Re: Does not make sense for a 36.3 sensor
12
thok wrote:
This teleconverter might be great for sensors with less resolution than 36.3 MP. I tested it with a Nikon D800 and a Nikkor 300mm 2.8 VR II. It seems you don't get any additional details compared to the DX crop mode of the camera. Check out my video for details: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SCt0FogCkOQ
I strongly disagree. I don't have that lens or TC but I have the 300mm f/4 Nikkor and the previous version, the TC-14E II, and I get more detail when the TC is used on my D800. The 300mm f/2.8 lens has greater resolving ability than my 300mm f/4 so something is wrong. Your video concludes showing this on the screen :
The 36.3m MP sensor of the D800 already maxes out the the Nikkor 300mm 2.8 VR II. If you add a TC 14E III you'll get more pixels per (cropped) frame but pay it with less light and sharpness.
Probably this teleconverter is more apropriate for sensors of less resolution?
No. Despite what you may think, the D800 does not have an resolution that comes close to challenging your 300mm f/2.8 or my 300mm f/4 Nikkor. In fact, the D800's DX crop area only has about 15mp resolution, slightly less than the D7000's 16mp resolution. I get more detail when I use my TC-14E II or TC-20E III with either the D800 or the 24mp D7100.
It could be that your copy of the TC-14E III is defective but I suspect that your results are more due to a combination of two things, less than perfect shooting technique and not shooting enough photos so that you can select the best copies to compare.
For the shooting technique, I noticed while your tripod appears to be very sturdy, that you didn't use Mirror-Up with a remote release. That produces better results than using the self timer and it helps even if you're shooting with relatively fast shutter speeds. Did you AF fine tune both the lens and the lens+TC at the shooting distance and focal length used to take the photos? Whether you did or didn't, focusing using the D800's Live View produces more accurate focusing than using the D800's phase detect AF sensors so I try to use Live View when possible.
Both AF methods often don't focus perfectly, there's some randomness to it, so you would need to shoot many photos and select the ones that are in best focus to compare. Also, are you aware that no matter whether you use PDAF or LiveView, if you defocus the lens slightly by turning the manual focus ring before autofocusing, you'll get slightly better focusing if you detune the focus in one direction rather than the other? I had been doing this routinely for a couple of years without mentioning it but then discovered a month or two ago that the advantage of using this detuning technique before autofocusing was described in one of Diglloyd's AF articles. Most of Diglloyd's articles can't be seen without subscribing, but the AF articles are in the publicly available "free" area.
I generally shoot 3 to 5 photos at each aperture (over a wide range of reasonable apertures) so when I do similar tests (one lens, with and without a TC) I might end of with nearly 100 photos to compare and rank.