CP+ 2019 Panasonic interview: 'We're proud of our cameraness'
The CP+ 2019 trade show in Yokohama, Japan, gave us the chance to speak to most of the major camera makers. Panasonic put forward an extensive team to discuss the company's move into the full-frame market.
- Michiharu Uematsu - Technical PR Adviser, Merchandising Dep., INBU
- Tetsuya Uno - Group Manager, Optical Engineering Dep., INBU
- Koji Shibuno - Manager, Software Engineering Dep. Key (responsible) engineer of AF engineering, INBU
- Takayuki Tochio - Senior Coordinator, Product Engineering Dep., INBU Key engineer of Picture Quality
- Hidenari Nishikawa - Senior Coordinator, Merchandising Dep., INBU
- Shiori Kitaoka - Senior Coordinator, Communication Dep. CMD
Please note that this interview was conducted partly via an interpreter, and has been edited for clarity and flow.
How different is it to design a lens for a much bigger sensor? What are the challenges?
When we're designing a lens, we look first at the most important properties: sharpness, transmission, distortion, vignetting, CA. But there are also some things are not measurable, quantitatively, such as bokeh. These are the 'taste' of the lens. So we need to understand this.
We assess bokeh at various distances. With Micro Four Thirds, the depth-of-field is deeper, relatively speaking. It's obvious where the tack-sharp range is and where is the 'big bokeh' [significantly out-of-focus area] range is. But now, for the full frame we need to consider the intermediate range: the 'small bokeh' area. It could be around the focal plane: that may already begin to be defocused with a full frame sensor.
We're constantly developing this to ensure the perfect 'taste' to our S-series lenses
We segment with depth: for the big bokeh area we want the beautiful bokeh with no onion ring effect and no unpleasant vignetting [of the bokeh: the 'cats' eye effect']. We need to have smooth vignetting from the center to edges, with circular bokeh in the center and a smooth progression to non-circular bokeh near the corners.
With the small bokeh [transitional] area we think about the double-line bokeh: which is considered a 'busy' bokeh effect. Around the focal plane area the transition between tack-sharp and out-of-focus is very important.
We needed a way to quantify and evaluate these usually qualitative aspects. This feeling when we look at the picture, we need to calculate or transfer those parameters to the quantitative evaluation.
We're constantly developing this to ensure the perfect 'taste' to our S-series lenses.
How well can you model bokeh or do you just have to build a sample lens and test it?
Thanks to very good simulation system we can roughly predict what the bokeh will look like beforehand. We create a prototype model but there can be gaps between what we expected from the simulation and exactly what we made, so we iterate with creation of the prototypes. So we model, create pre-production samples, evaluate and adjust before making another prototype model.
We firstly simulate a typical value of what we'd like to develop, then we can simulate the differences made by manufacturing tolerances, so we can predict those as well.
What are the challenges of making larger lenses with the high speed AF performance we've seen in Micro Four Thirds?
In terms of the mechanical part of the lens, we have a newly-developed double focus system and ultrasonic assist system. We have the double focus system in the 50mm lens and ultrasonic assist in the 24-105mm and 70-200mm.
In our double focus system, we have two groups of lenses which move independently for autofocus. Because we've separated the two groups, we can broaden the freedom of the development to give the best image quality and fast autofocus. Because we divided the AF into two, each group ends up being lighter, so they're faster, too.
We have a newly-developed double focus system and an ultrasonic assist system
For the ultrasonic assist, it's a new addition, on top of the linear focus actuator. The system keeps the lenses moving constantly, so that they don't have to overcome 'stiction' [the friction that needs to be overcome to start moving] before being driven to the correct location. This means the force needed to drive the lens is much less. So we have an ultrasonic system moving the lens a matter of nanometers, to ensure the lens isn't having to move from a dead start each time. It's a small enough vibration that you don't see it as AF wobbling.
Have you shared your DFD technology with Sigma and Leica?
The autofocus system protocol between the body and the lens is standardized in the L-mount alliance. So the other alliance members know what information the autofocus system needs. Beyond that it's up to the individual lens businesses whether they include that information to be fully compatible. It's up to them what they implement.
How do Leica L-mount lenses behave on the S1 and S1R?
Because this [DFD information] is already included in the protocol standard of the L-mount alliance, they already know how the body can command the lens to work.
The protocol hasn't changed: L-mount lenses that already exist should work in the same way as our new lenses. The protocol was already fixed when Leica started it as the SL system. Of course we're working on it all the time so it may be upgraded at some time, but for now it stays the same.
How does Panasonic plan to balance its resources between L-mount and Micro Four Thirds?
Because this was the launch of the S-series, we put the maximum effort into the S-series, including lenses. But you already know that we're developing the 10-25mm F1.7 lens for Micro Four Thirds, that's coming soon. So of course we are developing both S-series and G-series at the same time.
|The forthcoming Panasonic Leica DG Vario Summilux 10-25mm F1.7 is supposed to show the company's continued Micro Four Thirds ambitions.|
Has the expansion to a new system involved any expansion of engineering or manufacturing capacity?
We have optimized our human resources internally so that we can develop both S series and G series to the highest standard.
The S1 video spec is good but not up to GH standard. Do you see L-mount making sense for pro/semi-pro video?
First of all, let us confirm the concept of these cameras: the S1R is for the professional photographer while the S1 is for the hybrid stills and video photographer, so the concepts of those models are a little bit different. This might be why the spec is not beyond the GH series.
In the future, we'd like to consider the users' needs: it's open to users' feedback.
Do you feel there's an advantage to Micro Four Thirds, when it comes to video?
There are many categories of video shooters from broadcasting or run-and-gun, through to cinema and creative videography. If we are thinking about broadcasting or run-and-gun videographers, there may be some advantage to the small, compact and lightweight combination. That's the first benefit, compared to the larger sensor system. Image stabilization and overheating will be less of an issue, compared to full-frame sensors.
The degree of [creative] freedom broadens if you use a larger sensor, so maybe the cinema type of videographer would prefer the larger sensor, such as full frame. Maybe for cinema it's better to take full frame.
Was EVA-1 level videography considered when developing the L system and its lenses?
Of course we have been discussing with professional camcorder team as a fundamental part of the engineering, but we haven't discussed deeply how we might create such models. We're not discussing which mount would be used for the coming product.
Of course we don't disclose any further product information. At this point we don't have any future information we can disclose.
|Panasonic talks about the 'cameraness' of the S1: the degree to which it feels like a camera|
You're arriving in a very crowded sector of the market. What is it you think Panasonic can uniquely bring?
Firstly, cameraness: the interface, in terms of both hardware and software [making the device feel like a camera]. If you look at competitor models, they're very innovative cameras but they're having some negative comments in the market that the grips are smaller than expected or that the interface is [too] cutting-edge, leaving people confused when they first try to use them. We listened to a lot of customers' feedback to create the S-series, so we designed the position of buttons, shape of buttons and also the menu settings accordingly. We're proud of this cameraness and the interface, first of all.
In terms of features, we have the high resolution mode, which is number one in the market and Dual IS that gives up to six stops of stabilization. 4K/60p is a feature only we have in the full frame market and the electronic viewfinder is really high resolution: that too is number one in the market. This isn't everything, of course, but we can offer all those functions and features, to even professional users so that they can easily come to our system and start using them for their professional work.
Also our HLG Photo mode: this comes from our background in videography and this allows for a new photographic style.
What does HLG mean for stills photography: what happens next? Editing tools for HDR images?
The editing, as you say, and the public awareness are important in the near future. Firstly we'd like everyone to try the HLG HDR photos, where people can have a [means] of expression beyond the standard definition.
In terms of editing, we are co-working with an alliance: we're trying to find a solution to edit HDR images. On the technology side we'd like to be at least one step ahead of our competitors, so we will keep improving the image sensor technology to be capable for the high dynamic range world.
Of course we're one of the few companies that can create HDR TVs as well as cameras, so of course we're working with [our] TV business group. That way you're not only shooting but can also display and view HDR images in the best possible environment.
For the HDR Photo style we're working to have a wider [DR] option so that you can be really creative when shooting HLG photos.
This meeting was a mixture of briefing and interview, which is why some of the answers are quite long and detailed. The upshot of this is, perhaps, that you don't have to read quite so closely between the lines to see the message Panasonic wants to send. My own interpretation of it would be 'we're not just an electronics company: we care about even the most subtle aspects of image quality.' Or maybe that's just my response to hearing the word 'cameraness' again.
The thing I haven't been able to capture in the text is the slide Panasonic showed me about the autofocus hit-rate they measured when shooting their cameras side-by-side with phase-detection-based rivals. The testing protocol wasn't fully disclosed, but it showed their products delivering a hit-rate comparable to some pretty good cameras, and even out-performing phase-detection systems when the subject gets close to the camera.
My own interpretation of it would be 'we're not just an electronics company: we care about even the most subtle aspects of image quality.'
This is something we'll be looking at as we test the S1 and S1R, because the general perception of DFD is that it's flat-out inferior to phase-detection. This isn't helped by the visually disturbing 'flutter' as the cameras try to maintain focus on moving objects (an effect made more dramatic by the high res viewfinders and shallow depth-of-field of the lenses on the S cameras).
Overall, though, it's clear that Panasonic wants its S1 and S1R to appeal specifically to professional stills photographers. When it comes to video, the company's plans seem less well-developed. For now, at least, it seems that Panasonic sees the GH series as its main video/stills camera platform.
|Body Only, Base|
|Body Only, w/ Battery & Grip|
|Body Only, w/ 50mm|
|Body Only, w/ 70-200mm|
|Body Only, w/ Professional XLR Audio Video Microphone...|
|Body Only, w/ VLOG||See price on Amazon.com|
|w/ 24-105mm, Base|
|w/ 24-105mm, w/ 50mm|
|w/ 24-105mm, w/ 70-200mm|
|w/ 24-105mm, w/ Professional XLR Audio Video Microphone...|
|w/ 24-105mm, w/ VLOG||See price on Amazon.com|
|w/ 24-105mm, w/ Battery and Grip|
|Body Only, Base|
|Body Only, w/ Battery & Grip|
|Body Only, w/ 50mm|
|Body Only, w/ 70-200mm|
|w/ 24-105mm, Base|
|w/ 24-105mm, w/ Battery & Grip|
|w/ 24-105mm, w/ 50mm|
|w/ 24-105mm, w/ 70-200mm|
|Morning Crossing In Yellowstone by poppyjk|
from Poor Light
|On Fire by Frank van Eck|
|Oasis by kt|
from Wet - Dry
|White River by rainrunner|
from Spring Snow
Accessory maker Techart has announced the TZE-01, the first autofocus adapter for using Sony E-mount lenses with Nikon's Z series cameras.
Sandmarc's new accessory lens helps to create a cinematic look when shooting on the iPhone.
The ZenFone 6 flip camera withstands an awful lot of abuse by Zack from the Youtube channel JerryRigEverything.
Jordan reviews the Deity Connect wireless microphone. Find out why this is the mic system he's wanted for a decade, and why he thinks it's a compelling choice for so many people who shoot video.
Rumors have been circulating about a possible Spark 2 drone release from DJI this summer. DroneDJ recently confirmed that the release is now on hold indefinitely.
For the first time ever, Adobe has brought its cloud-based version of Lightroom to Apple's Mac App Store, complete with in-app purchases for renewing 1TB of online storage.
First teased back in February, Voigtländer has shared more technical specs for its 75mm F1.5 Vintage Line lens.
This isn't your average GoPro-style time-lapse camera. The TikeePRO 2+ can record 6K time-lapses from inside a ruggedized box with an integrated solar panel and GPS functionality.
We've re-scored the Nikon Z6 and Z7 to reflect the improved performance and usability offered by the latest firmware updates. We'll be doing more of this in the coming months.
New sizes allow for the use of ColorChecker targets in a wider range of photographic and video applications.
Leica's latest special edition camera is a Leica CL collaboration with French-Italian photographer Jean Pigozzi.
Nikon has made available a firmware update that brings significant improvements to autofocus. But it's continuous Eye AF that's the big headline. Science Editor Rishi Sanyal has given it a go, and finds its performance to be remarkably good... but with some snags.
This AI program can cutout a person or character and create an animated 3D model all from a single still image.
Same body and pixel-count, but the Hasselblad X1D II 50C moves quicker and offers the biggest rear screen in the medium format market – and it costs a lot less than the original.
It's two years late, but worth the wait, according to Hasselblad: the company says that its new XCD 35-75mm zoom is the best lens it has ever made.
Hasselblad will be reintroducing its medium format digital back for the V-system medium format film cameras, and has also announced a new slimline X-series body to go with it.
Olympus has released a major firmware update for its nearly three-year-old OM-D E-M1 Mark II. Many of the additions come straight from the company's flagship E-M1X, so now you can have a camera that shares many of the same features but in a much smaller package.
Olympus has announced a 2X teleconverter designed to be used with its 40-150 F2.8 and 300mm F4 Pro lenses, as well as the 150-400mm F4.5 TC1.25x IS Pro lens currently under development. This weather-sealed teleconverter will be available is available now for $429.
We've got our hands on a nearly final Fujifilm GFX 100 to begin using in earnest, and though it's not yet running final firmware, we couldn't help but put it in front of our studio scene to see what it can do – have a look for yourself.
Lensbaby is known for its interesting lens designs, but its new system is an add-on kit that can make interesting in-camera effects with what Lensbaby refers to as ‘effect wands.’
It shouldn't come as a surprise, but this marks the first time an official has been made regarding the existence of a flagship mirrorless camera designed to compete with Nikon's flagship D4/D5 DSLR series.
Datacolor's new SpyderX Capture Pro and SpyderX Studio tool suites are designed to be an all-in-one solution to getting the best color in your images and prints.
DJI introduced the Osmo Pocket, a portable, handheld device ideal for vloggers and recreational use, late last year. To slow shutter speed for more cinematic footage, and to reduce glare in photos, these polarizer and neutral density filters can be a great addition.
Dallas Morning News photojournalist Tom Fox was on-scene for a separate assignment when a gunman opened fire at a federal courthouse in Dallas, Texas. Fox captured an incredible image of the gunman
The backpack, which still has 39 days to go on Kickstarter, uses an internal organizer and features an exterior that's weather resistance and uses WANDRD's InfiniteZip system.
The four-and-a-half-minute video explains how Canon's new RF mount affords new possibilities in lens design that ultimately lead to better image quality.
Automation, a new feature within the Shortcuts app of iOS 13, allows for a clever workaround to open third-party camera apps as the default Camera app on the home screen
Users will soon be able to recover a hacked account via in-app functions, without getting in touch with the Instagram security team.
Whether you're headed to the beach or the ski slopes, a rugged, waterproof camera lets you focus on your adventure instead of worrying if the camera will survive. Find out which model is the best-in-class in our waterproof camera buying guide.
The FlexTILT Head 3D is the first product in Edelkrone's new ORTAK lineup, which is specifically designed to piggyback off the growing trend of 3D printing.