Conclusion - Pros

  • Very compact and pocketable
  • Excellent handling for a small camera
  • Solid build and excellent fit / finish
  • Good resolution and edge-to-edge consistency
  • Realistic natural color, subtle processing
  • Excellent range of manual exposure controls
  • Extensive system support for a compact - optional add-on lenses and flashguns
  • iTTL flash hot shoe
  • Optical image stabilization
  • Excellent output quality at lower ISO settings - subtle NR means more fine detail preserved
  • Best Shot Selector
  • Command dial and custom function button make for fast, simple control of exposure controls.
  • Easy to use - works well in 'point and shoot' auto mode
  • Optical viewfinder
  • Comprehensive range of image parameters
  • Very little purple fringing and well controlled distortion
  • In-Camera Red-Eye Fix works, but is slow
  • D-Lighting function
  • Excellent flash performance
  • Very keen pricing

Conclusion - Cons

  • Very slow focus and slightly sluggish performance overall
  • Unimpressive burst mode
  • Default settings produce images that are a bit soft and a bit flat - may or may not be a problem depending on your point of view
  • Screen can be difficult to see in bright light, occasional blooming of preview image
  • Finest quality JPEG is still quite heavily compressed, still no raw mode
  • Some aspects of the user interface still feel clunky
  • Lens range (36-126mm) not the most versatile - would be nice if it started wider
  • ISO 400+ noisy, ISO 3200 totally pointless
  • Sound cuts out before the end of movie clips
  • No live histogram

Overall conclusion

Unlike Canon, whose PowerShot G7 is a real 'statement' camera that has undisguised aspirations to be a genuine SLR replacement, Nikon has taken a much more cautious step towards a truly serious high end compact with it's new flagship model.

The P5000 - Nikon's first such camera since the days when you could charge the best part of a thousand dollars for a well-specified compact - is a considerably less ambitious product than the G7; it reminded me of a Coolpix 7900 with added bells and whistles, and it's not as big a leap forward from the P3/P4 as it first appears, physical design aside.

So is this a bad thing? Not at all; the P5000 offers pretty much everything the Canon G7 does - with SLR-like levels of control - in a package that is truly pocketable. This puts it, essentially, in a class of its own, and this is why the promise of Nikon quality and full photographic control in such a small package caused such excitement when the P5000 was announced earlier this year. I remember thinking myself that this looked like exactly what I'd been looking for as a 'carry anywhere' compact that gave me back the controls I missed with most pocket cameras.

As to whether it delivers on that promise depends on how - and what - you take pictures of. This is because the P5000, in common with most recent Coolpix models, has a serious issue with focus speed that makes it totally unsuitable for use in situations where quick reactions are essential. If you're taking landscapes you can live with waiting a second (or two if you're unlucky) for the camera to focus and take the picture, but snapping restless children (or in fact anything moving) is frustrating and ultimately a hit 'n' miss affair.

This is all the more infuriating because the P5000 is otherwise such an impressive little camera; it's got an extensive and useful range of features and an easily mastered control system that doesn't have you scrolling through menus to change the aperture, is expandable via add-on lenses and flashguns and is, if you know what you're doing, capable of superb results. And it does all this in a compact lightweight body that makes the Canon G7 look like a house brick - and at a price that means you can still feed the kids at the end of the month.

And so, in conclusion, the P5000 is a product that - like so many we look at - has an achilles heel that we feel is important enough to reduce its rating, because it has a serious effect on the overall usability of an otherwise excellent camera. Put simply it feels sluggish in use and has focus speeds that would have been considered 'average' 5 years ago. For many users it won't be a serious issue, but if you've got used to the focus speeds of the best cameras in this class (some of which focus 2 or even 3 times faster) it's irritating, to say the least, to miss shots because the focus takes too long. I found myself pre-focusing for virtually every shot to avoid the delay.

Weighed up against the many positives the sluggish focus has to be put into context; only you will know if the kind of pictures you take are going to be affected by an extra half second or so delay, and I can't stress enough that there is an awful lot to like about the P5000. For this reason it just about earns our recommendation, even if it's a recommendation that comes with an important qualification: 'if you don't need fast focus'.

  • Ideal for: Landscapes, learning about photography, use with external flash, traveling
  • Not ideal for: Shooting anything fast, point and shoot social snapping in low light
Detail Rating (out of 10)
Build quality 9.0
Ergonomics & handling 7.5
Features 8.0
Image quality 7.5
Optics 8.0
Performance (speed) 6.5
Value 8.5


Highly Recommended

Want to make sure you don't miss out on any future reviews?
Sign up for our free weekly newsletter!

Enter the 'Nikon Talk' Discussion Forum