Canon EOS 5D Mark II In-depth Review
Here you can see a generated GretagMacbeth ColorChecker chart, place your mouse over any of the labels below it to see the color reproduction in that mode. Select a camera/setting combination from the 'Compared to' drop-down to comparative boxes inside each patch.
As we've noted in most recent reviews there is now a fairly consistent response across all competing models and the 5D Mark II is no exception. Canon has now standardized the output of the entire EOS range using Picture Styles, and as you can see by choosing any recent model from the Compared to drop-down menu below, the results are remarkably similar from the top to the bottom of the range.
|Canon EOS 5D MK2||Compare to:|
Artificial light White Balance
The EOS 5D Mark II's automatic white balance performance is fairly similar to that of its predecessor (and basically every other current EOS DSLR). It is very good in natural light, almost acceptable in fluorescent light, and rather poor in incandescent light. Even using the incandescent light preset does not help much. It is worth carrying a gray card around for those times when tungsten lights are around.
Incandescent - Auto WB
|Incandescent - Incandescent Preset WB
Red:8.0%, Blue: -12.4%
|Fluorescent - Auto WB
Red: 5.4%, Blue: -8.2%
|Fluorescent - Fluo Preset WB
Red: 4.7%, Blue: -4.2%
Long Exposure noise reduction
The EOS 5D Mark II has the usual 'dark frame subtraction' noise reduction for exposures of one second or longer, enabled or disabled via C. Fn II-1. Dark frame subtraction NR works by taking a second equal exposure immediately after the first but with the shutter closed, any hot pixel noise in this second exposure can then be subtracted from the first to produce a cleaner image. Our 30 second exposure in this test produced no visible hot pixels.
|Noise reduction Off||Noise reduction On|
|ISO 100, 30 sec, F14||ISO 100, 30 sec, F14|
|(Brightness boosted by 50% in these crops)|
Auto Lighting Optimizer
The 5D Mark II has the Auto Lighting Optimizer feature that is present in virtually all current Canon cameras. In real use and in the studio this feature is very hard to provoke into doing anything worth commenting on. Here is an example of a very high dynamic range situation, and the effect of having ALO off and switched on to 'strong'. Looking at the detail inside the tunnel, there is a difference, but it is subtle. We have only included the off and strong settings here, as the standard and low settings have such a subtle difference that they are almost indistinguishable from off.
|Auto Lighting Optimizer Off||Auto Lighting Optimizer Strong|
|ISO 200, 1/60, F8||ISO 200, 1/60, F8|
|50% crop||50% crop|
Highlight tone priority
The EOS 5D Mark II features the same 'Highlight tone priority' option that's found all current generation EOS cameras. It is activated by C.Fn II-3 and according to the user manual "Improves the highlight detail." The measured effect on dynamic range (in our studio) is about 2/3 to 1 stop. In the real world it produced a subtle improvement, allowing the user to retain some detail in highlight areas where they would otherwise have been lost.
|Highlight tone priority off||Highlight tone priority on|
|ISO 200, 1/25 sec, F4||ISO 200, 1/25 sec, F4 (Highlight tone priority)|
Overall Image Quality / Specifics
The 5D Mark II has the same pixel count and the same sensor size as the flagship 1Ds Mark III. While it lacks some of the more robust professional features from the 1Ds, such as weather sealing and the more advanced AF system, it gives up little in terms of image quality. Images up to ISO 3200 retain plenty of fine detail and the high ISO performance is actually slightly better than the older 1Ds Mark III. With so much resolution to play with, it's quite easy to get usable images even at the higher ISO settings, as long as you're not looking to produce poster prints.
Images at lower ISO settings are typical Canon; punchy, and very clean, and the increase in resolution over the original 5D is obvious once you start to enlarge the output. There's no doubt that 5D upgraders will be more than happy with the improvement in image quality. Viewed at 100% the images are a little soft, and you may be surprised how much sharpening raw files need, but there's plenty of detail in there if you use a good enough lens.
The matrix metering on the 5D Mark II gets it right most of the time, but in bright backlit situations it can have problems, with clipped highlights not unusual. Here is an example where the highlights in the hair and some of the stone in the background are completely overexposed. In this case, even when working from the RAW file it was not able to recover the lost detail.
In other conditions the matrix metering behaves much like any other camera, requiring positive compensation in mostly white conditions, and negative compensation if mostly black subject matter is being photographed. In low light and indoor situations, the 5D Mark II tends to underexpose slightly, which is the same as the original 5D. In challenging lighting situations, the use of spot metering would be the best solution, as the spot meter is very accurate.
The weather sealing in the 5D Mark II, while not as good as some other cameras in its class (the Nikon D700 is better, for example), never presented a problem in use. We used the 5D Mark II in moderate rain and for 3 hours with snow falling continuously, and while the photographer was pretty miserable, the camera did not miss a beat. The biggest problem in adverse conditions is keeping the snow and rain out of the viewfinder and the front of the lens. In daily use, it is unlikely that the 5D Mark II will have problems due to its lack of true weather sealing.
|This image illustrates the kind of snow conditions the 5D Mark II survived without any problems.|
We did not get an opportunity to shoot any sports or fast moving action with the 5D Mark II, but it seemed to have the same issues as the original camera, in that it was more accurate and faster using the center focus point than the other non-cross type ones. In low light conditions, with any lens F2.8 or slower, the camera had difficulty focusing with anything but the center focus point. But overall the focus system felt the same as it did in the original 5D - hardly surprising since it is, as far as we know, unchanged in this model.
We did spot a touch of mild banding at ISO 25,600 (and only at that setting), though it was neither prevelant nor strong enough to be considered an issue (and you can more or less get rid of it entirely using chroma noise reduction when working from raw. The examples below show the extent of the problem (you'll need to download the full res files to see it):
|ISO 25,600, 1/30 sec||ISO 25,600, 1/80 sec|
Only the best glass will do
Full frame cameras (or more accurately, lenses) tend to have more problems with edge sharpness and chromatic aberration towards the edges of the frame than crop sensor cameras, something that becomes more and more of a problem as the resolution of sensors increases. The 5D Mark II is no worse than the 1Ds Mark III in this regard, but if you want to get the most of the sensor, you'll need to use high quality primes, or 'L' Zooms.
Canon has wisely continued to offer the 5D Mark II in a kit with the EF 24-105mm F4.0 L IS USM (introduced with the original 5D). This lens does suffer from distortion at both the wide end and the long end, but resolution and sharpness-wise it is very well matched to the 21 Mp sensor (not to mention that it has a good range and is perfect as a everyday standard lens). Canon has in the past had problems with wide angle lenses on full frame cameras, but have addressed the situation in the last couple of years with the introduction of the EF 16-35mm F2.8 L II USM, the EF 14mm F2.8 L II USM and the EF 24mm F1.4 L II USM. One of the strengths of the 5D Mark II is the wide range of both high quality (and expensive) 'L' lenses, and of more moderately priced and lighter lenses that cover most applications.
- 1 Introduction
- 2 Specifications
- 3 What's New
- 4 What's New
- 5 Body & Design
- 6 Body & Design
- 7 Body & Design
- 8 Operation & Controls
- 9 Operation & Controls
- 10 Displays
- 11 Displays
- 12 Menus
- 13 Menus
- 14 Performance
- 15 Features
- 16 Features
- 17 Features
- 18 Features
- 19 Video
- 20 Software & Raw
- 21 Photographic tests (Noise)
- 22 Photographic tests (Noise)
- 23 Photographic tests (Noise)
- 24 Photographic tests (Noise)
- 25 Photographic tests (DR)
- 26 Vignetting/Shading
- 27 Photographic tests
- 28 Compared to
- 29 Compared to (JPEG)
- 30 Compared to (JPEG)
- 31 Compared to (JPEG)
- 32 Compared to (JPEG)
- 33 Compared to (RAW)
- 34 Compared to (RAW)
- 35 Compared to (RAW)
- 36 Compared to (RAW)
- 37 Compared to (sRAW1)
- 38 Compared to (High ISO)
- 39 Compared to (Resolution)
- 40 Conclusion
- 41 Samples
|Owens Valley Milky Way by ed rader|
from Sign, sign, everywhere a sign..
|Break by Hank3152|
from Motion blur
|Camp by T bird|
from A Big Year - birds
|The Maasai Shepherd by cgravel|
from - African Man - (Portrait in Black and White + A Border)
The MIT’s Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Laboratory (CSAIL) has developed a drone that does not require any human control for recording tracking shots. Read more
In this terrifying video, Iraqi journalist Ammar Alwaely narrowly misses a sniper's bullet, which takes out his chest-mounted GoPro. Warning: strong language. Watch the video
A new report expects action camera growth to increase about 15% by 2021, with Ultra HD cameras driving demand. Read more
Profiles for Adobe Photoshop and Lightroom have been released for Irix's ultra-wide 11mm and 15mm primes. Like all profiles, these correct for distortion and vignetting.
An upcoming firmware update from DJI will cripple its drones unless they are 'activated' on the company's website. Live streaming will be turned off and flight radius/altitude will be limited.
Brent from ShareGrid rounds up the 10 most common products filmmakers are renting from one another for productions; chances are good you own one or more of them.
DaVinci Resolve is making strong moves to compete with Premiere and Final Cut Pro, including affordable control panels for colorists. According to Premium Beat, they're really good.
If you are not planning to fly your drone commercially you are not required to register it with the FAA anymore. This decision was handed down by a federal court in Washington, D.C.
Whether you're syncing a flash, wondering why banding is appearing in your image or getting strange images from your camera's silent shutter mode, the way your shutter works has a role to play. Here's what happens when you press the shutter button. Read more
William Vazquez travels all over the world documenting humanitarian work. He spoke to us about the challenges of his work, the importance of research and why a multitool and duct tape are your best friends in the field. Read more
These ten film cameras stand the test of time. They are easy to find, affordable and capable of excellent results. Read more
Photographer Aydın Büyüktaş uses a drone, 3-D rendering and Photoshop to create mind-bending landscapes.
They're offering tips for composing selfies and converting to black and white.
Whether you're seeking ultra-high resolution, first-rate autofocus or 4K video capture, there are some supremely capable 'semi-pro' cameras available. Find out which models we liked best in our updated semi-pro camera roundup. Read more
With composition specified by the director, drones may one day be able to navigate a movie set on their own.
Canon has made the previous version, 1.1.0 available for download again.
Impossible? Not if you have a fast lens and 5 stops of stabilization.
This 'strictly limited edition' is a refurbished original Polaroid 600 redesigned with a custom two-tone paint job.
Nikon today announced a reorganization of its corporate structure which will see several divisions and business units closed or merged. Read more
High school students from New York got he chance to shoot along with award-winning photojournalist Ron Haviv in Morocco.
VentureBeat reports that Monday's Surface Pro announcement will bring evolutionary updates to Microsoft's high-end Windows 10 tablet.
The Japanese Camera Journal Press Club has awarded Olympus three out of its four annual prizes after voting by photographic magazine editors and readers.
The photos are great, but whether drones should have been flying in a couple of these places is debatable.
It's not dead yet! A few years ago several high profile filmmakers convinced Kodak to keep making motion picture film. Now they need more facilities to process it.
We made a vlog about vlogging with the M6 (which we used to make the vlog).
A video from space!
The NY Times magazine takes a look at the history of food photography, including the requisite bullet-thru-an-apple shot.
Regardless of your feelings about colorizing iconic black-and-white photos, the results are pretty impressive.
Need we say more?