DPReview.com is closing April 10th - Find out more

Anybody here been to Truk?

Started 2 months ago | Discussions
kelpdiver Veteran Member • Posts: 5,564
Re: Some Truk feedback

PHXAZCRAIG wrote:

I overnighted in Guam in both directions, forced to retrieve bags due to longer-than-12-hour layover. (13 hours.)

I had to do so as well on the return, which was a 16 hr separation.

Of course they still had to deal with claim/reclaim at the first US airport. I found out how incredibly horrible it was to have to deal with only two bags in Honolulu. I think United is sucking hind tit there - they had the WORST locations, and it meant a very long slog.

yes, I have a very nasty letter brewing to United about this item, though it pales compared to the 2 cancelled TKK->GUM flights and the 3 day delay.

There is no sanity to how we walked through customs without stopping, picked up our luggage at carousel 1, and then had to walk blindly past carousel 31 to Uniteds check in terminal to then figure out where to drop it back off. The final insult is we then rechecked through security and had to walk all the way back to the same damn plane we arrived on. All told, it took about 1:15 to complete the process.

My Pelican case worked well, though I haven't yet opened it since I got home. I assume all is well inside.

I like to soak the housing in a tub for a couple of days when i return, since rarely do I get to do a decent rinsing when on site. At least make sure everything made it!

So....how did you make out with the Blue Lagoon boxspring only beds? That was rough. And the food situation was getting pretty bleak. Apparently the fresh food boat skipped them on the last pass. BL (and the island in general) was out of greens by the 15th, and BL's cheeseburger didn't appear to contain any beef at all.

But it sounds like you managed reasonably well. Truk is one of the harder spots to get to, so if that was tolerable, then Anilao is a cakewalk. Tahiti and Fiji are even easier. Solomons/PNG is on par with Truk. Only Indonesia is harder.

kelpdiver Veteran Member • Posts: 5,564
Re: Diving feedback, pics to come

PHXAZCRAIG wrote:

I was one of only 3 (out of 17) divers using a single tank. I did not get to dive the San Francisco Maru because my Oceanic Islander BCD was deemed to be unable to hook a spare tank to. Not sure why, but when everyone else did that dive, I ended up on another boat with a fairly new diver. (He had neither light nor dive computer, which made the wreck penetrations interesting.)

I preferred being on the 'beginner boat', and I talked the other single-tanker to join use for the rest of the trip. On the other boat we had 35 minute dives (95-120 feet), and then had to sit for another hour and a quarter for the last diver to come up. On our own boat, we could do a hour interval and get a second morning dive in. (And take the afternoon off).

On my "liveaboard," there were 5 single tankers, 4 using doubles, 2 using CCRs.  I used quotes because the engine was broken and so we just ran skiffs out of the harbor.  I nearly cancelled and went to BL instead, though this probably would have backfired due to the large crowds they had.    I did dive the first day (5th) with them.

Masters would only allow the CCRs and 2 of the doubles folks to do the San Francisco.  I think they required Tech 60 (trimix), but not quite sure why they DQd two of the doubles folks.

The mixture was disadvantageous, but so was the use of the skiffs to do two dives at a time.  We often would double dive the same site, so we'd do our dive, sit 60, do the second.  The tech divers would do one long dive.   But in a true liveaboard scenario, we would generally have 2 hours of surface time.    As another optimization for the techies, they filled their nitrox banks with ~28%, and I usually got between 27 and 28.   30 would have been better for single tank no deco divers.   I figure I lost 10 minutes on several dives because of these two factors.

When I visited in 2011 in mid summer, it was quite slow, and for 4 of the days I was the only customer (and 2 or 3 the first two days), which meant less silt in the interiors and their 3 dive schedule and light deco meant longer dives.  But this month there were multiple expedition type groups there with as you said, A LOT of travel cases.

Made me think how dangerous it was to not have a second independent source of air in those passages. An equipment failure there could easily have me dying in 30 seconds.

eh, maybe.   (will address in your other thread)

So for almost the first time, I started modifying ISO values when I went into cargo holds. Usually ISO 500 (iso-less setting there) but sometimes 800-1000 in darker areas. Some anemone shots got me back into the ISO 64-250 range. F8 and 1/160th.

I was pretty lazy and used auto iso and A mode most of the time.   I do need to work on the button muscle memory so I can better use manual.

Never did use any of the macro stuff I brought, though there was plenty of macro to shoot if you looked. And that was just on top of the wrecks. The 14-30 with Sea and Sea IRC seemed to do quite well.

there are macro subjects, but when I reviewed the dives I did in 2011 with the macro setup, very little of it was of merit.   I think you spend most of your time trying to find a purpose.   It would be most sensible if you return to a dive site later to reshoot something you tried to get at 30mm.   In my case, as we generally did 2 sequential dives on same wreck, there wasn't a lot of repeat potential that allowed for camera rework.

I did a 2 days with the fisheye, but most of the time with the 14-35.  It was a bit more flexible for smaller stuff, at the expense of being able to do the immersive view that I can do at 11mm.

Barmaglot_07 Contributing Member • Posts: 633
Re: Anybody here been to Truk?

PHXAZCRAIG wrote:

I do this (230mm dome port travel) partly with the idea that "I can still do it now, in a few years I won't be able to and would regret missing the chance."

I still don't want to go back to a 'lesser camera'. Underwater is by far the most challenging photography I've ever done, and I want the most capable camera in my hands in challenging conditions, not another point-n-shoot.

I wouldn't call WWL-1 solution a 'lesser camera'; see here for a sample comparison: https://www.facebook.com/NauticamThailand/posts/pfbid02Rx7a3XcKJzRSHnjVT9bx5G7XPVNBmVY1GpuxP24QNRqHCAAKpC6c4hbvWWYwvzn7l

On a Z9, you can use a Sony 28-60mm (via an adapter) with WWL-1B.

Another option for downsizing would be an 8-15mm fisheye, optionally with a teleconverter - unlike a rectilinear wide-angle, fisheye lenses work fine in a small dome, like 4.33" acrylic or 140mm glass.

Both would give you CFWA capabilities, at the cost of not being able to do over/under splits.

 Barmaglot_07's gear list:Barmaglot_07's gear list
Sony a6300 Canon EF-S 60mm f/2.8 Macro USM Sony E 30mm F3.5 Macro Sony E 18-200mm F3.5-6.3 OSS LE Sony E 10-18mm F4 OSS +5 more
PHXAZCRAIG
OP PHXAZCRAIG Forum Pro • Posts: 19,651
Re: Some Truk feedback

kelpdiver wrote:

My Pelican case worked well, though I haven't yet opened it since I got home. I assume all is well inside.

I like to soak the housing in a tub for a couple of days when i return, since rarely do I get to do a decent rinsing when on site. At least make sure everything made it!

Yes, all was well.

So....how did you make out with the Blue Lagoon boxspring only beds?

Hah! Well, I avoided the worst of the springs by lying to the side of one of them.

I didn't really mind the beds.  I've used hard beds like those for years, until I got my Purple.

That was rough. And the food situation was getting pretty bleak. Apparently the fresh food boat skipped them on the last pass. BL (and the island in general) was out of greens by the 15th, and BL's cheeseburger didn't appear to contain any beef at all.

Hmm.  The bleakest thing I found - though I left on the 11th - was the very ... slow service.   I thought the menu was very ambitious, and the chefs pulled off all of the items I ate, though some were a bit different. ("Toasted" peanut butter & jelly sandwich?)

I got the cheeseburger the first week and barely recognized that one.  Avoided it afterwards.

But it sounds like you managed reasonably well. Truk is one of the harder spots to get to, so if that was tolerable, then Anilao is a cakewalk. Tahiti and Fiji are even easier. Solomons/PNG is on par with Truk. Only Indonesia is harder.

Been to Fiji, by way of a 4-day layover in Aukland.   Been to Tahiti and had such a bad airport experience leaving that I am sort of scared and certainly reluctant to go back.  (No A/C, melted.)

My daughter has a goal of seeing all the national parks in the US, and she's seen most.  I want to take her to American Samoa and the Northern Marianas islands on a 2-week trip.   Those islands look quite close to Guam.    As long as I can afford a lay-flat seat on the flights to Guam, I'm pretty good with the getting there.  Now she'll have to learn to dive, and I intend to have her lug the heavy luggage too!  (She's 5'11" by the way).

-- hide signature --

Phoenix Arizona Craig
www.cjcphoto.net
"I miss the days when I was nostalgic."

 PHXAZCRAIG's gear list:PHXAZCRAIG's gear list
Nikon D80 Nikon D200 Nikon D300 Nikon D700 Nikon 1 V1 +45 more
PHXAZCRAIG
OP PHXAZCRAIG Forum Pro • Posts: 19,651
Re: Diving feedback, pics to come

You were on the Odyssey?   I saw it moored right there, and i heard it was going into drydock the following week.

I also heard a woman died on it the week before I arrived.

Heh - so you were basically doing the same diving we were, on small boats out of the harbor?  Except you were using the liveaboard boats?

I was getting Nitrox values from 27 to 31%.

It was hard for me to judge my diving and air consumption on this trip.  I was trying a new 5-mil, and I ended up using 21 pounds the first couple of days.   Eventually got down to 14, which was still two more than I expected.   That threw off my air the first two days for sure, plus the difference in the type of diving had me a bit nervous at times.

Blue Lagoon - interesting mix of nice & competent and what-the-heck?   Lighting in the room was ridiculous.  The TV was there to grace the wall.  I heard they bought a bunch (it looked new), had them installed thinking they were smart tv's (to work over wifi), and then they found they needed cable to them.   Wifi was a very intermittent offering in the rooms, though often worked at night.  Hot water - did have that a couple of times, and warm 3-4 times.

But I've been to the Reef House in Roatan 11 times.  I'm used to less-than-stellar accommodations.  Overall I thought the BL was fine, though definitely could use some light bulbs.

-- hide signature --

Phoenix Arizona Craig
www.cjcphoto.net
"I miss the days when I was nostalgic."

 PHXAZCRAIG's gear list:PHXAZCRAIG's gear list
Nikon D80 Nikon D200 Nikon D300 Nikon D700 Nikon 1 V1 +45 more
PHXAZCRAIG
OP PHXAZCRAIG Forum Pro • Posts: 19,651
Re: Diving feedback, pics to come

kelpdiver wrote:

On my "liveaboard," there were 5 single tankers, 4 using doubles, 2 using CCRs. I used quotes because the engine was broken and so we just ran skiffs out of the harbor.

Was this your boat? I wondered why it stayed there for so long.

I've finally got a more-or-less final version done of the pics. I posted them on my web server here:

https://www.cjcphoto.net/truk2023/

-- hide signature --

Phoenix Arizona Craig
www.cjcphoto.net
"I miss the days when I was nostalgic."

 PHXAZCRAIG's gear list:PHXAZCRAIG's gear list
Nikon D80 Nikon D200 Nikon D300 Nikon D700 Nikon 1 V1 +45 more
kelpdiver Veteran Member • Posts: 5,564
Re: Diving feedback, pics to come

no - that's the Odyssey.    My boat- Taka aka Truk Master aka PNG or Solomons Master was so broken, it was tied to the dock at the harbor.   Hopefully their engine parts have arrived by now - they hope to set sail for Bikini shortly.

The BL spot is calm water, so it's a decent home base.   They often will moor to the deeper wrecks for the tech customers, while using the skiffs to take the rec divers elsewhere.

The Thorfinn was anchored an island to the south, closer to the center point for the main groupings of wrecks.

Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum MMy threads