We put the HTC One's ultrapixels to the test
Shortly after the launch of its latest flagship smartphone, the One, HTC published a white paper explaining the thinking behind the 4MP 'ultrapixel' camera in its latest device. This covers some key factors affecting image quality, including the lens, sensor and processor, in a fairly non-technical way. The document is light on numbers though, and worryingly high in quotes from journalists so scientists and engineers may find it unsatisfying.
The core of HTC's argument is based around the idea that using fewer, larger pixels on a sensor that's the same size as the 13MP unit found in competitors such as the Sony Xperia Z should offer better image quality. This of course runs counter to conventional marketing, which has always contended precisely the opposite, i.e. that more pixels are better. We're a little dubious about these claims - there’s a pretty strong argument that what really determines image quality when looking at the image as a whole is the total amount of light captured by the sensor, not by each individual pixel.
However, the HTC One's advantages are not all about pixels - HTC is also talking about the (pretty unarguable) low-light advantages offered by the optically-stabilised F2.0 lens, along with the improvements to video footage that image stabilisation brings. The fast sensor read-out means its electronic shutter completes the exposure more quickly than previous sensors - 1/48sec vs 1/30sec - which should reduce the 'rolling shutter' effect in movie recording.
And there is an argument for using fewer pixels on a smartphone, since most images are shared at much lower resolution than 4MP, it's difficult to imagine the main advantage of high resolution sensors, i.e. higher image detail, being especially important to smartphone users. We have now finally had a chance to test HTC's ultrapixel-claims first hand. Andy Westlake at our London outpost got hold of a HTC One review sample and has shot a range of comparison scenes in different light situations with his the new HTC flagship and his iPhone 4s.
The current weather in the UK (only very brief moments of sunshine) meant we could not take as many shots as we would have liked to but the images below should give you a good idea of what to expect from the HTC One. We will follow up with a more detailed test under controlled lighting once we receive a test unit here at headquarters in Seattle.
Daylight, low ISO
The 4MP backside-illuminated CMOS sensor in the HTC One is made by ST Microelectronics and also being used in a number of video devices. This explains the, for a still camera, unusual aspect ratio of 16:9. Switching to 3:2 or 4:3 aspect ratios crops the image sideways. The latter for example reduces the overall pixel count to 3MP.
In the well-illuminated scene below the Apple sticks to its base ISO setting of 50 while the HTC reports a slightly unusual sensitivity of ISO 112. The HTC is doing a decent job in these conditions albeit with a much warmer color response than the iPhone, but the latter is clearly better. In good light more pixels simply means more detail and this is clearly visible in the samples below. Whether this persists in typical social media use is a totally different question though.
Here we've got another shot in good light but more overcast conditions. Both phones struggle rendering the distant low-contrast areas but again the Apple's 8MP sensor captures more detail overall. On the flip-side the HTC produces a cleaner image with visible less shadow noise.
Digital zoom is generally awful on smartphones apart from the Nokia 808 with its PureView technology and both the HTC One and iPhone 4s are no exception. That said, with its comparatively low 4MP pixel count the HTC's image quality is deteriorating faster than the digital zoom of higher resolution smartphone cameras as you can see in the samples below.
Low light, high ISO
In low light the HTC One is clearly better than the iPhone, producing a much cleaner, more noise-free image and giving brighter, more colourful images. It's difficult to isolate the effect the effect of the ultrapixels in this context as both the IS and the fast F2 lens playe a role too but in a way that’s academic, it's the end result that counts.
These images have been shot in Auto ISO mode but the HTC allows you to select ISO manually. However, a lack of information about shutter speed renders this feature pretty much useless.
When taking into account that many editing and sharing apps for smartphones reduce the size of images it also makes sense to compare the low-light samples above at roughly the same size. For this purpose we have reduced the iPhone 4s image to the same width as the HTC image (1520 pixels). Due to the Apple's 4:3 aspect ratio you end up with an image just over 3MP but the size of objects in the image is approximately identical in both photos.
As you can see in the 100% crops below the low-light advantage of the HTC is somewhat reduced when looking at images of the same size but the HTC One's image is still visibly cleaner with less luminance and chroma noise. So, when shooting in low light the HTC offers a real advantage over higher resolution sensors, even when the image size is reduced for sharing, social media or editing.
Soft image areas
In quite a few, but not all of our HTC One sample shots we noticed extreme softness on the right side of the frame. We haven't been able to determine the exact reasons for this but we are suspecting the effect could be caused by the image stabilization system decentering one of the lens elements. Once we get a review unit here in Seattle we will check if this is only a problem with the particular copy of the phone that Andy had in London and invesitage further. The problem is very visible in the samples which were taken within a few images. Exposure data for the two images is identical but if you click through to the full version of the image on the left you can see that are large area on the right side of the frame is extremely soft, making the image pretty much unusable.
First image quality impressions
Overall, from what we can see from these first sample shots, the HTC One with its 4 "ultrapixels" CMOS sensor performs pretty much as we would have expected. In low light and at higher sensitivities the HTC delivers cleaner images than the higher-resolution iPhone 4s. However, this is as much due to the optical image stabilization and fast F2 lens as the sensor. The HTC's advantage decreases if you compare images at the same size but is still clearly visible.
It doesn't come as a surprise that in good light the HTC trails noticeably behind its higher resolution peers in terms of detail capture. In good light more pixels simply mean more detail. The question is by how many users this will be viewed as a disadvantage, given a large proportion of smartphone images is being edited and shared at lower resolutions anyway.
We should also mention the HTC's strong tendency to produce purple flare with light sources that are located just outside the frame, a very similar effect to the one found on the iPhone 5. This is very obvious in the first image of our sample gallery below.
We will analyze the purple flare effect and image quality of the phone in general in much more detail once we receive a reviewable unit at our studio in Seattle. In the meantime we have included a few additional sample images in the preview gallery below for you to examine.
There are 12 images including a couple of panoramas in our HTC One preview samples gallery. Please do not reproduce any of these images on a website or any newsletter / magazine without prior permission (see our copyright page). We make the originals available for private users to download to their own machines for personal examination or printing (in conjunction with this review), we do so in good faith, please don't abuse it.
Unless otherwise noted images taken with no particular settings at full resolution.
Mar 21, 2016
Apr 24, 2013
Mar 22, 2016
Jun 4, 2013
|Steamin' Mad by ahrensjt|
from Angered Subjects (Street Photography)
|Smile by Olymguy|
from Ultra Asian Indian Female Faces
|Space Shuttle Cockpit- by vbuhay|
from Aircraft Control Stick
If you're thinking of using Canon's sports glass on the Sony a9, think again. The ultra-fast camera slows way down when you attach off-brand glass.
The Polish town of Katowice is not known as an area of beauty, but as all photographers know, that doesn't mean that beauty can't be found if you know where to look. Mariusz Pietranek used a drone to look down on the colorful sedimentation tanks at an ironworks.
New York Times video journalist Ben Solomon spent a harrowing three weeks accompanying Iraqi Major Sajjad al-Hour as he and his men fought to retake Mosul from I.S. forces.
The 3D VR camera launched through a crowdfunding campaign in 2015 goes on sale beginning June 26.
Noctilucent clouds, a crescent moon and Venus were visible in the pre-dawn sky over Budapest yesterday. Photographer György Soponyai captured NASA's astronomy picture of the day.
Squirming pets won't sit still for photos? A Kickstarter campaign is looking to help.
Find out how Chris Burkard shifted from editorial photography to his true passions: landscapes, conservation and, of course, surfing.
The updated EyeEm app scans your camera roll and picks images that are composed particularly well, have the best quality, or highest chance of selling on EyeEm Market.
It's three years old but still a solid option for a Micro Four Thirds shooter looking for a high-quality, fast, wide-angle prime. Take a look at how we got along with it.
Tamron has announced the longest all-in-one zoom lens currently available, the 18-400mm F3.5-6.3 Di II VC HLD. Designed for Canon and Nikon crop-sensor cameras, the lens will be available in July.
When you're ready to step-up to full-frame from an entry-level or midrange camera, the choices can be overwhelming. Find out which models came out on top in our $1200-2000 enthusiast ILC roundup.
Just a guy wearing a VR headset, smashing invisible Goombas in Central Park.
NASA's Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter captured this gorgeous aerial photo of the Martian landscape. And if you look really close, you can actually see the Mars Curiosity rover in the very middle.
The city of Laguna Beach, California has provided some clarification around the kinds of photography permits it offers.
Later this year, a VR180 camera will be Joining Yi's Halo and 360 VR cameras, which will offer stereo 3D capture, yet be as easy to use and compact as a 2D camera.
Caltech researchers have developed an 'optical phased array' chip that uses time delays instead of a lens to focus the incoming light.
Pricing and shipping have finally been revealed for two highly anticipated lenses from Sigma, announced in February.
These macro photos of clouds of paint billowing through clear water might look like high-quality CGI, but they're real photographs. And photographer Alberto Seveso told us how they were made.
Facebook is testing a feature that prevents people from saving, sharing, or even taking a screenshot of your profile picture.
We've reshot the Sony a9 in our studio. The short story: it's sharper! The long story... well you can read it all here.
The collection will be officially launched during the Europeana Transcribathon Campus Berlin 2017 crowdsourcing event which will be held on 22 and 23 June at the Berlin State Library.
Light gives us some insight into the preparations for the launch of the pre-order shipments of its much anticipated L16 multi-lens camera.
OnePlus co-founder Carl Pei has confirmed in a tweet that the second lens on the back of the OnePlus 5 uses a 1.6x optical zoom and that digital zoom is used to reach the claimed 2x zoom factor.
Fujifilm recently unveiled the second in its series of affordable cine lenses, the MK50-135mm T2.9. We got our hands on it for a couple days and took it for a spin.
Leica's first attempt at an M-series digital rangefinder was rough around the edges, but set a pattern for all of the cameras that came after it. In this week's Throwback Thursday article, Barney remembers the M8.
No stranger to extreme situations, legendary climber and filmmaker Jimmy Chin talks to Outside Magazine about his career, and the challenge of filming Alex Honnold's rope-free solo climb of El Capitain.
A company backed by Android co-founder Andy Rubin is attempting to make video conferencing less terrible.
Rangefinder magazine asked five professional portrait and wedding photographers about posting on Instagram; no surprise, they got five different answers.
This captivating stop motion film was created by stripping away one layer of wood at a time. It's hard to look away.
It will enable users to simulate the presence of the sun, moon and Milky Way and see how they interact with an area's topography.