DPReview.com is closing April 10th - Find out more

Classic Negative and Bleach Bypass film sims. in Capture One on Macintosh computers

Started Dec 3, 2020 | Discussions
OP RetiringGuy Contributing Member • Posts: 576
Re: Classic Negative and Bleach Bypass film sims. in Capture One on Macintosh computers

sir_c wrote:

RetiringGuy wrote:

(...)

Basically I decided that I would never use Bleach Bypass on any landscape images but that I might occasionally benefit from Classic Negative.

I first thought that too, but Bleach Bypass can work out pretty well in certain cases. It doesn't have that cyan shift of Classic Chrome, nor the weird greens of Classic Negative.

Some recent examples I made
https://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/65021274

I must admit to being an old-codger who is generally stuck in his ways.

Personally I normally prefer my images to be 'natural' (especially the colours) and to that end I have created my own ICC camera profiles for my X-H1 and X-T1 and use those profiles in Capture One using either the 'Film Standard' or 'Linear' curves (i.e. not a film simulation).

The main reason for my writing the original forum post was that at the time I was quite bored and also seeing quite a few forum posts bemoaning the lack of these film simulations for various cameras in Capture One.

As a retired professional engineer I also try to keep my brain active so the challenge of finding a solution was quite attractive.

Looking at your images I can also see where you are coming from but as I said above, I like natural looking images. Thank goodness that we are all different.

RG

Cutrone Silvano New Member • Posts: 4
Re: Classic Negative and Bleach Bypass film sims. in Capture One on Macintosh computers

i can't find it on my mac finder, help me 😀

Cutrone Silvano New Member • Posts: 4
Re: Classic Negative and Bleach Bypass film sims. in Capture One on Macintosh computers

RetiringGuy wrote:

I'll start off by saying that this post is primarily for Capture One users on Apple Macintosh computers.

I don't have a Windows based machine so I have no idea if any of the below might help you Capture One users on Windows.

I don't usually make use of film simulations on my landscape shots. I would normally choose the 'Film Standard' 'Curve' but I will sometimes use the 'Linear' curve. (I like the extra editing freedom.)

Anyway it started by me noticing that there seemed to be many people that wanted film simulations from later cameras than the cameras that they have at present. Especially the 'Classic Negative' and the 'Bleach Bypass' from the X-T3/X-T4 and X-T4 respectively.

So, I started to look at some of the existing film simulations available for my X-H1 and then changed the X-H1 RAW EXIF data to an appropriate value and checked out some more images with the Classic Negative and Bleach Bypass film simulations.

Basically I decided that I would never use Bleach Bypass on any landscape images but that I might occasionally benefit from Classic Negative.

I didn't want to have to go through the hassle of changing the EXIF data of many images just to see whether or not Classic Negative was a potential choice so I decided to try to just make the Classic Negative simulation available for my X-H1 in my Capture One 20 without having to change the file EXIF data.

I found a way to do this and then decided that others might want to do the same thing with that film simulation and Bleach Bypass on other X-T models (e.g Classic Negative and Bleach Bypass for X-H1s and X-T2s and Bleach Bypass on X-T3s). Expect disappointments as I tried the same method for my X-T1 but that just didn't work so I believe that the method is probably sensor dependent. (Colors were close-ish but tonal levels were way down.)

Now for the BUT.

I am willing to say what I did but, not in any detail as I do not want to annoy either Fujifilm or Phase One/Capture One. I am just describing a the abilities and use of the Mac Finder.

So, here goes ;-

The executable(s) i.e. Applications on Apple Macintosh OS(s) (macOS) are actually a 'package' containing its executable(s) and all supporting files and executables needed for the application to run correctly. So the App package must contain the data needed to give you the film simulations.

You can use the Mac Finder to look into the Capture One package (Application) and search for the directory that contains the film curve resources.

In that directory find the film simulation curve file that you want AND its' 9 other supporting files that are needed for that film simulation. (The file naming system makes it relatively easy to identifying those 9 supporting files.)

Select and COPY out to somewhere else the 9 supporting files and the curve file.

Keeping the same file name structure change the names of the copied files appropriately to apply to the camera you want them for.

Make a note of the filenames of the newly renamed files before the next step just in case it doesn't work and you want to delete/remove them.

Copy the renamed files back to the directory from which you copied out the original files.

You should now be able to run Capture One and choose that film simulation without editing the EXIF data.

RG

Example of X-H1 and X-T2 using Classic Negative simulation with X-T3 and X-T4 as references. (Un-adjusted RAW files from the DPR comparison tool.)

Classic Negative on X-H1 andX-T2 without EXIF changes

Example of X-H1, X-T2 and X-T3 using Bleach Bypass with X-T4 as reference. (Un-adjusted RAW files from the DPR comparison tool.)

Bleach Bypass on X-H1, X-T2 and X-T3 without EXIF changes

thank you very much I did it now

sir_c Contributing Member • Posts: 740
Re: Classic Negative and Bleach Bypass film sims. in Capture One on Macintosh computers

I mostly agree with your statement, as I tend to go for more natural looking images. The more artsy ones I use sparingly, as it gets boring really quickly.

But you should keep these in your toolbox for when the situation demands it, rather than ruling them out by principle.

 sir_c's gear list:sir_c's gear list
Fujifilm X-T1 Fujifilm X-T4 Fujifilm XF 35mm F1.4 R Fujifilm XF 14mm F2.8 R Fujifilm XF 18-55mm F2.8-4 R LM OIS +5 more
Rakosky Regular Member • Posts: 289
Re: Classic Negative and Bleach Bypass film sims. in Capture One on Macintosh computers

It works. I would be curious to see a compare between x-pro3 with native classic negative and x-pro2 with this classic negative. Are the images a bit different in color and rendering or they are quite similar?

 Rakosky's gear list:Rakosky's gear list
Fujifilm X-Pro2 Fujifilm X-Pro3 Fujifilm XF 35mm F1.4 R Fujifilm XF 56mm F1.2 R Fujifilm XF 35mm F2 R WR +4 more
fujiian
fujiian Contributing Member • Posts: 718
Re: Classic Negative and Bleach Bypass film sims. in Capture One on Macintosh computers
1

Rakosky wrote:

It works. I would be curious to see a compare between x-pro3 with native classic negative and x-pro2 with this classic negative. Are the images a bit different in color and rendering or they are quite similar?

Same.

I just did this for some X-T2 files and found it to look pretty bad. The difference between Classic Neg and Classic Chrome was shocking. I'll bet the difference in sensors will make converting them all look pretty rough.

To get the nuanced, subtle tweaks to images we're all looking for, it's probably best to lean on user-created film sim packages than shoehorning in simulations made for different cameras... as much as I wish I could 

 fujiian's gear list:fujiian's gear list
Fujifilm X-T2 Fujifilm XF 35mm F1.4 R Fujifilm XF 27mm F2.8 Fujifilm 16-55mm F2.8R LM WR Fujifilm 50-230mm II +4 more
MaxWiltshire New Member • Posts: 1
Re: Classic Negative and Bleach Bypass film sims. in Capture One on Macintosh computers
3

Hi everyone,

I have just tried this with Capture One 21 on Mac.

I wanted to use Classic Neg on my XT2 files and it works fine.

HOWEVER I also thought I would see if I could get the New Nostalgic Neg sim from the GFX100s - and that worked too!

So now I can use both Classic and Nostalgic Neg sims on my XT2 files.

If you want to do this the process is identical - just find the Nostalgic Neg files from the GFX100s section and follow the same process.

Ivan983
Ivan983 Regular Member • Posts: 258
Re: Classic Negative - X-T30?

boogisha wrote:

Portion Control wrote:

But I really just wanted to use this space to complain that the X-T30 doesn’t have Classic Neg “built in” even though it is the same generation as the X-T3, and further, I don’t think the C1 “version” of Classic Neg looks that good. It does offer the simulation for any X-T30 RAWs by default, which is nice. I can’t say for sure since I don’t have an X-T3+ to play around with, but the in-camera Classic Neg images I’ve seen just appear to have a little something extra to my eyes. But eh, maybe it’s just greener grass.

If that will make it any easier for you, not even X-T3 you mentioned has Classic Negative film simulation, either... It was introduced with X-Pro3 - yes, still same generation as both X-T3 and X-T30 - but never brought back, even though there was a lot of speculation (and high hopes, never fulfilled).

why not just setup one in custom sim menu? No difference from X-T4

Otherwise, I do find "Capture One" version of Classic Negative "good enough" - I can`t really say from the first hand experience how it compares to Fuji`s original, and the only drawback is I can`t take JPEGs with it in-camera (as I do sometimes share/print from camera directly).

 Ivan983's gear list:Ivan983's gear list
Panasonic LX100 Fujifilm X-T1 Panasonic Lumix DMC-GX85 Fujifilm X-T2 Sony a7 III +3 more
boogisha
boogisha Senior Member • Posts: 2,858
Re: Classic Negative - X-T30 - film simulation vs "recipe"

Ivan983 wrote:

boogisha wrote:

Portion Control wrote:

But I really just wanted to use this space to complain that the X-T30 doesn’t have Classic Neg “built in” even though it is the same generation as the X-T3, and further, I don’t think the C1 “version” of Classic Neg looks that good. It does offer the simulation for any X-T30 RAWs by default, which is nice. I can’t say for sure since I don’t have an X-T3+ to play around with, but the in-camera Classic Neg images I’ve seen just appear to have a little something extra to my eyes. But eh, maybe it’s just greener grass.

If that will make it any easier for you, not even X-T3 you mentioned has Classic Negative film simulation, either... It was introduced with X-Pro3 - yes, still same generation as both X-T3 and X-T30 - but never brought back, even though there was a lot of speculation (and high hopes, never fulfilled).

why not just setup one in custom sim menu? No difference from X-T4

Because it`s not the same...? And not sure what you mean by "no difference from X-T4"?

While tweaking film simulations can provide some interesting results (not to say occasionally/situationally similar), there are no tweaking options that allow matching what Classic Negative does in a wide variety of situations.

Think of it this way - "film recipes", that is film simulations with additional user configuration/changes, are more of a preset, static customization that is applied pretty much flat (always the same) on top of whatever the camera records for a given scene.

On the other hand, film simulations that Fuji provides can be programmed by Fuji engineers to behave differently depending on different scene and/or camera parameters. That level of in-camera customization is just not available to the user.

Otherwise, I do find "Capture One" version of Classic Negative "good enough" - I can`t really say from the first hand experience how it compares to Fuji`s original, and the only drawback is I can`t take JPEGs with it in-camera (as I do sometimes share/print from camera directly).

 boogisha's gear list:boogisha's gear list
Canon PowerShot A75 Canon ELPH 300 HS Canon PowerShot S120 Canon PowerShot G7 X Fujifilm X-E1 +15 more
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum MMy threads