DPReview.com is closing April 10th - Find out more

Minolta xg-1 lens fitment

Started 9 months ago | Discussions
Darren9857 New Member • Posts: 1
Minolta xg-1 lens fitment

Hi folks,

My name is Darren and I'm from Ireland and looking for some help in regards to purchasing a zoom lens for a minolta xg-1. A zoom lens in particular I'm just looking for some advice on what mount lens fits the camera or is there other brands of lens can can be used on the minolta with or without an adaptor?

Any help would be greatly appreciated 😊

sybersitizen Forum Pro • Posts: 24,269
Re: Minolta xg-1 lens fitment

Do you want a wideangle zoom? A midrange zoom? A telephoto zoom?

Whichever it is, I suggest looking for Minolta branded manual focus (not autofocus) lenses marked with the MC or MD designation. Third party companies produced lenses that are compatible with your camera, but the Minoltas are among the best quality-wise.

MikeInOr
MikeInOr Senior Member • Posts: 1,630
Re: Minolta xg-1 lens fitment

Minolta manual focus cameras use SR mount lenses. There are two different camera interfaces on the Minolta cameras for SR lenses, the MC and MD versions of the SR lenses.

"MD - In 1977, theXDseries introduced an additional tab on the lens which reported the smallest available aperture (f/16, f/22, or f/32) to the camera to accomplish shutter priority automatic exposure in S mode on the Minolta XD-7 (XD-11 in the U.S.A.), and later in the P (programmed automatic exposure) mode on the X-700. The proper use of this feature meant that the lenses had to be set to their smallest aperture. In 1981, MD lenses included a minimum aperture lock that prevented the aperture ring from accidentally being moved."

"The Minolta XG-1, introduced in 1978, was the second autoexposure camera model of the XG series of 35mm SLR film cameras produced from Minolta. Launched one year after the more sophisticated XG-7, the XG-1 was a lower-priced alternative. The model, however, is still fitted with the 'Touch Switch' system, which puts the camera's electronics on stand-by when powered up and activated by a touch of the shutter button."

You can use any SR mount lens (MC or MD version) with your XG-1. A MD lens will allow you to use the auto exposer mode of your XG-1 where the MC lenses will not.

The Minolta MD Rokkor-X 50mm F/1.7 lens is good inexpensive lens that will work very nicely with your XG-1. It will be a great place to start getting your feet wet with film photography. Depending on what you want to shoot and how you evolve as you get more comfortable with film cameras there are a huge range of SR mount lenses that will work well with your XG-1 camera. Minolta SR mount lenses are pretty inexpensive currently so I would recommend staying with Minolta branded lenses instead of purchasing third party lenses like Vivitar, Five Star or Quantara.

Zoom lenses have progressed immensely since the advent of computer aided optical design. As such older manual focus Minolta zoom lenses are going to be a big compromise between image quality for the convenience of being a zoom. Third party zoom lenses are generally going to have bigger image quality compromises.

If you must have a zoom lens I would guess that you would want a normal (wide angle thru telephoto) lens as a general use lens. The MINOLTA MD ZOOM 35-70㎜ f/3.5 is a good starting point for SR zoom lenses that will work nicely with your XG-1.

For best image quality, sharpness, contrast, flare resistance, etc. I recommend sticking with prime lenses for your XG-1.

 MikeInOr's gear list:MikeInOr's gear list
Sony SLT-A55 Sony a7R IV Sony 20mm F2.8 Sony 100mm F2.8 Macro Sony FE 12-24mm F4 +11 more
Michael Fritzen Veteran Member • Posts: 6,741
Re: Minolta xg-1 lens fitment

MikeInOr wrote:

... Third party zoom lenses are generally going to have bigger image quality compromises....

From own experience I can add that this is true!. Because of budget limitations I got 3rd party zoom  and started to regret it soon after. Then I saved up money and together with trading in the 3rd party lens I finally got a "true" Minolta Tele Zoom - which I kept until going to digital.

-- hide signature --

Cheers,
Michael Fritzen

sybersitizen Forum Pro • Posts: 24,269
Re: Minolta xg-1 lens fitment
2

MikeInOr wrote:

You can use any SR mount lens (MC or MD version) with your XG-1.

Right.

A MD lens will allow you to use the auto exposer mode of your XG-1 where the MC lenses will not.

That's incorrect.

The only autoexposure mode in the XG-1 is Aperture Priority mode, which works exactly the same whether the lens is MC or MD.

MC lenses will even work with the Shutter Priority AE mode of the XD series and the Program AE mode of the X-700 as long as the user remembers to set the aperture to the minimum f-stop. MC lenses lack the tabs that lock the minimum f-stop in place and signal the camera that it's been done, but those are just technicalities - not requirements.

FrancoD Forum Pro • Posts: 19,261
Re: Minolta xg-1 lens fitment

As stated you look for Minolta MC or MD mount lenses. Most often the third party lenses will have "for Minolta" or indeed MD printed on the rear  lens cap.

There are plenty of decent non Minolta made lenses but to give you an idea, if you cannot get the original Minolta look for Tamron SP, Tokina ATX and Vivitar Series I.

azul_liquido New Member • Posts: 1
Re: Minolta xg-1 lens fitment

Hi, this is my first message.

I'm trying to help a friend with an old XG-1.

I'm wondering which wide angle we should use for some night sky shoots.

It seems that the 16mm 2.8 would do the job but it looks a bit pricey after some research.

Is there any other you guys would recommend?

We would like to have something really wide, 16mm at least, (if it's 14mm even better) and with a decent aperture for low light (2.8, for example).

I am trying to figure out if there will be mount adapters that will allow me to use other lenses.

I would appreciate any help.

Thanks.

photogopinion Regular Member • Posts: 196
Re: Minolta xg-1 lens fitment

Darren9857 wrote:

Hi folks,

My name is Darren and I'm from Ireland and looking for some help in regards to purchasing a zoom lens for a minolta xg-1. A zoom lens in particular I'm just looking for some advice on what mount lens fits the camera or is there other brands of lens can can be used on the minolta with or without an adaptor?

Any help would be greatly appreciated 😊

There are three very good Minolta zoom lenses: 35-70 f3.5  or, optically the same but the Macro variety, the 35-70 f3.5 Macro. (Famously, Leica had Minolta design this for them.) An excellent lens. Then there is the 75-150 f4, and the somewhat heavier and larger (and obviously longer range) 70-210 f4.

If you go for the ‘MD’ designation, you can’t really go wrong, and none of these three are usually expensive. Best, given that, to go for Minoltas rather than the third party ones though some might be very cheap. (There were Sigmas, Vivitars, Tamrons, Tokinas and one or two others, but it’s generally agreed Minolta made some superb lenses and most people think they have a particularly special colour IQ. Some third party lenses could be pretty poor, and as few reviews of them are now extant, it would be difficult to find the better ones, so it’s really best to avoid them.)

Also recommended would be a standard 50mm f1.7, 28mm f2.8 or (a focal length that’s currently being ‘discovered’ on Youtube) the small ‘pancake’ 45mm. A useful site for modern assessments of Minolta’s ‘’MD/MC’ lenses is Philip Reeve:

https://phillipreeve.net/blog/manual-minolta-lens-ratings/

PS: technically, yes, the Minolta mount for all its manual focus cameras is the ‘SR’ mount, but everybody tended to use ‘MC’ or ‘MD’ from the designations of the later lenses. The only difference between them was, as some point out, there was a tab on the MD lenses which locked the aperture at f22, or the smallest, for use on cameras like the x700.

 photogopinion's gear list:photogopinion's gear list
Sony a6000 Sony a77 II Sony DT 16-80mm F3.5-4.5 ZA Carl Zeiss Vario-Sonnar T* Sony 70-300mm F4.5-5.6 G SSM Sony E 20mm F2.8 +1 more
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum MMy threads