DPReview.com is closing April 10th - Find out more

Samsung Expert Raw (Beta) comparison shots

Started Dec 7, 2021 | Discussions
Saabster Regular Member • Posts: 431
Samsung Expert Raw (Beta) comparison shots

Samsung has released (at least in Korea) a beta of their new Expert Raw camera app only for those on Android 12 and with an S21 Ultra, and it's available on several websites including:  https://www.rmupdate.com/2021/12/01/download-the-samsung-expert-raw-camera-app/

I downloaded it last week and am giving it a try. First a bit of background, I moved to the S21 Ultra from an LG V30. As a photographer I always used Pro Mode and RAW (DNG) for my cell phone photography. When I moved to the S21 ultra I was appalled at the poor quality of the ProMode/Raw images compared to what I was used to. The Straight photo mode which does it's computational processing magic is nothing short of amazing. The JPGs are phenomenal. But the photographer in me called out for more control than the photo give you. With the horrible raw quilty from the stock camera I was frustrated as no amount of processing could give me images like I wanted. Not to mention that it limited me to which lenses could be used.

I downloaded the Expert Raw camera app and gave it a try. The difference was like night and day. gone was the muddy off color, CA fringed images and instead clear color corrected DNG files with a small hint of CA. Plus I could use all the lenses the camera had to offer.

Here's two straight out of camera JPG images one from Expert Raw camera app and one from the Stock camera in Pro Mode. I did no editing on either image. I hope Samsung upgrades the stock camera app with this version of Pro mode.

Samsung Expert Raw JPG SOOC no editing

Samsung S21 Ultra Stock Camera Raw JPG SOOC No Editing

hubert08 New Member • Posts: 21
Re: Samsung Expert Raw (Beta) comparison shots

Hi,

This is a late answer. I have two questions.

Are the RAW files from the telefoto cameras 10 Mpixel Like the sensor size or upscaled 12 MPixel like the jpegs?

Could you provide some RAW samples from all 3 cameras so we can test these samples with pur own RAW development workflow.

I bought a Pixel 6 pro and these RAW files are completely unusable in capture one, RAW Therapie, darktable ... In all programs are the colors very weak and can not really recovered.

I hate surprises like this ...

Thank you

OP Saabster Regular Member • Posts: 431
Re: Samsung Expert Raw (Beta) comparison shots
1

Sure can. First thing is Expert Raw has been officially released and is available in the Samsung App Store. Not the Google Store, but Samsung's own. It's free of course.

Second: Looking at the file sizes, the DNG files range in size based on the camera used.

Here's a link the DNGs All were shot on Auto mode to maintain constancy, only the cameras were changed.

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1hA2BTNuUfnFcvp3h46CScG0k_52zJbPL?usp=sharing

Here's the SOOC jpgs of the same.

Ultrawide camera

Wide /Normal camera

Zoom Camera

Super zoom (10x camera)

Thomas K. Senior Member • Posts: 1,638
Re: Samsung Expert Raw (Beta) comparison shots

Thank you Saabster for the original DNG samples! Would be great so see some daylight outdoor samples at base ISO (50?).

Regards

Thomas

Gzoladz Contributing Member • Posts: 874
Re: Samsung Expert Raw (Beta) comparison shots

Has anyone found the flash settings? I am on an ultra s21 and.

 Gzoladz's gear list:Gzoladz's gear list
Nikon Coolpix P1000
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum MMy threads