Comparison Review: Sony FE 50mm F1.4 ZA vs 55mm F1.8 ZA
2 Bokeh, Fringing, Coma
Bokeh is hard to quantify or even test in a controlled manner. But taking a look at the rendition of out-of-focus highlights near and far from the focal plane can give us a good indication of what to expect. Here's we're comparing how the two lenses render defocused city lights as we focus beyond, and in front of, the plane of focus.
Immediately, it's obvious that the 50/1.4 has portraits like this.(a tell-tale sign of aspherics) compared to the 55/1.8. This helps the 50/1.4 render more natural out-of-focus highlights, which gives it a leg up in
However, somewhat surprisingly, the, at least when the city lights are slightly behind the plane of focus (when we're focused closer than infinity). Let's take a look at why this might be: note the the 50/1.4 displays when examined at 1:1 relative to the 55/1.8. While arguably quite pleasing, the extra detail in the rims of out-of-focus regions interfere, which detracts a bit from the smoothness of blur.
Interestingly, for objects in front of the focus plane (foreground objects), the differences appear, and it appears this is due to the 55/1.8 in addition to its onion-ring bokeh. In fact, the 50/1.4 has the edge here, because at least it lacks the severe onion-ring effect of the 55/1.8.
The bokeh differences become minimal when the city lights are. This is to be expected - significant defocus diffuses any patterning in the bokeh, which is why it's hard to detect significant bokeh differences between lenses in close-up portraits with distant, defocused backgrounds. Far more telling is what happens with slightly defocused objects in front of, and behind, the focal plane, as we've done above.
To sum up...
Overall, bokeh is very pleasing from both lenses, as one would expect with any fast prime of this focal length. Some photographers may prefer the slight soap bubble effect of the 50/1.4, even though it may come at a slight cost in smoothness of bokeh near the focal plane. In our opinion, the lack of severe onion-ring effect gives a leg up to the newer 50/1.4.
Longitudinal Chromatic Aberration
The bokeh comparison above tells us something else about the lenses as well: the 50/1.4 has considerably less longitudinal chromatic aberration (CA) than the 55/1.8. Note less refer to widget above as you click these links). The relatively low levels of axial CA is also evident in real-world photographs: for example, purple and green fringing in the black lettering in front of, and behind, the focal plane, respectively, are very well-controlled in the image below. Usually this sort of fringing is exceedingly easy to spot on high-contrast lettering such as the '4' below, yet it's largely absent with this lens.as well as behind, and in front of, the focal plane (
In fact, you'll generally note a lack of such fringing in all our images from the 50/1.4 sample gallery, and the same cannot be said for the FE 55/1.8. This is important, as axial CA plagues fast primes with aspherical elements, and is fairly difficult to remove in post-processing. A fair number of the most compact FE lenses, like the 55/1.8 and the Batis 25/2 are notorious for their levels of longitudinal CA, and we're quite pleased to see how well it's controlled on the 50/1.4.
Below, we take a look at coma (the spread of point sources at edges) performance of the two lenses, at apertures ranging from wide-open to F4 (beyond F4, coma tends to minimal on most lenses). The 50/1.4 takes the lead here, showing barely any coma at all even wide open, while the 55/1.8 needs to bebefore edge highlights appear circular (which is still quite respectable performance). There's some with our copy of the 50/1.4, but it's . The 50/1.4 also avoids odd - but kind of cool - artifacts like .
The new Sony FE 50mm F1.4 ZA is impressive. Our friend Roger Cicala over at LensRentals notes its central sharpness performance to exceed even the venerable Zeiss Otus, as well as the Sigma 50mm Art. He even found it to out-perform the 55/1.8 centrally, but fall behind it peripherally. Our results show the 55/1.8 to slightly pull ahead wide open both centrally and peripherally, with the 50/1.4 pulling ahead in central sharpness by F2.8. We'll look into nailing down the source of this discrepancy (it's always possible our copy of the 50/1.4 was slightly decentered), but sharpness performance between the two is comparable, and the 55/1.8 was already one of the most respected normal primes with respect to sharpness.
Therefore, we feel it fair to say the FE 50/1.4 pulls ahead of most, if not all, normal prime offerings from competitors (though we'd imagine the Sigma 50mm Art to put up a good fight). Despite a severely off-center composition, take a look at the tack-sharp eye of our model below, shot at F1.4.
Sharpness isn't everything of course, and in other respects, the 50/1.4 also impresses. Bokeh is pleasing, with very little onion ring effect, particularly compared to the 55/1.8. There is a slight soap-bubble effect to bokeh though, which may be pleasing to some, but can cost some smoothness in out-of-focus regions (but if it does, it's certainly not easy to spot in any of the portraits in our gallery). Longitudinal CA is impressively well-controlled, to the point where you won't notice much purple or green fringing near the focal plane even when shooting wide open. Nighttime cityscape and astro-photographers rejoice: coma is nearly non-existent even wide open. Videographers will appreciate the de-clickable aperture ring.
It's clear that Sony is trying to cement itself as a real option for pros, and the new FE 50mm ZA helps further that goal. We have no reservations recommending this lens. That said, if you can spend the extra time processing out the axial CA in post, don't mind onion-ring bokeh in out-of-focus highlights, aren't bothered by coma, and don't need the extra isolation or light-gathering capability of F1.4, the 55/1.8 is a compelling alternative that is lighter and cheaper, while offering smooth background bokeh and impressive, if not necessarily much greater, sharpness wide open. It also focuses significantly faster than the 50/1.4.* But for subject isolation that puts medium format to shame, while retaining respectable sharpness and contrast even far off-center wide open (and particularly by F2), the FE 50mm 1.4 ZA is the lens to own.
* The FE 50mm F1.4 ZA, like most recent Sony lenses, focuses stopped down at your selected aperture. This means that autofocus performance steadily drops as you stop down, since smaller apertures mean less light, and more depth-of-field (less phase difference) for the autofocus system to work with. By F9, phase-detect fails altogether, and you'll experience significant hunting in AF-C.
While the intent is to minimize focus shift and shutter lag, ironically you may experience an increased lag in shooting due to decreased AF performance when shooting at smaller apertures - particularly relative to the 55/1.8 which already focuses faster due to a smaller focusing group and potentially faster motor.
While we continue to express our disappointment at this focus behavior to Sony (we'd like to see the lens always remain wide open during live view, only stopping down to take the shot, with focus shift look-up tables for lenses exhibiting severe spherical aberration), we encourage you to let your thoughts regarding stop-down focusing known in the comments below.
|Intrepid View-072500 by vbuhay|
|Jazz Hands_ by Imagemi|
from Musical instruments
|Fire Urchin by sgitlin|
from Ricoh Challenge
Checkout allows Instagram users to select products for purchase and make payments directly in the app.
GauGAN as it's known, can create photorealistic images from basic drawings using the power of artificial intelligence.
The EOS RP is Canon's latest full-frame mirrorless camera, with diminutive dimensions and a diminutive price. Find out how it stacks up and get our thoughts in our early review.
Montana judge Dana L. Christensen has ruled the Republican National Committee did not infringe upon the copyright of photographer Erika Peterman after they took a photo from a Democratic candidate's Facebook page without permission and altered it to use in a derogatory promotional mailer.
Nikon has launched updates for three of its programs to address various bugs and glitches that could cause crashes and unwanted results.
LEE Filters has launched the LEE100, its next-generation filter holder that improves the design and looks in all the right places.
With the arrival of some much-needed sunshine and final production firmware for the Panasonic S1, we've been able to get outside and really start putting the camera through its paces.
Importing, culling and tagging photos is about to get a whole lot faster and look a whole lot better with the impending arrival of Photo Mechanic 6.
On its own, the FTZ adapter retails for $250 and when bundled it dropped the cost to just $150. Now, Nikon is offering it for free with all Z6, Z7 purchases in the United States.
Profoto said it spoke with Godox back at Photokina 2018 and continues to contact Godox in an effort to stop it from marketing its V1 light.
Product renders in Italian publication Notebook Italia show an unusual design that conceals all cameras with the help of a slider mechanism.
Canon says its new EF 400mm F2.8L IS III and EF 600mm F4L IS III lenses can suffer from an intermittent flickering when shooting video in M or Av modes with certain cameras.
Leica recently announced the Q2, a digital rangefinder with a fixed 28mm F1.7 lens. It's a heck of a lot of fun to shoot with, but is it right for you? Based on our time with the camera, and its specifications, we've examined how well-suited it is for common photography use-cases.
Now that our Panasonic Lumix S1R has final firmware, we couldn't wait to get out shooting with it - and we also tried the high-res mode, which combines files to get 187 megapixel images. Because sometimes, 47 megapixels just isn't enough.
In this article, travel and landscape photographer Mitch Green encourages us to spend more time in the the field.
the lens lacks any electronics whatsoever and is constructed entirely of glass and metal. Of course, that comes at the expense of weight — this thing weighs in at 1.1kg / 2.43lbs.
Drones can be useful tools in urban areas, where they're utilized for everything from news reporting to building inspections, but flying in these areas requires careful preparation. Here's what you need to know to do so safely.
Hasselblad has released a new cable release and USB double battery charger for its X1D medium format camera .
After a report published by NBC News, Flickr has taken heat for allegedly letting IBM 'scrape' photos for use in its facial recognition datasets. But the problem isn't what it seems on the surface.
Samyang has announced the impending arrival of the AF 85mm F1.4 FE lens for full-frame Sony cameras.
Some Photoshop shortcuts are simple and obvious. Others, not so much. Here are 15 shortcuts that are actually useful.
Twitter has redesigned its in-app camera for easier access from the timeline screen.
Independent cinema lens manufacturer SLR Magic has announced it will offer all of its existing MicroPrime range in the Fujifilm X mount and has even created a Fuji-specific 12mm lens.
We've updated our buying guides with three more cameras: the Canon EOS RP, Nikon Z6 and Olympus E-M1X.
CFexpress 2.0 cards will come in three different form factors, each of which will offer different maximum speeds.
Lensbaby has added a third tilt lens to its Optic Swap system, this time a 35mm lens, adding to the existing 50mm and 80mm options.
Sigma has released firmware updates for a number of its lenses as well as its EF-E adapter to address various errors and features with Canon, Nikon and Sony cameras.
We've added the Fujifilm X-T30 and Sony a6400 to our 'Best Cameras under $1000' buying guide. These two mirrorless models pack in a lot of features for just $900 body only.
Instagram, Facebook and other Facebook-owned services are down for users around the world.
Think Tank Photo has unveiled its new Vision series of shoulder bags, including the Vision 10, Vision 13 and Vision 15.