DPReview.com is closing April 10th - Find out more

Color of M5...

Started Nov 24, 2017 | Questions
vinrouge0 Contributing Member • Posts: 534
Re: Color of M5...

Sure, but colour preferences are very subjective and some of us prefer slightly cool to slightly warm. I like the balance in the above pic

 vinrouge0's gear list:vinrouge0's gear list
Nikon Z50 Nikon Z6 II Nikon Z 24-70mm F4 Nikon Z 50-250mm F4.5-6.3 VR Nikon Nikkor Z 28mm F2.8 (SE) +2 more
fstopx2 Senior Member • Posts: 1,088
Re: Color of M5...

J A C S wrote:

fstopx2 wrote:

If you dont like the colors you can modify them via the picture styles. You can either modify one of the existing picture styles, create a new one or get one off the web. There are tons of them out there that can emulate all kinds of things.

This is like saying that if you do not like your speakers, you can use an equilizer. It can only help a little.

BTW, that picture lacks warmth.

Who doesn't like options?

Actually it will help a lot. Go look at what picture styles can do. Instant Leica look if you so choose.

J A C S
J A C S Forum Pro • Posts: 20,521
Re: Color of M5...

fstopx2 wrote:

J A C S wrote:

fstopx2 wrote:

If you dont like the colors you can modify them via the picture styles. You can either modify one of the existing picture styles, create a new one or get one off the web. There are tons of them out there that can emulate all kinds of things.

This is like saying that if you do not like your speakers, you can use an equilizer. It can only help a little.

BTW, that picture lacks warmth.

Who doesn't like options?

Actually it will help a lot. Go look at what picture styles can do.

I have been doing that for more than a decade.

DiegoAV New Member • Posts: 4
Re: Color of M5...

One Picture profile to Rule them All:

This week I had a 1DC for a job. I had enough time mimic it's color science and port it to the M5.

I had a 1DC an M5 the fabulous CN-E50MM T1.3 L (Canon cinema lens) so I took the same picture of a color chart with same iso, exposition and light conditions.

With the eos utility I matched the colors of the 1DC to the M5, so this is the result, you can use it an edit it any way you like:

https://gofile.io/?c=gGc8KW

I'm sharing the original raws if someone wants to give it a try:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1UCfMuoDVQWkuK5tq0BzZROcP4-RWC9Zq/view?usp=sharing

Cheers!

J A C S
J A C S Forum Pro • Posts: 20,521
Re: Color of M5...
1

DiegoAV wrote:

One Picture profile to Rule them All:

This week I had a 1DC for a job. I had enough time mimic it's color science and port it to the M5.

I had a 1DC an M5 the fabulous CN-E50MM T1.3 L (Canon cinema lens) so I took the same picture of a color chart with same iso, exposition and light conditions.

With the eos utility I matched the colors of the 1DC to the M5, so this is the result, you can use it an edit it any way you like:

You did not match the colors (not even visibly). You run an algorithm which knows what the colors were and just replaced them with the known numbers.

https://gofile.io/?c=gGc8KW

I'm sharing the original raws if someone wants to give it a try:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1UCfMuoDVQWkuK5tq0BzZROcP4-RWC9Zq/view?usp=sharing

Cheers!

Miguel-C
Miguel-C Senior Member • Posts: 2,321
Re: Color of M5...

lumenite wrote:

Recently I got M5 and have been testing it.

Yesterday, my family visited Joshua Tree National Park with my new camera.

Definitely, it is faster than my original M. Using EVF is also fun, though I did not use it much because I needed low and high angles.

But the problem is the color that does not satisfy my family. Especially, when looking at the color of the back LCD, I can tell M is better than M5. Now others' concern become mine.

Here are some examples of M5:

What do you think of from them?

My wife is saying, "Let us sell it out. The original M is better. Color is more important than control and speed. If we have to do RAW conversion, we would better use 1D."

They look natural, but if you want more pop have you tried messing with the picture profiles?

 Miguel-C's gear list:Miguel-C's gear list
Fujifilm X-T2 Canon EOS M5 Panasonic Lumix DC-S5 Canon EF-M 11-22mm f/4-5.6 IS STM Fujifilm XF 35mm F2 R WR +3 more
DiegoAV New Member • Posts: 4
Re: Color of M5...
1

J A C S wrote:

DiegoAV wrote:

One Picture profile to Rule them All:

This week I had a 1DC for a job. I had enough time mimic it's color science and port it to the M5.

I had a 1DC an M5 the fabulous CN-E50MM T1.3 L (Canon cinema lens) so I took the same picture of a color chart with same iso, exposition and light conditions.

With the eos utility I matched the colors of the 1DC to the M5, so this is the result, you can use it an edit it any way you like:

You did not match the colors (not even visibly). You run an algorithm which knows what the colors were and just replaced them with the known numbers.

https://gofile.io/?c=gGc8KW

I'm sharing the original raws if someone wants to give it a try:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1UCfMuoDVQWkuK5tq0BzZROcP4-RWC9Zq/view?usp=sharing

Cheers!

The pictures you are seeing are the jpgs, not the procesed raws.

The approch was number driven not empirical (the way it should be if you ask me).

As for the algorithm there is not such process, you have to sample color by color and do the math on each value.

If you apply the 1DC picture profile to the M5 picture you get the same color results as if you shot it with a 1DC, that works for the color chart or the world...

J A C S
J A C S Forum Pro • Posts: 20,521
Re: Color of M5...
1

DiegoAV wrote:

J A C S wrote:

DiegoAV wrote:

One Picture profile to Rule them All:

This week I had a 1DC for a job. I had enough time mimic it's color science and port it to the M5.

I had a 1DC an M5 the fabulous CN-E50MM T1.3 L (Canon cinema lens) so I took the same picture of a color chart with same iso, exposition and light conditions.

With the eos utility I matched the colors of the 1DC to the M5, so this is the result, you can use it an edit it any way you like:

You did not match the colors (not even visibly). You run an algorithm which knows what the colors were and just replaced them with the known numbers.

https://gofile.io/?c=gGc8KW

I'm sharing the original raws if someone wants to give it a try:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1UCfMuoDVQWkuK5tq0BzZROcP4-RWC9Zq/view?usp=sharing

Cheers!

The pictures you are seeing are the jpgs, not the procesed raws.

The approch was number driven not empirical (the way it should be if you ask me).

As for the algorithm there is not such process, you have to sample color by color and do the math on each value.

This is an algorithm. The patches have a very limited range of spectral densities known to the software. The algorithm is to interpolate between them, and hopefully to match the colors in other situations somehow.

If you apply the 1DC picture profile to the M5 picture you get the same color results as if you shot it with a 1DC, that works for the color chart or the world...

No, this works for this particular chart in a trivial way - the colors are known. It would not work in all situations if there is visible metamerism between the two sensors.

Microprism Contributing Member • Posts: 865
Re: Color preferences can be very subjective...

lumenite wrote:

Ben Herrmann wrote:

...and no two folks will agree on what they like. Having said that, I personally prefer the overall color tonality coming from both the M and M2. To be the M and M2 have an overall "warmer" look to the colors (more traditional Canon, that is).

With the M3 and M10 (I don't have the M5 or M6), I find the color tonality shift towards a slightly more yellowish or greenish hue (not in all scenes though - but it is noticeable). This effect is even more noticeable when the sun has a more warmish glow as in Autumn scenes.

But since I shoot in RAW only, regardless of what camera I use, I will try to adjust whatever is needed to get the look I'm aiming for.

Yes, I want to be warmer and more vivid. At this point, it is difficult to run RAW converting as my main process. But I will try some later. Thank you.

Outdoors, I always, always use the daylight white balance setting. The AWB is not to my taste in coloration. You might try shooting some comparisons of the settings as a test.

 Microprism's gear list:Microprism's gear list
Canon EOS 5D Canon EOS 7D Canon EOS M6 Canon EOS M6 II Canon EF 50mm F1.4 USM +22 more
DiegoAV New Member • Posts: 4
Re: Color of M5...
1

J A C S wrote:

DiegoAV wrote:

J A C S wrote:

DiegoAV wrote:

One Picture profile to Rule them All:

This week I had a 1DC for a job. I had enough time mimic it's color science and port it to the M5.

I had a 1DC an M5 the fabulous CN-E50MM T1.3 L (Canon cinema lens) so I took the same picture of a color chart with same iso, exposition and light conditions.

With the eos utility I matched the colors of the 1DC to the M5, so this is the result, you can use it an edit it any way you like:

You did not match the colors (not even visibly). You run an algorithm which knows what the colors were and just replaced them with the known numbers.

https://gofile.io/?c=gGc8KW

I'm sharing the original raws if someone wants to give it a try:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1UCfMuoDVQWkuK5tq0BzZROcP4-RWC9Zq/view?usp=sharing

Cheers!

The pictures you are seeing are the jpgs, not the procesed raws.

The approch was number driven not empirical (the way it should be if you ask me).

As for the algorithm there is not such process, you have to sample color by color and do the math on each value.

This is an algorithm. The patches have a very limited range of spectral densities known to the software. The algorithm is to interpolate between them, and hopefully to match the colors in other situations somehow.

If you apply the 1DC picture profile to the M5 picture you get the same color results as if you shot it with a 1DC, that works for the color chart or the world...

No, this works for this particular chart in a trivial way - the colors are known. It would not work in all situations if there is visible metamerism between the two sensors.

Sorry I don't get your point... I have the habit of not getting in arguments with strangers on Internet.

For those who are interested in getting a good color profile on the M5:

I tried today the Picture Style in a real life situation, Fun Fair and open air kids theater. Meaning lots of skin tones and rich color decorations. I cannot post any pictures because there are children in them (including mine).

I found out the 1DC picture style needs some in camera adjustments.

This is what worked better for me (this totally my taste).

Sharpness Strength: 2

Sharpness Fineness: 4

Shapness Threshold: 4

Contrast: -3

Saturation: 3

Color Tone: -3

Hope you find it usefull.

Cheers!

J A C S
J A C S Forum Pro • Posts: 20,521
Re: Color of M5...

DiegoAV wrote:

J A C S wrote:

DiegoAV wrote:

J A C S wrote:

DiegoAV wrote:

One Picture profile to Rule them All:

This week I had a 1DC for a job. I had enough time mimic it's color science and port it to the M5.

I had a 1DC an M5 the fabulous CN-E50MM T1.3 L (Canon cinema lens) so I took the same picture of a color chart with same iso, exposition and light conditions.

With the eos utility I matched the colors of the 1DC to the M5, so this is the result, you can use it an edit it any way you like:

You did not match the colors (not even visibly). You run an algorithm which knows what the colors were and just replaced them with the known numbers.

https://gofile.io/?c=gGc8KW

I'm sharing the original raws if someone wants to give it a try:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1UCfMuoDVQWkuK5tq0BzZROcP4-RWC9Zq/view?usp=sharing

Cheers!

The pictures you are seeing are the jpgs, not the procesed raws.

The approch was number driven not empirical (the way it should be if you ask me).

As for the algorithm there is not such process, you have to sample color by color and do the math on each value.

This is an algorithm. The patches have a very limited range of spectral densities known to the software. The algorithm is to interpolate between them, and hopefully to match the colors in other situations somehow.

If you apply the 1DC picture profile to the M5 picture you get the same color results as if you shot it with a 1DC, that works for the color chart or the world...

No, this works for this particular chart in a trivial way - the colors are known. It would not work in all situations if there is visible metamerism between the two sensors.

Sorry I don't get your point... I have the habit of not getting in arguments with strangers on Internet.

This is not an argument. I am just telling you how profiling works.

Microprism Contributing Member • Posts: 865
Re: Color of M5...

Incidentally, being very old school (and pretty old), I find the daylight colors from my M6 a little cool. It can be corrected in post, but an easier solution for me is to put Skylight 1B filters on all my lenses to add a touch of warmth. I like the results, ymmv.

 Microprism's gear list:Microprism's gear list
Canon EOS 5D Canon EOS 7D Canon EOS M6 Canon EOS M6 II Canon EF 50mm F1.4 USM +22 more
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum MMy threads