Canon SD870 IS Digital ELPH (IXUS 860 IS) Concise Review
With tiny, high pixel count chips noise is always going to be an issue, and to a large degree this is more a test of the effectiveness (both measurable and visible) of a camera's noise reduction system. Designers have to balance the desire to produce smooth, clean results with the need to retain as much detail as possible (if you blur away the noise, you blur away image detail too). Although Canon still uses a much more light handed approach to noise reduction in the middle of the ISO range than its competitors, the SD870, like other recent Powershots, shows obvious NR artefacts at ISO 400 and up, and at ISO 1600 the combination of noise and NR smearing makes the output all but unusable.
|ISO 80||ISO 100||ISO 200||ISO 400||ISO 800||ISO 1600|
Indicated ISO sensitivity is on the horizontal axis of this graph, standard deviation of luminosity is on the vertical axis.
As you would expect, the SD870's overall noise levels are a little higher than its less pixel-dense predecessor. The graphs bear out the conclusions suggested by the crops - that noise is essentially fairly benign up to ISO 200, at which point noise reduction is applied (Chroma noise actually drops below ISO 200 and 400). The noise levels at ISO 1600 are literally off the scale and, as can be seen from the crops, much of the detail has disappeared from the images too.
Low contrast detail
What the crops and graph don't show is the effect of noise reduction on low contrast fine detail such as hair, fur or foliage. An inevitable side effect of noise removal is that this kind of detail is also blurred or smeared, resulting in a loss of 'texture'. In this test the crops below show the effect of the noise reduction on such texture (fur) as you move up the ISO range.
|ISO 80||ISO 100||ISO 200|
|ISO 400||ISO 800||ISO 1600|
As the crops above show, at ISO 80-100 the loss of fine detail is restricted to the very finest low contrast areas (Middle right of these crops), while at ISO 200 and 400, indistinct, blurry regions are starting to appear. ISO 800 and 1600 maintain a little - but not a lot - of the luminance detail, but the results look noisy and by the time you get to ISO 1600 are devoid of all but the broadest brushstrokes. Like the SD800 IS before it, the SD870 IS should be locked on its lowest ISO setting when shooting landscapes as the loss of the finest low contrast detail (distant foliage for example) due to noise reduction is visible at ISO 200, and in some cases even at ISO 100. If you want big prints with lots of detail, it's got to be ISO 80.
Optical image stabilization
The SD870 IS offers three IS modes: Continuous (IS on all the time), 'Shoot only' (IS is activated at the moment the exposure is made) and Panning (IS only compensates for vertical movement for when panning horizontally). The first option makes framing easier - the IS system steadies the preview image - but the second is easier on the batteries and, in theory more effective (though our tests don't appear to bear this out). With its 28-150mm equivalent lens you would reasonably expect to be able to get steady shots at 1/30th of a second at the wide end of the lens and 1/120th at the long end without the aid of IS.
At the 105mm equivalent end, we tested the IS system at a shutter speed of 1/60th of a second (One stop slower than ideal for consistently steady shooting), and could only really detect camera shake in the IS-off shots by scrutinizing fine detail on our resolution chart. The shots with IS in either continuous or shoot-only mode were consistently excellent, though, suggesting some benefit. At 1/30th of a second (two stops slower than ideal), only one in three shots was sharp with IS turned off while all were sharp with IS in continuous mode. IS in 'shoot only' mode, however, yielded a similar success rate to leaving it turned off.
At three stops down, working with a shutter speed of 1/15th, the IS system made no appreciable difference to the number of acceptably sharp images recorded. Regardless of mode, we were only able to record sharp images one third of the time.
At the wide angle end of the lens, 1/15th is only one stop better than you'd normally expect to handhold and, regardless of mode, we found no real difference between the shots with IS on and off, with all the shots acceptably sharp. Moving down another stop to 1/8th of a second, all shots showed similar levels of camera shake suggesting that IS is only of particular use at the longer zoom lengths.
|1/30 second, hand-held, 105mm (equiv.)|
|IS off||IS on ('continuous' mode)||IS on ('shoot only' mode)|
I own it
I want it
I had it
Discuss in the forums
|scrum break away by al booth|
from Sport competition
|Chinese Acrobat by lim yau tong|
|Parking Deck by Olaf R|
from Your City - Parking Garage
|Communication Tech by alberto_b|
|With & without by OBellini|
from Empty - Full
In this weeks' Throwback Thursday article, Simon raises a toast to the Sony Digital Mavica FD71 - a little camera which used really big memory cards.
It's been half a decade since Canon first debuted the original 6D and finally its successor is here. So what does five years of innovation look like?
The Canon EOS 6D Mark II brings more resolution, better autofocus and faster continuous shooting to Canon's entry-level full-frame camera. And we've had the opportunity to shoot with one.
The Canon 6D Mark II will ship to consumers in August, but we've been able to do some shooting with a pre-production unit well in advance.
Rumors have been swirling around for a while, and Canon has just unveiled the long-awaited successor to the popular and long-serving EOS 6D. Read all about it in our hands-on preview.
Canon's latest entry-level DSLR is here. The new Rebel SL2 (EOS 200D) is the belated successor to 2013's Rebel SL1, billed at the time as the smallest and lightest DSLR on the market.
Nearly five years after the announcement of the EOS 6D, Canon has finally replaced it with the EOS 6D Mark II. The Mark II features an all-new 26.2MP Dual Pixel AF full-frame sensor, 6.5 fps burst shooting, a fully articulating touchscreen, 1080/60p video and much more.
Canon has announced the EOS Rebel SL2 (also known as the EOS 200D), which replaces the aging SL1. This ultra-compact DSLR features a 24MP sensor, DIGIC 7 processor, Dual Pixel AF system and a 3" fully articulating touchscreen LCD.
When one of his friends got a filter stuck on his $1,700 Canon EF 24-70mm F2.8L, former MythBuster Adam Savage removed it using an unlikely, terrifying tool: a band saw.
The New Yorker asked Magnum's famed photographers, in town for the agency's 70th anniversary, to go out and capture 'the fleeting beauty of New York City's golden hour.' This is what they shot.
Roger Cicala is a difficult man to impress, but he's been waxing lyrical over at Lensrentals about Sony's new 12-24mm wide zoom.
Glassware is one of the most challenging subjects to photograph, especially against a white background. This tutorial shows you how to do it with hardly any gear.
Handevision is now shipping its all-metal Iberit 90mm F2.4 short telephoto lens for Leica M-mount 35mm and full-frame cameras.
Isocell comprises four sub-brands: Bright, Fast, Slim and Dual which are tailored to specific mobile device market demands.
The new store will be located at the Fotografiska center for contemporary photography in Stockhom, Sweden and carry the full range of Hasselblad products.
A recent vacation gave Richard a chance to think about the needs of travel photography – and how our reviews might recognize the perfect travel camera.
Need more evidence that 2017 is the year analog begins its comeback? Well, welcome another new film stock to the world.
The winners of the 10th annual iPhone Photography Awards have been announced, and they're striking.
If you were disappointed by reports that the Sony a9 struggles with adapted Canon glass, you might be able to take some comfort from Metabones' latest update.
Blackmagic Design has dropped the prices of its Video Assist external monitor/recorders for a limited time. Prices of the SD card-based recorders will be reduced in all markets, while supplies last.
Instagram has started testing a new feature called 'favorites' that enables users to share photos with only certain people. Only a small number of users have access to the feature at this time, though it may roll out to everyone in the future.
Lensbaby has announced the Velvet 85 F1.8 for interchangeable lens cameras. The lens is available in Canon, Nikon, Sony E, Sony A, Pentax K, Samsung NX, Fuji X and Micro 4/3 mounts.
It's the end of an era. Parent company Micron has announced that they are discontinuing the Lexar retail brand. This includes 'memory cards, USB flash drives, readers, and storage drives.'
Youthful trainspotter turned adult photographer, John Sanderson has traveled across the United States, documenting the country's railroads. But you won't find any trains in his pictures.
Sony's new CMOS sensor is backside-illuminated and offers an all-pixel global reset function which should drastically reduce rolling shutter effect when panning.
Shoulderpod has converted its offerings into a lego-like modular system by offering all individual parts of existing products separately, allowing users to build exactly the rig they need for a specific project or simply replace a damaged part.
Photographer Felix AAA has spent the past ten years touring the world with a variety of musicians, capturing behind the scenes shots and portraits. He talks about some of his favorite images on the FujiFilm Blog.
A roll of film discovered in an Argus C2 from an Oregon Goodwill turned out to contain some incredible images – and has been re-united with the original owner's family.
Nikon's 28mm F1.4E ED appears to roundly complete the company's updated lineup of fast, professional prime lenses. We've already seen some initial images from a Nikon ambassador, but we've worked through a gallery of our own, with a lens of our own over the past week. Take a look.
Google is holding a competition that could see your Pixel photos gracing millions of screens.