Have you ever wondered what exactly happens when you press your DSLR's shutter button? Many of us know the theory, we may have even seen (or made) diagrams and GIFs showing how the standard mechanical shutter works. But for this video, YouTuber Chris Marquardt actually yanked the shutter out of a Nikon D500 to show you the mechanism IRL.
The demonstration is pretty simple, showing you how the two spring-loaded curtains move across the frame, and revealing the electromagnets that keep them in place when the curtains are cocked.
"The first and second curtain are both cocked against spring tension and held back by electro magnets," explains Marquardt. "When it's time to fire the shutter, the electronics release the first curtain, then after the exposure time is up, the second curtain." It's definitely an interesting demo if you enjoy these kind of tear downs, although you might want to turn the volume down... or off. As our own Richard Butler put it, the music "makes me want to rip my sound card out of my computer and destroy it." Okay then...
Once you've watched the video (sound card intact, we hope), click the button below to read our more comprehensive dive into all things shutter related.
what annoys me is people phrase about ES and how quiet it is but still enable MS simulated sound. ask them why, they say need it for confirmation. why do manufacturers develop ES and provide a MS simulated sound? if the MS sound is desired, why do we bother arguing about shutter sound?
I have Nikon D70 & D3100 DSLRs, and Canon 5D, 5Dii and 70D. They are all quieter than my film Nikons of the past (F and F2). My Olympus E-PLs are just as noisy as the Canons - mirrorless but mechanical shutter. I hate the soundtracks on videos where there is no relation between the sound and the visuals. Is it the millennial mind that needs constant aural stimulation?
it's not my type of music, but the warning made me expect something much worse too. The music sounds synthetic and is also repetitive, as you say, and I think it's too distractive for this kind of video content, but I think the writer has overdone the warning.
If you've ever had the pleasure of standing amongst 50 to 100 press photographers and listening to the magical symphony of high speed shutter releases you would shave your hipster beards, ditch your mirrorless and revel in the sound of mechanical shutterdom forever!
That's not a "magical symphony". That's the sound of the soon-to-be past. I prefer a quieter world. Thankfully, technology is steadily allowing us to move towards a quieter world that isn't filled with so much un-necessarily noise pollution.
@T3 Honestly, I had people with mirrorless close to me whose shutter sound was much louder than the sound of my D-SLRs mirror and shutter altogether. So, at the moment, D-SLRs are quiter than mirrorless with mechanical shutter because some companys focusing on mirrorless still don't have the tenth of years experience to get them quiter. This will still come of course :) At the moment mechanical shutter is preferred for moving subjects as it is still faster than global/rolling electronic shutter resulting in a less apparent effect of tearing in stills, banding with flickering light sources or other effects because the electronic one takes a bit longer. I think it takes about ten years till an electronic shutter beats a mechanical one so I wont talk about soon. Ok if you only take photos of static subjects, you can get a nice benefit right now but you could also take great pictures then with a cellphone on a tripod ;)
@cosinaphile Of course, I haven't heard the sound of all mirrorless cameras beside me. Mainly the sony or olympus ones. With electronic shutter, they were noiseless but with mechanical, most of them were louder than the mirror. Haven't met one with fuji yet - so I don't know better.
PS: the AF of one of my sigma lenses was louder than everything else ;)
Ah ok. My most recent D-SLR is a 7DII and its damn queit for a flapping mirror especially when set to silent continious shooting mode (but even the "normal" 10fps mode is everything but noisy).
Let's see when I meet someone with a fuji or at least stay close to one. But recently, I see more and more people taking photos with sonys..
And btw, the nicest shutter & mirror sound has still my old eos 400D. This camera just sounds nice :) As if it were moving a film (note: I'm too young for the film era), but that sound is just magic in my ears.
@mgblack74 - More and more mirrorless cameras are giving us the option of electronic shutters. Furthermore, for those mirrorless cameras that do have shutters, they lack the "clack" of a reflex mirror flipping up and down, which also adds quite a bit of noise. I have a Fuji X-E1, and even with a mechanical shutter it's quieter than my DSLR because it doesn't have a flipping mirror.
I'd like to echo Photoreader's question - how does the electromagnetic system work when the camera is a) turned off, b) the battery is removed, or c) the battery is just dead? What state is the shutter in normally, i.e. between shots? I know that in the days of manual shutter winds, moving the film advance lever not only advanced the film by one frame but also "cocked the shutter" - i.e. put it into a state of tension, which would be released by taking an exposure. In fact, in those days there was advice that it wasn't a good idea to leave the shutter cocked when the camera wasn't being used - the springs could lose tension.
But what happens these days with DSLRs with shutters?
Get some clue of what? As the engineers at Nikon did construct this device, and all it's predecessors, what could they learn from such a video? Aside from the fact that people are interested in their technology.
they can learn how to make proper shutter mechanism, so customers are not have to send their camera back to manufacturer for 3rd time to fix defective shutter.
Blimey, it looks like an escapee from the Oxford Museum of the History of Science. And all so light can hit a chip rather than film. Does a mirrorless shutter work like this?
When the cocked shutter curtains are held by solenoids, how does this work with the camera turned off or when the battery is removed? Are the curtains cocked before taking the picture? Wouldn't the delay be too long? Or is there a kind of locking mechanism or will the internal battery of the cam be used then?
Yes, but they get burned with holes when trying to take pictures of sun. The cloth is coated with rubber. With time it does not seal light very well.
Also, because of the size, it needs to be horizontally traveling, so traveling time is slower, which means you cannot sync flash on very short times, the limit is usually up to 1/60, and shutter speed is rarely beyond 1/1000.
Nikon tried to overcome some of these problems with titanium curtains on Nikon F, F2, and F3. Canon did the same on F-1N.
Eventually all camera manufacturers switched to the vertically traveling mechanism as shown in the clip. In high end cameras curtains are not metal or plastic, but composite, like carbon fiber reinforced.
Anyway, most of the noise is made by the mirror, you could take an advantage of quiet shutter only on range finder. Cloth shutter was not super quiet either. Really quiet mechanical shutter was and still is leaf shutter.
@TheCollector Thanks for the great recap. In my mind I can hear the sound of a horizontal cloth shutter right now... Canon were the last to abandon it, yes?
Some less popular camera makers continued using cloth shutter until the very end of film photography era. They just couldn't catch up later when the digital came.
Sorry, but this is a shutter from a Canon EOS 1000 F . The principle on a D500 would be the same, but have a look at the electronics. This is technology from the last century.
Thanks. I figured that the camera model was wrong because that thing was way worn and old looking. I don't think you could wear a D500 that much in only a year of use.
This is similar to the lever mechanisms used in the optical viewfinder shutter curtains of the film camera heydays, mostly in Nikon interchangeable viewfinders. They were painted in red and had a lever knob on the side of the eyepiece. The viewfinder curtains kept the light entering the eyepiece from striking the light meter and displaying a false reading.
Pro Nikon bodies still have these viewfinder shutters, got one on my D800 and D3. It supposedly stops light leaking in from the viewfinder during night shots, personally speaking I have never noticed this problem with the curtain open and shooting long exposures of the night sky.
Oh boy! I forgot about the viewfinder shutter on my D800 during my first daylight shot of a waterfall with a 10-stop gray filter. The images were ruined. It is about the ambient light level compared to the light allowed to enter through the lens. My Minolta XE-1 that i bought in 1976 has a viewfinder shutter. Some claim the mirror closes off the viewfinder prism. That is a good hypotheses, but on my D800 it is not validated by practical use. A piece of dark cloth is a quicker and less fiddly solution than the D800 lever that is a cheapo version of the lever on my Minolta.
Yes, for now. the a9 reads 12 rows at once, instead of one row at a time, like the mechanical shutter does. this causes the famous a9 banding issue. other than that, image quality is similar.
i also think (if i remember the number right) that the A9's eStutter speed is about twice as slow as the mechanical shutter ... fast enough, but still slower overall. That and the 12 line grouping, i think, are the only disadvantages that remain.
The DR decrease is due to the fact that (in true global shutter cameras) the pixel surface is smaller because a lot of electronics have to be fit in order to read all the pixels at once.
The A9 is not a global shutter. It just reads 12lines at a time, in a continuous cycle, until it finishes all the sensor.
'It's quite remarkable to note the camera's 1/160s electronic shutter rate - only 1 EV behind the 1/300s shutter rate of mechanical shutters - thanks to the high readout speed. This means that the electronic shutter in continuous drive is almost as good as a mechanical shutter in terms of avoiding banding at high shutter speeds under artificial light. Only under very unusual light sources have any problems arisen.'
The last line links to the Jared Pollin review where he experienced issues with the LED boards at a football game.
@new boyz The 'banding' was caused by the very high cycling of the LED lights at a football game - more than 7000Hz. The panels were at the side of the pitch and the light changes were only visible as reflections on the players and ball when they were close to the boards. A mechanical shutter would also have recorded light pulsing this fast.
I yearn for days when the shutter was photographer's palm; few magical movements in front of the lens, then screw in the lens cap again. And the photo magically appeared inside the box.
Spring-loaded shutters create shutter shock. They are obsolete for high-resolution sensors. It would be more interesting to see how the shutter manufacturers have dealt with this problem with magnetically-driven shutters. And manipulating sensitive mechanics with oily fingers, without gloves? Yech...
I like the subject, and the video is okay-ish, BUT! I HATE it when they show some complicated technical stuff with subtitles. You have to watch it twice or pause it all the time, because otherwise you'll miss either the video or the text.
Interesting. Although not all FP shutters work in exactly the same way and in some the blades are driven electromagnetically rather than by spring tension. The shutters in the latest Panasonic Lumix cameras are driven that way, which is why they are so quiet and free from vibration. And of course the entire shutter floats in a five-axis electromagnetic field. Now THAT'S high tech!
If you want to see a really fast shutter, just remove the lens and press the shutter button. It isnt very impressive looking because the shutter rate is still significantly longer than the 1/4000 shutter speed
As well as I know, flash sync speed is the fastest shutter speed with one curtain full open. Shutter speed that exeeds that is with smaller and smaller slot. (Two curtains) FP flash is "pulsing" (thus shorter light distance) all way up to 1/8000 Sek
Correct. So, the faster the shutter blades can move, the faster the flash sync speed can be. For FP shutters it's usually somewhere around 1/200 - 1/250 of a second but there are exceptions (in both directions) I guess this is partially determined by how powerful the springs are that drive the shutter blades open.
I'd say it is probably more about the material the shutters are made of. The higher quality carbon fiber or titanium ones are probably faster and last longer, but cost more to make, which is likely why they are only found in the more expensive cameras. Too bad they haven't figured out how to make them work reliably at twice the speed, so we can shoot at 1/500 sec. flash sync speed.
I would argue that if they're able to make a full frame camera sync at 250-320/s (e.g. D800), it should be easily possible to make a crop sensor or smaller camera sync at faster speeds than that. Smaller sensor means shorter distance to travel, so if all else is equal, it should enable a faster x-sync.
It may be seen as simply modern technology by many people but I never cease to be amazed at the miracle that is the digital camera. It wasn't very long ago that we humans mastered fire. . .
I concur. I still have two lenses to fix. I even removed the aperture blades of the Carl zeiss Jena 180mm f2.8 sonnar. When I opened it up to clean it bits fell out and I had no idea how to put these back. This lens should be used at f2.8 anyway otherwise I there is no point. Similarly, a Tair 300mm f4.5 photosniper. The blades are out of position and looks complicated to re position. I save that job for a rainy day.
Yep, get aperture blades out of position and you're in trouble. Recently cleaned several elements of my cheap Tamron 70-300 and had to disassemble the aperture blades housing to clean one of the rear elements. Not too complicated, but an enervating job nonetheless. Patience is a must.
I think the title is a bit misleading. What is being shown is not a specific shutter for DSLR cameras, but a focal-plane shutter, which is also used in mirrorless and rangefinder cameras. Anyway, the article is interesting for anyone who has never seen a focal-plane shutter with metal curtains working.
The Sony RX100 VI is a spectacularly capable travel camera, combining a flexible zoom range with impressive autofocus. But there's no getting around the fact that it's an expensive camera, and a longer lens comes with certain trade-offs. Read on for our full analysis.
The Tamron 70-210mm F4 Di VC USD is a lightweight telephoto zoom lens for DSLR cameras that comes in at an MSRP of $799. How does it perform? Find out in our full review.
Samsung's flagship Galaxy S9+ comes with comprehensive photography features like dual optically stabilized rear cameras, smooth 4K video and of course, beauty filters for your selfies. But is it the best smartphone camera for you? Find out how it compares against the likes of Apple's iPhone X and Google's Pixel 2 in our full review.
The Domke F-6, also known as the 'Little Bit Smaller' bag shares a lot of characteristics with the venerable (and a Little Bit Bigger) F-2. Senior Editor Barnaby Britton has been using one for several years.
The instant camera market is heating up, and with four formats and 15+ cameras to choose from, we felt it was high time to examine them all and pick our favorite.
Whether you're hitting the beach in the Northern Hemisphere or the ski slopes in the Southern, a rugged compact camera makes a great companion. In this buying guide we've taken a look at seven current models and chosen our favorites.
What's the best camera for a parent? The best cameras for shooting kids and family must have fast autofocus, good low-light image quality and great video. In this buying guide we've rounded-up several great cameras for parents, and recommended the best.
What's the best camera for shooting landscapes? High resolution, weather-sealed bodies and wide dynamic range are all important. In this buying guide we've rounded-up several great cameras for shooting landscapes, and recommended the best.
What’s the best camera costing over $2000? The best high-end camera costing more than $2000 should have plenty of resolution, exceptional build quality, good 4K video capture and top-notch autofocus for advanced and professional users. In this buying guide we’ve rounded up all the current interchangeable lens cameras costing over $2000 and recommended the best.
The iPhone Photography Awards (IPPAWARDS), was founded in 2007, making it the longest running iPhone photo competition in the world. Now in its 11th year, the winners of the IPPAWARDS have just been announced.
Our technical evaluation of the Panasonic GX9 has included a trip to the studio, where we put its 20MP Four Thirds sensor in front of our standard test scene.
The Sony Cyber-shot DSC-RX100 VI earned high marks in our recent review, and we've revisited our collection of buying guides to reflect our final conclusions. Click through for links to our updated guides covering the best pocketable and long zoom compacts as well as the best choices for travel, which has a new winner (hint, hint).
Fujifilm has announced the XF 200mm F2 R LM OIS WR telephoto lens along with a matching 1.4x teleconverter. This weather-sealed lens - 'matte silver' in color with a bold green hood - has a total of 19 elements, a nine-blade aperture and five stops of shake reduction according to Fujifilm. The lens and teleconverter kit will be available in late October for $6000.
Fujifilm's widest X-series zoom lens to-date, the XF 8-16mm F2.8 R LM WR, will hit the market in late November for $2000. The weather-sealed lens features ED, Super ED and aspherical elements along with a Nano GI coating.
We've seen different flavors of 360° cameras over the past couple of years, but the Vuze XR may be the first one that's designed to shoot both 360° spherical and 180° stereoscopic video in a single unit.
Huawei has launched the world's first photography contest with both AI and human judges. The contest began on July 12 and will run for 8 weeks. During this time, photographers can submit their images via a Facebook Messenger chatbot.
Fujifilm has announced the XF10, a premium compact camera with a fast 28mm equivalent F2.8 lens and 24MP APS-C sensor. This replacement for the X70 will ship in August for $500.
It won't come as a surprise to anyone that there are some unpleasant, predatory men within the photography industry. However, a long-form, extensively researched special report in the Columbia Journalism Review about sexual harassment is still a depressing, eye-opening read.
Leica Camera AG is now an investor in Light, the makers of the innovative L16 camera. According to the company, the funding will allow Light to 'expand the reach of its imaging platform beyond consumer photography'
YouTuber ZY Productions has a video wherein he provides a succinct summary of how phase detection autofocus systems work, their benefits and their shortcomings.
The X-U is Leica's first ruggedized compact camera and is still the only waterproof camera on the market with a large APS-C sensor. That sensor sits behind a 35mm-equivalent, F1.7 lens, and we've taken it to the mountains and back to see just what it's capable of.
There have now been seven variants of the Sony RX100 series, and at least six of them are still current models. Confused? Here's an updated look at their differences, and our recommendations among them now that we've tested the Mark VI.
The Kodak-branded 'Kashminer' Bitcoin mining scheme announced at CES has apparently collapsed, with Eastman Kodak distancing itself from the company behind it.
As part of a promotional giveaway, Fujifilm Korea has released kimchi-flavored instant noodles wrapped in branding inspired by Fujifilm Provia 100 color reversal film.
The Leica Noctilux-M 75mm F1.25 ASPH is a fast, high-quality and decidedly heavyweight short telephoto prime lens, designed for use with Leica's digital M-series rangefinders. We've been grappling with it for a little while - take a look at our sample images.
70-200mm F4 zoom lenses may not get as much attention as their faster F2.8 siblings, but for many photographers these lenses hit the perfect sweet spot of price, performance, and weight. This week, we shoot the new Tamron 70-210mm F4 alongside the equivalent Canon and Nikon models to see how they stack up.
Blackmagic recently worked with Apple to develop Blackmagic eGPU, an external GPU that brings "desktop-class graphics performance" to the new MacBook Pro laptops with Thunderbolt 3 ports.
Lightroom alternative Luminar has received numerous updates across both its Mac and Windows versions, primarily improvements to existing features, as well as support for additional cameras from Fujifilm, Sony, Olympus, Panasonic, Canon, and Pentax.
Sony has quietly updated its RX100 V, bringing a couple of the goodies from the RX100 VI travel zoom. The updated RX100 VA gains a new processor and various firmware tweaks but misses out on the VI's other hardware improvements.
Apple has updated its MacBook Pro series of notebooks with 15in and 13in models that are claimed to be better for intense image and video editing. The company says the new models are the most advanced ever, and that they feature 8th generation Intel Core processors for faster performance.
Manfrotto has launched its new Noreg camera bag series with the Backpack-30 and Messenger-30 models. Both bags are designed for premium mirrorless camera systems, each featuring internal camera units that can be removed and used independently of the larger bags.
Industrial designer Thomas Müller has created a concept device that attempts to democratize film development using an all-in-one device that sits on your countertop.
The Sony RX100 VI is a spectacularly capable travel camera, combining a flexible zoom range with impressive autofocus. But there's no getting around the fact that it's an expensive camera, and a longer lens comes with certain trade-offs. Read on for our full analysis.
Comments