DPReview.com is closing April 10th - Find out more

Silica Gel Packs for Moisture

Started Oct 5, 2018 | Discussions
YnotMe Regular Member • Posts: 204
Silica Gel Packs for Moisture

I've always been a freak about moisture and my gear and when ever I've received a package that has silica packs in it I've saved them. Eventually they tear, so no longer good. In all honesty I'm not sure if they've ever done any good, but I've never had fungus issues. In cool or damp weather I always put my gear in my bag before I entering anything warm like a car, house or other, maybe that's what's saved me.

My stash is diminishing and about to order a bunch online. I normally throw in 15-20 of these little packs throughout my bag, now a Mindshift 180°. A couple for each lens and body compartment. Is that honestly enough for cold or damp weather just as a precaution or should I go more? Also, are there other products on the market that won't take up much space and provide better moisture protection?

petrochemist Veteran Member • Posts: 3,619
Re: Silica Gel Packs for Moisture
1

The little ones supplied with lenses etc don't have much capacity to absorb water & fall apart if you try regenerating them. You can get larger packs that can be stuck in an ordinary oven at 120°C to dry them out.

I got mine from work brought for an instrument we no longer use - but I'm sure others can be found on the likes of Amazon. Just make sure you get regenerative desiccant.

 petrochemist's gear list:petrochemist's gear list
Pentax K100D Sigma SD14 Pentax K-7 Panasonic Lumix DMC-GF2 Pentax Q +19 more
OP YnotMe Regular Member • Posts: 204
Re: Silica Gel Packs for Moisture

Thank-you. They seem to be sold/advertised in grams, 3, 5, 10. What size would be sufficient if still putting in different pockets throughout my bag?

Dper2016 Regular Member • Posts: 239
Re: Silica Gel Packs for Moisture
2

YnotMe wrote:

I've always been a freak about moisture and my gear and when ever I've received a package that has silica packs in it I've saved them. Eventually they tear, so no longer good. In all honesty I'm not sure if they've ever done any good, but I've never had fungus issues. In cool or damp weather I always put my gear in my bag before I entering anything warm like a car, house or other, maybe that's what's saved me.

My stash is diminishing and about to order a bunch online. I normally throw in 15-20 of these little packs throughout my bag, now a Mindshift 180°. A couple for each lens and body compartment. Is that honestly enough for cold or damp weather just as a precaution or should I go more? Also, are there other products on the market that won't take up much space and provide better moisture protection?

Silica Gel was once (and maybe still) available through Chemists/pharmacies/chemical suppliers. I have about 500grams of it. It was possible to buy "Indicator" Silica Gel that was colored Blue when dry and then turned Pink when it became moisture saturated. This is the best type to buy as you will know when it is absorbing moisture, or not. With white Gel there is no knowing if it is working,

I use the 'Indicator' Silica Gel at about an 'egg cup full' to keep a sealed cake 'tin' dry with camera and lens. Note I say "sealed"- that could be like Tupperware or similar- air tight!

I use a frypan or saucepan with gentle heat to dry out the Gel once it turns to Pink, then store it in capped bottles (as Blue) until needed with cameras, etc.

Those little white bags that come with new equipment are virtually useless for any purpose once removed from the original packaging, and throwing them into your camera bag is totally useless. How could 2-3 grams of gel absorb all the moisture in the atmosphere when you are opening a bag repeatedly ? Think about it. Even throwing in 15-20 will do little good unless they have been re-generated, but in fact could be just storing moisture in your bag with your equipment (like a wet sponge).

So my recommendations- Buy Indicator Silica Gel, store (when returning home) cameras and lenses in sealed containers with the Gel, dry out the gel when it becomes exhausted.

And I always have a laugh when I see the little white bags that have been in the bottom of camera bags for 10-20-30 years....

petrochemist Veteran Member • Posts: 3,619
Re: Silica Gel Packs for Moisture
1

YnotMe wrote:

Thank-you. They seem to be sold/advertised in grams, 3, 5, 10. What size would be sufficient if still putting in different pockets throughout my bag?

It depends on where you are, how big the bag/pocket is, how well sealed it is & how often you regenerate.

I think the packs I have hold 25g.

I've always steered clear of making my own packs _ they'd need to have free circulation of air but hold in the silica. Despite it's name Silica gel is a hard grainy material that could scratch lenses. We have a wide variety of mesh sizes at work ranging from about 5mm to fine dust.

 petrochemist's gear list:petrochemist's gear list
Pentax K100D Sigma SD14 Pentax K-7 Panasonic Lumix DMC-GF2 Pentax Q +19 more
OP YnotMe Regular Member • Posts: 204
Re: Silica Gel Packs for Moisture

Got it. Thanks

zoeker
zoeker Forum Member • Posts: 56
Re: Silica Gel Packs for Moisture

petrochemist wrote:

YnotMe wrote:

Thank-you. They seem to be sold/advertised in grams, 3, 5, 10. What size would be sufficient if still putting in different pockets throughout my bag?

It depends on where you are, how big the bag/pocket is, how well sealed it is & how often you regenerate.

I think the packs I have hold 25g.

I've always steered clear of making my own packs _ they'd need to have free circulation of air but hold in the silica. Despite it's name Silica gel is a hard grainy material that could scratch lenses. We have a wide variety of mesh sizes at work ranging from about 5mm to fine dust.

I did make my own pack from a piece of strong fabric on the sewing machine of my wife. A strip of velcro to close the bag. It holds a paper-like bag with 60 gram silica gel. It is not real paper and it gets wet while regenerating (at 120 C in the kitchen oven) but does not fall apart. But it feels fragile and when it rips you have the silicagel all over your equipment. So thats why i made a stronger bag.

On the photo you see the silicagel bag at the right and the self made bag at the left. The silica bag only gets out when it is time for regenerating.

 zoeker's gear list:zoeker's gear list
Canon EOS M Canon EOS M6 II
petrochemist Veteran Member • Posts: 3,619
Re: Silica Gel Packs for Moisture

zoeker wrote:

petrochemist wrote:

YnotMe wrote:

Thank-you. They seem to be sold/advertised in grams, 3, 5, 10. What size would be sufficient if still putting in different pockets throughout my bag?

It depends on where you are, how big the bag/pocket is, how well sealed it is & how often you regenerate.

I think the packs I have hold 25g.

I've always steered clear of making my own packs _ they'd need to have free circulation of air but hold in the silica. Despite it's name Silica gel is a hard grainy material that could scratch lenses. We have a wide variety of mesh sizes at work ranging from about 5mm to fine dust.

I did make my own pack from a piece of strong fabric on the sewing machine of my wife. A strip of velcro to close the bag. It holds a paper-like bag with 60 gram silica gel. It is not real paper and it gets wet while regenerating (at 120 C in the kitchen oven) but does not fall apart. But it feels fragile and when it rips you have the silicagel all over your equipment. So thats why i made a stronger bag.

On the photo you see the silicagel bag at the right and the self made bag at the left. The silica bag only gets out when it is time for regenerating.

Looks good.

The packs I have are in metal canisters so could scratch paintwork etc. if I get careless. I guess fabric bags would be a better option.

 petrochemist's gear list:petrochemist's gear list
Pentax K100D Sigma SD14 Pentax K-7 Panasonic Lumix DMC-GF2 Pentax Q +19 more
HRC2016 Veteran Member • Posts: 6,874
Re: Silica Gel Packs for Moisture

Is there a way to recycle the bags you get with new gear? I would prefer not tossing them in the landfill.

-- hide signature --

I believe in science, evolution and light. All opinions are my own. I'm not compensated for any of my posts. Can you honestly say that?

 HRC2016's gear list:HRC2016's gear list
Panasonic Lumix G Vario 45-200mm F4-5.6 OIS Olympus M.Zuiko Digital ED 12-50mm 1:3.5-6.3 EZ Olympus M.Zuiko ED 75-300mm 1:4.8-6.7 II Sigma 150-600mm F5-6.3 | C Olympus 12-100mm F4.0 +2 more
petrochemist Veteran Member • Posts: 3,619
Re: Silica Gel Packs for Moisture

HRC2016 wrote:

Is there a way to recycle the bags you get with new gear? I would prefer not tossing them in the landfill.

You can dry them out if you have a vacuum oven, but I'd rather doubt you do. The one in our lab cost over £1000, without the vacuum pump...

I suppose you could cut them open & repackage them in sown fabric, of perhaps just sow the seams of the packages as they are - so you can heat them to about 120C in a normal oven, but I suspect the amount of silica gel in them isn't enough to be worth the effort. The usual packs only have 1 - 2 g in them which would get saturated very quickly in anything you open often.

The contents are a silicon oxide not dissimilar to sand. Water insoluble & fairly unreactive. AFAIK the only hazard is a s a fine powder in the air where it can cause silicosis if breathed in..

 petrochemist's gear list:petrochemist's gear list
Pentax K100D Sigma SD14 Pentax K-7 Panasonic Lumix DMC-GF2 Pentax Q +19 more
MarkHu Senior Member • Posts: 2,418
Re: Silica Gel Packs for Moisture

I have used Silica Gel for cats. 5 kg  bag is cheap and lasts looong...

-- hide signature --

Mark H
"Life is worthy to photograph"
https://www.flickr.com/photos/139785057@N08

 MarkHu's gear list:MarkHu's gear list
Olympus E-M1 II Olympus M.Zuiko Digital 45mm F1.8 Olympus M.Zuiko Digital 17mm F1.8 Olympus 12-40mm F2.8 Pro Olympus 9mm F8 Fish-Eye Body Cap Lens +2 more
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum MMy threads