Apple still hasn't made a truly 'Pro' M1 Mac – so what's the holdup?
The in-house developed M1 architecture that powers Apple's latest machines allows them to be sleek and power-efficient, but there are still some things it can't offer professional users.
Ever since Apple unveiled the M1 System on a Chip (SOC)—the CPU/GPU/RAM combo pack that powers the latest 13-inch MacBook Pro, MacBook Air, Mac mini, and the redesigned 24-inch iMac – the creative world has been buzzing. It's fast, it's power efficient, it barely needs to be cooled, and since it was designed by Apple for an Apple operating system, the M1 system is optimized to within an inch of its life.
The M1 is a preview of coming attractions
In so many ways, the M1 has done more, and done it better, than anyone dared hope when plans for Apple Silicon were first announced. So why are many users clamoring for a "pro-level" M1 that has yet to be released?
The problem is that the M1 was never meant to power professional-grade hardware. It's a preview of coming attractions – an extraordinary appetizer designed to serve the enthusiast and amateur community, while tantalizing pros with a mere taste of what's possible. Seven months on, the pros are getting impatient.
|Maxed-out M1 Macs top out at 16GB of memory and 2TB of storage, among other limitations.
Photo by DL Cade
From a pure performance perspective the M1 Macs are already professional grade, at least among laptops. Especially with apps that either can't or won't take full advantage of a discrete GPU, performance is within spitting distance of the most powerful PC laptops on the market.
In benchmark after benchmark, the M1 iMac we're currently reviewing (stay tuned) either kept pace with or outperformed higher-specced machines like the Razer Blade 15 Advanced and ASUS G14 – computers that sport 8-core/16-thread CPUs, NVIDIA RTX 30-series GPUs and twice the RAM of any M1 computer.
|24-inch iMac||Razer Blade 15 Advanced||ASUS Zephyrus G14|
|CPU||M1 8-core||Intel 10th Gen Core i7-10875H||AMD Ryzen 9 5900HS|
NVIDIA RTX 3080
16GB DDR6 VRAM
NVIDIA RTX 3060
6GB DDR6 VRAM
|RAM||16GB Unified Memory||
|Storage||1TB NVMe SSD||1TB NVMe M.2 SSD||1TB NVMe M.2 SSD|
|Display||24-inch 4.5K LCD||15-inch 4K OLED||14-inch QHD LCD|
Take Adobe Lightroom Classic for example. We ran import and export benchmarks on all three of the machines shown above, building 1:1 previews on import and exporting 100% JPEGs that were heavily processed using an identical preset. Tests were run on 100 Canon EOS R6 raw files, 100 Nikon Z7 II raw files, 100 Sony a7R IV raw files, and 100 Fuji GFX 100 raw files.
In an effort to make the times as comparable as possible, we used the studio scene photo from each of these cameras and simply duplicated it 100 times.
You can see the results in both table and graph form below:
|EOS R6 Import||EOS R6 Export||Z7 II Import||Z7 II Export||a7R IV Import||a7R IV Export||GFX100 Import||GFX100 Export|
The situation is similar in Premiere Pro, although the iMac's lack of discrete GPU begins to take a toll. Using a 4K test video made up of 8K Sony a1 footage – complete with titles, Lumetri color grading, stabilization, etc. – we rendered previews in 4K ProRes 4:2:2 and exported in three different formats: the master file (using previews), an H.264 file, and an H.265 file. We also applied Warp Stabilize to a 15 second clip from this same project.
The M1 is slower than the Intel-based Blade 15 and AMD Ryzen-based ASUS G14 in all but Warp Stabilize, but the difference isn't huge. It's approximately 12% slower at render and 18% slower at encoding H.264 and H.265 files.
|Render All||Export Master||Export H.264||Export H.265||Warp Stabilize|
Intel recently released its 11th Gen Tiger Lake H-series processors, which should make the next generation of Intel-based machines even faster, but my point stands: these PCs boast some of the most powerful CPUs and GPUs on the market, and the M1 holds its own against both of them despite some inherent limitations – an integrated GPU, only 16GB of RAM, and minimal cooling.
From a pure performance perspective, there's not much more that we could ask for. So what exactly is the problem?
The issue with the M1 is not raw benchmark performance, it's that it was only designed to run on enthusiast-level hardware. Except for the 12.9-inch iPad Pro – which is still limited by iPad OS – each of the four M1 Macs currently available would be considered "entry-level" in their particular product category. In effect, Apple has packed professional performance into four computers (and an iPad) that were never aimed at professionals.
Many of the design choices that Apple made come down to limitations of the M1 SOC itself. There are only so many lanes available on a chip this size, and that translates into some frustrating bottlenecks: the maximum amount of RAM is 16GB, the maximum amount of storage is 2TB, and the maximum number of true Thunderbolt 4 ports is only two.
The M1 iMac and Mac mini offer a little bit more connectivity. The Mac mini has an HDMI 2.0 port and two USB Type-A ports while the iMac can be configured with 2 additional USB Type-C ports that are not Thunderbolt. Both can be configured with Gigabit ethernet, and you can upgrade to 10 Gigabit ethernet on the Mac mini. But all five M1 Apple products suffer from the same 16GB RAM and 2TB internal storage limit.
For many professional users, these limitations make every M1 Mac unusable from the get-go. And so we wait...
The potential for what's next
|You can configure the latest M1 iMac to have a total of four USB-C ports, but only two are Thunderbolt 4 capable.
Photo by DL Cade
It's almost like Apple didn't realize just how capable the M1 would be. As the first generation of Apple Silicon inside the Mac, it was always supposed to be the "entry-level" chip that would power Apple's smallest, lightest, and thinnest devices (and the relative affordability of these machines further reinforces this). But the M1 has done so well that there are very serious comparisons between the tiny Mac mini and Apple's flagship Mac Pro tower. Comparisons that the Mac mini sometimes wins.
The entire creative industry is practically salivating, not because the M1 isn't good enough, but because the M1 is already so good. If this is what Apple was able to achieve in a tiny package with only 8 CPU cores, 8 GPU cores, and 16GB of RAM, imagine what future Apple Silicon Macs will be able to do with proper cooling, 16 or 32 cores, and 32GB or 64GB of unified memory.
There's potential for a beefier computer that prioritizes performance over thinness
Despite the M1's professional-grade performance, there is currently no Apple Silicon Mac with enough ports, enough storage, enough RAM, or even the right design sensibility for professional workflows. The potential is there, we're just waiting for Apple to realize that potential by creating a larger M1X or M2 and packing it inside of a bigger, beefier computer that prioritizes performance over thinness and professional applications over pretty colors.
Until they do, you'll continue to hear grumbles from the professionals in the audience. We've seen what's possible. We're ready for the main event.
The Panasonic GH5M2 is a refresh, rather than complete reworking, of the company's image-stabilized, video focused GH5. We didn't find live streaming as reliable as we'd hoped but we appreciated the improved feature set.
Compact camera releases are few and far between these days, which is why we're excited to try out the new Ricoh GR IIIx. It's based around the same 24MP APS-C sensor as the GR III, but features a 40mm equivalent F2.8 lens. See how the image quality looks in our sample gallery.
To celebrate 80 years of manufacturing cameras, Hasselblad has released a limited-edition kit for its 907x camera that will retail for $15,000.
In 2018, Pixii announced its first product, the Pixii camera. The 12MP digital rangefinder eschewed a rear display and card slot. Now, Pixii has a new version of its camera, featuring the same design but a different 26MP image sensor.
iPhone release season isn’t complete until iFixit gets its hands on Apple’s latest devices to tear them apart and see what’s inside.
Hasselblad has taken to social media to tease an announcement that will take place at 1pm CEST (UTC+2) on September 28, 2021.
The year 1839 began with the announcement that people could make permanent pictures. But it was the middle of that year before anyone (other than the few inventors) really could. And the drama involved meant that for quite a while after 1839, some people couldn't.
Canon was a pioneer of electronic, multi-mode cameras, and some of the design decisions that the company made way back in the 1980s persist even now, in its high-end EF and RF cameras. So join us, as we go back in time...
ACD Systems has announced ACDSee Photo Studio 2022. The digital asset management and photo editing application leverages AI to deliver new facial recognition tools, improved organization and more.
The app, which is available to download for free with an optional in-app purchase, includes more than 40 film simulation recipes you can apply to JPEGs captured with Ricoh GR, GR II, GR III and GR IIIx cameras.
Stephen Dowling, founder of Kosmo Foto, shares the details of the OM-X, a prototype camera Olympus had planned on releasing before 'technical difficulties' during production led them to releasing the OM-1.
There are conflicting reports as to whether it'll be 6GB or 4GB per minute, but whatever the case is, be prepared to have plenty of storage on hand.
The annual Siena Drone Photo Awards recently announced their winners and finalists.
Tired of multiple devices using different charging cables? So is the European Union's European Commission. Proposed legislation will require all electronic devices to use USB-C charging ports starting in 2023.
The Rokinon (Samyang in most regions) AF 35mm F1.8 FE is an impressively sharp standard prime for full-frame Sony mirrorless bodies. See how it performs in a variety of situations in our sample gallery.
Entrepreneur Chris Whalen is using his app, Historik, to bring parts of his hometown back from the distant past. Using augmented reality, Historik lets users explore 3D AR recreations of historical artifacts.
Today, at its Surface event, Microsoft announced the Surface Pro 8, Surface Laptop Studio and Surface Duo 2, all of which bring welcomed improvements to their respective predecessors.
Photographer Markus Hofstaetter is never one to back down from an interesting photography project. His latest work takes his wet-plate photo process and applies it to food photography.
This year's iPhone 13 lineup is all about bigger sensors and faster lenses. Apple managed to cram the 12 Pro Max camera into the 13 Mini this year, and have stepped up the game with its largest sensor ever.
While we're waiting to receive our review unit, we've rounded up a collection of video and written reviews that dive into the details of Apple's new iPhone 13 lineup.
The budget-friendly lens offers autofocus, EXIF support and a built-in USB-C port for installing future firmware updates.
Vaonis has announced another smart telescope, the Hyperia. Vaonis's latest telescope camera has a 61MP full-frame image sensor and a large 1050mm optic.
The three-minute video is an overview of the features Samsung's new HP1 mobile image sensor offers, including its various pixel-binning modes, Smart ISO and Double Super PD autofocus capabilities.
The monitor doesn't quite match the specifications of Apple's Pro Display XDR monitor, but it does include a built-in stand and retails for $1,000 less than Apple's offering.
Find out why DPReview TV's Jordan Drake is planning to buy the iPhone 13, what excites him about its new cameras, and what he thinks of Cinematic mode. He also explains why he probably won't use ProRes for video.
Capture One 22 will launch this December with new features like HDR merging and panorama stitching. If you've yet to give Capture One a go, Capture One has announced that new users can purchase Capture One 21 during a limited window and receive Capture One 22 for free in December.
Ilford aims to make film photography more approachable and fun with a trio of new products, including a Pop-Up Darkroom, Darkroom Starter Kit and 35mm Gift Calendar.