Had a chance to finally play with one. My interest here is tilt-LCD, small small and more small, and given it uses the new Super Street Fighter II Turbo VIII Turbo Pic processor, felt maybe it focuses better and faster than a PenF.
This won't be an extensive review but a rather concise list of thoughts in different categories. Hope it may help you if you have to make a call though I suspect the target market doesn't hang out too much here.
Focusing
- Yes, it sure seems to focus a bit faster than PenF, acquire face-eye detection better, can focus faster in lower light.
Usability
- Camera operates faster than its controls would suggest.
- Camera responds fast, faster than the PENF when dialing in shutter speeds, etc.
- Tilt LCD is great but see below
- 4k video benefits from IBIS, IBIS + electronic stabilization pretty reasonably well
- Buttons are small, but feel better than the cheapo- feeling I was expecting- particularly those in the back of the camera
- I think the record video button is well placed, avoiding accidental thumb press by being inset-protected with the mini-thumb rest
- Little grip/thumbrest work better IMHO that whatever he PenF tried to do with one of them.
JPEGS
- JPEGS have great color and filter options
- JPEGS miraculously, like on the PenF, kill chroma noise at high iso rather well
Draw backs / Not so cool things
- electronic shutter mode is separate and it's own mode, can't combine with PASM modes. You can only do exposure shift. This point goes into my "deal breaker for me" bucket.
The electronic shutter does allow also 1/16,000 second exposure, but ONLY in this camera mode, no combination with PASM.
This would be fixable with a firmware upgrade.
- RAW converter- you can't modify a lot of things for the RAW conversion, in particular the exposure. I use this all the time on the Panasonic/Olympus cameras I have to check how much range some of the highlights have and overall adjust when needing to send something via-phone.
This would be fixable with a firmware upgrade
- Tilt LCD for selfies tilts underneath camera in a rather unnatural annoying way. Even if you are not using a tripod, holding the camera using the LCD below the camera is annoying.
- Default noise reduction and even taking it out, seems at times a bit aggressive, but could just be that AA filter.
- AA filter- often the camera output just looks/feels a bit too smooth. This is not an issue for the GX9/PenF - whoever says 20 MP don't make a difference- they do- though that sensor not only has more resolution, it's better overall too. But not having the AA filter really helps also. I remember some rather sharp shots from the GX85 (no AA filter).
Pleasant Surprises
- Probably best "calibrated" m43rds 16 MP old sensor camera around, with the best highlight range I have seen of all of the m43rds models carrying this sensor. I find the GM5/GX850 clip a bit easily, though the shadow recovery is there. The PenL9 seems better balanced overall.
- No electronic shutter penalty in DR (unlike the Panasonic's with 16 MP in e-shutter modes which loses ~one stop of shadow DR).
- IBIS works quite well to its rated limit (25mm F1.8 prime lens, 3.5 CIPA). I even got with some care 4 stops. I don't feel confident shooting the PenF at 5 stops (its CIPA) or even at 4, for the most part.
- The simplified options/menu actually show just how much BETTER the Olympus UI could be if they focused on simplifying the current mess they are in and how to categorize better the options.
- Advanced Photo mode which they use to "surface" a few features that normally would be hidden in a menu, works for this intended purpose.
I would be vastly more inclined to buy this EPL9 if...
- Had the new 20 mp sensor
- with no AA filter
- e-shutter as the regular option it can be with PASM
I understand Olympus trying to simplify for the target market, but I think they should do that with reasonable defaults and have a special advanced-custom menu (just put in the gear as its won item or something) to enable a few options in all PASM.
Note to those who keep saying "we have smaller options in m43rds for those who don't want big camera bodies..."
No, we don't have those options. The EPL9 pretty much proves the point- it's targeted at entry level. There's no "small pro" option with Panasonic abandoning that (hey, at least a GX950 20 MP sensor camera then would be nice) and Olympus doing a product like this without a couple of key options.
The EPL10 could adress both markets by having by default the accessible menus, hints, modes and have extra configurable options for those who know what they are doing and want a pretty good performance-small m43rds camera.
The little features I outlined above would do it. Maybe an EPL10 in the future is for me if it happens.
Biggest danger for this camera is how much can it expand over cell phones. I took a shot with a modern phone and I was surprised just how close it was (and better in some areas of the shot) to the EPL9, though the EPL9 overall with different lenses has a bigger envelope. A Fuji XT30 would make this camera look pretty sad, but there's a price diff. (for the the EPL9 smaller size is an attractive feature on its own).
-- hide signature --
Raist3d/Ricardo (Photographer, software dev.)- I photograph black cats in coal mines at night...
“The further a society drifts from truth the more it will hate those who speak it.” - George Orwell