DPReview.com is closing April 10th - Find out more

Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1

Started Jan 25, 2022 | Discussions
Hlouis New Member • Posts: 3
Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1

I am looking to upgrade from my now old Stylus 1 and was wondering if anyone has found a better all in one system that the Stylus 1? I would like a bigger zoom range like 400-600 in about the same compact size than the stylus. Also looking for a better dynamic range SOOC. I shoot jpegs and always have to do a batch adjustment with auto tone correction to get the best result. I have tried various in camera settings for gradation but it seems not as efficient as the OV3 auto tone correction. I shoot a mix of animal, scenery and city. Thanks for your recommendations.

John McCormack
John McCormack Veteran Member • Posts: 7,098
Re: Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1

My choice would be the Panasonic FZ300 since it has similar specs to the Stylus 1 but is bigger. I own one and like it a lot but prefer Olympus colors. Currently the FZ is in stock at a good price at the big online sellers.

Highlights

  • 12.1MP 1/2.3" MOS Sensor
  • Venus Engine Image Processor
  • Leica DC Vario-Elmarit f/2.8 Lens (constant all the way to 600mm.)
  • 25-600mm (35mm Equivalent)
  • 1.44m-Dot 0.7x OLED EVF
  • 3.0" 1.04m-Dot Free-Angle Touchscreen
  • 4K UHD Video Recording at 30 fps
  • Built-In Wi-Fi Connectivity
  • ISO 6400, 12-fps Shooting, 4K Photo Mode
  • 5-Axis HYBRID O.I.S.+, DFD AF System
Michael Meissner
Michael Meissner Forum Pro • Posts: 27,998
Re: Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1

John McCormack wrote:

My choice would be the Panasonic FZ300 since it has similar specs to the Stylus 1 but is bigger. I own one and like it a lot but prefer Olympus colors. Currently the FZ is in stock at a good price at the big online sellers.

I have both the FZ300 and the Stylus-1. I've been thinking of selling the FZ300 since I also own micro 4/3rds cameras, and I haven't used the FZ300 in awhile. I bought it used for a vacation in Hawaii in 2018, and I haven't used it much after 2019.

Note, I only shoot JPG. I do use the 2x electronic zoom on Olympus gear (but not on Panasonic gear where I feel it degrades the image, but the Olympus 2x zoom does not degrade the image as much). Because I use the 2x electronic zoom, the extra zoom range on the FZ300 doesn't buy me that much.

Part of the issue is the size. It is the same size as my E-m5 mark 1 or mark III with the 14-150mm f/4-5.6 lens. But obviously, if you don't have the larger high end gear, the weight and size calculation will be different. The main reason I like the Stylus-1 is I can put the camera in a pants or jacket pocket, and only take it out if I'm going to take pictures. With the FZ300 (or the micro 4/3rds gear), you need to carry it around with either a camera bag or on a neck/shoulder strap. Or I can throw the Stylus-1 it in a cramped suitcase a lot easier.

The FZ300 uses a 1/2.3" sensor, while the Stylus-1 uses the 1/1.7" sensor. While both cameras have a f/2.8 lens, I feel the Stylus-1 is better at low light without a flash shots. I would probably rate it as a stop better. Where I might usually shoot the Stylus-1 up to ISO 800 and sometimes push it to ISO 1600, I would typically want the FZ300 to be at ISO 400 and push it to ISO 800. Unfortunately, I don't track the FZ300 in my photography statistics, so I can't say how often I've used it at higher ISO's. I attribute this to a combination of the sensor size and Panasonics JPG algorithms tend to make the picture turn to mush sooner than the Olympus.

But the FZ300 does have some advantages:

  • It is splash resistant, and I have shot with it in light rain.
  • It has a native zoom of the equivalent of 25-600mm without using electronic zoom.
  • It is better for recording movies (fully articulating screen, external microphone, support for using a dummy battery, 4K video support, etc.).
  • You can use filters like polarizing filters directly.
  • It is newer than the Stylus-1, and it is still being sold by Panasonic.
  • It has an OLED viewfinder which means if you wear polarized sunglasses, you won't get distortions in the viewfinder when shooting in horizontal mode.
 Michael Meissner's gear list:Michael Meissner's gear list
Olympus Stylus 1 Olympus TG-5 Olympus E-M5 III OM-1 Olympus M.Zuiko Digital ED 9-18mm F4.0-5.6 +13 more
daverebel New Member • Posts: 17
Re: Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1

I have & still use the Stylus 1 occasionally. There are no true heirs to the Stylus 1. If you want a camera with better image quality with a decent zoom that fits in a pocket (even a jacket pocket), you are limited to 200mm or under.  And you will want a 1 inch sensor type camera for better image quality.  See either the Sony RX100VI or VII (24-200mm), or the Canon G5X II (24-120mm).  I have the Sony VII and use it a lot (biggest issue for me is poor battery life), and have used the Canon G5X (found the zoom too limiting & autofocus was much slower--not sure how much faster the AF is on the Mark II). You can tweak the JPEG output of the Sony as you see fit, and I find it pretty good.  If you are willing to go bigger, the Panasonic FZ300 as noted earlier, but I would actually say go for the Panasonic FZ1000 (I, or Mark II if you want a touchscreen). The FZ1000 image quality with its 1 inch sensor is much better than the FZ300's smaller sensor.

Nacha Regular Member • Posts: 467
Re: Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1
4

i think a real upgrade would be the sony rx10 mk iii or iv. otherwise  i think these other cameras are really more lateral moves. of course it is a much bigger camera, but has very sophisticated tech and a big lens.

 Nacha's gear list:Nacha's gear list
Olympus E-M1 Olympus 7-14mm F2.8 Pro
Smaug01
MOD Smaug01 Veteran Member • Posts: 6,966
Re: Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1
4

Firstly, welcome to DPR fora! I hope you enjoy your stay.

Secondly, I don't think there is a path you can take that will let you have it all. A lot of us have tried it.

If you want the better dynamic range, while still having this zoom range, it means you'll need a bigger sensor, which means bigger lenses and something bigger to carry around.

As someone suggested, you could go with a Lumix FZ300, but you will actually LOSE dynamic range and low light capability. (because it has a smaller sensor)

In essence, you have to pick your poison.

I can tell you from my experience that I started with compact, fixed lens digital cameras with smaller sensors. I started with 1/2.3" sensors, like everyone. Then went to 1/1.7" sensors in the Olympus XZ-1 and Pentax MX-1. Then on to 1" sensors in a couple of Canons. I've also tried APS-C, µ4/3 and FF.

For compact, fixed lens cameras, the sweet spot is 1/1.7" with an excellent lens.

When I went to the Canons with their 1" sensors, the lens designs were so compromised that the sharpness was noticeably degraded from 1/1.7", so I wouldn't go that path. I had a G9x and a G7x II.

Going up to µ4/3 and keeping your Stylus-1 seems like a good way to go: you would not be committing to something that needs huge lenses, but bigger than you're used to with the Stylus-1. When you decide to take the µ4/3, you would buy and choose your lenses carefully. Decide whether you want a point & shoot style body with only the rear screen or if you want something a bit bulkier to have a proper viewfinder.

The setup I have is an E-M10 III, which is a compact SLR-style body. It has a viewfinder, which I wanted, but is still light and relatively compact. It's not trying to be heavy and pro like the E-M5 and E-M1 models. I have a nice array of lenses for it, and try to choose just a few, sometimes just one that I might need for the day's shooting. The "prism housing" on the camera makes it pocket-hostile, but that's the cost of having a viewfinder.

If you want it to still be (jacket) pocketable, you could go with a late E-PL body, which are more compact, and have Olympus' excellent collapsible "pancake" zoom mounted. That gives you a 28-86 eq. rig that is very small. Then, have a simple telephoto zoom in another pocket in case you need it. Olympus 40-150 f/4-5.6 is great and not expensive.

By the way, "pocketable" is just a size and bulk reference. I don't recommend putting ANY of these cameras in your pocket without some kind of case, or the cameras will end up with lint and dust inside them, either jamming up the works or making the sensor dirty.

A very common kit that I take is the E-M10 body, the 12-60 zoom lens (all around), the 17/1.8 (fast prime for low light), and the body cap fisheye (ultra-wide, takes up almost NO room)

When I don't want to deal with that, I take the Pentax MX-1 and accept that I won't have ultra-wide or super-tele.

Hlouis wrote:

I am looking to upgrade from my now old Stylus 1 and was wondering if anyone has found a better all in one system that the Stylus 1? I would like a bigger zoom range like 400-600 in about the same compact size than the stylus. Also looking for a better dynamic range SOOC. I shoot jpegs and always have to do a batch adjustment with auto tone correction to get the best result. I have tried various in camera settings for gradation but it seems not as efficient as the OV3 auto tone correction. I shoot a mix of animal, scenery and city. Thanks for your recommendations.

-- hide signature --

-Jeremy
*********
"A book breaks the shackles of time."
-Carl Sagan

 Smaug01's gear list:Smaug01's gear list
Panasonic Lumix DMC-TS30 Ricoh GR III Olympus OM-D E-M10 III Nikon Z5 Olympus M.Zuiko Digital ED 40-150mm F4-5.6 R +25 more
nearly-an-old-codger
nearly-an-old-codger Veteran Member • Posts: 5,115
agree +1

I own 2 om-d m1ii and a tough tg5 so use oly as well as my sony rx100 (zoom out to 200mm pocket rocket 1 inch sensor) as well as my sony a7riv.

the guys at my camera club are very happy with the sony rx10 mk iv and win awards competing against larger sensor cameras. as the mod said below its all about compromise.

the em 10 is a nice size capable camera

-- hide signature --

Brian

 nearly-an-old-codger's gear list:nearly-an-old-codger's gear list
Ricoh GR III Leica Q2 Monochrom OM-1 Olympus 40-150mm F2.8 Pro Olympus 8mm F1.8 Fisheye Pro +10 more
OP Hlouis New Member • Posts: 3
Re: Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1
3

Thank you everyone for you suggestions and welcome.

After reading your posts I have the feeling that there is really no similar improved package and that I will have to give up on something. What I really like about the stylus is the compactness and lightness of the camera, the constant aperture and the viewfinder. I stopped following new camera release since I bought the stylus1 in 2015. I thought there would be new choices similar to what the Stylus offered 7 years ago. For me it was the perfect direction for a point and shoot.

The Sony RX10 is very tempting but I don't think I can deal with the size and weight. Same for all the Panasonic. They are in a different category for portability. The Sony Rx100 seems very good but the 200 telephoto is a bit too short for my need. I might stick with the stylus for now and deal with the x2 digital Zoom for additional range.

OP Hlouis New Member • Posts: 3
Re: Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1

I was reading on the TCON-17X 1.7x teleconverter. This could be a great option for me since  I am looking for more range. It's not clear to me if it gives you access to the full range when attached or only full tele?

WillF Regular Member • Posts: 375
Re: Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1

See Imaging-Resource's review of the Stylus1 with the tcon 17x, it mentions zoom range possible with tcon 17x attached (5.9x to 10.7x), I think.

https://www.imaging-resource.com/news/2014/05/10/olympus-stylus-1-meets-tcon-17-transformation

-Will

tomhongkong Veteran Member • Posts: 4,699
Re: Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1
2

Hlouis wrote:

I was reading on the TCON-17X 1.7x teleconverter. This could be a great option for me since I am looking for more range. It's not clear to me if it gives you access to the full range when attached or only full tele?

I have the TCON-17 but honestly cannot recommend it.  I plan on taking it back to UK next month and Ebaying it, it is that useless (for me) The beauty of the stylus 1 is its compactness, and that is lost with the TC, and the image quality is not that good either!  Others will disagree and that's fine.

The Stylus 1 is really unique and there is no upgrade for it yet especially if you like the long, fast, lens (as I do).  I find it is a really interesting camera to have.  The controls have obviously been designed by a real photographer (unlike many other models, it seems) The RX100 is fiddly to use, even though the Mk vii has a lens nearly as long (after cropping). The Panasonic TZ200 has muddy IQ compared with S1.  The biggest S1 shortcoming for me is the lack of water resistance.

I have an EM5iii and an EM1ii and each camera has its place and use.  (e.g. EM5iii with 12-200 for boating pics, EM1 with 100-400 for wildlife). If I am going on a casual trip or picnic the S1 in a small belt holster is no trouble to carry which either of the EMs would be.

Of course it needs a bit of PP to make the results sparkle, having said that, with PL5 and Deep Prime I find it is often very good.  There are other cheaper software packages  which need a bit more work to PP.

Actually I have two S1s in case one packs up!  I like it that much.  Don't give up on it, you will be disappointed!

tom

Neoredpill Regular Member • Posts: 121
Re: Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1
1

Hlouis wrote:

I am looking to upgrade from my now old Stylus 1 and was wondering if anyone has found a better all in one system that the Stylus 1? I would like a bigger zoom range like 400-600 in about the same compact size than the stylus. Also looking for a better dynamic range SOOC. I shoot jpegs and always have to do a batch adjustment with auto tone correction to get the best result. I have tried various in camera settings for gradation but it seems not as efficient as the OV3 auto tone correction. I shoot a mix of animal, scenery and city. Thanks for your recommendations.

Nothing in my opinion compares in terms of handling and pocketable size. In the past I've had a RX100 m4, the image quality is better, zoom range is not so good and the handling is awful as the battery life. So I've sold it.

I prefer the joy of using dials and the handling of the Stylus1, a successor could be a big success in my opinion.

John McCormack
John McCormack Veteran Member • Posts: 7,098
Re: Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1
2

Neoredpill wrote:

Hlouis wrote:

I am looking to upgrade from my now old Stylus 1 and was wondering if anyone has found a better all in one system that the Stylus 1? I would like a bigger zoom range like 400-600 in about the same compact size than the stylus. Also looking for a better dynamic range SOOC. I shoot jpegs and always have to do a batch adjustment with auto tone correction to get the best result. I have tried various in camera settings for gradation but it seems not as efficient as the OV3 auto tone correction. I shoot a mix of animal, scenery and city. Thanks for your recommendations.

Nothing in my opinion compares in terms of handling and pocketable size. In the past I've had a RX100 m4, the image quality is better, zoom range is not so good and the handling is awful as the battery life. So I've sold it.

I prefer the joy of using dials and the handling of the Stylus1, a successor could be a big success in my opinion.

+1. I had the same experience with the RX100 IV. Sure it's smaller but menus are awful compared to Olympus. My Stylus 1copy has been very reliable except that the capacitor for date & time loses memory when the battery is removed. My wife says the same about me. 🙃

InkedMarie
InkedMarie Senior Member • Posts: 2,403
Re: Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1
1

John McCormack wrote:

+1. I had the same experience with the RX100 IV. Sure it's smaller but menus are awful compared to Olympus. My Stylus 1copy has been very reliable except that the capacitor for date & time loses memory when the battery is removed. My wife says the same about me. 🙃

LOL I literally spit coffee out! If your wife finds a battery for you....let me k ow be my husband sure needs one.

Marie

 InkedMarie's gear list:InkedMarie's gear list
Olympus Stylus 1s Olympus OM-D E-M10 II Olympus M.Zuiko Digital ED 40-150mm F4-5.6 R Olympus 12-100mm F4.0 7artisans 7.5mm F2.8 Fisheye
elliottnewcomb Forum Pro • Posts: 18,223
Re: Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1
4

Hlouis wrote:

I was reading on the TCON-17X 1.7x teleconverter. This could be a great option for me since I am looking for more range. It's not clear to me if it gives you access to the full range when attached or only full tele?

I'll add a late welcome to the forum, I just saw this, I've been inactive, sporadic at best.

........................................

There is simply nothing else like the Stylus 1, many of us buy spares. I worked hard to learn mine, posted my setup suggestions here:

https://www.dpreview.com/forums/thread/3729814

My advice:

1. buy a spare when you see a good deal

2. try/learn the 2X feature (in-camera crop and in-camera upscale back to 12mp).

you get (ALL F2.8) camera 28-300mm optical + 2X: 301-600mm in ONE Jacket Pocket.

3. Get thee a TCON 1.7X, you will love it. 28-510mm optical + 2X: 511 to 1,020mm.

Did I say 1,020mm F2.8? Yes I did! Amazing.

In TWO Jacket Pockets, nicely balanced, while walking about

or, in a Shoulder Bag loose or with it attached, this one is only 9" long (that's an rx100m1 in pants pocket case alongside the barrel).

you need an adapter tube which allows the camera's lens to extend within/behind the conversion lens

This vacation package is Oly; Plus 1.7X; Plus rx100m6; Plus MagFilter CPL ...

I simply mix and match my bags as needed, the base Stylus fits the brown belt/shoulder bag

.........................................

Oly 2X is better than Sony's similar CIZ in three ways

1. Image Quality

better results, so good it is hard to recognize it was used.

2. Implementation

Oly's 2X is a toggle, INSTANTLY doubling any optical focal length, and instantly back to optical original. After you instantly double, you can zoom further in or out, and instantly return to optical from anywhere.

Sony's is a slow progressive zoom, slow into extra reach and slow back out. You have to first zoom to the end of optical, then zoom bit by bit into CIZ.

3. information

Sony: you will need to dig into the photo's EXIF properties to find out IF and what amount of CIZ was used. (see Digital Zoom info)

Oly: if you remember to tell the camera in the menu that the tele lens (or wide lens) is on, the camera will do the 1.7x (or 0,8x) math for you, showing the effective 35mm equivalent in EXIF.

My Stylus 1 is my Sports Camera (4 active grandkids), lots of fast bright reach.

When the children were just beginning, when I could walk the sidelines, I could use my rx100m1 f1.8 quite effectively. when the fields get bigger, not allowed along the sidelines, the bright reach of the Stylus 1 is needed.

In good light, the Sony m6 or m7, using 280mm SMART ZOOM (10mp image size/in-camera optical crop) is darn good, but it will be f4.5

...............................................

Panasonic. Not for me.

years ago, prior to the longer reach Sony m6,m7 I tried a longer reach Pany. Detailed shootout, the Sony bested it for Image Quality of base and extended Jpegs

and, I did not like the Pany Jpeg Colors.

-- hide signature --

Elliott

 elliottnewcomb's gear list:elliottnewcomb's gear list
Sony RX1R Sony RX100 III Olympus Stylus 1s Sony RX100 VI Sony Xperia XZ +1 more
elliottnewcomb Forum Pro • Posts: 18,223
Re: Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1

Hlouis wrote:

It's not clear to me if it gives you access to the full range when attached or only full tele?

When tele is on, no zoom used, it is adding .7x so your minimum optical reach, widest view is 48mm, thus 48-510mm optical, 511-1,020 2X.

-- hide signature --

Elliott

 elliottnewcomb's gear list:elliottnewcomb's gear list
Sony RX1R Sony RX100 III Olympus Stylus 1s Sony RX100 VI Sony Xperia XZ +1 more
Bob A L Veteran Member • Posts: 7,071
Re: Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1
1

The Panasonic ZS100 and ZS200 both have the 1" sensor and 250 or 380mm FF equivalent optical zooms.  But the Stylus 1 is a hard act to follow. These panasonics are smaller, and have the 20mp 1" sensor, but lenses are slower. Just got myself the ZS100 and the verdict is still out on replacing my Stylus 1.  So far, I see the 1" sensor will handle higher iso ratings, and image quality is good, but still learning, and for sure still have my Stylus 1 and intend to keep it also.

Bob A L Veteran Member • Posts: 7,071
Re: Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1
1

In retrospect - it does not exist,  there is no upgrade for it available today.

Ken Croft Senior Member • Posts: 1,803
Re: Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1
  1. The upgrade from the Stylus1 is the Stylus1s, but of course that is just a readily available firmware upgrade which adds a few features. To the person who is happy with Olympus the upgrade would be to a small mft camera. But of course as has been said many times there is no other camera with the features and small size of the S1. In my case my main cameras are Olympus OM-D, but as a knock about I have a Stylus1s. I like it so much I bought a second one as a stand-by, and then for almost no money at all, another complete but non-working Stylus1, that will be a doner camera for parts. I live in SW France and there are dozens of Stylus1 for sale privately from about 130€ to 400€. I even saw a new unused boxed Stylus1 that sold for 150€. Sadly I was too late for that one.
-- hide signature --

Ken C

Ken Croft Senior Member • Posts: 1,803
Re: Upgrade suggestion from Stylus 1

I know that this is an Olympus forum, but I am going to comment upon another brand as a possible upgrade, shock horror!! I have been an Olympus user for many years, my first being a C2000Z in around 2000 and now owning 3 Stylus 1 cameras and a couple of Om-D bodies and a stock of lenses. I like Olympus cameras.

A friend of mine who is beyond any doubt not a photographer has recently bought I camera that I was totally disinterested in, until I handled it yesterday. The guy just wants to take pictures as memories and records of where he has been and what he has seen. He never prints, never does any post processing and needless to say, he does not make fine art. In fact he makes no kind of art at all! Though not a bird watcher he does like to record the distant rare bird he spots on his wanderings, so a long focal length is important to him. His new camera is a Panasonic Lumix TZ90. It has a zoom range from an equivalent focal length of 24mm to  720mm at f3.3 to f6.4. AND it has an electronic viewfinder. It is very slightly lighter than the Stylus1 and about the same size. It feels very solid and chunky and I liked the feel of it a lot. So it beats the Stylus1 at the wide end, which is very good, in my view that is the weakness of the Stylus1. The sensor is slightly smaller than the Stylus1 and the viewfinder is very small, unlike the lovely large EVF on the Stylus1, but at least it does have one. Of course the Stylus 1 has a constant f2.8 but I wonder how many people really value this. Is the smaller sensor of the Lumix significantly different to make a difference to picture snappers who set-and-forget the camera to iAuto? In my opinion, the TZ90 is very definitely worth considering, especially for people who value a really long focal length. The inclusion of an EVF, despite its small size, puts it ahead of most other truly compact cameras for non-photographers. I would be very reluctant to buy any camera that does not have an EVF.

So that is it, traitor that I am.

Ken C

Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum MMy threads