Mano a mono(chrom): the humbling of a color-only photographer
Let me begin this article by explaining what it isn't. This isn't a review of the Leica Monochrom (specifically the Typ 246 but henceforth referred to simply as 'Monochrom' since life is short). We all know that the Monochrom is a strange and unique camera,1 priced and positioned in a way that puts it out of reach for most photographers, myself included. But that's why it's so fascinating, and why when I got the opportunity to borrow one for a recent trip to Japan, I jumped at the chance.2
Over the years, my 'no black and white' rule for personal work has become pretty firm
My relationship with black and white imaging is complicated. I started out in the late 90s shooting black and white film, but since switching to digital in the early 2000s I've worked entirely in color. Very rarely – if ever – do I convert an image into monochrome unless at the request of one of my friends who wants to class-up their online dating profile. Over the years, my 'no black and white' rule for personal work has become pretty firm.
This display case is full of urns of earth, collected from WW2 cemeteries across the world. The colors of the flags have faded almost to the point where this scene is monochromatic.
Leica Monochrom, 28mm @ F2.8, ISO 6400
Why such a rigid personal policy? Catch me on an especially bumptious day and I might tell you that I think that converting a color image into black and white is cheating. That if the picture didn't work in color in the first place, then it probably won't be any more interesting in monochrome. For the most part I stand by that – at least insofar as it holds true for the kind of images that I take. But it's not the only reason why, after 15 years of color-only photography, I'd become so mono-averse. I was out of practice – plain and simple. My hope was that shooting with the Leica Monochrom for a week would be the creative kick in the backside that I needed.3
I nearly (very, very nearly) took the Monochrom to Japan as my only camera for the trip, but I'm glad (very, very glad) that I didn't. Because – and sorry for the spoiler – while the Leica Monochrom is an excellent black and white camera, I'm going to need a lot more practice before I would consider myself a good enough black and white photographer to really take advantage of it.
This image was a fairly monochromatic scene to begin with, and loses nothing by being shot natively in black and white.
Leica Monochrom, 35mm @ F5.6, ISO 1000
Shooting with the Monochrom alongside the M10 turned out to be an interesting exercise in comparing and contrasting, and not just for the obvious reasons. The M10 incorporates several handling improvements over the Type 240 and its variants (of which the second-generatIon Monochrom is one), and next to the newer M10, the Monochrom definitely feels like a less polished tool. Its LCD screen is lower resolution and less sharp than the M10's, its rear button interface is cluttered and I found myself frequently ending up in continuous shooting mode accidentally, thanks to the soft detents of the combined off>s>c>timer switch.
I used live view a lot on both cameras when shooting with a 21mm lens
The last issue is a minor annoyance, but the Monochrom's fiddly ISO setting interface and inconsistent Auto-ISO behavior gave me a fresh appreciation for the M10's relative accessibility (and stability). I used live view frequently on both cameras, especially when shooting with a 21mm lens, and the M10's superior screen resolution, sharper feed and faster shot-to-shot time leave the Monochrom in the dust.
|Another basically monochromatic scene - hundreds of Buddha statues in large glass cabinets at the Ryozen Kannon war memorial in Kyoto. I tried this shot in color but it didn't work: the vague colored reflections of foliage and flowers in the glass ended up being distracting. With the 21mm, I frequently used live view for precise framing.
Leica Monochrom, 21mm @ F8, ISO 400
I thought the Monochrom's thicker body compared to the M10 would bother me, but as it turned out, with my eye to the finder I barely noticed the difference. In fact the two cameras are so similar that I had to activate the red framelines in the Monochrom viewfinder (sadly not an option on the M10), to keep track of which one I was shooting with.
The Monochrom's fatter body does impart one major benefit though: a commensurately fatter battery. After a couple of hundred frames on both cameras, I found that the M10's battery would typically be depleted by about 50%, but the Monochrom would still be going strong at 85% or so.4
I must say though that it was a rare day with the Monochrom that I shot more than 200 frames. Japan is so full of color – and I'm so used to composing images around it – that I kept reaching for the M10 instead.
Annoyed with myself for remaining so uncomfortably inside my comfort zone, I tried a compromise of sorts. Every time I shot a picture in color on the M10, I would deliberately replicate it in black and white on the Monochrom. I pretty quickly gave that up, partly because it’s a slow and annoying way of working, but mostly because I always seemed to prefer the color images. Plus I had Carey with me, and Carey gets bored easily.
No – it was clear that the only way I was going to really give the Monochrom a proper chance was by going cold turkey, and leaving the M10 back in the hotel. So for two days in Tokyo and Kyoto that's exactly what I did.
This is the point where normally you’d expect me to write ‘it was the best decision I could have made’, but I'm not going to write that because it was miserable. I felt like I wasn’t even seeing interesting images, let alone capturing any.
Rangefinders can be frustrating enough at the best of times, but with the Monochrom I was fumbling so many shots that I began to second-guess everything from the sharpness of my lenses to my choice of career. And the shots I was missing weren’t even that interesting to begin with. After years of only shooting in color, being limited to black and white was like biting into a bacon sandwich and tasting oatmeal. I could tell Carey was running out of patience with my constant griping because he had stopped making fun of me, which is never a good sign.
Once I stopped beating myself up, my images definitely started to improve
Eventually though, however the meal tastes, a man's got to eat. On reflection, ditching the M10 (however temporarily) was probably a good decision. Most of my favorite images from the trip were taken in color, but a couple of days of strict abstinence from the newer camera gave me no choice but to engage with the challenge of getting interesting pictures in black and white. And once I stopped beating myself up, my images definitely started to improve – funny how that works. If nothing else, as an exercise in refreshing my creative process it was definitely valuable.5
By the end of the trip I was shooting with the Monochrom alongside the M10, and no longer feeling like I was cheating on either of them (or myself). Instead, I just felt the normal feelings of guilt and shame that any liberal-minded person would when carrying $20,000-worth of camera equipment around their neck in a foreign country. For his part, I think that Carey was just relieved that I’d stopped whining.
If you’re a dedicated black and white photographer, the Monochrom was built for you
I’m home now and the Monochrom has gone back to Leica, but I still have the itch. I’d like to borrow it back at some point (assuming Leica will let me, after reading this article). Even if I had the money though, I probably wouldn’t buy one. I don’t think I’d use it frequently enough – or well enough – to justify the purchase. But that's just me: If you’re a dedicated black and white photographer, the Monochrom was built for you. There's nothing else like it.
1. Native monochrome capture has several advantages over B/W converted Bayer-pattern color, some more esoteric than others. The most obvious advantages are higher resolution, since there's no need for demosaicing, and no distracting color moiré (obviously). Base ISO is also higher than the Typ 240 (ISO 320, compared to 200) which makes the Monochrom a somewhat cleaner low-light camera than the standard model. The newer sensor in the M10 closes the high ISO gap though, and having a native minimum ISO of 100 available means that shooting at wide-apertures in daylight doesn't require the use of an ND filter quite so often.
2. I hereby acknowledge that I am enormously fortunate to be able to borrow a $7,500 camera for two weeks, for free. If I were you, I'd be annoyed with me too.
3. You don't need to buy a dedicated monochromatic camera to shoot black and white, obviously. Pretty well all digital cameras have a black and white mode, including the Leica M10. I just enjoy making life difficult for myself, apparently.
4. Given that I tended to favor the Monochrom when shooting at 21mm, this kind of stamina is even more impressive. I probably used live view for more than 50% of my shooting on the Monochrom.
5. Albeit one that I could have achieved – at least in spirit – for free (see point 3, above, and point 2 if you're feeling particularly uncharitable).
|Brown Crown by Nilesh Trivedi|
from brown challenge
|D72_4852_DxO Smug by richpics|
from Aviation Legends: X-Planes
|Everyone look at the camera by cjf2|
from Looking down the lens.
|Ancient Bristlecone Pine by ed rader|
from My Best Picture of the Week
Sony's new 12-24mm F2.8 GM is the widest fast aperture zoom for full frame. Based on our tests it's a worthy recipient of Sony's 'GM' moniker.
Chris and Jordan took the new Sony 12-24mm F2.8 GM to Calgary's eclectic Ingelwood neighborhood. From record stores to spice shops, find out what got their attention when it was time to go wide.
The six prize-winning photographs and four honorable mentions were narrowed down from more than 6,000 entries captured across North America.
Though Thunderbolt 4 remains at 40Gb/s, its minimum requirements include dual 4K monitor support, faster external drive speeds and more.
You can now use compatible Fujifilm cameras with video conferencing software on macOS hardware without the need of a dedicated capture card.
The Epson V600 remains one of the most popular flatbed film scanners on the market. Revisit our review of this affordable and (mostly) easy-to-use option and see how its output compares to local lab scans.
Canon's mirrorless EOS R5 comes with a ton of features and capability stemming from its design inside and out. Come along with us on a guided tour of Canon's new high-end, high-megapixel camera and check it out for yourself.
Announced alongside the EOS R5, the R6 offers a lot of the same technology but in a more affordable, slightly more enthusiast-focused model. Take a closer look.
Alongside the EOS R5 and R6, Canon has announced a brace of lenses, all in the short to long telephoto range. Filling out the 'long' end are one L-series zoom, and two innovative primes.
Alongside a trio of telephoto lenses, Canon also announced a new 85mm this week. The RF 85mm F2 Macro IS STM is a compact, affordable alternative to the pro-oriented 85mm F1.2L.
The EOS R5 has been a long time coming – we knew it had 8K and we knew it had an AF joystick. But now that's it's here, what is it really like to use? Find out in our initial review based on hands-on time with the camera.
The R6 doesn't promise quite such headline-grabbing specs as its big brother, but it still packs a punch, whether you shoot stills, video or both.
Think you've read everything there is to know about the new Canon cameras? Chris and Jordan share eight important things you may have missed from today's Canon EOS R5 and R6 announcements.
We've been shooting around with the new Canon EOS R6. Initial impressions of image quality are positive, and out-of-camera JPEGs appear similar to that of the gold award-winning Canon EOS-1D X III. Have a look for yourself.
Canon has officially released the long-awaited EOS R5, the company's top-end full-frame mirrorless camera. Featuring a new 45MP CMOS sensor, Dual Pixel AF II system, 8K video capture and 20 fps bursts, this is the RF-mount camera we've been waiting for.
Although the Canon EOS R6 doesn't have the 45MP sensor and 8K video capture of the higher-end R5, it's still an incredibly capable camera with specs that outshine similarly priced peers.
The Canon RF 100-500mm F4.5-7.1L IS USM is the company's first super-zoom lens for RF-mount. Despite a relatively slow aperture range, it's very versatile, offering five stops of stabilization, weather-sealing and compatibility with Canon's new teleconverters.
Canon's RF 85mm F2 Macro IS STM is an inexpensive telephoto prime lens with a minimum focus distance of just 0.35m (14") and a 0.5x magnification. When attached to the new R5 and R6, it offers a whopping eight stops of shake reduction.
Canon has announced a pair of super-telephoto fixed-aperture primes. The 600mm and 800mm use diffractive optics to keep their size and weight down. They'll also be compatible with new 1.4x and 2x RF teleconverters.
Canon has announced a new small-footprint inkjet photo printer, the imageProGraf Pro-300. it will produce prints up to 13 x 19" and it goes on sale later this month for $900. A new textured photo paper will also arrive in July.
The new compression standard is set to reduce video file sizes by half to save space and speed-up transmission, paving the way for more portable 8K footage.
Sony recently confirmed plans to launch a successor to the video-centric a7S II. We don't even know the name of the camera, but Jordan already has a feature wish list for the new 'a7S III' – and it doesn't include 8K.
The Profot B10 is the first studio flash system that can be used when shooting with an iPhone camera.
The Pixii camera is an interesting little rangefinder camera that features a 12MP APS-C sensor and lacks a rear LCD display, opting instead to pair with your mobile device, which can be used to view and transfer images.
Sirui is launching an Indiegogo campaign for a wide-angle answer to its existing 50mm F1.8 anamorphic lens. The 35mm APS-C lens will come in a Micro Four Thirds mount with adapters for other systems.
Sony has added a 12-24mm F2.8 to its top-shelf 'G Master' series of lenses. It's the widest constant F2.8 zoom currently offered for full-frame, with a hefty price tag to match: it will sell for $3000 when it ships in mid-August.
Take a look at the view from Sony's new ultra-wide F2.8 zoom – we paired it with the a7R IV for some initial shooting.
Canon's EOS-1D X Mark III is one of the best DSLRs ever made. With fast burst speeds, great video quality and impressive autofocus, the 1D X III is equal parts cinema rig and sports shooter. Find out how it fares against steep competition in our full review.
Nikon Rumors is reporting that Nikon will announce successors to its Z6 and Z7 camera systems by the end of the calendar year.
Canon says the event, set to take place at 14:00 CEST in two days on July 9, will be its 'biggest product launch yet.'