UPDATED: Sony a7R III is still a star eater
We sent some files to our friend Jim Kasson for analysis, and he confirms that the Sony a7R III is definitely still a Star Eater, despite several claims to the contrary that have been published online over the past week. That said, while his analyses don't suggest so, our images shot in the field suggest at least some improvement (more on this in the 'real world' section below).
Looking at Kasson's graphs, one can clearly see the noise reduction kick in at 4s and above in Kasson's Fourier transform energy plots. Indeed, in our own shots of the stars with the a7R III and latest a7R II bodies, while the a7R III looks slightly better, all bodies only show stars that are larger than one pixel with a few neighboring pixels. This suggests that smaller (single pixel) stars are indeed 'eaten' or dimmed due to a spatial filtering algorithm.
|At a 3.2-second exposure, the 'spacial filtering' (Star Eater) is mild to non-existent: noise (in dB) is similar at all frequencies, so your stars shouldn't be affected. Credit: Jim Kasson|
But as soon as you hit 4-seconds, spacial filtering kicks in, which you see here as a drop in noise (in dB) at the highest frequencies (the right side of the graph, where 0.5 f / fs is the Nyquist limit). That means the smallest details have noise reduction applied to them, causing similar Star Eater problems that were seen in the a7R II. Credit: Jim Kasson
We did our own night sky shootout of an a7R III vs. an a7R II v3.30 vs. an a7R II v3.00. Below, you can compare the a7R III vs. an a7R II with v3.00 firmware (which Jim confirmed to have similar noise reduction in his analyses):
Many parts of the image, especially where stars are densely concentrated, show little to no difference between the Mark III and Mark II (v3.00). But if you look at, the Mark III does show an improvement: there are stars that aren't there in the Mark II shot, and there's generally more 'pop' to the stars. This is encouraging, but it's also difficult to rule out how the spatial filtering algorithm interacts with shots that might be ever-so-slightly focused differently.
Should you care?
While it's possible Sony may have tweaked the spatial filtering algorithm, the difference is often subtle, and we're still not seeing any pixel-sized stars in any of our shots (indeed, Jim Kasson visually shows us that single pixel-size detail is removed at 4s and above). But on the other hand, we still got some very nice starry skies out shooting in Sedona. Have a look at the full a7R III shot below and compare it to a similar one from the a7R II v3.00.
While we have yet to do a direct comparison of a star field vs. a camera that doesn't employ such an algorithm, we can say this with confidence: while a lot of stars still survive 'Star Eater', the a7R III continues the trend of noise reduction that dims or erases small stars at exposure longer than 3.2s. There's some sense in this: Sony is ostensibly using this algorithm to avoid hot pixels that might otherwise riddle long exposures. But some nightscape and astro- photographers wish to be given a choice as to whether or not this form of noise reduction is applied. Alternatively, the noise reduction could (reversibly) be applied in post.
And so, this seems a missed opportunity for Sony, which could have offered a choice to its users. Instead, the forced noise reduction may give pause to dedicated astrophotographers who can opt for cameras without this issue (see a similar energy plot for the Nikon D850 at 30s). Other photographers happy with the number of stars still in their shots likely won't care.
We'll be investigating further to see if the improvements we noted in portions of the Mark III image over the v3.00 Mark II one are real, so stay tuned.
|Bowing Ballerina by Kukla|
from Best Photo of the Week...
|Midnight Storks by wam7|
|Ice Pond by wam7|
from moving snow in winter
The OPPO Reno 10x hybrid zoom smartphone uses similar technology as the Huawei P30 Pro to achieve a longer than usual tele reach.
The 15 second video teases upcoming support for eye-detection autofocus with Nikon's Z6 and Z7 cameras.
The Olympus E-M1X offers a faster burst speed than the D5, but Nikon's legendary autofocus system and optical finder outshine this Micro Four Thirds beast.
The lens is available for Canon EF and Nikon F mount cameras and is currently available to pre-order for $799.
A new smartphone app removes the need for doctor visits and lab referrals to get your urine tested.
Zeiss has announced the impending release of the 100mm F1.4, the fourth lens in its Otus lineup.
In a series of 16 slightly quirky questions Adobe determines your creative personality.
If the report holds up, no longer will you have to first import photos into the iOS Camera Roll before importing them into apps like Adobe Lightroom CC and Affinity Photo.
ON1 has announced that the next major version of ON1 Photo RAW 2019.5, will be released in mid-May 2019.
Whether you've bought an inexpensive Fujifilm X-A5 with a kit lens, or a higher-end body like the X-T3, at some point you're going to want some new glass. We've picked out the best X-mount lenses for various shooting situations to aid you in your search.
Nikon's latest point-and-shoot might look like a toy, but it's not lacking in features.
Firmware version 1.10 for the GR III is said to improve low-light autofocus performance and adds a new Wi-Fi option for transferring images via Image Sync.
A leaked data sheet has detailed the specifications of a 63MP full-frame CMOS sensor with Dual Pixel AF.
We've been working through our full review of Panasonic's high-megapixel full-frame flagship, the Lumix S1R, and its lower-resolution S1 sibling, and have published our studio scene images from them – including the R's 187MP high-res mode. It's, well, very high-res.
The update adds Wi-Fi SnapBridge connectivity and addresses a number of bugs.
Panasonic's S Pro 70-200mm F4 is one of three lenses to launch with the full-frame S system, covering a popular focal range with a claimed 6 stops of stabilization to boot.
CareerCast has released its 2018 Jobs Rated Report and among the list was ‘photographer.’
A teardown video shows how Huawei has managed an impressive amount of technology including a 5x tele lens into the body of its flagship smartphone.
Cooperative of Photography, more commonly referred to as COOPH, has shared a video on its YouTube channel showing five inexpensive ways to take unique macro photos.
RawTherapee version 5.6 adds a new Pseudo-HiDPI mode, a new 'Unclipped' processing profile, and hundreds of other improvements and bug fixes to speed up editing.
Astronaut Terry Virts may have had the coolest photography job in the world – or outside of it – shooting over 300,000 photos during seven months in space. On this Earth Day, Virts tells us what it's like to be a space photographer.
Frans Lanting has inspired generations of artists and ecologists with his photography and environmental advocacy. To mark Earth Day 2019, we caught up with Frans to speak about his career and his hopes for the future.
The lens features a 1:1 maximum magnification ratio, a minimum focusing distance of 30cm (11.8in) and weighs 570g (1.3lbs).
Seattle-based photographer Neil Buckland has been working with University of Washington scientist Dr. Tony Irving to photograph, in incredible detail, slices of meteorites that have fallen to earth with his Pentax K-1 and a custom-built rig. Get a look into space, and into the past, with some of Buckland's images.
They say that the best camera is the one you you have with you. Senior Editor Barnaby Britton has been taking the Ricoh GR III with him a lot recently.
The Fujifilm X-T30 and Sony a6400 are two of the newest, most exciting mid-range mirrorless cameras on the market. Chris and Jordan break down the differences between these models to see which comes out on top.
Brian Ach shoots everything from rock and roll world tours to automotive ads. What follows is a detailed look at his workflow.
Nikkei Asian Review says the increasing capabilities of smartphones are at least partially to blame for the downturn in sales.
One of the main features that defines Instagram is its like count. Jane Manchun Wong, who is renowned for her reverse engineering skills, recently discovered that the service is considering hiding like counts.
Leica is facing backlash in China following the publication of a video called 'The Hunt' set in 1989 during, among other things, the Tiananmen Square pro-democracy protests.