Fujifilm X-Pro1 in-depth review
Raw and Raw Conversion
The Fujifilm X-Pro1 is provided with the 'FinePix CD' software disc which includes:
- MyFinePix Studio Ver 3.2 - A basic file viewer / manager (Windows only)
- FinePix Viewer Ver 3.6 - A file viewer / manager (for Mac OS X 10.3-10.6)
- RAW File Converter EX - A powerful, fully-featured RAW converter based on SilkyPix
The X-Pro1 ships with its own customized, but fully featured version of SilkyPix, called RAW File Converter EX. This is a hugely flexible piece of software that includes a vast range of options and adjustments, and which is capable of producing pretty impressive results. It's not the easiest converter to get to grips with though: its menus give the impression of having been machine-translated, the available options aren't necessarily very logically organized, and the on-screen 'Help', although comprehensive, is about as obtuse as you'll ever find (it tends to repeat what the options are, rather than explain what they mean). But if you're prepared to put in the time and effort to work it out, then the results can be very worthwhile.
Once you've worked your way past the slightly odd terminology (images are called 'scenes', and parameter sets get saved to the 'cloakroom'), you'll find a vast range of tools to rival industry leaders such as Capture One or Adobe Camera Raw. This includes features you won't always find in bundled software, such as highlight recovery, lens aberration correction, and perspective correction (here known, somewhat obtusely, as 'Digital Shift').
As usual we like to compare the supplied RAW conversion software, any optional manufacturer RAW conversion software and some third party RAW converter. In the case of the Fujifilm X-Pro1 we used the supplied RAW File Converter EX and the Adobe Camera Raw 7.1 plugin for Photoshop CS6.
- JPEG - Large/Fine (default settings)
- RFC - RAW File Converter EX (default settings)
- ACR - Adobe Photoshop Camera Raw 7.1 (default settings)
Sharpness and Detail
Most cameras show distinctly more detail in RAW compared to their JPEG output, due to a combination of over-enthusiastic noise reduction and unsubtle sharpening, but not the X-Pro1. Instead the in-camera JPEG conversion pulls a huge amount of detail out of the sensor data. Adobe Camera Raw perhaps offers slightly crisper fine detail (although this is due to higher sharpening more than anything else). Meanwhile Raw File Converter at first sight lags behind the other two, but on closer examination this probably reflects its slightly muted colour saturation rather than actual detail rendition.
|JPEG (Default settings, manual WB)
ISO 200 studio scene 100% crop
|Adobe Camera Raw 7.1 RAW ->JPEG (Default settings, manual WB)
ISO 200 studio scene 100% crop
|RAW File Converter EX, (Default settings, manual WB)
ISO 200 studio scene 100% crop
In this comparison of the high-contrast detail of a test chart, the situation is slightly different. The in-camera processing produces a clean image that's entirely free of artefacts. Neither RAW converter can deliver higher resolution, and neither can quite match it for cleanliness either. SilkyPix is close, but still gives a little false colour in some areas of the test pattern; in contrast, Adobe Camera Raw shows lots of artefacts including an odd green/magenta 'beat' pattern beyond Nyquist.
|JPEG from camera||RAW File Converter EX (RAW)|
|Adobe Camera Raw 7.1 (RAW)|
The X-Pro1's unique feature is, of course the X-Trans CMOS sensor, with its non-Bayer colour filter array. This requires an entirely different demosaicing approach to produce an image file from the sensor data, and consequently third-party Raw converters can't support the camera as easily. Rather than simply re-calibrate the Bayer conversion processes that they have refined over a decade or more, the developers have to start again from scratch. This means that there's greater potential for conversion artefacts in 'difficult' areas of the image that might require special treatment.
We can see this when comparing the output from Adobe Camera Raw and, to a lesser extent, Raw File Converter to out-of-camera JPEGs. In certain areas of the image ACR's output is problematic - most notably when looking at text on a coloured background. Meanwhile SilkyPix tends to show a little more false colour on fine patterns than either the camera JPEG or ACR.
In the crops above, ACR 'fills-in' the white text on the battery and paintbrush with the surrounding color, while desaturating regions between the letters. The size of the text appears to be important here - you won't see this effect when it's much larger than in these examples. ACR also has the biggest problem with the colour of the hairs crossing in front of red and blue blocks of colour on the third set of crops.
Below we're looking at the X-Pro1's resistance to moiré and false colour. In the first set of crops all three versions suffer from diagonal yellow lines, but the hue difference is most pronounced from RFC. Meanwhile RFC also produces some colour mottling on the second banknote that isn't visible in either the camera JPEG or the ACR conversion. Overall, Fujifilm's own processing for the camera's JPEGs provides the cleanest output in both cases. (Bear in mind that these regions cause problems for many cameras, and are scarcely typical of real-world shooting.)
While our studio test scene reveals these processing errors, we've found them not to be much of a problem in normal shooting. Obviously you can find similar examples in real-world images if you go looking for them - Adobe's colouring-in of text can be visible in road signs, for example. But with the vast majority of the images we shot, both ACR and Raw File Converter give perfectly acceptable results.
As illustrated in our Lenses and Lens Corrections page, however, there are a couple of larger differences. Most notably, ACR doesn't correct for lateral chromatic aberration by default, although this can be turned in the Lens Corrections tab by clicking a single checkbox. Also, rather strangely, the two raw processors both correct distortion from the 18mm F2 lens slightly differently to the camera's own processing (and each other).
Real world advantages
As we've shown above, Fujifilm's excellent processing means that the X-Pro1's JPEGs lose nothing in terms of detail compared to RAW. On top of this, the camera's generally-reliable white balance and appealing colour rendition (especially in Soft/Astia mode) means that for many purposes it makes perfect sense to shoot JPEGs with the full intent of using them. What's more, if you shoot RAW alongside, then you can use the in-camera processing to apply many of the changes that make shooting RAW worthwhile, e.g. to correct for white balance errors, tweak image brightness, or adjust colours.
The example below was shot using Velvia mode on a dull day, and the camera's automatic white balance has delivered a rather cool image. By adjusting the in-camera development parameters (see below) we've managed to tease out a much more pleasing version of the shot. However this can be a rather drawn-out process, because you can't preview your changes 'live' as you work.
|Original JPEG||RAW file reconverted in-camera|
Development parameters: Push/Pull Processing +2/3 EV; Film Simulation Astia/Soft; White balance 6300K; Highlight Tone M-Hard; Shadow Tone M-Soft.
The big advantage of using a raw editor rather than the camera, of course, is that you can judge your adjustments much better as you go along, and apply more sophisticated processing that the camera can't match. In this second example the RAW file has been developed using Adobe Camera Raw, with the white balance tweaked and significant fill-light applied to bring out detail in the shadows. However even with optimized sharpening the fine detail isn't improved.
|Original JPEG||RAW + ACR|
|100% crop||100% crop|
One point of note here is just how far you can pull up shadow detail without it being spoiled by excessive noise. This example was shot at ISO400/DR200 and the shadows have been pulled up by a couple of stops in ACR, and yet they still look fine. In context, this is essentially the same thing as lifting shadows about three stops at ISO200.
Finally, you can also correct white balance errors and apply your own personalized noise reduction when shooting RAW. However the X-Pro1's automatic white balance tends to be pretty good, and the in-camera processing does an excellent job of noise reduction, so the advantage here is not as great as with some other cameras.
|JPEG (ISO3200 NR 0)||
This example, shot under low-intensity fluorescent light at ISO 3200, compares the X-Pro1's default JPEG noise reduction with ACR's. The RAW is grittier and shows less smearing of the finest detail, but the camera's processing is has done an excellent job of balancing detail against noise, and you'd struggle to tell these apart in a print. (Indeed if you look at the complete images side-by-side, the overall differences are smaller than these crops might suggest).
Overall, the excellent quality of the X-Pro1's in-camera JPEG processing means that for many purposes it makes perfect sense to shoot JPEG+RAW with the full intent of using the JPEG by default, and only resorting to the RAWs when you want to pay an image special attention. You can also use the camera's own processing to make global tweaks to white balance and exposure for images that only need minor changes. Of course it's still best to use RAW for more extreme manipulations.
RAW files for download
Don't just take our word for it - take a look at the Fujifilm X-Pro1's RAW files for yourself, and run them through your preferred software and conversion settings. Here, we provide you with a selection of raw files of 'real world' scenes, and if you want to take a closer look at the X-Pro1's studio scene shots you can download original raw files from our 'Compared to (Raw)' page.
- 15 Photographic features
- 16 Image Quality Tests
- 17 Noise & Noise Reduction
- 18 Resolution
- 19 RAW mode and RAW conversion
- 20 Dynamic Range
- 21 Lens corrections
- 22 Movie Mode
- 23 Image Quality Compared (JPEG)
- 24 Image Quality Compared (High ISO)
- 25 Image Quality Compared (Raw)
- 26 Conclusion
- 27 Image samples
|New Forest pony by Dutch Newchurch|
from Equines in 2018
|Leader of the pack by Wu Jiaqiu|
from My Best Photo of the Week
|Czech Crown by Tobik|
from Coins - Macro only
For KFC Hong Kong’s latest ad campaign, New York City-based advertising agency Ogilvy and Mather used Photoshop to magically morph pieces of flaky fried chicken into fire and smoke in various scenes.
The Android and iOS app from Surpuba AR lets you place animated 3D models in real-world environment using augmented reality technology. You can alter poses and location, insert lighting equipment, and more... right from your phone or tablet.
Under the agreement, the two companies will work together to develop Oppo's smartphone camera roadmap, covering optical zoom, depth mapping and other innovative imaging features that dual cameras allow.
Canon is jumping into the portable printing game with the new IVY Mini Photo Printer: a rechargeable battery-powered printer for creating 2x3 prints and stickers of your smartphone snaps on-the-go.
The program first launched last year, but only as a temporary promotion limited to previous-generation GoPro cameras exchanged for discounts on current-generation models. This time around, GoPro is accepting nearly any digital camera in any condition.
One of the most usable 360° cameras on the market is getting even better. With its latest update, Rylo adds a 180° mode, bluetooth remote capture, and a cinematic motion blur effect for your timelapse shots.
Phase One has released the first major update to its Capture One Pro 11 photo editing program. The update adds support for 8 new cameras and 16 new lenses, and includes several new features and functional improvements that speed up workflow.
We recently got our hands on Samsung's latest and greatest smartphone, the dual camera, variable aperture Galaxy S9+, and took it to mostly sunny Southern California for a long weekend.
It's spring, and that means wedding season is upon us! If you're one of the many photographers planning wedding shoots this year, this is a great time to think about including aerial photography in your plans.
The first firmware update for the Sony a7 III addresses an issue in video mode wherein "blinking pixels" would show up along the base of footage recorded with certain settings.
Researchers with Switzerland's EPFL have developed a soft exoskeleton that enables its wearer to control a drone using their upper body. The human-robot interface is said to offer "natural and intuitive control of drones."
Photokina has released an official list of confirmed exhibitors for the 2018 expo, quieting rumors that major brands like Canon and Profoto might follow in Elinchrom's lead and skip this year's show.
For owners of Sony's a7R III, a9 and the new a7 III, there's now an easy fix for the rare but dreaded 'striping' in backlit shots with lots of flare. Click through to learn more.
The team behind the ubiquitous JPEG format has unveiled an all new image format designed to quickly and efficiently stream content across wired and wireless networks alike. Surprisingly, it actually uses less compression than traditional JPEG.
Canon USA has released a promotional video showcasing its latest CMOS sensor technology. Albeit over daraticized, it’s an interesting overlook at the work it’s continually putting into its camera systems.
The large-format digital LargeSense LS911 is the "world's first 8x10 digital single shot camera for sale." The camera features a 12-megapixel 9x11-inch monochrome CMOS sensor, which translates into massive 75 micron pixels.
Pricing and availability have been announced for Tokina's high-end Fírin 20mm F2 FE AF autofocus lens for Sony E-Mount. If you're curious about this lens, you'll be able to pick up your own starting in June for $950 USD.
It's the copyright lawsuit that refuses to die. In September 2017, PETA finally settled its monkey selfie lawsuit with photographer David Slater, but the request to dismiss the case has since been rejected by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.
As part of his ongoing ‘Good Light’ YouTube series, London-based photographer Sean Tucker has created a simple tutorial on how to find good natural light for portraits.
The 2018 Pulitzer Prizes were announced yesterday, with the photography awards going to photojournalist Ryan Kelly for image of a car plowing into protesters in Virginia, and the entire Reuters photo staff for a series on Rohinga refugees fleeing persecution.
When it was announced in 2016, the Rokinon AF 14mm F2.8 FE was among the first full-frame autofocus lenses for Sony's a7-series mirrorless cameras. We wanted to see how this affordable wideangle prime performs on Sony's latest a7R III.
ARQ files shot using the Pixel Shift mode in the Sony a7R lll—and processed using Sony's own Imaging Edge software—can now be opened and edited in Lightroom Classic CC after the latest update.
Lensrentals put together a very useful overview of all the memory card options out there for photographers and videographers. It covers speed ratings, card formats, and explains everything you need to know to pick the right card for the job at hand.
If you look at the cameras used to shoot the winning photos in the prestigious World Press Photo 2018 competition, you'll see that DSLRs dominated over mirrorless, and Nikon dominated over everyone.
The MindShift Gear BackLight 18L daypack joins the 26L and 36L versions, providing users the same heavy-duty build and convenient rear-panel access in a more portable form factor.
You think you know everything there is to know about Lightroom? Think again. Photographer and YouTuber Jamie Windsor thinks he can still teach you a thing or two.
Skylum Software has released the latest update to its image processing software Luminar. The update improves speed across Windows and MacOS, and brings new features including automatic image distortion correction and a new Raw conversion engine.
With the Canon EOS M50 review wrapped up, we've revisited our Best Cameras for Parents Buying Guide – and have some new recommendations in the category.
The Xperia XZ2 Premium's dual-camera system is designed for low-light performance. It's also the first phone capable of recording 4K HDR footage.
For a few years now we've been recommending the Nikon D750 to enthusiasts and semi professionals needing the most reliable camera for the money. But it might finally be time to change that recommendation...