Canon PowerShot G1 X Mark II Review
One would expect a camera with a 1.5"-type sensor to have great photo quality, and the Powershot G1 X Mark II delivers on that promise. Photos are sharp (save for some corner blurring that both of our review samples had, in different corners) with a good amount of detail captured. Even at ISO 8000, the camera is still producing great-looking photos - even using the JPEG format. The G1 X II gives you a higher sensitivity limit than things like the Sony Cyber-shot DSC-RX100 II and, as shown in the chart on the intro page, gives you more control over depth-of-field.
|The combination of a fast lens and large sensor on the G1 X II allows for impressive background blurring. ISO 100, 1/800 sec, f/3.9, 120mm|
Exposure is good most of the time, though the G1 X II does have a strong tendency to clip highlights. Thankfully, you can get some of that back by shooting Raw, you'll see below. Colors are typical of Canon PowerShots, meaning vibrant.
One of the issues we ran into with the G1 X II was its program line. If shooting in Program mode - which we understand not every photographer will use - the camera will almost always keep the aperture open. While this works on compact cameras with tons of depth-of-field, that's not the case on the large-sensored G1 X II. If you're taking portraits this is no big deal. However, landscapes can end up not looking as you imagined, with detail becoming blurred unintentionally. There doesn't seem to be an effect on corner blurring or overall sharpness, which is a good thing.
Solutions are pretty straightforward. You can shoot in aperture priority mode, either full-time or when you catch the camera using an undesirable aperture. If you're sticking to Program mode, program shift is an option, though you'll need to set that up by mapping the Shortcut button to handle AE Lock.
In terms of fine detail when shooting JPEG, the G1 X II does a pretty good job. While you can do a little better with Raw, the improvement is not as dramatic as on smaller-sensored cameras. Here, have a look:
|JPEG, ISO 12800, 1/80 sec, f/3.9, 120mm equiv.|
|Raw (processed with ACR 8.4.1)|
As you can see, our retouched Raw conversion has additional detail, and less false color. Even so, the original JPEG looks pretty darn good for a fixed-lens camera.
One thing we would've really like to have seen is in-camera Raw conversion. While Canon's higher-end DSLRs have this feature, it has not yet trickled down to PowerShots.
Raw Dynamic Range
In recent years, the advances we've seen in sensor development effectively manifest themselves as greater Raw dynamic range, which is perhaps most easily understood as 'processing latitude.' For the most part, these differences in sensor performance are rarely visible in the cameras JPEGs - it's when you start to process the Raws that you see the difference.
There are two examples above, which you can switch between using the pull-down menu at the top of the widget. The first shows a scene with high contrast, with the emphasis on what's outside the window. Weto see how things look. At first glance, the image looks much improved. Upon further inspect, however, there's a lot of noise, including hard-to-correct pattern noise hiding just below what is visible in the JPEGs.
In this even more, you'll see that while the brightened version looks okay downsized, in reality there's a lot of chroma noise and not much detail. The aging sensor on the G1 X II has a pretty high noise floor, which means there's not a lot of information beyond what's already in the JPEGs.
Versus the Sony Cyber-shot DSC-RX100 II
The G1 X II should have a clear advantage over its closest competitor - the Sony RX100 II. A combination of larger sensor and brighter apertures (across most of its lens range) means there should be no competition. And yet: because the Canon uses a sensor that appears to have a lot in common with the 18MP APS-C chip it first introduced in 2009, while the Sony uses the latest BSI CMOS technology, the difference isn't as large as you might expect.
These examples (and our test scene on the coming pages) suggest that the RX100 II's sensor is so much better than the G1 X II's that it cancels-out much of the dynamic range and high ISO noise advantages that the G1 X II's larger sensor should bring. The G1 X II does still have an aperture advantage, especially at the long end of its zoom. This means there are still occasions where it can use lower ISOs than the Sony, and it can offer much more control over depth-of-field (meaning you can shoot the kind of portrait shown at the top of this page).
Overall, though, the larger sensor in the Canon is much of the reason that the camera is so much less pocketable than the Sony, yet the full benefits of that additional sensor size are not realized: the Canon's image quality advantage isn't proportionate with its greater bulk.
Raw Files for Download
Jul 20, 2016
Nov 21, 2016
Nov 2, 2016
Apr 4, 2016
|Home from first day. by Frank LoPriore|
from Back to School
|Hummingbird in Flight by Lensmate|
from A Big Year - birds
|Green turtle in the shallows by gcachon|
|Bruce Green by George Veltchev|
from -Yuge and Nasty-
The new Surface Book 2 laptops come with Intel's 8th generation quad-core processors and NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1050 and 1060 GPUs. In other words: they pack a serious punch.
Leica is resurrecting a portrait lens from the 1930s: the Thambar-M 1:2.2/90. This lens features just 4 lens elements, and was famous for its spherical aberration that creates extremely soft images.
Google's Visual Core is an Image Signal Processor designed to power and accelerate HDR+ processing and other imaging tasks in the new Pixel 2 devices (and beyond).
The Google Pixel's camera is among the best we've reviewed, and its successor has already been hailed as class-leading. With expectations set high, the Pixel 2 has nonetheless left a very good first impression on us as we shot some initial sample images.
Leica is one of the oldest names in photography, and has long been one of the most prestigious. Recently, we had the opportunity to visit Wetzlar, to see for ourselves how Leica's lenses are put together.
Canon went and put an APS-C sensor in a G series compact. The result is a mighty tempting camera for travel.
Google Photos is adding a few pet-friendly features that will make it easier to find photos of your favorite pooch. Now, you can organize your pet photos by facial recognition, and you can even search your library by breed.
Colorful tripod maker MeFOTO has launched a new tripod... and a whole new brand name. Meet the GlobeTrotter travel video tripod, the first product to be released under the MeVIDEO brand.
If you own a Moto Z, you'll soon be able to attach a Polaroid instant printer to it. Check out the unreleased Moto Mod, which was leaked earlier today.
DJI has developed a technology called AeroScope that allows law enforcement to identify and track airborne drones that are breaking UAV regulations, while simultaneously addressing privacy concerns.
The Nikon D850 is a 45.7MP full-frame DSLR with an autofocus system lifted wholesale from the pro-sports focused D5. 4K capture, continuous shooting at 7 or 9 frames per second make it sound like the ultimate all rounder. Is it all that these specs suggest?
The Mate 10's Kirin 970 chipset with integrated AI processing allows for object recognition, motion detection and automatic scene selection in the camera app.
DxO has announced version 3.0 of the iOS app for its 'One' connected camera. It adds support for multi-camera Facebook Live broadcasting and both time-lapse still and video capture. Android users will be pleased to hear that a One for their platform is on the way, as well. Several new accessories are available, including a battery pack.
Canon has introduced the PowerShot G1 X Mark III, which borrows the 24MP APS-C sensor and Dual Pixel AF system from the company's recent mirrorless and DSLR cameras, adds a 24-72mm equiv., F2.8-5.6 lens and puts them into a lightweight body – but it'll cost you quite a bit.
It's not often that we see a genuinely interesting compact camera, and the Canon PowerShot G1 X Mark III is one such beast. We've pulled out the top features of the camera and tell you why they matter – and put the Mark III up against the competition.
Apple's HDR effect in the iPhone 8 Plus is on by default and more aggressive than in previous generations. It's also good enough to convince DPR contributor Jeff Carlson to leave it on all the time.
Canon's 28mm F2.8 IS USM may be small in size, but it's big on fun. We wrote about our experience using it as our only lens in Big Sur, California, but in case you missed out on our full gallery, take a look to see what this little lens can do.
Travel photographer Elia Locardi tells the story behind this gorgeous (and rare) panorama of the Dubai cityscape draped in fog.
Bison, drift cars, horseback riders, antelope – from the beach to the race track, the Sony 100-400mm G Master is one versatile piece of kit.
"Wildlife photography in Yellowstone National Park is an incredible opportunity, yet some bad photographers are giving all photographers a bad name by not following the rules."
Casio's bionic-looking new action camera, the GZE-1, is built with extreme sports in mind. The little camera is drop-proof, freeze-proof, dust-proof, and waterproof to 50 meters.
Yashica recently released the digiFilm Y35: a camera that tries to simulate the "experience" of shooting film... and it's just the worst.
Western Digital has revealed some interesting new technology that, it claims, will allow them to develop 40TB hard drives by the year 2025.
Photographer Micael Widell wanted to see just how affordable it could possibly be to get into digital photography—so he bought a full DSLR kit with battery grip and 50mm lens on eBay for just $80.
Confused about DxOMark's scoring system? This straightforward video by Marques Brownlee breaks down how DxO gets its scores, and why you should always look beyond that "overall" number.
It's not exactly a revolutionary device, but the iPhone 8 Plus does promise some evolutionary updates in the camera department. DPR contributor Jeff Carlson has been putting the 8 Plus to the test in some everyday shooting situations – take a look at how it fared.
This week in Hollywood, DJI introduced its new Zenmuse X7 camera, a Super 35 format cinema camera of its own design that can also capture 24MP still images in APS-C format. Is it time to start thinking of DJI as a camera company?
Landscape and astrophotographer Asif Islam shot a series of timelapses starting in Los Angeles and getting farther and farther away, showing how the Milky Way emerges as the light pollution fades.
Ultraviolet photography is something that relatively few photographers explore, but it’s a fascinating realm to explore with less of an investment in equipment than most people think.
After almost fifteen years of nearly buying one, Barney recently found a working Canon PowerShot G5 in his local thrift shop. It must be Throwback Thursday.