Nikon D3S In-depth review
We wouldn't normally devote two pages to discussing a DSLR's AF performance, partly because AF - and especially AF tracking - is difficult (to say the least) to test in a consistent and clear way. Naturally, after analyzing the many hundreds (if not thousands) of frames that we might shoot during a typical DSLR test we're confident that we're in a good position to comment on any obvious strengths or failings. However, ultimately, when it comes to discussing the AF systems of a camera as complex as the Nikon D3S, we know we don't have the same authority as a professional sports photographer, for example, with years of experience.
With that obvious caveat in mind, we do make every effort to test particular DSLRs in the environments for which they are designed, where applicable. The Nikon D3S is intended as a multi-role camera, and AF speed and versatility are its key selling points. We therefore went out of our way during the shooting for this review to test AF performance as thoroughly as possible, in a range of different lighting conditions. As you'll see in our upcoming in-depth review of the Canon EOS 1D Mark IV, we shot the same subjects with Canon's new flagship sports camera as well, under the same lighting, and with as near-parity in lenses as we could manage.
What follows is our take on the efficacy of the D3S's AF system, and although it shouldn't be considered definitive, we hope that our notes - and the images shown here and in the main image gallery - will serve as a decent summary of the D3S's AF capabilities. A full test of its rival, the Canon EOS-1D Mark IV, will follow this one online very soon.
Key AF specifications
- 51 point Phase-detection AF with 15 cross-type sensors
- 11-point AF pattern mimics D2XS AF array (when DX crop mode is selected)
- 3D AF tracking uses dedicated 1005-pixel CCD sensor to incorporate color/contrast information when tracking moving subjects
- Virtually 100% compatibility with all AF Nikkor lenses (excluding those designed for the F3-AF)
- Electronic rangefinder and focus indicator for manual focus with AF or MF lenses (excluding Pre-AI lenses, many of which will jam when mounted on the D3S.)
The D3S features the same 51 point auto focus sensors the D3/D3X. The center fifteen (3x5 grid) are cross point sensors. There are two AF point selection modes (CSM a8), and you can opt to be able to select from all 51 points or 11 points in a similar layout as the D2XS. The D3S's larger sensor area means that the AF points don't occupy as much of the frame as the D300S, but obviously, if you switch to DX cropped mode the focus points cover virtually the entire frame.
|51 point AF selection mode||11 point AF selection mode|
With the main AF mode switch set to AF-S, the D3S acquires focus quickly and positively in almost all situations, and is impressively resistant to flare caused by sidelight. Although it struggles with silhouetted subjects, when presented with a convenient edge, the D3S can almost always achieve accurate AF lock. It is reassuring, too, to see that even in light so low that ISO 102,400 might conceivably be the only option for exposure, the D3S can usually deliver accurate focus given a little bit of contrast to work with.
In general use, the major limiting factor to AF speed is the type of lens used. Most older AF-D lenses are barely any slower than Nikon's most recent large-aperture AF-S offerings (the AF-D 80-200mm f/2.8 for example acquires focus almost as quickly as the new AF-S 70-200mm f/2.8 II) but ironically, some current AF-S lenses really slow the system down. The worst offenders are Nikon's smallest, most compact AF-S optics, including all 'kit-type' DX designs and (more annoyingly for prospective D3S owners) the new 50mm f/1.4.
The Nikon D3S offers virtually 100% compatibility with all AF lenses created for the F system. There are a couple of quirks, however, which users of older lenses should be aware of. The first is that on rare occasions when using AF-D lenses, the D3S might decide that accurate focus has not been achieved, even when it has. The camera's default behavior in this situation is to flash a warning in the viewfinder to let you know that AF cannot be acquired.
This happens very rarely in our experience, but if you notice it, the issue can be solved easily by changing AF-S priority selection from 'Focus' to 'Release' via csm a2. We have noticed the same glitch on other Nikon DSLRs, including the D3 and D300s, and the focus priority selection fix does the trick in all cases.
However, regardless of whether you use AF-D or AF-S lenses, should you for whatever reason feel the need to set csm a2 to 'release', you should be prepared for something rather odd to happen when the cameras is set to continuous shooting mode (either L or H). For some reason, when this custom function is set and drive mode is switched to 'CL or CH', the D3S attempts to reacquire focus after every exposure, regardless of the position of the main AF-S/AF-C' switch on the front of the camera body.
If your preferred method of shooting off-center subjects is to focus with the center point and then recompose, this means that potentially, if you're in continuous drive mode, only the first frame in your sequence of images will be in focus. The fact that the D3S exhibits this odd behavior even during a bracketed burst - where as far as we're concerned it is wholly undesirable - is surprising. We have voiced these concerns to Nikon, but at time of publication, we had yet to receive an official response. At such time as we received detailed feedback we will update this review accordingly.
The continuous autofocus system of the Nikon D3S is essentially unchanged from that featured in the D3 and D3X. As such it represents a huge leap forwards in terms of complexity and versatility compared to the 11-point AF system in the previous generation D2-series. The AF array has 51 points, selectable automatically or manually, of which 15 are of the cross type (and work with lenses with maximum apertures of f/5.6 or faster). There are two 'master' AF modes, - Single and Continuous, which are set using a physical switch on the front of the camera. When set to Continuous AF, the camera can track moving subjects in four modes - single point, dynamic-area, 3D tracking AF, and Area AF.
3D AF Tracking debuted in the D3, in 2007, and is a sub-option of dynamic area AF. When 3D tracking is enabled, all 51 AF points are called into service, and the D3S aims to track a moving subject based on its color/contrast, and distance from the camera. To do this, it uses information from the same dedicated 1005-pixel CCD sensor that provides data to the camera's metering and white balance systems.
Despite this complexity, the AF system of the Nikon D3S is remarkably easy to get to grips with. The key settings (AF/AF area modes) are adjusted using physical switches that can be accessed without removing your eye from the viewfinder, and few of the 10 custom functions that relate to AF performance relate to aspects of the camera's performance that need to be changed frequently. You'll find a more detailed account of the various settings, and how they perform, on the next page.
- 18 Photographic tests (Noise)
- 19 Photographic tests (DR)
- 20 Photographic tests (DR)
- 21 Photographic tests
- 22 Movie Mode
- 23 Compared to
- 24 Compared to (JPEG)
- 25 Compared to (JPEG)
- 26 Compared to (JPEG)
- 27 Compared to (RAW)
- 28 Compared to (RAW)
- 29 Compared to (RAW)
- 30 Compared to (Higher ISO)
- 31 Compared to (Resolution)
- 32 Compared to (Resolution)
- 33 Conclusion
- 34 Samples
|Perfect symmetry by Bassaidai|
|Autumn by Eduard Metela|
from blowing leaves
|Bending road by Starsta|
from Found letters "S" in capital or lower case
|Pelican by rajeev22675|
from 100mm or greater..
This year’s overall winner is a humorous image of an adorable lioness getting a little too playful for her own good.
Here are 10 photography gifts you'll actually want this year, picked out by photographers for photographers. And yes, it's OK to buy them all.
The lens features a 1:1 magnification ratio, Tokina's One-Touch Focus Clutch Mechanism and will retail for $429 when it hits shelves on December 6.
Sony's a6x00 series (especially the most recent ones) are very good cameras. Yet our in-house contrarian, Richard, isn't convinced their design is well matched to any one type of user.
The previous winner of our 'Best cameras under $500' buying guide was the Canon EOS M100, and the recently announced M200 - which offers an improved AF system and 4K video capture - is the obvious choice to take over first place.
Today saw the opening of the public phase of impeachment hearings against President Donald Trump. But even before the questions had started, something else caught our eye.
The first of the two updates will add 'controls for video recording from Gimbal / Drone via USB communications,' according to Fujifilm.
Adobe has posted a video showing a new feature in a forthcoming update to Lightroom for iOS that makes it possible to import photos directly from external storage, such as SD cards and SSDs.
The new film stock will be available starting November 22, 2019 in both 35mm and 120 formats.
The 16-inch MacBook Pro replaces the previous 15-inch version and can be configured with up to an 8-core Intel i9 processor, maxes out at 64GB of RAM and can be ordered with up to 8TB of internal SSD storage.
With its newly improved Super Resolution Zoom, the Pixel 4 makes a case for itself as a replacement for a compact camera with a 4-6x zoom range. And for the most part it succeeds – compacts still have their advantages, but they're pretty much history for most users.
Last week Panasonic announced a major firmware update for the G9, adding video features once exclusive to the GH5 series. Does Chris love the autofocus? Can Jordan replace his beloved GH5s? Tune in to find out.
We've rounded up a few accessories and gadgets that will help the smartphone photographer in your life open up new creative possibilities and get the most out of their device.
RED maintains its hold on the compression of Raw video after the latest challenge, by Apple this time, fails to get support from the courts.
The two new kits from PolarPro include a mattebox for PolarPro filters, as well as a dedicated landscape filter kit.
Volta might not be conventional or the most aesthetically appealing device, but it’s hard to argue with an extra 8,000mAh battery power on the go.
Our tests using Blackmagic Design's Disk Speed Test program confirmed the 1TB version of the Plugable NVMe SSD can reach sustained write speeds of 1915MB per second and sustained read speeds of 2331MB per second.
The Sigma fp has clearly been designed with filmmakers in mind, and after using one for a few days, we suspect that they'll love it.
Whether you make a living out of taking professional portraits, or are the weekend warrior who knows their way around flashes and reflectors, you'll want a camera with high resolution, exceptional autofocus and a good selection of portrait prime lenses. Click through to see our picks.
Kodak film is making progress, in revenue figures at least, while the rest of the company posts a loss for the last quarter.
The 3rd-gen lineup includes the 24-core 3960X and 32-core 3970x CPUs made with a 7nm 'Zen 2' core architecture, 140/144MB cache and up 88 PCIe 4.0 lanes. AMD says the new CPUs will offer a 47% performance boost in Adobe Premiere.
The two lenses are the first designed specifically for 8K-capable broadcast cameras from Canon, which it claims are becoming more popular in documentary production and sports coverage.
The lens was teased earlier this year and effectively replaces the 75mm F1.8 Heliar Classic lens Voigtlander previously offered.
It's not every day you get to speak to the man who's had a hand in the design of every professional Canon SLR since the T90.
Family moments are precious and sometimes you want to capture that time spent with friends or loved-ones in better quality than your phone can manage. We've selected a group of cameras that are easy to keep with you, and that can adapt to take photos wherever and whenever something memorable happens.
Nikon and Canon have both launched a new APS-C mirrorless camera each, and now that we've had a chance to use both of them, here's how we think they compare against each other.
When her work began to include more and more video, pro photographer Suzi Pratt gradually drifted from her DSLRs to mirrorless hybrid cameras. So what's it like switching back to a DSLR for a vacation?
The confirmation comes from Instagram's CEO Adam Mosseri from an interview earlier this week.