Ever wonder whether a more expensive camera is truly worth the cost? Sam and Niko of Corridor recently set out to compare footage from a $50 Sony HD camcorder and the RED Epic Dragon, a $50,000 6K cinema camera. As you'd expect, the differences are immediately apparent, cost aside, when the two cameras are put side-by-side: the RED camera's lens alone is about the same size as the entire Sony camcorder.
The RED Epic Dragon has proven capable many times throughout its life, with perhaps one of the model's most notable achievements being a trip into space where it was used by NASA astronauts to capture images from the International Space Station. The RED camera has also been used for several major Hollywood movies. The Sony HD camcorder used in the video, however, is a simple model with a low price point aimed at the average consumer.
At nearly 15 minutes in length, the comparison video above runs through several major aspects of both cameras' footage, looking at things like noise level, exposure, low-light performance, post-processing results and more. As expected, the RED camera dominates in each category. More of the team's videos can be found on the 'Sam and Niko' YouTube channel.
The Sony CX405 is already 2 1/2 years old. And it only shoots in 1080P. Compare an older Red to a new 4K Sony camcorder and the Sony will wipe the floor with the Red. This video is a farce, made by a liar.
Wow. A lot of people on here pretty mad about this interesting video. Anyone able to see how this might be useful / entertaining / enlightening for those other than yourself? It's clearly not aimed at professionals / experienced enthusiasts.
If you bother to look at what that channel is about, you'd see that its an entertainment channel not one based on in-depth professional-level technical analysis
I understand plenty about the principles behind all this but still found it interesting, and it would certainly answer a lot of layman questions about justification of expensive rigs vs basic consumer-grade kit.
I personally like content like this. Others may not, but criticising DPR for sharing seems bizarre.
people like to be whiny complainers, the guy says in the video why he is comparing the two, and everyone that complained seems to have not watched the video at all.
that being said, i though the dumb wasabi food eating was odd to put in the video.
great stuff: if this is their standard in video production then they proved the point beautifully. They can work with a palm /camcorder because it wouldn't make any difference given the "cut" of the lighting, post, sound. A camcorder will do just fine, or a cellphone for that matter
I actually have a Sony HDR-CX405,that I bought a couple years ago. It's sensor is about the size of a phone sensor, but with an optical 60X zoom. It's fine for what it is..... the thing is, it's not meant to be a challenger to RED cameras - they're comparing apples to airliners......
For what it is - a ~$100 (NOT $50.... must have bought used....) cheap and easy camcorder to record (in my case) 90 minute music lessons for review, as well as (for example) university lectures, parties and family gatherings, and fun moments in family vacation - it's pretty excellent - cheap, fast, trivially easy to use, a 64GB memory chip lasts for days of recording, and no 29 minute restriction.
To film "The Hobbit"? Yes indeed, you'd want something else. Like the $50K RED camera. Is that even a question, though?
Niko, thanks for the nice comparison and great explanation of the different aspects of video footage. But you forgot a few things there: Boot time (RED loses) Size & weight (RED loses) Try entering into major theme parks (won't let your RED in there) Recording time (RED loses, even with massive XL batteries) Computer horsepower required to churn through the files (RED loses)
All kidding aside, as others have pointed out already, would be nice to see a better comparison, like with: GH5 with Log option, Sony A7S mk2, Panasonic UX180, Sony FS7, Sony FS5, Sony A6500, Canon C200, Canon 1D-X mk2, iPhone 7 Plus, Pixel XL, Galaxy S8, RED Hydrogen :-)
Hell, even a Canon G40 camcorder would have been a great way to compare "cheap"-ish consumer VS "expensive" Pro.
I would even throw in the DJI X5S 5.2K camera that can be attached to the Inspire 2 drone. It's about 6000 USD with all codecs and stuff, yet still a lot cheaper than the RED Epic Dragon. And it can fly...
Like most people here I ask how that kind of comparison useful? Are there many out there that really thinking to buy one or the other?
Personnally I wonder, how different would it have been with just a GH5 for example a camera actually used by hollywood ?
And then 2 things in between, like a camera in the 500$ range and another one in the 5000-10000$ range... This way we would have had more interresting comparison...
Nothing unexpected and nothing we don't already know. The performance gap is massive, the image quality gap is massive. I'd be surprised if it were otherwise actually.
You'll be surprised how off that statement is reading this very comments board.
Comments vary, but show people simply didn't "get it", all the way to "I don't see any massive difference".
And even for those who "got it" and "saw the massive difference", it's a great video to illustrate exactly / precisely where, how and why there's a 49.950 price difference.
Those that claim that there isn't $49,950 worth of difference between the the camcorder and the RED, I have five words for you - The Law of Deminishing Returns
Reading the comments here it just shows how the average DPR poster knows little about video.
Some people said "hey, they kinda look similar. At least not $49.950 different". Yes, for the intended purposes, it is a 49.950 difference.
Blow up both images to movie theater screen size, both of them being heavily color graded, pushed, pulled and whatever else you can ask those files, then it becomes insanely obvious why the RED shoots Hollywood movies and the camcorder don't.
Here on YT, differences are already huge enough, but blown up to gigantic screen sizes, those differences just yells at you until your ear explodes.
7K likes on youtube and a downpour of sheer ingratitude, misunderstanding and questionable thinking by a lot of DPR commenters. Yes, the DPR has a more topic-focused audience but the comments show a disturbing amount of pointless negativity. Not terribly surprised given other feedback on DPR articles but give it a rest people. It's free content. The video does what it said it does and provides useful info about how video is handled. You want something else? Go do it or go look elsewhere. I'll take DPR and their content contributors' backs here and take the heat - practice gratitude and think a bit about the people that create and bring content before posting.
So much hate on these guys. I think Corridor did a close to perfect explaination on the importance of codec, dynamic range, etc, with examples using the red and the camcorder. The idea is to teach these aspects. Obviously everyone knows that the red will beat the sony. Duh.
Absolutely. Excellent and fascinating for newcomers, hobbyists, and others like me who are wholly unaware of video technology but regularly shoot stills professionally. I have friends who are professional videographers. They work mainly for nonprofits, using relatively inexpensive Sony and Panasonic cameras, homemade tracking sleds, etc. They shoot almost entirely for the Web, and for smaller projection screens. I'm sure they're aware of what the RED cameras can do, and that this video would just be fairly boring for them. But maybe not. Those who dissed the video are prancers.
In D&D terms, a great red wyrm will wipe the floor with one 1th-level character of any class. A comparison with a high-end P&S camera (5th-level), the same for a bridge/EVIL/whatever (10th-level), etc. would have been much finer.
As for the other, while the dynamic range /resolution of a potato may pale in comparison with high-end and especially professional gear, why to comply if the potato is more than enough for casual purposes and especially can be effortlessly carried elsewhere without the fears of damaging or having stolen a thing as said camera?
They were filming the vid on a Canon 1DX (don't know if it was mkI or II). I'd have like to see the intermediate comparison with this camera since they already had it on hand.
Well, kind of fun, but kind of silly. On the $50 camcorder, every detail was designed to meet a price, and no one expects it to be much good. More interesting would be a comparison with a one or two thousand dollar modern dslr or mirrorless, where the engineers were trying to squeeze in as much quality as possible, and the buyers DO expect pretty decent quality. Just a guess: the Red would be better, of course, but you'd have to work a lot harder the demonstrate the differences.
Yes a Red vs Panasonic would be a more interesting fight. This is like someone comparing a Ferrari to a Fiat Punto, of course the Ferrari will win on everything except fuel consumption. Now Ferrari vs M5 would be a bit more interesting.
And just add to the SONY A7/A9 MILC an equivalent priced camescope like PANASONIC HC-XC1 or HC-XC1000, or a Blackmagic URSA mini 4K to make a real bench.
Just to showcase to all camps what are the features you can get onto moviecam vs photograph MILC. And a good comparison should include the workflow too, just in order to get a decent final cut movie.
Well, the video it doesn say that the videos of the sony camera are smaller and don't need to be processed to compress them later on. They are more practical to the 99% of people who wants to film something. And depending on the format of the video, you can put them directly in a dvd/bluray and play them in a dvd/bluray reader.
Interesting video. This provides some idea about how video quality scales between the lowest and highest quality. Something in between like a 2K camera would have been nice as a comparison.
Where would we be without such in-depth studies and experiments? ;) OK, I'm just having a touch of fun. Obviously a 50K camera is going to be better, this shouldn't have to be tested to be proven, but I do applaud the efforts that went into it.
Next up: a $100,000 Ferrari vs. a $5000 Whatever. On your mark, set, go!
There's similar difference between a Toyota and a BMW. Those men can shoot video of a building, some bridge, one K9, two kittens, plants with a $50 camcorder, and no pretty model will pose for them.
I think it would be much more interesting to test 3 levels of quality videocams. Low level consumer, top level consumer and accepted professional level. How much difference between top level consumer and professional level ?
And what about a Alpha 7s II with a good Zeiss lens against the Red? Or wait for the A7s III with the 4k and 60 frames plus raw video. Lets say 5000 against the 50000 bugs. Then the ice might become a little thinner for the professional tool, maybe? A cinema production might not be that expensive in future anymore.
The Canon fanboys would claim, that nobody needs 4k or an uncropped full sensor readout or a contemporary codec or even video on DSLRs any more, since their brand is blackmailing them towards the cinema line. That at least have been the arguments with the releases of the 5 Douche Mk IV and 6 Douche Mk II. But for an ambitioned videographer, a new or even the actual 7s with a reasonable log curve might be quite an option. I cannot imagine, that the difference might be that big, to justify the investment into a RED.
DVD vs Blu-ray all over again! "You can't see the difference if sitting 50 feet away from the neighbors yard, so buying a Red Ultrazord Dragon is pointless! Stick to recording with Vaseline coated potato."
@mick232 Amazing, a still camera device does better job taking still photographies than a moving camera ? Who can be surprised as shutter does not work the same way ?
Do you have the video that compare the movie quality for both set ?
The Nikon Z30 is the company's latest 'creator' focused mirrorless camera, a 21MP APS-C model made to be more vlogging friendly than ever. Find out what it offers and what we think so far.
Nikon has announced the Z30, an entry-level Z-mount camera aimed at vloggers and other content creators. What are our initial impressions? Better watch to find out.
Sony has just released a trio of impressively small, light, ultrawide lenses for APS-C. These lenses are designed for vloggers, so Chris decided to film himself and find out how they perform.
What’s the best camera for around $2000? These capable cameras should be solid and well-built, have both speed and focus for capturing fast action and offer professional-level image quality. In this buying guide we’ve rounded up all the current interchangeable lens cameras costing around $2000 and recommended the best.
What's the best camera for shooting landscapes? High resolution, weather-sealed bodies and wide dynamic range are all important. In this buying guide we've rounded-up several great cameras for shooting landscapes, and recommended the best.
Most modern cameras will shoot video to one degree or another, but these are the ones we’d look at if you plan to shoot some video alongside your photos. We’ve chosen cameras that can take great photos and make it easy to get great looking video, rather than being the ones you’d choose as a committed videographer.
Although a lot of people only upload images to Instagram from their smartphones, the app is much more than just a mobile photography platform. In this guide we've chosen a selection of cameras that make it easy to shoot compelling lifestyle images, ideal for sharing on social media.
Watch Richard race the clock as he explains topics such as what Log is, why manufacturers have several log curves and what the HEIC a HEIF is all in under sixty seconds in our social series Under A Minute.
The Urban Wildlife Photo Awards has announced the winners and finalists for their competition. We've rounded up the winners and some of the best finalists into a gallery.
Panasonic has released firmware version 2.0 for the GH6 camera, and it's all about ProRes and ProRes Raw. Does this make it the ultimate video machine? Will Jordan's torrid love affair with the GH6 continue? Tune in to find out.
Photographer Stewart Marsden, the official photographer for the London New Year fireworks display and a National Geographic contributor, has written a lengthy tutorial that shows how to capture the best fireworks photographs possible.
Ahead of a full announcement next week, details have emerged about Xiaomi's upcoming flagship smartphone, the 12S Ultra. The phone, co-developed with Leica, will include the Sony IMX989 sensor, a new 1"-type sensor that Xiaomi reportedly developed alongside Sony.
Kosmo Foto founder, Stephen Dowling, has written a comprehensive tribute to the Olympus OM-1, a camera that set a new path for SLRs with its compact form factor and extensive lineup of lenses.
The Nettle Magic Project uses a hidden Raspberry Pi device with an IR camera to scan and decode a deck of cards marked with invisible UV reactive ink. The scan produces a full breakdown of the deck and delivers it to the performer in nearly real-time.
We go hands-on with Nikon's new compact super-telephoto lens, the Nikkor Z 400mm F4.5 VR S, to see what all Nikon has managed to pack into this lens, even without the help of PF elements.
Profoto's new A2 monolight is extremely compact and lightweight. It's about the size of a soda can and weighs around 770g with its battery and optional stand adapter attached. The 100Ws light is designed to be portable and easy to use.
DigiKam is a free, open-source raw photo management and editor for macOS, Windows and Linux. The team has recently released the latest version, bringing the app to version 7.7.0. The update adds many bug fixes, new features and file support.
The Nikon Z30 is the company's latest 'creator' focused mirrorless camera, a 21MP APS-C model made to be more vlogging friendly than ever. Find out what it offers and what we think so far.
Nikon has announced the Z30, an entry-level Z-mount camera aimed at vloggers and other content creators. What are our initial impressions? Better watch to find out.
Nikon has announced the Z30, a 21MP APS-C mirrorless camera aimed at vloggers and content creators. It has a lot in common with the existing Z50 and Z fc with a few tweaks and a lower price tag.
The Nikkor Z 400mm F4.5 VR S is incredibly compact, measuring just 104mm (4.1”) in diameter by 235mm (9.3") long and weighing 1245g (2lb 12oz) with the tripod collar. It's set for a July 2022 launch.
NASA and the University of Minnesota are working on a citizen scientist initiative alongside the Juno Mission and need your help. Volunteers are tasked with identifying atmospheric vortices on Jupiter, as captured by the Juno spacecraft.
The PROII CPL-VND 2-in-1 Filter offers a variable neutral density filter with between 3-7 stops of compensation as well as a circular polarizer filter. Independent control means you can dial in the exact type of compensation you want in a single filter.
Joining its diverse lineup of ONE R and RS action cameras, Insta360 has announced the 1-inch 360 Edition camera, co-engineered with Leica. The camera sports dual 1"-type image sensors and records 21MP still photos and 6K/30p video with a full 360-degree field of view.
Capture One Mobile bring Raw photo editing to iPadOS devices. While it's a familiar look and feel, it's clear Capture One has focused on providing a touch-first interface, designed for quick and easy culling and editing on-the-go.
Godox has announced the R200 ring flash for its AD200 and AD200Pro pocket flashes. The new add-on is a lightweight ring flash that works with numerous new light modifiers, promising portable and controllable ring light.
Even sophisticated microphones can't eliminate ambient noise and the effect of acoustics. But researchers at Carnegie Mellon University have developed a camera system that can see sound vibrations and reconstruct the music of a single instrument in an orchestra.
Do you want to shape and create content for the largest audience of photography and video enthusiasts in the world? DPReview is hiring a Reviews Editor to join our Seattle-based team.
In our continuing series about each camera manufacturer's strengths and weakness, we turn our judgemental gaze to Leica. Cherished and derided in equal measure, what does Leica get right, and where can it improve?
A dental office, based in Germany, had a team of pilots create a mesmerizing FPV drone video to give prospective clients a behind-the-scenes look at the inner workings of their office.
Samsung has announced the ISOCELL HP3, a 200MP sensor with smaller pixels than Samsung's original HP1 sensor, resulting in an approximately 20 percent reduction in the size of the smartphone camera module.
Street photography enthusiast Rajat Srivastava was looking for a 75mm prime lens for his Leica M3. He found a rare SOM Berthiot cinema lens that had been converted from C mount to M mount, and after a day out shooting, Srivastava was hooked.
Comments