Jon_T
•
Veteran Member
•
Posts: 6,393
Re: G5x ii vs Rx100 vi / Aperture vs Reach
1
larkhon wrote:
Jon_T wrote:
larkhon wrote:
The OP doesn't need to test both cameras at a concert nor does it have to be a Pro grade review/comparison in order to be meaningful. Let's not be snobbish about it...
Really?
My reply was simply if "anyone" wants to do a "IQ comparison" between two cameras the test parameters (subject, lighting, exposure) need to be the same, or test results are useless. (Garbage In, Garbage Out)
This is completely irrelevant. It isn't about comparing the IQ of two cameras, ...
Re-read the OP's FIRST post about his "TEST" in a ROOM which my replies were 'mainly' to, in addition to OP comments on concerts.

... it's about putting them in a tough, real life situation. ..
Been shooting in "real life" conditions for over 40 years.
If one cannot get shots right in practice shooting, they're not going to get right in "tough real life situations".
... Until recently I owned both cameras and I would use them in concerts too. First of, the Sony shot is either blurry because of the slow SS ...
User error.
Not an error, a choice. I would have used the same SS but then the exposure would have been different.
DUH! That's when experience helps you to make make the right choices; not excuses.
... or because it's been resized to 1.8mp ...
Again user/ settings error. My RX10 IV has never resized the sensor's 20 MP image to lower size; nor I have read any posts by any users in the "Sony Cyber-shot Talk" forum stating this.
An experienced user would have thought the OP had resized the picture with a software, I don't know where you got this idea that the camera was doing it??
Sorry I do not ESP to read anyone's thoughts. That's not the way you post read:... "
... First of, the Sony shot is either blurry because of the slow SS or because it's been resized to 1.8mp (which is unnecessary, in my opinion," ...
Nothing indicating of PP.
Any knowable photog would have known the results of downsizing to 1.8 MP beforehand.
The RX100 VI/ VII images posted by "experienced" users in the "Sony Cyber-shot Talk" rebuke your comments.
Then again, you can always have a bad copy or have a very specific use case.
I've read through quite a few of your past posts, and look at your images in your DPR Gallery, your the typical type that's 'All TALK' and 'No WALK'; with nothing more than excuses and manure.
Hence not going to waste my time with any further replies — I've added you to my profiles' "Ignore User".
Bye