DPReview.com is closing April 10th - Find out more

Does the SX730 deliver better IQ than the IPhone 8?

Started Aug 3, 2018 | Discussions
VOODOOXI New Member • Posts: 16
Does the SX730 deliver better IQ than the IPhone 8?

I recently bought an IPhone 8 and have been quite impressed with the image quality assuming that one doesn’t ask the camera to do too much.

My question is, is the IQ from the SX730 as good as the IPhone 8? I’ve owned older cameras in this line and I swear that the Iphone produces a better image.

I would  be quite happy if the SX730 gave an equal or better image than the IPhone 8 with the option of a 40x zoom.

Canon PowerShot SX730 HS
If you believe there are incorrect tags, please send us this post using our feedback form.
(unknown member) Senior Member • Posts: 2,265
Re: Does the SX730 deliver better IQ than the IPhone 8?
1

VOODOOXI wrote:

I recently bought an IPhone 8 and have been quite impressed with the image quality assuming that one doesn’t ask the camera to do too much.

My question is, is the IQ from the SX730 as good as the IPhone 8? I’ve owned older cameras in this line and I swear that the Iphone produces a better image.

I would be quite happy if the SX730 gave an equal or better image than the IPhone 8 with the option of a 40x zoom.

If you want the best IQ why are you buying an iPhone as opposed to what appear to be many better android phones?

It is always strange these comparisons where people are comparing against a raft of different cameras but the only phone that exists in the world on DPR is the iPhone. It is as though everyone troops out and buys an iPhone without a though in the world and then start getting fussy about which camera to buy for IQ.

A phone will probably in its limited range as will any short focal length fixed focus camera give a better image and the sensor development and computational image making will be better funded but these cameras are for long zoom so railing that the camera falls behind in the tiny operational environment a phone functions in serves little purpose and these are just such different bits of kit.

The compact world has to fund development out of less than a millions units a month so the smartphone will give better results in its fixed wide angle world and maybe a bit of zoom with 2 cameras but at a price.

If you want quality in a comparable equivalent camera to your iPhone get a fixed focus 28mm equivalent aps-c camera like the Fuji XT-10 XF 10 as the camera world has to up the sensor size to really compete. Comparisons with a cheapish small sensor super zoom just make no sense.

Sorry to be so snarky but these iPhone posts on such markedly different bits of kit do wear me down a bit

In some ways these posts boil down to my fixed focus lens gives sharper images than my zoom lens which is just a basic fact of physics and the phone sensor being better than the camera sensor of the same size is also a given.

digitallollygag Senior Member • Posts: 1,338
Re: Does the SX730 deliver better IQ than the IPhone 8?
2

There is more to this than just IQ. You didn’t really say all that you plan to photograph with a tiny-sensor camera.

My wife’s iPhone8 has a substantially better camera than my iPhone6, but there are at least two or three Android phones that yield better IQ than the iPhone8.

KeepCalm may be right: if you’re happy with the angle of view you get with an iPhone but are looking for better IQ, then you might be happier with that new Fuji XF10. To compare a smartphone to a super zoom compact like the SX730 HS is an apples-to-oranges kind of thing.

saaber1 Senior Member • Posts: 2,164
Re: Does the SX730 deliver better IQ than the IPhone 8?
2

digitallollygag wrote:

.... To compare a smartphone to a super zoom compact like the SX730 HS is an apples-to-oranges kind of thing.

Agree. It would be more apt perhaps to compare a iphone to a fix-focused camera of similar focal length like the Ricoh GRII. A phone cannot take shots like the ones in this thread: https://www.dpreview.com/forums/thread/4304842

The Dandelion sx730 shot is probably close to iphone focal length.

OP VOODOOXI New Member • Posts: 16
Re: Does the SX730 deliver better IQ than the IPhone 8?
1

Yeah, thanks for the lecture. I’m sorry I offended you with such a horribly offensive question. By the way you didn’t even read the question properly and went off on some odd rant for no apparent reason. For the record, I didn’t buy the IPhone for the camera which for some strange reason you seem to want to take me to task over...Get a life!

(unknown member) Senior Member • Posts: 2,265
Re: Does the SX730 deliver better IQ than the IPhone 8?

VOODOOXI wrote:

Yeah, thanks for the lecture. I’m sorry I offended you with such a horribly offensive question. By the way you didn’t even read the question properly and went off on some odd rant for no apparent reason. For the record, I didn’t buy the IPhone for the camera which for some strange reason you seem to want to take me to task over...Get a life!

Sorry if it is me you are talking about. The smartphone is destroying our hobby and it will be all that is left in the end so it will all be academic in a few years apart from very expensive specialist options. We can get a bit passionate about this.

Coaster95 Regular Member • Posts: 173
Re: Does the SX730 deliver better IQ than the IPhone 8?

Sounds like KeepCalm needs to keep calm!

You're asking a perfectly reasonable question to which I don't know the answer but you could have a look on Flickr at other peoples photos taken with the SX730 and see what you think. https://www.flickr.com/search/?text=sx730

It does seem to be quite good for sneaking shots of ladies in bikinis!

 Coaster95's gear list:Coaster95's gear list
Sony RX100 VI
digitallollygag Senior Member • Posts: 1,338
Re: Does the SX730 deliver better IQ than the IPhone 8?
1

KeepCalm wrote:

VOODOOXI wrote:

Yeah, thanks for the lecture. I’m sorry I offended you with such a horribly offensive question. By the way you didn’t even read the question properly and went off on some odd rant for no apparent reason. For the record, I didn’t buy the IPhone for the camera which for some strange reason you seem to want to take me to task over...Get a life!

Sorry if it is me you are talking about. The smartphone is destroying our hobby and it will be all that is left in the end so it will all be academic in a few years apart from very expensive specialist options. We can get a bit passionate about this.

Funny, I thought yours was a reasonable response to the OP. It was PhotoRoo who seemed to get all worked up.

marksee Contributing Member • Posts: 969
Re: Does the SX730 deliver better IQ than the IPhone 8?

Ok, back to the original question. For me the main and most important difference is the F 1.8 of the iPhone as apposed to the F 3.2 of the SX 730. I can get low light shots I just couldn't with the Canon. Hope this helped.

OP VOODOOXI New Member • Posts: 16
Re: Does the SX730 deliver better IQ than the IPhone 8?

KeepCalm wrote:

VOODOOXI wrote:

Yeah, thanks for the lecture. I’m sorry I offended you with such a horribly offensive question. By the way you didn’t even read the question properly and went off on some odd rant for no apparent reason. For the record, I didn’t buy the IPhone for the camera which for some strange reason you seem to want to take me to task over...Get a life!

Sorry if it is me you are talking about. The smartphone is destroying our hobby and it will be all that is left in the end so it will all be academic in a few years apart from very expensive specialist options. We can get a bit passionate about this.

No worries. I hate the damn things myself. As a novice I just can’t figure out what camera to buy. Have a great day,

digitallollygag Senior Member • Posts: 1,338
Re: Does the SX730 deliver better IQ than the IPhone 8?

VOODOOXI wrote:

KeepCalm wrote:

VOODOOXI wrote:

Yeah, thanks for the lecture. I’m sorry I offended you with such a horribly offensive question. By the way you didn’t even read the question properly and went off on some odd rant for no apparent reason. For the record, I didn’t buy the IPhone for the camera which for some strange reason you seem to want to take me to task over...Get a life!

Sorry if it is me you are talking about. The smartphone is destroying our hobby and it will be all that is left in the end so it will all be academic in a few years apart from very expensive specialist options. We can get a bit passionate about this.

No worries. I hate the damn things myself. As a novice I just can’t figure out what camera to buy. Have a great day,

Maybe the best way to go forward is to buy the SX730 HS. It is likely selling soon at a reduced price now that the SX740 HS has been announced. Your big purchase, the iPhone 8, has already been made, and the Canon is probably about half the price. The iPhone 8 has a pretty darn good camera module, and the little Canon has all that zoom range. Win win.

OP VOODOOXI New Member • Posts: 16
Re: Does the SX730 deliver better IQ than the IPhone 8?

Thanks for the help!

redtailboas Regular Member • Posts: 420
Re: Does the SX730 deliver better IQ than the IPhone 8?
2

In terms of "pleasingness" straight out of the camera, the majority of your images from iPhone 8 will look a couple of levels better than SX730.

I'm talking just normal scenery and people snapshots. In low light I'd be surprised to find iPhone 8 not beating SX730 as well.

Pixel level sharpness may not match SX730, but might.

Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum MMy threads