DPReview.com is closing April 10th - Find out more

Try This Focus Trick On Your OM-1

Started 4 months ago | Discussions
Tumulous Junior Member • Posts: 26
Re: Try This Focus Trick On Your OM-1

ProDude wrote:

JRobins wrote:

  • ProDude wrote:

A friend of mine who also has a OM-1 and shoots hard to track sports made a discovery the other day. He'd been struggling with hits of focus that were accurate using 15fps in burst shooting of his son who is very active in sports. He had him, from about 50 feet away run towards him and while doing so gyrated twisted and turned and had his head both towards and away from him in the process. Previously and with prior firmware (prior to the new 1.3) he noted he'd miss more than a few shots. Out of desperation he turned both the Eye/Face Human detection on but ADDED the C-AF-TR mode which worked in tandem (I didn't know nor think about this before). The TR mode has been blasted prior for being useless. Well what happened was he now got over 90% of his attempted shots like this in this setting perfectly IN focus. He was astounded and repeated it and it was identical in both instances. I saw a Youtube by a British guy who reported he'd also noted the C-AF with TR mode in place also was MUCH better then it was ever before.

So I figured it was time I gave it a try. I played with the TR mode before and indeed found it near worthless as it lost the subject very easily when moved about. I place it in the C-AF AND TR mode adding the Human Eye/Face detection and tried it with my wife in a poorly lit which before when I tried to track and shoot, all the shots were out of focus/blurry. This was in Aperture Priority mode by the way and I didn't up the shutter speeds. Well wouldn't ya know it, I took 4 shots in a row with these conditions and noted that the TR portion allowed for my blinking little green boxes (I have my setting to show these) to remain tracking right on her upper body and mostly the back of her head when she turned away from me. As soon as she began turning back to face me barely on the side of her face it nailed her eye with a small white box completing the larger box on her face. This is near exactly as a test I did while trying out a Sony A7R5 with their new AI. (I sent the Sony back by the way). I tried this 4 times and each time it never lost her head and then nailed focus on her eyes and face. No accident to be sure. Without the TR in effect, it was NOT as effective by a considerable margin as NONE of the shots were in focus. WITH the TR in effect along with the C-AF and EYE-FACE detection it was nailing it 100% and this was in rather poor light. So I encourage you folks to give this a try and see if it doesn't turbocharge your focus abilities as well. I can't wait to try this on birds soon.

When you try it on birds, please let us know the results! Sounds hopeful!

I thought I was clear. It is exclusively a feature that works for HUMAN Eye/Face detection. Do NOT use CF-A-TR in Subject Recognition mode you will be very unhappy.

Eh? So why did you say that you couldn't wait to try it out on birds at the end of your post?

Dan Veteran Member • Posts: 4,383
Re: Try This Focus Trick On Your OM-1

If you know the guy can you shoot next to him?  Good luck and looking forward to your results / comparisons.

My question is to OM where online or in the manual do they at least give folks a starting point for photographing a certain scene and the settings to use?  Seems they should provide this vs folks here figuring this or that out.  They should also keep it up to date as firmware improves / modifies settings required.

Good luck again.

Dan

 Dan's gear list:Dan's gear list
Canon EOS 5DS R Nikon D5 Olympus OM-D E-M1X GoPro Fusion
OP ProDude Senior Member • Posts: 4,855
Re: Try This Focus Trick On Your OM-1

Tumulous wrote:

ProDude wrote:

EZGritz wrote:

My friends with Z9s think they did better with their Nikon DSLRs. They are not satisfied wiht the Z9

I have a friend who is a sports shooter and he tried a Z9 and A1 sending them back. He is thrilled with the ergo's and setup and performance of the OM-1. He said he get's very close to the 100% keeper rate which the others didn't come close to. I've noted several posts and Youtube's floating around of others that used an A1 or Z9 and found the OM-1 superior in ALL regards. But it's like some well kept (more like buried) secret that doesn't sit well with the fanatical FF crowd. Oh well. it's their money. I sent one back for a refund as it brought NOTHING to the table my OM-1 wasn't doing.

So how come you reordered a Sony A7RV only a couple of days after writing that and now have it in your possession?

Well, not like I have to apologize. I decided after careful examination of the images I took during the trial, that the A7R5 would make some sense for the landscape and portrait use. It's not like I NEED it. More of a want. I tend to shoot birds perched far away and such and the cropability of a 61mp FF setup does have it's merits. I just figured it might be a decent 2nd body to have around for some applications. One thing is for sure. If I travel on a vacation and such or attempt to shoot fast moving subjects, the OM-1 will be THE body and lens combo in my bag.

-- hide signature --

Name the gear and I've probably owned it and used it.

OP ProDude Senior Member • Posts: 4,855
Re: Try This Focus Trick On Your OM-1

Tumulous wrote:

ProDude wrote:

JRobins wrote:

  • ProDude wrote:

A friend of mine who also has a OM-1 and shoots hard to track sports made a discovery the other day. He'd been struggling with hits of focus that were accurate using 15fps in burst shooting of his son who is very active in sports. He had him, from about 50 feet away run towards him and while doing so gyrated twisted and turned and had his head both towards and away from him in the process. Previously and with prior firmware (prior to the new 1.3) he noted he'd miss more than a few shots. Out of desperation he turned both the Eye/Face Human detection on but ADDED the C-AF-TR mode which worked in tandem (I didn't know nor think about this before). The TR mode has been blasted prior for being useless. Well what happened was he now got over 90% of his attempted shots like this in this setting perfectly IN focus. He was astounded and repeated it and it was identical in both instances. I saw a Youtube by a British guy who reported he'd also noted the C-AF with TR mode in place also was MUCH better then it was ever before.

So I figured it was time I gave it a try. I played with the TR mode before and indeed found it near worthless as it lost the subject very easily when moved about. I place it in the C-AF AND TR mode adding the Human Eye/Face detection and tried it with my wife in a poorly lit which before when I tried to track and shoot, all the shots were out of focus/blurry. This was in Aperture Priority mode by the way and I didn't up the shutter speeds. Well wouldn't ya know it, I took 4 shots in a row with these conditions and noted that the TR portion allowed for my blinking little green boxes (I have my setting to show these) to remain tracking right on her upper body and mostly the back of her head when she turned away from me. As soon as she began turning back to face me barely on the side of her face it nailed her eye with a small white box completing the larger box on her face. This is near exactly as a test I did while trying out a Sony A7R5 with their new AI. (I sent the Sony back by the way). I tried this 4 times and each time it never lost her head and then nailed focus on her eyes and face. No accident to be sure. Without the TR in effect, it was NOT as effective by a considerable margin as NONE of the shots were in focus. WITH the TR in effect along with the C-AF and EYE-FACE detection it was nailing it 100% and this was in rather poor light. So I encourage you folks to give this a try and see if it doesn't turbocharge your focus abilities as well. I can't wait to try this on birds soon.

When you try it on birds, please let us know the results! Sounds hopeful!

I thought I was clear. It is exclusively a feature that works for HUMAN Eye/Face detection. Do NOT use CF-A-TR in Subject Recognition mode you will be very unhappy.

Eh? So why did you say that you couldn't wait to try it out on birds at the end of your post?

Only that I wanted to see if the 1.3 firmware update made much improvement in that area as well. I hadn't tried it.

-- hide signature --

Name the gear and I've probably owned it and used it.

EZGritz
EZGritz Senior Member • Posts: 6,256
Re: Try This Focus Trick On Your OM-1
1

I'm going to post the photos with some background info so people can decide for themselves.

 EZGritz's gear list:EZGritz's gear list
Olympus E-M5 III OM-1 Olympus Body Cap Lens 15mm F8.0 Olympus M.Zuiko Digital 17mm F1.8 Olympus M.Zuiko Digital 25mm F1.8 +7 more
EZGritz
EZGritz Senior Member • Posts: 6,256
Re: Try This Focus Trick On Your OM-1

We know each other. I've done this with him before. I can shoot right next to him, follow him from corner to corner. I'll be meeting him there.

The difference between us is he does this every week. He knows the locations, angles, car speeds. He knows when to fire the shutter. I don't. I can take 4,000 photos but I don't want to. The last time we did this he zoomed closer in than I did. That's a matter of experience. I'm not sure I can do this as well as he does. I'll try.  Other than that this will be a fair equipment test because we will be standing near each other.

This is imperfect. I don't know my camera yet. It will be the second time I used it. I'll have to use AF pretty much out of the box because I don't know any better except that I'll use auto subject recognition and CAF. I hope the camera will find helmets and faces through the glass and capture them as well as the R5 does and the images will be as clear and noise free. I don't expect the backgrounds to be as nice because the 40-150 f/2.8 is notorious for making ugly backgrounds. That's a lens problem, not a system problem. The DoF will be two stops different. This should show how much of a delta there is in a real-world shoot. These are the things I'm looking to compare:

* Will the OM-1 capture helmets and faces - the biggest and most important difference I saw using an EM5.3 and the 14-150

* Will the images be as clean and noise-free in low light

* Will the subject separation be similar or a lot different

If year to all three I'll have to conclude the OM-1 is as good as the R5 for this use case. That's what I want to know. I think shooting side by side and comparing the images on the same computer is the best way to know. Random photos is not. - A few out of each camera does not produce an accurate conclusion because distance to the subject and the background and lighting can be vastly different and can skew the results. I expect the school photographer to make better photos overall because of his experience but a few of the same car, in the same location at the same time viewed on the same monitor should be able to answer my questions. That's the theory. I'm more interested in how they compare in the field in a real-world photoshoot outdoors in relatively low light. The forecast is rain and a temperature range for 40-50. there will be lots of mud, muddy water, and small rocks thrown up in the air. Perfect!

 EZGritz's gear list:EZGritz's gear list
Olympus E-M5 III OM-1 Olympus Body Cap Lens 15mm F8.0 Olympus M.Zuiko Digital 17mm F1.8 Olympus M.Zuiko Digital 25mm F1.8 +7 more
EZGritz
EZGritz Senior Member • Posts: 6,256
Re: Try This Focus Trick On Your OM-1

Did you see an improvement?

 EZGritz's gear list:EZGritz's gear list
Olympus E-M5 III OM-1 Olympus Body Cap Lens 15mm F8.0 Olympus M.Zuiko Digital 17mm F1.8 Olympus M.Zuiko Digital 25mm F1.8 +7 more
ahaslett
ahaslett Forum Pro • Posts: 12,651
Re: Try This Focus Trick On Your OM-1

ProDude wrote:

Tumulous wrote:

ProDude wrote:

EZGritz wrote:

My friends with Z9s think they did better with their Nikon DSLRs. They are not satisfied wiht the Z9

I have a friend who is a sports shooter and he tried a Z9 and A1 sending them back. He is thrilled with the ergo's and setup and performance of the OM-1. He said he get's very close to the 100% keeper rate which the others didn't come close to. I've noted several posts and Youtube's floating around of others that used an A1 or Z9 and found the OM-1 superior in ALL regards. But it's like some well kept (more like buried) secret that doesn't sit well with the fanatical FF crowd. Oh well. it's their money. I sent one back for a refund as it brought NOTHING to the table my OM-1 wasn't doing.

So how come you reordered a Sony A7RV only a couple of days after writing that and now have it in your possession?

Well, not like I have to apologize. I decided after careful examination of the images I took during the trial, that the A7R5 would make some sense for the landscape and portrait use. It's not like I NEED it. More of a want. I tend to shoot birds perched far away and such and the cropability of a 61mp FF setup does have it's merits. I just figured it might be a decent 2nd body to have around for some applications. One thing is for sure. If I travel on a vacation and such or attempt to shoot fast moving subjects, the OM-1 will be THE body and lens combo in my bag.

You are not alone in that!

Also, having MFT and FE mounts gives a very large set of lens and body options.  The A7Rv is a significant step up from the A7Riv but I can’t justify it in my mind.

Andrew

-- hide signature --

Infinite are the arguments of mages. Truth is a jewel with many facets. Ursula K LeGuin
Please feel free to edit any images that I post

 ahaslett's gear list:ahaslett's gear list
Sigma DP1 Merrill Sigma DP3 Merrill Olympus E-M1 Sony a7R Panasonic Lumix DMC-GM1 +33 more
OP ProDude Senior Member • Posts: 4,855
Re: Try This Focus Trick On Your OM-1

EZGritz wrote:

Did you see an improvement?

With human face/eye detection indeed I noted it was able to pick them up from a greater distance. Also was immediate in general to create that box around the face and then a small eye box. I did find using the TR mode added to tracking with humans it tends to stay right on the head better waiting for the person to turn their head to face you more. It even grabbed the eye on the side of the face which impressed me.

For animals it doesn't need the TR mode at all as it puts a box around their body immediately and nails the eye very well indeed. So I'd say the 1.3 certainly did make an improvement.

-- hide signature --

Name the gear and I've probably owned it and used it.

OP ProDude Senior Member • Posts: 4,855
Re: Try This Focus Trick On Your OM-1

ahaslett wrote:

You are not alone in that!

Also, having MFT and FE mounts gives a very large set of lens and body options. The A7Rv is a significant step up from the A7Riv but I can’t justify it in my mind.

Andrew

I will be curious to see just how much faster and more accurate the A7R5 is at grabbing and holding onto a face/eye. Lower light seems to be very challenging in this regard with my OM-1. We shall see........

-- hide signature --

Name the gear and I've probably owned it and used it.

ahaslett
ahaslett Forum Pro • Posts: 12,651
Re: Try This Focus Trick On Your OM-1

ProDude wrote:

ahaslett wrote:

You are not alone in that!

Also, having MFT and FE mounts gives a very large set of lens and body options. The A7Rv is a significant step up from the A7Riv but I can’t justify it in my mind.

Andrew

I will be curious to see just how much faster and more accurate the A7R5 is at grabbing and holding onto a face/eye. Lower light seems to be very challenging in this regard with my OM-1. We shall see........

The OM1 in SAF focusses on ordinary targets like stationary number plates in near darkness.  It carries on when the A7Riv gives up.  I doubt the Riv will beat the OM1 at that.

The A7Riv is already pretty good at EyeAF and head following in CAF-TR.

Interested to hear you get on.

Andrew

-- hide signature --

Infinite are the arguments of mages. Truth is a jewel with many facets. Ursula K LeGuin
Please feel free to edit any images that I post

 ahaslett's gear list:ahaslett's gear list
Sigma DP1 Merrill Sigma DP3 Merrill Olympus E-M1 Sony a7R Panasonic Lumix DMC-GM1 +33 more
EZGritz
EZGritz Senior Member • Posts: 6,256
Re: Try This Focus Trick On Your OM-1
2

Sounds good. I'll try it for the first time Sunday. I used FW1.2 for birds one-time last year. It was impressive. Way better than the EM1.2 with its latest FW.

People who haven't tried the OM-1 and are holding off for whatever reason don't know what they're missing. I didn't until I bought one. So far I think I can get the same photo with the last-generation sensor most of the time but the OM-1 is so much easier and so much more fun. This is a better experience than with any camera I ever bought and I've enjoyed many of them.

I'm lucky to have a big, successful local store. The manager says they sold a hell of a lot of OM-1s last year, maybe the most of any body. They have a lot of high-end FF customers who bought them. He didn't know if it was the best-selling body because he didn't have a count in early December. He said it might have been and he isn't getting any of them back. They will take back any product they sell after a 14-day trial. I thought I might return it until I had a day of shooting birds with it. After that, no way.

They had a backlog of deposits on the 150-400 until December when they had the first one for inventory. He didn't get any of those back either. I expect them to show up at the lake this spring.

 EZGritz's gear list:EZGritz's gear list
Olympus E-M5 III OM-1 Olympus Body Cap Lens 15mm F8.0 Olympus M.Zuiko Digital 17mm F1.8 Olympus M.Zuiko Digital 25mm F1.8 +7 more
OP ProDude Senior Member • Posts: 4,855
Re: Try This Focus Trick On Your OM-1

ahaslett wrote:

ProDude wrote:

ahaslett wrote:

You are not alone in that!

Also, having MFT and FE mounts gives a very large set of lens and body options. The A7Rv is a significant step up from the A7Riv but I can’t justify it in my mind.

Andrew

I will be curious to see just how much faster and more accurate the A7R5 is at grabbing and holding onto a face/eye. Lower light seems to be very challenging in this regard with my OM-1. We shall see........

The OM1 in SAF focusses on ordinary targets like stationary number plates in near darkness. It carries on when the A7Riv gives up. I doubt the Riv will beat the OM1 at that.

The A7Riv is already pretty good at EyeAF and head following in CAF-TR.

Interested to hear you get on.

Andrew

Oh believe me this isn't a fight between the two cameras. The OM-1 is my "Go To" in probably at least 75% or more of all cases. You're right, at -8ev with a fast lens the OM-1 will best a Sony A7R5 all day long at -4ev. But I don't usually shoot in even lower light, so it's not much of a challenge to me. But you can bet I'll be stressing it out to see what it CAN do. The OM already passed all the tests with flying colors. I simply wanted to see what it would be like to have a NATIVE higher rez camera on board for those portrait and landscape stuff I do. We'll see. I'm not 100% on board. It is a heck of a machine though. Just want to see how much of it's goodies actually work.

-- hide signature --

Name the gear and I've probably owned it and used it.

ahaslett
ahaslett Forum Pro • Posts: 12,651
Re: Try This Focus Trick On Your OM-1

ProDude wrote:

ahaslett wrote:

ProDude wrote:

ahaslett wrote:

You are not alone in that!

Also, having MFT and FE mounts gives a very large set of lens and body options. The A7Rv is a significant step up from the A7Riv but I can’t justify it in my mind.

Andrew

I will be curious to see just how much faster and more accurate the A7R5 is at grabbing and holding onto a face/eye. Lower light seems to be very challenging in this regard with my OM-1. We shall see........

The OM1 in SAF focusses on ordinary targets like stationary number plates in near darkness. It carries on when the A7Riv gives up. I doubt the Riv will beat the OM1 at that.

The A7Riv is already pretty good at EyeAF and head following in CAF-TR.

Interested to hear you get on.

Andrew

Oh believe me this isn't a fight between the two cameras. The OM-1 is my "Go To" in probably at least 75% or more of all cases. You're right, at -8ev with a fast lens the OM-1 will best a Sony A7R5 all day long at -4ev. But I don't usually shoot in even lower light, so it's not much of a challenge to me. But you can bet I'll be stressing it out to see what it CAN do. The OM already passed all the tests with flying colors. I simply wanted to see what it would be like to have a NATIVE higher rez camera on board for those portrait and landscape stuff I do. We'll see. I'm not 100% on board. It is a heck of a machine though. Just want to see how much of it's goodies actually work.

I have a similar split of uses.

Andrew

-- hide signature --

Infinite are the arguments of mages. Truth is a jewel with many facets. Ursula K LeGuin
Please feel free to edit any images that I post

 ahaslett's gear list:ahaslett's gear list
Sigma DP1 Merrill Sigma DP3 Merrill Olympus E-M1 Sony a7R Panasonic Lumix DMC-GM1 +33 more
Dan Veteran Member • Posts: 4,383
Re: Try This Focus Trick On Your OM-1

Sounds like a plan and good luck.  Maybe you can chimp whilst he's chimping lol.  

Will be interested in your results and thoughts comparing the two.

Dan

 Dan's gear list:Dan's gear list
Canon EOS 5DS R Nikon D5 Olympus OM-D E-M1X GoPro Fusion
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum MMy threads