Markr041 wrote:
steve ohlhaber wrote:
Can you explain exactly what is wrong with the Kandao Ego. You seem a little defensive about this relative to what you like to use. The Ego is not for VR180, it is just 3D video.
I have shot 3D video with lots of cameras, including the Sony 3D camcorder, the Fuji W3, and twin GoPro's (I have actually shot 2D video with the Scam E1). So I am aware of what has been available. I also have tried out the dual fisheye Canon VR180 rig.
Yeah, I was hoping the Ego would be something I could just easily use and get better results than the Gopro Dual Hero. Its simply not from a quality perspective. This is sort of hard to believe given the duel hero is now 12 years old, but here is the deal:
1. The thing takes FOREVER to even turn on, which everyone notices instantly. Like 30 seconds.
2. The thing will overheat, even when you are not shooting. It simply being on is enough for it to overheat and shut down. Like in 3 minutes of simply being on, it will overheat.
3. It will not focus even though it is a manual focus camera. You manually use a slider and it simply does not work. I cannot believe how many blurry still images i get out of this thing. Its incredible. This is daylight and blurry, so its NOT camera shake. This feature alone makes it worthless. Its software focus, so I bet, it defaults to some mid focus, then checks the last setting, and because its software, they cant get it to work, so you get 50% of the time, maybe it works. If it had no focus at all and just stayed at infinity, it would be radically better and worth buying just because when it took a shot it would be in focus.
4. Video quality looks like a camera made about 15 years ago. I know because I have those cameras, shoot them to compare and its that bad. Video compression in a camera isnt easy and Kandao is not any good at consumer grade, so it sucks bad. Video quality is way worse than the still quality on this camera. Like WAY worse. To get an idea, I replaced the lenses in a gopro hero 3+black long ago when I started to shoot 3d with the dual hero because I wanted a 28mmish FOV. So, I can grab that rig that is over 10 years old, shoot video and that compares DIRECTLY to the EGO because the FOV is the same. The Gopro CRUSHES the SH** out of the Kandao. Then you try stills with the Gopro. If the stills would freaking focus on the Ego, it would easily win due to the newer sensor, but you get 50% focus issues on that POS. I have no love at all for stuff that simply does not work. I like stuff that works. I dont care about the cost. There just isnt anything new out there that is worth a damn. I mean, the fuji 3d was like $800 or something crazy when it came out, but it freaking worked. Its just that Kandao loves to be chinese and make cheap unreliable crap. If you made the mistake of buying the kandao 8k 360 camera they made a couple years ago, you know what I mean.
5. It costs the money that a camera that should work would cost. This should go for around $200 given how bad it is.
6. Battery life is total crap.
In general use, the old gopro dual hero with swapped 5.4mm lenses easily beats the use and results. The only 1 thing the Ego has going for it is, its small. Thats it. It wont work. You will not "get the shot". And this is compared to the ancient gopro dual hero, which already seemed hard to use as it takes a while to boot up also, but it freaking works when it comes up.
The ability to see the result with the little headset thing, ok, thats ok, but I dont know who cares. Its like the Fuji 3d and also Sony TD video cameras, I really didnt care that the display was 3d. I would have liked a normal brighter 2d screen and a cheaper product. Its like Kandao saw the advertisement and shot for that and do not care about the product. They are proving it with each release.
Video is way way worse than stills. If the stills would freaking focus, it would be at least almost be useful, but then it overheats then the battery dies. By now, someone should be able to beat the gopro dual hero. This easily does not in quality, so somehow, that misses, and beyond that it is super buggy and overheating and battery issues and focus.
The other rig I have that really is nice is the synced gopro hero 4 cams with the mewpro sync. This is ultra sketch to get set up, but if you are lucky enough to wire it up, the hero 4 is a big step up from the hero 3+plus black, like double. You get solid 4k 3d synced. Its been really nice, but I had to buy 2 as one totally failed to work and that thing aint cheap, but it works.
So, its the Ego fun as a toy sure, if you just use the display it come with on the camera, you probably never will notice how bad the focus is or how bad the quality and you probably wont know that cameras released 12 years ago were actually better quality than its best result. I keep trying to use this because its pocketable, but it just isnt worth it.