Fireworks noise reduction on?

Alfonso Bresciani

Senior Member
Messages
1,798
Reaction score
37
Location
New Orleans -, LA, US
Do the images get really noisy if on bulb open at 10 secs? (20d body)

I'd hate to wait for the second frame if noise reduction is on.

--
Alfonso Bresciani
P_o_m_p_o M_u_l_t_i_m_e_d_i_a
============================================
===
You will know fear...Then you will know pain.
Then you will use a Mac.
http://www.pompo.com/neworleans.html
 
I would turn NR on. I always have it on, but i shoot primarily at night as well, so my exposures run anywhere from 15 sec to 30sec. I'll certainly have NR on for shooting fireworks this year.
 
so you miss the rest of the show then...uh...
how wonder how bad it would be without noise reduction on?
ya know?

--
Alfonso Bresciani
P_o_m_p_o M_u_l_t_i_m_e_d_i_a
============================================
===
You will know fear...Then you will know pain.
Then you will use a Mac.
http://www.pompo.com/neworleans.html
 
I would turn on NR just for the hot-pixel removal. You can do this later with clone (if in jpeg) or Adobe Capture RAW should remove hotpixels automatically. But it's easier for the camera to do it on the fly.
 
I ain't worried about hot pixels...so the NR is just for that?

--
Alfonso Bresciani
P_o_m_p_o M_u_l_t_i_m_e_d_i_a
============================================
===
You will know fear...Then you will know pain.
Then you will use a Mac.
http://www.pompo.com/neworleans.html
 
The long-exposure NR takes one shot when you push the button and then takes another shot - just as long - with the shutter closed and it subtracts what it gets from that 2nd exposure from what it got with the "real" exposure. That gets rid of a lot of the hot-pixels.

But you miss half of the fireworks show or lightning, or whatever, while waiting for it to do the 2nd exposure every time.

So one other thing you can do is to shoot with the long-exposure NR off and then do this:

Take one shot every so often throughout the show using the same long shutter speed and ISO. But shoot it with the lens-cap on and the aperture stopped all the way down.

Then, later, you can use Photoshop or whatever to subtract THAT single dark-frame from all of the neighboring similar shots. In effect, you've made one correction frame to use for a bunch of shots and you don't have to be annoyed by missing the best fireworks while waiting for the camera to make a dark-frame shot for each exposure.

Supposedly, you should make one of these "home made" dark frames for each ISO and shutter speed that you'll use and also any time the camera's temperaure changes significantly (whatever that means).

I guess for me, it's more agonizing to be missing the fireworks than it is to have some hot pixels. The "spot healing brush" in Photoshop takes care of those with great ease anyhow. And using the home-made dark frame method works quite well too.

But the in-camera long-exposure noise reduction does do a good job of eliminating the hot pixels. I just find it frustrating for lightning, meteor, or fireworks shooting because it always seems that I end up missing "the big one" when I use it :)

--
Jim H.
 
well I heard of that before, I guess I can also go home afterwards and take
blank frames with the cap on with same exposure lenght.
--
Alfonso Bresciani
P_o_m_p_o M_u_l_t_i_m_e_d_i_a
============================================
===
You will know fear...Then you will know pain.
Then you will use a Mac.
http://www.pompo.com/neworleans.html
 
My 10D doesn't have noise reduction, so I obviously don't use it. I've never had a problem with noise when shooting fireworks. The 20D has better noise handling than my camera, so I don't think you'll need. Plus, you'll miss half the show if you turn it on.

--
...Mike
Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
When did photography become about technology instead of vision?
Trying to work my way up to rank amateur.

PBase Gallery: http://www.pbase.com/mikealex
PhotoSIG: http://www.photosig.com/go/users/view?id=176063
 
for noise reduction...

Just kidding. I've never used the noise reduction feature. Doesn't seem necessary.

Good luck!
--
When I ask which Canon lenses are best,
people tell me to 'go to L.'
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top