Reading mode: Light Dark

News Reviews Articles Buying Guides Sample Images Videos Cameras Lenses Phones Printers Photos Forums Galleries Challenges

Best cameras and lenses

Now reading: Imatag protects your images with invisible watermarks 43 comments

Imatag protects your images with invisible watermarks

Published Dec 21, 2017 | Lars Rehm

With advanced technologies such as Google's AI capable of removing watermarks from images, and intelligent upscaling technologies like EnhanceNet, including visible watermarks on your images and uploading them at low resolution are no longer necessarily sufficient safeguards against your valuable images being stolen.

Invisible watermarking could be an efficient answer to these high-tech pirating methods. Imatag is a new service that adds an invisible and indelible watermark to your images, all without any degrading effect on image quality. This allows agencies and photographers to track their work and prove ownership when images are found to be illegally used on the web or in print.

On the Imatag website an online demo allows you to upload your own image, inspect the visual quality of the watermarked image and assess the robustness of the watermark. You can crop, scale and compress the original image to see see at what point the Imatag algorithm loses its ability to detect the watermark.

Another way of testing the system is by registering for a free account which allows you to upload 1GB worth of images. Uploaded images will be watermarked and hosted on the website but not be publicly available unless you make them visible. You can then download a watermarked image, edit it in your preferred image editing software and re-upload the modified image to check if the watermark can still be detected.

During a brief test with a couple of images we found that the modifications required to make the watermark undetectable were so strong that they would severely limit the usability of the resulting image. If you think Imatag could be a useful tool for your photography business but 1GB of storage is not sufficient for your purposes, 10 Euros per months subscription fee buy you 100GB. Special packages for agencies are available as well. More information is available on the Imatag website.

Tags: technology, watermarks

View Comments (43)

Comments

All (43)

Most popular (4)

Editors' picks (0)

DPR staff (0)

Oldest first

Andre-ju

I think that for many photographers, the subscription cost for this service would be more than they are actually losing from image theft.

Dec 26, 2017permalink

sirhawkeye64

And what's not to stop someone of just taking a screenshot of your image, even at full/high resolution? If the watermark is indeed invisible, then a screen capture program probably wont capture (or at least record) the invisible watermark. I can see where this will keep the honest people honest, but that would be my concern is screen capture software/devices.

Dec 24, 2017permalink

tfurax

Of course our invisible watermark is robust to a screen capture. This is what the demo is all about: to showcase our great robustness to commun editing process. Indeed, our watermark is robust to print & scan (even with a smatphone).

Dec 24, 2017permalink

HenryEckstein

This took like THREE MINUTES to figure out!

You boost and/or reduce the luminance on any RGB pixel and on the individual Red, Green and Blue colour channel values that are above 240 and below 20 (when using 24-bit RGB colour or 8-bits per channel) in terms of luminance and use a subtractive and/or additive function to find Primary Magenta, Blue/Cyan and Yellow values within either the darkest or lightest areas of any image which you search.

Then, it took like ANOTHER FIVE MINUTES to design the source code for the C++, Basic, Pascal, JAVA/JavaScript AND Python code to remove that watermark without mangling the original image! Sorry but you need to do WAAAAY better….I did all that in less than an hour and DID NOT NEED A.I. but rather SIMPLE DSP (Digital Signal Processing). I'll open source the code!

AND YES it passed your tests!

Dec 30, 2017*permalink

jwasturias

I remember spilling some tap water on my negatives in 1991. Definitely identifiable as mine.

Dec 23, 2017permalink

Photomatte

Does this new 'invisible' watermark depend on data embedded into the EXIF file, or other such means? What if someone just grabs a screenshot on their PC or does Command-4 on their Mac and only lifts the image itself, not the file? Will this service still work?
I shoot weddings for a living and I use Smugmug for my clients' galleries. I'm sure many of my clients will still download their favorites and post them all over social media. This is why I embed each image (each file, that is) with loads of SEO keywords as well as my copyright info. That way, if my clients do 'share' my images, it actually helps me. So far I haven't had anyone steal my images and use them for profit (ie, as if they were a wedding photographer).

Dec 23, 2017permalink

Fujica

Everybody can do this. In fact it is nothing more then writing a text file into an image file. Those who are in the know can see the message, those who are not aware will never see it. They will never search for it either.

The way it works is actually quite simple, and its easy to find how to do this yourself via a Google query.

Don't waste your money on serverspace you don't need.
The scripting to make this 'watermarking' is available for free.

Dec 22, 2017*permalink

Charlie Jin

I think that the point is whether someone can remove the watermark (easily).

Dec 23, 2017permalink

Gruyo

I don't think they are talking about EXIF data, but actually altering pixel data in a way which is hard to detect for humans but easy to process for their algorithm.

Dec 27, 2017permalink

Fujica

No they are not Gruyo - When you add text to an image it is usually NOT done in EXIF, but into the imagefile itself. It is put in a place you'll normally never will look unless you work for law enforcement or special agency.

Its a smart way of tagging images and having a secret watermark or other text.

Dec 27, 2017*permalink

photojoe55

Nobody steals my images. ...that makes me very sad!

Dec 22, 2017permalink

obsolescence

Are you so sure about that?

Dec 23, 2017permalink

zzzxtreme

Wow this is actually very smart

Dec 22, 2017permalink

Astro Landscapes

The ONLY good watermark, is an invisible watermark.

Dec 22, 2017*permalink

falconeyes

Every time watermarking is a topic, I cannot but repeat myself ...
Static watermarks are a lack of ingenuity, and not very useful actually. Even if executed nicely as seems to be the case here.

A much better way is to embed meta data about the downloader (IP address, timestamp) into the watermark. So that at a later time, the person violating the original copyright can be tracked down. And if communicated, would prevent people from stealing in the first place. That would be a useful example of a cloud service, actually. Static hosting isn’t.

Dec 22, 2017*permalink

Arek Halusko

I can grab any image that has meta data and it'll be stripped out after a conversion to any other format. Its security through obscurity.

If you don't want it used with out permission don't put it on the internet and might as well put on a nice unobtrusive watermark on the image to get some free advertising if someone does use it,

Dec 22, 2017permalink

tfurax

Imatag watermark is static. Actually, you can watermark the same image several times. This creates several versions of your work for different uses, and being able to monitor each version. We will soon propose such a service at the downloading time.

@RED: The metadata are stored in our registry (EXIF, IPTC, XMP). The watermark ID is embedded in the pixels of the image making the link with the registry. Thus, the watermark ID is robust to a conversion to any other format.

Dec 22, 2017*permalink

falconeyes

@tfurax Thanks for your reply
Of course it is possible to have several versions of an image with different watermarks. That wasn’t my point though.
My point was that ANY link like “img src=“ would return a DYNAMICALLY watermarked image, different from any other. A watermark unique within any browser cache. Of course, this requires a certain server muscle. But everything else is just plain uninteresting and destined to fail as a business proposition.

A dynamic server side watermark though could be provided and licensed as a microservice (docker) to image hosting sites such as SmugMug, ShutterStock, HegreArt etc. So photographers can track any copy found in the wild to any particular client who may have purchased the image.

Dec 22, 2017*permalink

falconeyes

@RED: You are not getting it. Photographers have no choice but to eventually provide photos to their clients. They normally do this via protected galleries, only accessible to paying clients. Still, these photos are criminally redistributed afterwards, as soon as more than only a few clients had access. I’ve seen photographer friends going out of business because of this. The problem developed over the last 10 years. E.g., the market for erotic photography is basically dead now (prints don’t sell, digital gets stolen immediately).

Dec 22, 2017*permalink

Arek Halusko

@falconeyes

Sorry but no amount of water marking is going to save your failing business, that's a business model failure.

Dec 22, 2017permalink

falconeyes

@RED people who feel its right other people fail due to criminal action aren’t my friends. End of communication.

Dec 22, 2017permalink

Arek Halusko

@falconeyes

There is no right for a business not to fail, if you are saying you lost your photo business because people stole all of your work that you posted on line you have a bigger problem then the copy right infringes. If you are saying this watermarking technology was going to stop all this and save your business again you have way bigger issues as to why the business failed.

How do you explain all those other successful photographers in the world? What sort of voodoo water marking do they use to keep their business from failing?

Dec 22, 2017*permalink

sirhawkeye64

I have to agree with RED on some of the comments made... particularly about the circumventing the watermarking. The same goes for software and most other digital materials. In some regards, the more effort you put into trying to protect it from theft, the more people tend to steal it. Look at Microsoft and Windows. Now, you technically can use a version of Windows 10 (or even 7 or 8) for free without ever buying a license. You'll have an ugly watermark in the side of the desktop screen but otherwise, the OS runs normally (although some features are disabled--like you can't change the background). This is far from the Windows XP anti-piracy measures, where XP would refuse to let you log in if you didn't purchase and activate a license. My point is that someone will find a way around it, but it will keep the honest people honest, but there are people out there that will find some flaw or way to copy the material and get away with it. It's just reality of digital material.

Dec 24, 2017*permalink

tfurax

@sirhawkeye64: Please have a try! Create your free account. Upload a picture. Download its watermarked version. Distort it with your preferred image editing software. Check if the watermark is still detected. It is certainly possible to remove the watermark, BUT the image is then so damaged that it is useless. Again, please have a try.

Dec 26, 2017permalink

falconeyes

@tfurax,
I really think you are on to something, great technology.
Pls, give my point a consideration too, could change something great into a game changer.

Dec 26, 2017permalink

Muskokaphotog

The meta data might help on line but it isn't going to tell me rhat a client printed out their family portraits without permission. A visible watermark also tells the less savvy that the image ain't for free.

Dec 26, 2017permalink

desertsp

I remember seeing something like this 10 or 15 years ago in the form of a Photoshop plugin (I think). Wish I could remember the name!

The nice thing is it embedded your actual information, not just a lookup key.

Dec 21, 2017permalink

lightandaprayer

Digimarc is the name. The company is still in business but I haven't kept up on it.

Dec 21, 2017permalink

Arek Halusko

If you already own the image and have the originals does it really matter if someone steals it? Unless this service is constantly scouring the net for infringement not having a nice brandable watermark on say the bottom right corner you're just losing out on free advertising. Besides its much less work to take an image that has no visible branding then to take one, crop out the watermark/braiding and then use it.

Dec 21, 2017permalink

Astro Landscapes

You're joking, right?

Dec 22, 2017permalink

Arek Halusko

You think an invisible watermark gives you more protection than you actually owning the copyright and original files?

Someone sees your image with an invisible watermark and takes it for their own use.

Someone sees your image with a visible watermark and decided to move on as they won't want to be bothered with trying to crop out/remove the watermark.

Dec 22, 2017permalink

MyReality

If you own the image and someone steals it, you either care or do not care. If you do not care, end of story. If you care, do you care enough to pursue copyright infringement? If you do, do you want to spend the thousands of dollars it may cost? Not many photographers will.
An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.
Hence, I am in favor of big visible mater marks.

Dec 22, 2017*permalink

Astro Landscapes

I was mainly referring to the "it's free advertising when someone steals your photo" line.

Dec 22, 2017*permalink

MyReality

@matthew saville - It's only free advertising if the credit goes to you. People stealing photos are not going to give the photographer credit.
People wearing T-shirts with logos on them are giving free advertising, but most people will know who the credit goes to.

Dec 22, 2017permalink

tfurax

Visible and invisible watermarks address different goals and are indeed complementary. Visible watermarking warns the user about copyright, advertises your works... but it is easily removed. Invisible watermarking protects your images and enables efficient content tracking.

Dec 22, 2017permalink

badi

That's exactly what i was going to say ... just use both watermarking systems :) Actually in my opinion the invisible watermark makes real sense together with the visible one.

But the "Invisible watermarking protects your images" is kind of not really true. It does indeed helps you to prove that the image was yours to a jury/judge, enable content tracking and so on.
But if a thief doesn't see the "invisible watermark" he is just going to steal it, and the "tracking" will help that he is caught easier and faster.

Dec 22, 2017permalink

ManfredGrebler

For finding illegal uses an Invisible watermark is no longer neccessary today. There are services searching the net for your images just by image compare.
This has one very big adavantage: It works for all your images that are already on the internet not just for the latest ones.

Dec 22, 2017permalink

tfurax

@ManfredGrebler: Not so true. See, for instance, the story of Eduardo Martin ( http://imatag.com/en/blog/2017/09/07/photo-theft-how-to-frame-the-usurper/ ) who easily deluded similarity search engines. Similarity search is meant for ranking images according to their similarity with a query. But it cannot assess that an image is indeed a copy of that work. When you crawl the web, it just triggers far too many false positives.

Dec 22, 2017permalink

lathspell

I've uploaded an aRGB image to the demo site, and after generating the watermark the image looked like if the color profile had been removed and the JPEG therefore interpreted as sRGB. Fail.

Dec 21, 2017*permalink

tfurax

Oups! This is indeed true for this simple demo (we will fix it). The service Imatag.com should take into account color profiles.

Dec 22, 2017*permalink

lathspell

Ok, I can't tell about the actual service since I didn't go further than to the demo site. Because when a demo doesn't work … (You've got a private message with more details.)

Dec 22, 2017permalink

semorg

can you at least not verbatim copy the PR language?
It's very unclear how the fees work. Do you need to host your images there? I'm not sure what their model is.
Do you need the their service later to identify your watermark?

Dec 21, 2017permalink

tfurax

Images, watermark secret key AND metadata are hosted on our side.
You need the service to identify watermark.

Dec 22, 2017permalink

Latest sample galleries

Nikon Z30 Sample Gallery

Canon RF 135mm F1.8 L IS pre-production sample gallery

Fujifilm XF 30mm F2.8 R LM WR Macro sample gallery

Fujifilm X-T5 pre-production sample gallery (DPReview TV)

See more galleries »

Latest in-depth reviews

Every year, DJI releases a new consumer-grade smartphone gimbal. The Osmo Mobile 6 is the latest model in the series. Is it good enough to enhance your videos and photos?

The Fujifilm X-T5 is the company's latest classically-styled APS-C mirrorless camera. It gains the 40MP sensor and AF system from the X-H2 but in a body with a more stills-focused slant.

DJI Mavic 3 Classic review: A more affordable entry into the Mavic world

Almost one year ago, DJI debuted its Mavic 3 standard and Cine drones featuring a dual-camera setup. Today they've released their Classic, a less expensive single-camera sibling. Who's it for and is it a worthy addition to the Mavic family?

The EOS R6 II is Canon's latest enthusiast-oriented full-frame camera. It may look a lot like the original R6 on the outside, but it includes refinements and features that make it a more capable and better-performing camera.

DPReview TV: Canon EOS R6 Mark II initial review

The Canon 6D Mark II is a substantial improvement over its predecessor, and we spent a couple days in sunny San Diego to test it out!

Latest buying guides

The best cameras for family and friends photos in 2022

Family moments are precious and sometimes you want to capture that time spent with loved ones or friends in better quality than your phone can manage. We've selected a group of cameras that are easy to keep with you, and that can adapt to take photos wherever and whenever something memorable happens.

Best affordable cameras for sports and action in 2022

What's the best camera for shooting sports and action? Fast continuous shooting, reliable autofocus and great battery life are just three of the most important factors. In this buying guide we've rounded-up several great cameras for shooting sports and action, and recommended the best.

Buying Guide: Best camera for a family vacation

Family vacations can produce the kinds of memories you want to keep forever, and having some great photos can help with that. But you need a camera that's convenient to keep with you.

What's the best camera for travel? Good travel cameras should be small, versatile, and offer good image quality. In this buying guide we've rounded-up several great cameras for travel and recommended the best.

Best cameras for landscape photography in 2022

What's the best camera for shooting landscapes? High resolution, weather-sealed bodies and wide dynamic range are all important. In this buying guide we've rounded-up several great cameras for shooting landscapes, and recommended the best.

Check out more buying guides »

Latest articles

DPReview TV: The best camera for wildlife photography (at 3 budgets)

There are few types of photography are more demanding than wildlife, and we've picked the best cameras at three price ranges for you!

Nov 26, 2022257 video

2022 Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals on cameras, lenses and more

The holiday season is here and we've rounded up a collection of the best deals for photographers and videographers. This will be a living article that gets updated often, so be sure to check back to keep up with the latest offers!

Nov 23, 2022115

DJI unveils the O3 Air Unit, a transmission system for a variety of third-party drones

DJI has introduced the O3 Air Unit, featuring the drone manufacturer's proprietary wireless transmission technology, it's compatible with a variety of third-party FPV rigs.

Nov 23, 202235

One Thing: The wrist strap is the killer app

In photography, half the fun is finding out what works for you. For DPReview's Chris Niccolls, the neck strap had to go and the wrist strap was here to stay.

Nov 23, 2022253

DPReview TV: The best deals on used cameras

There have been some exciting camera releases lately, but don't forget about used gear! Chris and Jordan walk you through some of their top picks.

Nov 23, 202275 video

Best cameras around $1500 in 2022

What’s the best camera for around $1500? These midrange cameras should have capable autofocus systems, lots of direct controls and the latest sensors offering great image quality. We recommend what we think are the best options.

Nov 23, 2022

Here's what we would buy this holiday if cost were no object

If you've got the funds, then why not buy something ridiculous this holiday season? DPReview writers and editors came up some ideas in case you've got some money to burn.

Nov 23, 202234

Every photo accessory you need for your new camera

We've rounded up all the important accessories you might want to pick up to go alongside your fancy new camera. From memory cards to cleaning tools, we've gathered a few pieces of gear you'll probably need for your photo adventures.

Nov 22, 202296

Best cameras around $1000 in 2022

Around $1000 is increasingly becoming the entry point for modern interchangeable lens cameras. We look at what you can get for your money, and which we think is best.

Nov 22, 2022

One Thing: A fear of flash flirted with failure

The world of photography and video is filled with tools and gadgets that promise to take your visuals to the next level. DPReview's Shaminder Dulai reflects on a time he listened to the tools and advanced his photojournalism.

Nov 22, 202248

A rare print of the only image of Neil Armstrong on the moon is expected to sell for $30,000 at auction

There's only one known photo of Neil Armstrong on the moon during Apollo 11's EVA. Prints of the image are almost as rare. The auction house Bonhams will have one available as part of its upcoming Space Photography Auction, and the auctioneers expect the print to sell for up to $30,000.

Nov 21, 202277

Video: watch this FPV drone fly over and through the Florida Gators football team as they take the field

FPV pilot Jay Christensen returns with a fly over and through the Florida Gators college football team as they take the field ahead of a game in Gainesville, Florida.

Nov 21, 202233 video

Review: DJI Osmo Mobile 6

Every year, DJI releases a new consumer-grade smartphone gimbal. The Osmo Mobile 6 is the latest model in the series. Is it good enough to enhance your videos and photos?

Nov 21, 202232 accessory review

One Thing: How a little camera made my day less stressful

Investing in a standalone webcam can be a game changer that boosts confidence and improves your connection with others when you can’t be face to face.

Nov 20, 2022110

DPReview TV: The good and bad of Fujifilm cameras

It's time to take a look at what Fujifilm is doing right and wrong with their cameras in 2022. Chris and Jordan have plenty of opinions!

Nov 19, 2022213 video

NASA's InSight lander sends what will likely be its last photos from Mars

NASA's Insight Mars lander has been operational for nearly four years on Mars, far exceeding the original one-year mission duration. However, earlier this year, NASA announced that the mission would be ending due to significant dust buildup on InSight's solar panels.

Nov 18, 202265

Nextorage announces 'world's fastest' CFexpress Type B cards with 1950MB/s read speeds

Nextorage's B1 Pro series cards can achieve read and write speeds up to 1950MB/s and 1900MB/s, respectively, and are available in capacities ranging from 165GB to 1330GB in the Japanese market.

Nov 18, 202262

Film Friday: Brendan Barry turns a canal boat into a giant floating camera

Brendan Barry is known for his crazy DIY camera contraptions, but this floating camera obscura might just take the cake for the most interesting.

Nov 18, 202223

Fujifilm Japan is temporarily ceasing X100V orders due to having too many to process

Fujifilm’s X100V APS-C compact camera was released nearly three years ago, but the company is still having to temporarily cease new orders due to having too large of a backlog to process, according to a new report.

Nov 17, 2022254

CosmoCap is a new camera cap with a built-in slot for an AirTag or other tracker

A new Kickstarter campaign promises photographers peace of mind through a new camera body cap with a built-in slot for an Apple AirTag or other similar tracking device.

Nov 17, 202297

PSA: Sony’s latest firmware updates for FX3, FX30 pulled for causing boot loop issues

Sony's latest firmware updates for its FX3 and FX30 Cinema Line cameras are causing boot loop issues for some users, rendering their cameras useless for the time being.

Nov 17, 202254

Canon EOS C70 firmware brings 120p AF tracking, XF-AVC 4K/60 and more

Hot on the heels of new firmware for the EOS C500 Mark II and EOS C300 Mark III, Canon has announced a firmware update for its EOS C70 4K cinema camera, giving it better autofocus, new video modes, additional remote control compatibility and more via the free update next month.

Nov 16, 202210

These are the cameras aboard NASA's Orion spacecraft headed to the moon aboard the Artemis I rocket

Today, NASA's Artemis I rocket successfully launched, sending the Orion spacecraft toward the Moon. As part of the mission, there are 24 cameras, including 8 on Artemis I and the remaining 16 on Orion itself.

Nov 16, 2022101

17 years after releasing its last camera, Konica Minolta kills off its customer service repair center

It's been nearly two decades since a camera with the Konica Minolta branding was released, but its customer service and repair center has still been up and running. Or, it was, until yesterday, when it was announced it would be shutting down.

Nov 16, 2022122

One Thing: Want more cinematic lighting? Try taking light away

Lighting may seem resource-intensive on the surface, but as DPReview's Jordan Drake discovered after watching a pro, great effects can be achieved without a lot of expensive equipment. Using a simple tool to remove and modify the light can make for a compelling image.

Nov 16, 202254

Qualcomm's Snapdragon 8 Gen 2 mobile platform has new Cognitive ISP, 18-bit processing and more

At its ongoing summit, Qualcomm has announced its new Snapdragon 8 Gen 2 Mobile Platform. The new platform is the company's fastest yet, and promises improved AI, better performance and more capable photo and video processing capabilities.

Nov 15, 202280

Nikon's Q2 financials show better-than-expected revenue, profit for imaging division

Nikon's Imaging Products Business (its business division for all cameras and lenses) has higher-than-expected revenue and operating profit throughout the first half of the company's 2023 fiscal year.

Nov 15, 2022317

Elgato unveils Stream Deck Plus: Customizable buttons, dials and display at your fingertips

Elgato's new Stream Deck Plus includes eight customizable buttons, a touchscreen and four control dials, providing users with direct access and control over customizable, app-specific shortcuts and tools.

Nov 15, 202254

Leica partners with watch experts Hodinkee for limited-edition Q2 ‘Ghost’ model

The special edition Leica Q2 Ghost is available in two variants and is inspired by the iconic Rolex ‘Ghost Bezel’ submariner watch.

Nov 15, 2022151

Fujifilm Instax Buying Guide: What You Need to Know About Cameras and Printers in 2022

Confused by the array of Fujifilm Instax cameras currently available for sale? Torn between a camera and a smartphone-friendly printer? We've got everything you need to know about the latest and greatest Instax Wide, Square and Mini gear in one place.

Nov 15, 202237

Tips or suggestions? Contact us!

www.dpreview.com

Mobile site

About

Editorial content

Cameras & Lenses

Community

All content, design, and layout are Copyright © 1998–2022 Digital Photography Review All Rights Reserved.
Reproduction in whole or part in any form or medium without specific written permission is prohibited.


Sentons CameraBar uses ultrasonic tech to add virtual buttons to smartphones Dec 7, 2020	Xiaomi announces retractable lens technology for future smartphones Nov 5, 2020	Samsung details new 65/14nm stacked sensor design for improving power efficiency, density of mobile image sensors Oct 7, 2020	Coming into focus: how Panasonic's DFD gamble may yet pay off Sep 7, 2020


Face on Plane Tree Bark by chrisby from Things in Nature that Look like Faces – Unlimited!	Lighthouse by Miguel Mealha from In the Style of Pinhole Photography	polar bear had a nice swim by summicron from King in the North	Dune Bashing by Nilesh Trivedi from 4x4 Offroad	Golden Hour Heron by poppyjk from Wild: Dusk to Dawn; "Golden light"	Back in the Summer of 83 by Surfwalker from I'm having Fun!!!	Downtown Girl by mcece from People Photography 2022

Imatag protects your images with invisible watermarks

Comments

You may also like

Latest sample galleries

Latest in-depth reviews

Latest buying guides