Leica Q In-depth Review
Our latest test scene is designed to simulate both daylight and low-light shooting. Pressing the 'lighting' buttons at the top of the widget allows you to switch between the two. The daylight scene is shot with manually set white balance aimed at achieving neutral grays, but the camera is left in its Auto setting for the low-light tests (except Raw, which is manually corrected during conversion). We also offer three different viewing sizes: 'Full', 'Print', and 'Web', with the latter two offering 'normalized' comparisons to more fairly compare cameras of differing resolutions by ensuring equivalent viewing sizes.
The Leica Q has no direct rivals. If you want a full-frame fixed-lens camera, the Sony's 35mm F2 RX1R II is your only alternative. If you're more of a fan of 28mm equiv, then the likes of the Fujifilm X70 and Ricoh GR are options but these both have F2.8 maximum apertures and smaller, APS-C sensors. Our studio scene should show the differences this makes.
The Leica Q shows an impressive level of detail, considering how closely it has to be shot to our test chart. Its 24MP sensor can't match, but it's more than a match for the or . is fairly well handled, with no signs of halos, but there is a little stair-stepping on high-contrast edges, suggesting the camera is pushing to the very limits of what it can capture.
Color is not the Leica's strength.are neutral and unsaturated to the point of being unflattering, when compared with any you choose to compare it to. And even in this carefully white balanced scene, there's a slight green tinge to everything. takes itself very seriously - neutralizing tones to a greater extent than any of its , though still leaving that tiny hint of green.
The camera's noise reduction suppresses chroma noise very heavily, but leaves the more grain-likeessentially untouched. This isn't a bad decision, but can't compete with the more sophisticated system offered by , which manages to suppress AND retain detail and saturation. The Leica may be struggling with at higher ISOs but its means it can easily outperform the Ricoh and when it comes to overall image quality.
The sharp lens and lack of AA filter means the Leicawith the consequent risk of moiré. The is far from shabby, despite the application of distortion correction as part of the lens's design, even when compared to a very good, uncorrected prime lens shot further from the chart.
Noise performance is a little behindand perhaps even a touch better than other . This means it shows something like the 1.3EV benefit that its sensor size should give it, over the likes of the , and that's before you take into account its maximum aperture being 1.4EV faster.
Overall, then, an impressive performance from both the sensor and the lens but, while the rather simplistic JPEG noise reduction is pretty well judged, we have real concerns about the color rendering and white balance performance - concerns borne-out in our real-world shooting.
Sony doesn't consider distortion corrections to be an essential part of its lens design so allows them to be turned off. In this scene, the JPEGs were shot with correction on but the Raws were processed with it switched off. The Leica requires the correction as part of its design so they are engaged in both cases.
Real-world image quality
As we've covered previously, the Leica Q will reward you with predictably good image quality in most situations. The dynamic range may be lacking for some more demanding landscape photographers (or if you mis-judge your exposure and need to push several stops), but noise levels are usually fairly well controlled into higher ISOs.
|In most shooting situations, files out of the Leica Q are perfectly fine. Photo by Carey Rose. F8 | 1/320 sec | ISO 100|
However, there are two issues we repeatedly ran into with files from the Q, one of which is relatively minor, and the other relatively major.
The minor issue concerns JPEG processing out of the Q, with real-world results mimicking our studio findings above. Leica claims that the JPEG output is intentionally neutral, at the expense of bright, printable images. However, with limited JPEG engine customization options (color space, sharpness, contrast, saturation), users coming to the Q from other systems may find the JPEG performance lacking, and will simply turn to the Raw files. The 'greenness' of default yellows in the Q's JPEGs does show up in real-world shooting, and can cause unpleasant results when photographing people. Couple that with unreliable auto white balance performance under artificial light, and frankly, I ignored the JPEGs altogether.
In the below comparison, note how the out-of-camera JPEG is skewed green, compared to a more pleasing white balance when processed from Raw.
|Out-of-camera JPEG||Processed to taste from Adobe Camera Raw|
The second issue is arguably more major. Although outright noise performance is good with the Q, pushing the exposure or shadows of your Raw files in post processing can result in noise 'banding.' The degree to which you'll see it varies from 'barely' all the way to 'terrible,' and it is present even at base ISO. The more random nature of the additional noise you see at higher ISOs can help to hide some of the worst banding, but it is still visible.
In the below example, the original exposure was a bit dark. It was pushed by 2.45 stops in Adobe Camera Raw, with the shadows lifted some more. Banding is clearly evident (and clearly unpleasant), but this level of adjustment is not a particularly strenuous exercise for the majority of full-frame cameras on the market (most notably, those with Sony sensors).
|Photo from our Leica Q real-world sample gallery. Photo by Barney Britton. F1.7 | 1/60 sec | ISO 200|
It's also important to note that files that have only had slight exposure adjustments (and not additional shadow pushing) can still show banding, if you look carefully. In the below example, the out-of-camera shot looks a bit dark, and so exposure was brought up slightly, and banding is just visible on the car interior to the right of the dog's head. A final extreme adjustment shows the banding pattern more clearly.
If you're not one to really push your Raw files, this probably won't concern you. But it does represent an additional shortcoming that users coming from other systems may not be prepared for from a fairly recent full-frame sensor. To get a more in-depth and controlled look at this banding and its implications, jump to the next page of our review which goes into more detail concerning the Q's Raw dynamic range.
|Incoming by Scott Vail|
from Your Duck shot
|Lake Louise by MIRANDA1|
from blue challenge
|Looking for dinner!!! by Chairman1|
The Google Pixel 4 will likely launch with an astrophotography feature, HDR in the preview image and a range of other new imaging functions.
In the first part of his series, landscape photographer Erez Marom starts with the very basics of drone photography – namely, what a drone is and how it works.
Blackmagic has announced an update to Blackmagic RAW that adds support, via plugins, to Adobe Premiere Pro and Avid Media Composer. Blackmagic also announced a pair of Video Assist 12G monitor-recorders with brighter HDR displays, USB-C recording and more.
This week Chris and Jordan review the new Canon EOS M6 II mirrorless camera. Even if you're not interested in the camera, you should probably watch just to see Jordan sing a Dire Straits cover.
A new gallery from the Canon EOS M6 II, shot by Chris and Jordan while filming this week's episode of DPReview TV. As usual, it comes complete with reflected images in puddles.
STC Optics announced new filters for Panasonic Lumix M43 camera systems, Z Cam E2 4K Cinema Cameras and Blackmagic Pocket Cinema Camera 4K units.
Atomos continues its partnership with camera manufacturers to get the best image possible from the sensors inside the latest camera systems.
Sony has announced the impending arrival of its next-generation video camera system, the FX9. The full-frame E-mount system is set to be released later this year with a 16-35mm E-mount lens to follow in spring 2020.
Slow-mo videos are awesome on their own, but have you ever wondered what 72 slow-mo cameras are capable of producing? Well, wonder no more.
Google uses machine learning to pick your best photos from previous years and pins them to the top of your gallery.
The new tool uses AI and machine learning to automatically reframe video sequences to fit different aspects ratios so a single video can easily be edited for publishing on multiple platforms.
The Canon RF 85mm F1.2L USM is one of the most impressive lenses released for the nascent RF system, and we've just updated our gallery of sample images.
The new calibration systems are designed to work with bright HDR monitors and OLED screens of every shape and size.
The XEEN CF lenses will be offered in 16mm, 24mm, 35mm, 50mm, and 85mm options for Canon EF, Sony E and PL mounts.
It's an extremely minor firmware update, but it's better to be safe than sorry. The last thing you want is to have to stop mid-shot in the field to address a little software glitch.
After a string of so-so entry-level ILCs, Fujifilm appears to have pulled out all the stops with its new X-A7.
The Fujifilm X-A7 is the newest addition to the company's X-series lineup. Despite its relatively low price of $700 (with lens), Fujifilm didn't skimp on features. Click through to find out what you need to know about the X-A7.
The entry-level Fujifilm X-A7 improves upon many of its predecessor's weak points, including a zippier processor, an upgraded user experience and 4K/30p video capture. It goes on sale October 24th for $700 with a 15-45mm F3.5-5.6 kit lens.
LaCie has announced a trio of SSDs with ruggedized protection for the harshest of environments.
Irix says the new lens is designed for 8K recording and features a cinema-specific optical construction.
The update brings hundreds of bug fixes, a new Film Negative tool and support for rating images.
The a7R IV represents our first chance to analyze Sony's new 61MP backside-illuminated sensor. Take a look at what it's capable of.
The delays will only affect shipments to Japan, according to a Venus Optics spokesperson.
Sony's habit of giving similar names to cameras that look the same can make it difficult to choose between them. We've broken down the differences and how they compare to their rivals.
Robert Frank's unconventional approach to photography and filmmaking defied generational constraints and inspired some of the most influential artists of the 20th century. He passed away today at age 94.
Sigma is getting serious about cinema with its classic-inspired lens lineup, updated cine primes and a new PL to L mount adapter that's in the works.
All three devices offer a standard 12MP camera plus, for the first time on an iPhone, an ultra-wide 13mm camera module. The 11 Pro and 11 Pro Max also retain the telephoto camera of previous generations.
The new Huawei mobile chipset offers hardware noise reduction among other new imaging features.
The Polaroid Originals is effectively a modernized version of its 'Impossible Lab' first released back in 2013.