DPReview.com is closing April 10th - Find out more

Sony (A mount) considering big move to Canon - Advice?

Started Jul 24, 2016 | Discussions
DR05
DR05 Regular Member • Posts: 223
Sony (A mount) considering big move to Canon - Advice?

I'm currently a Sony A mount user (Sony A99 SLT). There are a few reasons I'm thinking to Canon instead of to Sony E Mount (mirrorless). But my mind isn't 100% made up yet and would appreciate any input.

I'm eagerly awaiting the Canon 5D Mark IV official specs. If it goes 4k/60p I'm going to be excited and that might seal the deal. I do think the A7R2 (Sony E mount) is a fantastic camera, and there's still a small chance I might switch to that. But being with Sony now, I hold Nikon & Canon in higher regard when it comes to quality, durability and longevity.

My summary: I'm a landscape/cityscape amateur photographer and will be moving into more professional portrait, architecture/real estate & potentially wedding photography shortly. While cityscapes are my passion, a 4k capability is important to me. And I'd like to stick with one system for lenses. So it would be all Sony E-mount/mirrorless for photos+video or all Canon for photos+video)

Here are my reasons for the potential switch to Canon:

  1. After buying the flagship Sony A mount camera system a few years ago, I'm now learning the entire mount is most likely dead and the value of my existing glass will go down even more. And, obviously, no more new A mount glass. The Canon EF mount will be around for awhile.
  2. Canon's lens selection is FAR superior. And access to more 3rd party glass, including native support for Zeiss Otus & Milvus. Yes you can adapt Canon lenses to the A7R2, but autofocus speed is TERRIBLE for AF lenses. Sony's A mount selection is decent (my current system), but its dying. And likewise A mount to E mount converters have slow AF.
  3. Sony's flash sync system is terrible. Native & crappy/expensive wireless support is just launching now for E mount. No native wireless support and VERY limited 3rd party options on my Sony A99 (A mount). On Canon native wireless is built right into many cameras, no messing around with infrared transmitters.
  4. Canon build quality seems higher than Sony. I've had heard about a higher rate of Sony A7R2s failing and having issues than Canon (& Nikon) cameras.
  5. Canon (& Nikon) have better support options. I belong to Sony pro support, but I still have to send my gear to a 3rd party in the US for repairs.

I'd love to hear your thoughts before making the substantial financial dive. Thanks again.

 DR05's gear list:DR05's gear list
Sony a9 Sony FE 35mm F1.4 Sony FE 90mm F2.8 macro
Sony Alpha a99
If you believe there are incorrect tags, please send us this post using our feedback form.
mburns
mburns Regular Member • Posts: 448
If you continue to use your camera, a proper postprocessor ...
1

For  Sony, my guess from inspecting badly colored examples of photographs is that incorrect post processing of the compressed raw format is responsible for the problems that I have seen.

A gray scale ought not to wander away from neutral in the direction of magenta and then green. Surely there is a brand of post processor that will decode the Sony format correctly.

 mburns's gear list:mburns's gear list
Canon EOS-1Ds Mark II Canon EOS 5D Mark II Canon EOS 7D Canon EF 20mm f/2.8 USM Canon EF 85mm F1.8 USM +56 more
PaddyC Regular Member • Posts: 374
Re: Sony (A mount) considering big move to Canon - Advice?
1

I sold my Sony a850 (which I loved) and my remaining a mount lenses this spring and switched to Canon. I did consider the A7 cameras very carefully before making the decision.

Your needs and budget are probably different from mine but there are two key considerations I think:

1. EVF – doesn't look like you are going to get one in a Canon for a while. So if you like working with one it's worth giving that some serious thought.

2. Lenses – I can't justify a lot of expensive lenses and I like using native lenses. Canon offered a greater range and much better value allowing me to build a system that suits my needs and budget. FE mount lenses are expensive for what you get IMO and I was quite concerned about the optical quality of the lenses and the overall QC. I don't want to buy a 35 1.4 FE only to find it is decentered.

 PaddyC's gear list:PaddyC's gear list
Canon EOS M Canon EOS M50 Canon EF-M 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6 IS STM Canon EF-M 22mm f/2 STM Canon EF-M 11-22mm f/4-5.6 IS STM +1 more
CameraCarl Veteran Member • Posts: 9,204
Re: Sony (A mount) considering big move to Canon - Advice?
1

Although I use a Sony NEX-6 and a6000 for travels with my family, I've been using Canon for decades. If there is ever a serious assignment, I always take the Canon.  I'm simply more used to it, think it ergonomically superior to the Sony, and gives better image results in both color and quality.  But I think the most important thing Canon provides is superior repair service.  I can send in a camera for repair or cleaning and have it back in a week (assuming that parts are on hand, of course).  Once I dropped off a couple of lenses for a clean and check at a Canon repair facility near Chicago.  They were in the mail back to me before I got home.  Having read the users complaints in the Sony forums for years now, I dread the day that I will ever need service on my Sony cameras or lenses.

Nick on Forum Member • Posts: 90
Re: Sony (A mount) considering big move to Canon - Advice?
1

Hi,

Whilst im not interested in 4K video, I made the switch from a99 and zeiss/ Minolta G glass to canon 1 series and L glass and couldn't be happier. The Sony a99 was lovely, but so are the canon bodies, and I've not got the latest ones, but 1ds mk3 and 1d mk4, both superb. I was never impressed with the Sony build quality or the AF performance, especially tracking. The canons are better AF and vastly better build. Also, like you say, they have a great lens lineup (both old and new) and a much better flash system. I missed the EVF for a start, but once you get used to the OVF, it's not an issue.  I certainly don't regret switching.

Hope this helps.

 Nick on's gear list:Nick on's gear list
Canon EOS-1D Mark II Canon EOS-1Ds Mark III Canon EOS-1D Mark IV Leica M Typ 240 Canon EF 35mm F1.4L USM +5 more
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum MMy threads