DxOMark Mobile Report: HTC One M9
The One M9 is HTC's latest top-end smartphone. The new model is a touch smaller and thinner than its predecessor, the One M8, but otherwise sports a very similar design. Under the hood HTC has finally dropped the 4MP "ultrapixel" sensor of the predecessors that produced only mediocre image quality results in our testing. Instead, the One M9 comes with a 20MP BSI CMOS sensor that is combined with an F2.2 lens. There is no optical image stabilization but the M9 is the first One model capable of recording 4K video.
With a DxOMark Mobile score of 69 the HTC One M9 improves over its predecessor by only one point and slots into the DxOMark smartphone rankings at a slightly disappointing position number 22. The DxOMark team reports that in bright light "colors and nice and pleasant, detail is good and the autofocus performs well". However, they also found the colors to be over-saturated in low light, "white balance is often inaccurate in both bright and low light" and there is a "loss of sharpness in the corners of the image". The testers also criticized "strong quantification and color gradations" in areas of plain color and "strong ringing".
When shooting in video mode the HTC One M9's autofocus is accurate and video footage shows "good noise reduction in bright light". On the downside "a lot of detail is lost in both bright and low light" and there is no video stabilization. The testers also found "visible luminance steps during exposure changes" and over-saturated colors in low light".
Color, Exposure and Contrast
The DxOMark team found that on the HTC One M9 "exposure behavior was overall good" and that the camera rendered "nice and pleasant colors in bright light". However, "white balance is often very green in bright light", there is "visible color shading in bright and low light" and "colors are saturated in low light".
Overall DxOMark awarded the HTC One M9 scores of:
- 4.3 out of 5 for Exposure
- 3.0 out of 5 for White Balance accuracy
- 3.5 out of 5 for Color shading in low light*
- 2.5 out of 5 for Color shading in bright light*
- 2.5 out of 5 for Color Rendering in low light
- 4.5 out of 5 for Color Rendering in bright light
*Color Shading is the nasty habit cellphone cameras have of rendering different areas of the frame with different color shifts, resulting in pictures with, for example, pinkish centers and greenish corners.
Noise and Details
DxOMark's engineers reported that the HTC One M9 images show "very nice detail preservation in bright light" but that "details is smoothed in low light condition", there is "strong luminance noise in bright light" and "low frequency chrominance noise is visible in low light".
Texture acutance is a way of measuring the ability of a camera to capture images that preserve fine details, particularly the kind of low contrast detail (such as fine foliage, hair or fur) that can be blurred away by noise reduction or obliterated by excessive sharpening.
Sharpness is an important part of the quality of an image, but while it's easy to look at an image and decide visually whether it's sharp or not, the objective measurement of sharpness is less straightforward.
An image can be defined as "sharp" if edges are sharp and if fine details are visible. In-camera processing means that it's possible to have one of these (sharp edges) but not the other (fine details). Conventional MTF measurements tell us how sharp an edge is, but have drawbacks when it comes to measuring fine detail preservation. Image processing algorithms can detect edges and enhance their sharpness, but they can also find homogeneous areas and smooth them out to reduce noise.
Texture acutance, on the other hand, can qualify sharpness in terms of preservation of fine details, without being fooled by edge enhancement algorithms.
At first sight, the images from these two cameras may appear equally sharp. A sharpness measurement on edges will indeed confirm this impression, and will even show that the second camera is sharper. But a closer examination of low contrasted textures shows that the first camera has better preservation of fine details than the second. The purpose of the texture acutance measurement is to qualify this difference.
Visual noise is a value designed to assess the noise in an image as perceived by the human visual system, depending on the viewing condition (size of image, size of screen or print, viewing distance). The measurements have no units and can be simply viewed as the weighted average of noise standard deviation for each channel in the CIE L*a*b* color space. The lower the measurement, the less noise in the image.
Noise and Detail Perceptual scoring
- Texture (bright light): 4.8 out of 5
- Texture (low light): 2.8 out of 5
- Noise (bright light): 3.5 out of 5
- Noise (low light) 3.1 out of 5
Phone cameras, like entry-level compact cameras, tend to suffer from artifacts such as sharpening halos, color fringing, vignetting (shading) and distortion, which can have an impact on the visual appeal of the end result. DxOMark engineers measure and analyze a range of artifacts. Their findings after testing the HTC One M9 are shown below:
- Strong ringing
- Strong quantification in areas of plain color or color gradation.
- Slight fringing
- Loss of sharpness in the corners of the image
- Sharpness 3.5 out of 5
- Color fringing 3.5 out of 5
- Ringing center 20.6%
- Ringing corner 9.1%
- Max geometric distortion -0.1%
- Luminance shading 0.2%
Distortion and Chromatic Aberrations
DxOMark also tests autofocus accuracy and reliability by measuring how much the acutance - or sharpness - varies with each shot over a series of 30 exposures (defocusing then using the autofocus for each one). As with other tests these results are dependent on the viewing conditions (a little bit out of focus matters a lot less with a small web image than a full 8MP shot viewed at 100%). Using the 8MP equivalent setting, the HTC One M9 performs reliably in bright light but shows some weaknesses in low light. The overall score is 78/100 in bright light and 67/100 in low light.
- Autofocus is reliable in bright light
- Autofocus slightly slows down in low light
- Some errors in low light
- When refocusing from macro to infinity sometimes strong overshooting is noticeable
DxOMark scored the HTC One M9 a low 60/100 overall for its flash performance, making its flash mode one of the worst among the current generation of top-end smartphones.
- Good flash uniformity
- Details are lost
- Colors are under-saturated
- Color clipping is noticeable
- Strong noise in the corners
- Color shading when flash is mixed with a tungsten light source
Overall DxOMark Mobile Score for Photo: 73 / 100
DxOMark engineers put phone cameras through a similarly grueling set of video tests, and you can read their full findings on the DxOMark website here. Overall DxOMark found the HTC One M9's autofocus performance to be reliable in video mode but footage shows little detail, oversaturated colors and stepping during exposure changes.
- Good noise reduction in bright light
- Accurate autofocus
- A lot of detail is lost in both bright light and low light
- No video stabilization
- Visible luminance steps steps during exposure changes
- Colors are oversaturated in low-light
Overall DxOMark Mobile Score for Video: 61 / 100
DXOMark Image Quality Assessment
With a DxOMark Mobile score of 69 the HTC One M9 is only a slight improvement over its predecessor M8. At position number 21 in the DxOMark smartphone rankings it trails behind its main rivals in the current crop of high-end smartphones.
In its testing the DxOMark team found detail and color to be good in bright light but things go downhill quickly as the light gets dimmer. In low light they found the colors to be over-saturated and white balance to be unreliable. There is also some noticeable corner softness and visible compression artifacts in areas of plain color.
The HTC One M9's video mode cannot convince either. Autofocus is accurate but footage shows little detail, there is no video stabilization and brightness "stepping" is noticeable during exposure changes. For a more detailed analysis, visit www.dxomark.com.
|2014_1211_140657AA by old shutter bugger|
from The Bride
|Overloaded by NZ Scott|
from Your City - Delivery Boy
|Barley by Will B Milner|
|APPLE & ROACH by TX Photo Doc|
from Delicious - Unpalatable
Try your hand at this blind portrait shootout between the Canon 1DX Mark II, Nikon D5 and Sony a9. With all bias removed, you might just rank your favorite camera brand worst.
Photo sharing site 500px has just added support for wide-gamut color profiles such as AdobeRGB and ProPhotoRGB, even allowing users to filter their searches by color profile.
DJI just released a mandatory firmware update for the DJI Spark. If you own a Spark and don't update your firmware by September 1st, DJI will remotely ground your drone.
Affordable flash manufacturer Godox has updated its smartphone app so that it can be used to control all of its wireless X flash units, not just the A1 smartphone flash.
Western Digital's new My Book Duo external desktop storage system offers up to 20TB of storage capacity, and comes with RAID-optimized WD Red hard drives.
Version 1.04 of the Sony a6500 firmware can be downloaded from the Sony Support website now.
Not sure how to choose your first drone? In this article, the second of a 3-part series, we discuss what factors you should consider when deciding what drone is right for you.
NASA photo editor Joel Kowsky didn't just capture the solar eclipse from his vantage point in Wyoming, he also managed to capture the ISS buzzing across what remained of the sun.
In these videos, talented photographer and filmmaker Daniel DeArco breaks down several tips that will help flash photography newbies start experimenting with artificial light.
Photographer and master potter Steve Irvine makes incredibly intricate, functional ceramic pinhole cameras that look like robots and monsters.
Chinese gimbal manufacturer Gudsen has released a firmware update for its Moza Air that lets you control the direction and angle of the head remotely just by moving a small handlebar-mounted control unit.
Curious how the Sony a9 performs underwater? Our friends at Backscatter took the camera diving off the Baja California coast, to find out how it handled shooting great white sharks.
While most of the DPReview crew put away our cameras and just watched the celestial event, Rishi decided last-minute to hack together a rig and capture a few shots.
Defunct Russian camera maker Zenit is making a comeback, and they're planning to release a full-frame mirrorless camera in 2018.
The days where you're more or less locked into premium or first-party flash units has gone. They're less than $50 now, so there's one less excuse not to get one. Here's our case for adding one to your kit, and a few pointers to get you going.
If you're shooting the solar eclipse here's a hint: don't fry your camera's sensor. Use a proper solar filter that offers at least 16 stops of light filtration, along with UV and IR filtering. More important? Don't look at it unless you've got solar filters. Sensors can be replaced, your retinas can't.
Photographer Rick Wenner recently captured an odd event called the Race of the Gentlemen with a rather odd camera: The Phase One XF IQ3 Achromatic, the world's only 101MP black-and-white digital back.
Buying used is a good way to save some dough, and with the right precautions you can protect yourself from falling victim to a scam.
This two-part video series takes a deep dive into the world of dynamic symmetry and geometric composition, using iconic photographer Henri Cartier-Bresson's brilliant photographs as a guide.
Award-winning photographer Jeremy Cowart tells the moving story behind this drone photograph, captured in the aftermath of the devastating wildfire in Gatlinburg, TN in 2016.
Happy 2017 World Photo Day! We asked everyone on staff at DPReview to share one photo that they took within the last year that makes them jazzed on photography. Here's what we chose.
French President Emmanuel Macron has lodged a legal complaint against a paparazzo who snuck onto the president's private vacation property to take pictures.
Ever wonder what the difference is between compressed, uncompressed and lossless compressed Raw files? Photography Life's Nasim Mansurov breaks it down for you in this informative article.
The oldest known portrait of a US president was just discovered after over a century in storage. It's going up for auction in October, where it's expected to fetch between $150,000 and $250,000.
If you're using the popular Sigma 24-70mm F2.8 Art lens with Sigma's MC-11 converter, listen up: you'll want to update your lens and converter firmware ASAP.
If you've heard it once, you've probably heard it a thousand times: never check in your camera gear when flying. This shattered $11,000 lens is what can happen when you do.
Lensrentals just did its first Cine lens comparison, pitting five top-notch 35mm primes against each other: the Zeiss CP.2 35mm T2.1, Canon CN-E 35mm T1.5, Sigma 35mm T1.5 FF, Rokinon Xeen 35mm T1.5 and Schneider Xenon 35mm T2.1.
A team of Google researchers have found that slightly warping watermarks when embedding them into images can help prevent automatic removal.
You don't have to empty your savings account to take your photography to the next level. These cheap buys cost about $50 or less, and come with outsized benefits for your photography.
Joey L, Dani Diamond, Brandon Woelfel and Jessica Kobeissi go head-to-head in an episode of "4 photographers shoot the same model."