 10-bit mode, since there are still 768 available values, even with the highest values left blank. It's still not optimal for users who aren't using Varicam cameras alongside their GH5S but a partially empty 10-bit space still allows a vast improvement over using a full 8-bit container.
Our recommendation would be to only ever shoot V-Log L in 10-bit. This will mean using an external recorder if you plan to shoot 4K at 59.94 or 50p with Log.
HLG as Log capture mode
Is it better to use HLG mode, rather than V-Log L, for greater flexibility in the edit?
Hybrid Log Gamma (HLG) is primarily designed as a no-processing-necessary way of shooting footage for HDR playback (ie: showing greater dynamic range on high-dynamic-range screens, not to be confused with garish attempts to compress large amounts of dynamic range into a disconcerting psychedelic nonsense). However, at its heart HLG is a Log curve that, like V-LogL, tries to squeeze lots of highlights and shadows into a file but while devoting most values to the tonal information of the midtones.
Because it isn't trying to provide compatibility with a different camera's workflow, HLG uses a much wider range of the available values in the file, which should mean more data values are available to retain tonal information. And, although this means you can't simply use an off-the-shelf V-Log to... LUT when you first import the footage, the HLG curve looks like it's going to be a widely-enough accepted standard that we'd expect to see HLG to standard DR LUTs become increasingly common.
Of course there's more to optimizing video than just the gamma curve, and HLG's means of retaining color information isn't necessarily as sophisticated as the one Panasonic's engineers have developed for VLog L (HLG is, after all, intended as a ready-to-watch medium). But we'll have to do more tests and wait until there are cameras and footage in the hands of more experienced colorists, before the full picture will be known.
So how much Dynamic Range does the GH5S have?
Having talked so much about the ways of capturing and preserving the most possible dynamic range, just how much DR can the GH5S capture?
Manufacturers love to throw around DR figures for their cameras, especially on the video side of things. We've shot our dynamic range brightness wedge to see how many of the 1/3EV increments we could distinguish between, before the footage clipped to black or to an unacceptable noise level.
Interestingly, when shot side-by-side with the a7R III in S-Log2 mode, we got pretty similar results, but for different reasons. The GH5S's darkest tones become progressively noisier until they become indistinguishable after around 11.3EV. The big sensor Sony shows a little bit of noise and then suddenly hits a wall at a similar point. This makes sense: the GH5S will have noisier deep shadows than a camera getting much more light. However, the 8-bit Sony runs out of values to keep distinguishing between tones, so the full benefit of that extra DR gets lost.
What will be really interesting will be when we step out from the studio and shoot some side-by-side footage. The Sony should capture cleaner midtone information than the Panasonic but again will have fewer values to record this subtlety. The Panasonic will capture a slightly less clean signal but will preserve that information with its greater bit-depth. We'll be shooting more side-by-side footage soon.
|The Lone Photographer by ed rader|
from My Best Photo of the Week
|_ERN9064 by ernesto juarez|
from Shoot yourself ! (with your camera)
|Neighbourhood Watch by Stevie Boy Blue|
from Zoo trip ~ Cute...
Canon has announced its latest superzoom camera, the PowerShot SX70 HS. Compared to the SX60 that came before it, the SX70 has a longer lens, higher resolution EVF, 4K video capture and support for Canon's new CR3 Raw format.
Cosina has announced its eighth lens designed specifically for Sony's E-mount system. The Voigtlander 21mm F3.5 lens is due out October 2018.
Sony has taken the wraps off of its new 24mm F1.4 GM full-frame lens, which the company claims is the lightest in its class. Despite its fast aperture, the 24mm F1.4 is remarkably light, weighing just 445 grams (15.7 ounces). The lens will set you back $1400 when it ships next month.
In this episode of DPReview TV we take a look at Sony's brand new 24mm F1.4 GM lens, a desirable focal length for many photographers. How does it perform? Chris and Jordan give us their first impressions.
We've had a little time to shoot with Sony's new wide/fast prime, both close to home and on the water in San Francisco. Check out our initial sample images.
Fujifilm released a firmware upgrade for its X-T3 mirrorless camera that addresses issues with distortion compensation and the mechanical lock on SD cards.
The app's algorithms have been trained using using 200 million cropping data points from real photographers.
Thanks to a software update, the Loupedeck+ editing console can now be used for video editing.
British photographic engineer MTF Services is claiming the world’s first third-party lens adapters for the new Nikon Z system with a collection of four units designed to allow cinema lenses to be mounted on the mirrorless full frame bodies.
Think Tank Photo has updated its line of heavy-duty rain covers and introduced a new, compact version for emergency situations.
The X-T3 is our first opportunity to analyze what's likely to be Fujifilm's next generation image sensor. Take a look at how it performs next to the competition in our studio test scene.
Canon's new normal is seriously sharp wide open. After shooting with it for a few days, we've prepared a gallery of real-world sample images.
Nikon will cease offering Brazil-based customer service and technical support, though the company stresses that it will still offer technical assistance and warranty repairs for valid warranties.
Two years ago, CatLABS of JP announced a plan to save Packfilm from the dead. Now, it's announced it's giving up its efforts to better focus its resources elsewhere.
The GoPro Fusion is designed to make it easy to capture 360-degree video and stills. We took it out recently on a typically hot Seattle summer day to see what it can do.
We've got our hands on a full-production Nikon Z7 camera and have updated our gallery with additional samples.
A new Kickstarter campaign seeks funding for Chroma Chrono, a programmable RGB camera flash that emits multiple colors during long exposures.
Think Tank Photo has launched a new lineup of six dual-access, water-resistant protective lens cases it calls Lens Case Duo.
Canon and Nikon finally entered the full-frame mirrorless market this summer with the brand-new RF and Z mounts. Now that we've had some time with the cameras, we wanted to revisit our earlier predictions and take stock.
The devices' camera specs look pretty much identical to last year's iPhone X but under the hood a number of important improvements have been made.
Blackmagic Design has announced the public beta of its new Blackmagic RAW video codec. The company says the new format combines the benefits of shooting Raw video with the ease of use and smaller file sizes usually associated with non-Raw video files.
Serif, the company behind the Affinity suite, has announced the latest update for its mobile Photoshop competitor Affinity Photo for iPad.
The Atomos Ninja V external video recorder and monitor will be ready to ship at the end of this month. The 5.2in Ninja V is designed to provide a smaller option, while still offering many of the features of the larger 7-inch models.
Having shot with the camera, spoken to Canon and read the tea leaves, here's what DPR Technical Editor Richard Butler thinks the EOS R tells us about Canon and the RF's mount's future.
After last week's teaser, lighting manufacturer Profoto has announced its 'small big' new product. The B10 is designed to be used as studio flash head but in a very small body, and has a powerful continuous light source for videographers as well.
Konseen has launched Photo Studio, a new light box tent large enough to photograph people, as well as objects.
Seagate has introduced new high-capacity hard drives for Network Attached Storage (NAS) devices: the 14TB IronWolf and 14TB IronWolf Pro HDDs.
The case was first announced earlier this year as a Kickstarter campaign and comes with a range of features aimed at iPhone photographers.
Manfrotto has introduced a new two-in-one tripod to its Befree lineup. Called the Befree 2N1, this new addition is both a tripod and monopod in one and is available with both of Manfrotto's locking mechanisms.